Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanisms
Bill Tindall
This topic could be of some practical interest because if the wear mechanism for sharpening is different that that for dulling there exists the possibility of finding a steel for tools that has long edge lasting but it is readily sharpened.
I had an opportunity to spend some time with a textbook on Tirbology, the study of abrasion and wear.
Some conclusions from time spent:
1.This field is boggling complicated and this book not well written.
2. There is stuff relative to sharpening that is has practical application. For example, the huge enhancement proper lubrication can have on rate of material removal, the role of particle shape and hardness, etc. It became clear why diamond on cast iron with a bit of lubrication works so well and why the modern ceramic particles provide rapid material removal rates. I may study this section some more. The details of how alloying and hardening steels improve abrasion resistance was interesting.
3. There is little chance that adhesive wear is important in tool edge dulling. The physics and chemistry for adhesive wear just aren't available for a cellulose contact with a metal. If their atoms did mingle, something unlikely, the stronger steel would pull particles of wood from the wood surface, not the other way around. Adhesive wear is observed for some kinds of plastic rubbing on steel but it is the plastic that looses material, not the steel.
3. While it is a fact that unless the hardness of the substrate is less than the abrasive particle abrasive wear can not occur, there are factors that can result in a soft material abrasively wearing a harder material. The classic example is pure soft coal abrading steel. This section will require more study than what I devoted to it.
4. There are other wear mechanisms that may be involved in dulling plane blades and the like. One possible candidate is corrosive wear. In one study it was found that wood with higher volatiles produced more wear.





