New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanisms

Posts

Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanisms

#1

Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanisms

Bill Tindall

This topic could be of some practical interest because if the wear mechanism for sharpening is different that that for dulling there exists the possibility of finding a steel for tools that has long edge lasting but it is readily sharpened.

I had an opportunity to spend some time with a textbook on Tirbology, the study of abrasion and wear.

Some conclusions from time spent:

1.This field is boggling complicated and this book not well written.

2. There is stuff relative to sharpening that is has practical application. For example, the huge enhancement proper lubrication can have on rate of material removal, the role of particle shape and hardness, etc. It became clear why diamond on cast iron with a bit of lubrication works so well and why the modern ceramic particles provide rapid material removal rates. I may study this section some more. The details of how alloying and hardening steels improve abrasion resistance was interesting.

3. There is little chance that adhesive wear is important in tool edge dulling. The physics and chemistry for adhesive wear just aren't available for a cellulose contact with a metal. If their atoms did mingle, something unlikely, the stronger steel would pull particles of wood from the wood surface, not the other way around. Adhesive wear is observed for some kinds of plastic rubbing on steel but it is the plastic that looses material, not the steel.

3. While it is a fact that unless the hardness of the substrate is less than the abrasive particle abrasive wear can not occur, there are factors that can result in a soft material abrasively wearing a harder material. The classic example is pure soft coal abrading steel. This section will require more study than what I devoted to it.

4. There are other wear mechanisms that may be involved in dulling plane blades and the like. One possible candidate is corrosive wear. In one study it was found that wood with higher volatiles produced more wear.

Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanisms

#2

Tool Wear vs tool geometry

Mark Hennebury

One part of the equation is cutting geometry.

We know that it affects

1. Wood Surface quality.

2. Required effort.

How much does it affect tool wear?

What are the correlations between Rake angles, Feeding force, Tool wear?

What would be the differences in the wear on the two tools cutting the same amount of lineal feet of shaving, as in the following diagram using:

Same wood,

Same tool,

Same feed direction,

Same chip size,

Same feed speed,

Different rake angles.


Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanisms

#3

May I make a suggestion?

Schtoo

I try very hard to stay out of these kind of threads. Egos tend to get in the way a little too much for my liking.

Anyway, the wear on a blade is something I tend to think about quite a lot. After all, I'm in the business of making the blades sharp again.

What I tend to think is happening when a blade is blunted is not a single action, but a combination of abrasive, corrosive, erosive and perhaps even a little adhesive wear. It's never a constant type of wear, as the material being cut is rarely constant and consistent.

To hinge the wear on a woodworking blade on a single method of wear is, I think, more than a little short sighted.

At the same time, the only method of getting things sharp being stated as pure abrasion is just as short sighted.

I'm not going to get any more involved in this discussion, as I can't really spare the time to get 'into it', and fear my lack of scientific terminology and methodology would stand out and make anything I write appear to be lacking somehow.

All I ask is that you guys with the big brains and big libraries here avoid tripping yourself on a single 'thing' and please accept that even the really big brains in white coats can and do get it wrong.

Good luck,

Stu.

Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanisms

#4

Kato and Kawai shed some light

Bill Tindall

They found that wear was greatest where the pressure of the saving was greatest. If one can successfully speculate shaving pressure in these two situations wear can be predicted. In a paper we have no translated rake angle was investigated.

Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanisms

#5

Re: May I make a suggestion?

CStan

I've found that using tools makes them dull. I call it 'user wear.'

Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanisms

#6

Re: May I make a suggestion?

Mark Hennebury

It seems that you too have an opinion ( thats the part in the middle of you post) on the topic.

It seems that you also have an ego ( thats the part at the begining and end of your post where you separate yourself from everyone else with an opinion.

Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanisms

#7

Good points, well said.


Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanisms

#8

I'm interested...

James Watriss

I'm completely un-versed in any of the topic. But blade longevity was something you brought up in the initial discussions of cap irons. In some videos (IIRC) the chip would split out ahead of the iron once the cut had been started, so the blade wasn't working the full time.

Different steels definitely sharpen differently. Even with diamonds, D2 is an unmitigated beast that doesn't take finest edge, but will hold 'working sharp' for a long time. And M2 is a kitten, with a really fine edge that also holds up for a long time. So it's clear that the abrasion properties are different. Wouldn't surprise me to hear that different dulling characteristics were at work.

Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanisms

#9

Re: May I make a suggestion?

david weaver

Sounds like a toxic fundamental flaw. "User wear".

Could be a marketing opportunity if you say your tool has less or none of it!

:b

Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanisms

#10

Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanism

wilbur

I wouldn't be too quick to dismiss adhesive wear just based on chemistry issues alone. Cellulose (actually, the plant cell wall) is not a homogenous material, and even if we are talking about cellulose alone, the presentation of cellulose to the steel can cause it to wear in different ways and to different degrees. We've all had the experience of planing with the grain resulting in less wear than planing end grain.

In addition, there's other stuff in wood as well: silica and sap are two that I can think of off the top of my head.

Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanisms

#11

Abrading steel alloys

Bill Tindall

Just abrading carbon steel is a complex situation with each crystal structure of the steel, and iron carbides, presenting different challenges to the sharp hard abrasive particle plowing or milling across the steel surface. The addition of alloying elements that make exceptionally hard carbides, for example vanadium, have the effect of putting rocks in the field to be plowed. An abrasive particle happily milling out a shaving hits one of the carbide rocks that is harder than the abrasive particle(unless the abrasive is diamond) and the abrasive particle fractures, dulls or jumps out of the furrow, thereby interrupting its plowing(abrading). Make these "rocks in the field" well attached, numerous and well distributed and the result is an alloy resistant to sharpening and, we have found, dulling, for example the particle steel versions of M4, M2, M42 or even 3V.

Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanisms

#12

Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanism

Bill Tindall

Unless one can identify something in the wood structure that has a greater tensile strength than the steel cutting it then adhesive wear can be dismissed as a relevant mechanism.

The mineral content could provide abrasive wear. The volatiles and extractives could promote corrosive wear.

As Kato and Kawai demonstrated factors that increase shaving pressure promote wear in the high pressure areas. One does not have to conjure different wear mechanisms to explain the different amounts of wear observed at different rake angles relative to the grain orientation. These results can be rationalized by the difference in shaving pressure on the blade tip.

Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanisms

#13

User wear spiraling out of control.....

Bill Tindall

......attributed to the recent surge in successful Bailey plane usage with close set cap irons.

Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanisms

#14

Re: May I make a suggestion?

CStan

Good one... funny.

Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanisms

#15

Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanism

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

As Kato and Kawai demonstrated factors that increase shaving pressure promote wear in the high pressure areas. One does not have to conjure different wear mechanisms to explain the different amounts of wear observed at different rake angles relative to the grain orientation. These results can be rationalized by the difference in shaving pressure on the blade tip.

And pressure creates heat. One only has to hold a card scraper (high rake angle) long enough to experience this.

The question is whether this is relevant, and if so, how does this heat create wear?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanisms

#16

Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanism

Brian Anderson Gunsmith

When I first read the OP, I had to check to make sure that it was not very early April.

In any analysis, of a crime. This one of the dulling of cutting edges, there are suspects that may appear to have an alibi. That permits the superficial removal of them as suspects. Then of course all the suspects may not have been examined.

I wonder if dulling is really a form of compression and NOT abrasion.

Heat as one has mentioned is also a worth suspect.

Just my 2 cents worth.

But alas it is June.

Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanisms

#17

Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanism

TomD

The end grain example is interesting, Heat seems to be lower in end grain planing, due to interruptions, might not be the case when planing a butcher block. It is the same material whichever way you plane it. Main difference appears to be mechanical.

Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanisms

#18

Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanism

CStan

The molecules of the steel move around enough (heat) to bugger the edge?

Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanisms

#19

Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanism

TomD

So Bill, is the adhesive mechanism that something first bonds to the edge, and that thing has higher tensile strength, so it then pulls some part of the edge off? And some plastics are strong enough to do that to steel?

By the way, isn't adhesion the non-chemical stickiness? So you would in many cases not only not have something with the tensile strength to pull away steel, but also the bond would not be strong enough, most materials aren't higher tensile strength than steel.

The form of adhesive dulling I most often see is deposition related. A cutting tool looses it's edge when crud builds up, virtually welding itself to the edge. This is common with machine tools, but it isn't abrasive. So it isn't what you are looking for.

Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanisms

#20

Re: I'm interested... - goog point

TomD

"In some videos (IIRC) the chip would split out ahead of the iron once the cut had been started, so the blade wasn't working the full time. "

If true, the big payoff might be one working on that geometry. As much as wear is an interesting subject, and one that has a nice scientific character, what are the real chancs of getting enough out of it to get an answer, then find a steel, then get some sufficient results to topple current preferences. For most people the breaker thing was great because they already had a plane, all they had to do was move a breaker nearer the edge.

If one could specify a geometry where there was low tear-out, and the edge was only fully abraded for a small part of each stroke, that would seem a lot more transferable.

Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanisms

#21

Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanism

Larry Williams

I've been digging into this for four or five years. Some here might say it's for the sake of argument but it's not even though I've been ridiculed and dismissed here for suggesting it's not abrasion that dulls tools. The information is useful to us. Just one example is that I've been able to significantly increase tool life in our metal shop by just modifying the application of coolant.

I'm not sure what tribology text Bill read but I've been through several of them and tried to read everything I can find on the Internet on the topic unless involved subscribing to academic journals which almost always involves more than $10,000. Sometimes a lot more.

Here are some simple generalizations I've been working with:

1. Abrasion involves wearing away of a surface by particles harder than the surface being worn.

2. Corrosion involves volumetric increase of the surface being corroded.

3. Heat is definitely a cause or contributing factor in edge wear and heat has little effect on abrasion.

Here are some quotes from one of those the many articles I have stored on my computer. This is one from people working on adhesive wear and aluminum:



"Thus, it is clear that a better understanding of

adhesion, lubrication and wear will have a positive impact

on many industries and help lead to ‘greener’ manufacturing.

Unfortunately the field remains dominated by Edisonian

approaches yielding short-term solutions; we believe that

there is a great need for a fundamental, atomic-scale study of

the critical mechanisms and processes involved in adhesion,

lubrication and wear."

Adhesion: there is no simple analytical model to predict

adhesion between different materials, so we discuss

the use of electronic structure methods to investigate

adhesion between Al and various ceramics, to determine

the factors that control adhesion.

Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanisms

#22

Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanism

Brian Anderson Gunsmith

A couple more questions. Some are to clear up what may be my ignorance.

1. If dulling is an abrasive process, do we actually find metal material from abrasive on/in our work?

I have never seen any. But until this thread, I really thought of it.

we should be careful to not include material from sharpening that didn't get cleaned off of our blade

before use.

2. Anybody know of pictures of a well sharpened edge and the same edge after dulling.

pix should be very detailed, like an electron microscope.

I would like to overlay the two views to show deformation or lack their of.

3. When we sharpen a chisel do we actually "damage" the metal at the edge,

ie is it truely homogenous metal. the same as all the other parts of blade.

Alternatively worded; what is the thickness/radius of a sharpened cutting edge.

And what is the thickness/radius of a dulled cutting edge.

Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanisms

#23

Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanism

Brian Anderson Gunsmith

I have strong doubts about corrosion being involved as the number of woods that cause dullness includes some that don't appear to have any corrosive properties.

Also corrosion appears to take time on a scale much greater than the appearance of dullness.

We may have avoided including one source of material here , that being our own sweat/blood.

Some human blood can cause rust another form of corrosion. But that corrosion takes time.

No discussion about dullness is complete without a joke.

I have a list sayings and insults...... Please do not attribute this post as an insult to anyone!

"He is not only dull himself; he is the cause of dullness in others." -

Samuel Johnson

Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanisms

#24

Re: Larry, you haven't been totally dismissed..

david weaver

..I've read the discussion with some interest, because I can't otherwise explain why my HSS planes last so many multiples longer than an A2 or O1 plane in cocobolo, but in more pedestrian woods, the ratio is not as high.

Not that I guess it should really matter to me about why that is, but it's confused me.

My first guess would've been that in a wood where there is truly a lot of abrasive content (like cocobolo), the characteristics of a HSS plane iron are more valuable.

Who knows, though? I can only attest to the difference, not why it occurs.

Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanisms

#25

Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanism

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Brian,

"2. Anybody know of pictures of a well sharpened edge and the same edge after dulling.

pix should be very detailed, like an electron microscope."

There is actual, quantifiable metal loss associated with dulling. Steve Elliott for one, has microphotos before and after that he has superimposed. His photos show the original sharpened edge, then the same edge after 50, 100, 200...lineal feet of planing. His objective was to discover the geometry of the dulling edge--was it rounded symmetrically or more early metal loss on the lower side rubbing against the wood. His photos show the loss of clearance as the blade dulls.

Kato and Kawai also have papers that show and quantify metal loss, or 'recession' of the blade edge. Bill Tindall has these, and is working on translation, I believe.

Wiley