New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Woodies

Posts

Woodies

#1

Woodies

roninkokomo

Any of you made the transition from metal bench planes to woodies? New ones or vintage? How have the change worked out? What are the considerations?.

All input appreciated.

Ron

Re: Woodies

#2

going the other way

Bill Tindall

I started using Krenov style planes and a Primus of some sort. The problem is that I only need a plane from time to time in the course of fitting pieces into furniture. So when the needs arise and I reach for a plane it needs to work as expected without fiddling with the plane. Too much fiddling with these wooden planes when they sit for a while between needs.

For those that plane to plane I can understand the attraction of wood gliding on wood and shavings shooting out (when the cap iron is adjusted right). And they feel nice in the hand. But the fiddling was intolerable for my style of woodworking.

Re: Woodies

#3

Have both, use both.  Not moving in any direction.


Re: Woodies

#4

I've ended up with two shops.

Chuck Nickerson

At home I have a 6'x9' hand tool-only shop. I rent my brother's garage for my blended shop.

My woodies have all migrated to the HTO shop, and my metal planes live in the blended shop.

It helps me keep my mind-set correct while working.

Re: Woodies

#5

Re: Woodies

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Ron

I use both equally and interchangeably. I cannot say that I prefer one over the other. They have different charms, pros and cons.

Wood is light, slick, and warm. Metal is durable, heavy and clinical.

As the planes get bigger, I appreciate the lightness of wood. As the wood gets harder and the grain more interlocked, I prefer the extra mass of steel.

Sometimes it comes down to whatever is sharp! :)

Regards from Perth

Derek (working on building another woodie)

Re: Woodies

#6

With one exception, no...

John in NM

The exception is a scrub plane I made to replace the one that I broke.

I will certainly make some more if I ever line up the shop time, I have a nice piece of 12/4 mahogany for a jointer plane, and some cocobolo that would make a nice if small smoother.

I have several wood molding planes, though there is not really a common metal substitute for those, so I assume they don't enter into the question.

Re: Woodies

#7

Stephen Shepherd

Re: Woodies

Stephen Shepherd

I started out my apprenticeship with both, I had metal block and jack plane and an Ulmia wooden smoother. I only have one metal plane now, a rebate plane.

I like the feel of wooden planes, they don't damage things if you drop your plane on something you are working on. You can also drop a wooden plane on a concrete floor more than once. I seldom drop planes.

My reason for using wooden planes, most of them vintage is the better quality plane irons on old planes. Laminated blades are far superior to solid steel blades. I also have a few planes I have made and those too have laid steel blades.

Stephen

Re: Woodies

#8

Re: Woodies

david weaver

Attempted to a few years ago. But made the decision that using both types makes more sense than going one way or the other.

Still use both types. I personally wouldn't plan on buying some new wooden planes and then as part of the transaction just throw away all of my metal planes.

Re: Woodies

#9

Michael Donaldson

Both

Michael Donaldson

I have and use both. I find that each plane has its own personality and temperament, and I use that to choose which one to use for a given task.

Re: Woodies

#10

Re: going the other way

TomD

If there is a fiddle factor, there is something wrong with the plane. I had two planes in 30 years that were sensitive enough to be affected by seasonal moisture problems, one had bad wood in the block, and the other was an extreme plane and seems to have settled down in my new shop.

I also find initial setting is also faster with wood. I did that test a few weeks back where a plane from working to blade out to working was 15 seconds. There was about another 10 seconds to get a specific thou setting. I probably wouldn't have taken the extra time in the real world, but for the sake of not having someone ask me what was the size of the shavings before and after, I netted it out.

Re: Woodies

#11

Re: Woodies transitions

TomD

Purely on the transition, the two types of plane are pretty similar around the blades as far as the skills are concerned. Almost everything else is going to be a little different. So you are going to have to relearn everything. Some differences are slight, others might be more substantive.

I find the big problem is whether people want to be that guy. Some people are just more comfortable with technology, dials are good, tapping with hammers is bad. But the reality is that dials have backlash and a variety of other problems, while a tap of a given force with a given hammer, to a wedged blade can only move a given amount, it actually works better. But it seems primitive to people.

The key to having consistency is to have a process you repeat with every plane. Tend towards a light touch. So I support the blade in the mouth, which means a consistently above final starting depth. Then I hand tighten the wedge, or it might need a light tap. Then I tap for depth. Then I seat the wedge, which probably draws the blade deeper. So you either want to have accounted for that increase, or another way is to set the blade till it only touches the wood, then set the wedge harder/deeper blade, then tap to greater depth, knowing that with a hard set, blade movement will be finer.

Doesn't mater how you do it specifically, just have a consistent process, and proceed logically, and it should work great. If you aren't getting consistent results you don't have a consistent pre-shot routine.

Re: Woodies

#12

Re: Woodies

TomD

+1 on that, but let me play advocate a little...

"Wood is light, slick, and warm. Metal is durable, heavy and clinical."

Let me add that for me it is less about the materials, there are better materials, maybe, than wood. To me it is about the different formats, and the wedge etc... format is just better.

Wood is also durable. In the amateur shop they look hardly used after 40 years. they don't suffer if dropped, etc. Weight is basically never an advantage, but you can make light heavy, you can't make heavy light. Normally technical products want to be made light, then you can put the weight were it needs to be rather than were the structure says it has to be.

"As the planes get bigger, I appreciate the lightness of wood. As the wood gets harder and the grain more interlocked, I prefer the extra mass of steel."

Extra weight is always bad. Planes that need more weight to plane well are simply badly designed. A well designed plane use geometry and design, rather than weight. And weight not only tires the planer out, but reduces speed. Speed is part of the secret to planing since cutting power increases to the square of speed. More cutting power improves the quality of the cut, or the speed of stock removal.

"Sometimes it comes down to whatever is sharp"

So true, though since the wedged plane is a lot faster to cycle, it should be easier to keep sharp.

Re: Woodies

#13

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Both

Jim in Burlington ON

I have a few newer planes from Steve Knight and some that are from the 1800-1930's. You can certainly hog off more material with a wooden jointer. It seems to provide more feedback than a metal plane. To say that one or the other requires more skill or experience would be false. Sharpening has more to do with performance than any other factor. Personally I put the blade in while the wooden plane is flat on the bench then the wedge. Give one very light tap on the wedge and then plane away adjusting it as you go. Metal planes require some serious tuming to get great performance but can be tuned finer performance but this takes a bucket load of time and patience with the frog and sole. Metal block planes are far superior to a couple of woooden one's I have used. Infil planes are also a bunch of fun for final smoothing.

Re: Woodies

#14

Re: Woodies

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

+1 on that, but let me play advocate a little...

Hi Tom, all good points, but I will return your serve ...

Let me add that for me it is less about the materials, there are better materials, maybe, than wood. To me it is about the different formats, and the wedge etc... format is just better.

A number of my steel planes are designed with wedges, and so the format is the same. I do not differentiate the planes according to format as adjusting a wedge is for me about the same effort as adjusting a mechanism. The materials therefore are part of the difference.

Extra weight is always bad. Planes that need more weight to plane well are simply badly designed. A well designed plane use geometry and design, rather than weight. And weight not only tires the planer out, but reduces speed. Speed is part of the secret to planing since cutting power increases to the square of speed. More cutting power improves the quality of the cut, or the speed of stock removal.

I do not see extra mass as a way of compensating for a poor design. I see extra mass as aiding in planing especially hard woods. Mass aids in creating momentum. This is not in place of a sharp blade, but an addition to it. While we have been discussing and advocating the chip breaker effect, mouth size also has a part to play, and mass adds to the part played by a small mouth.

Two of my favourite woodies (that I built) ..

15" Jack plane in Mesquite (this uses a 5/16" thick 2" wide D2 blade):


36" Jointer in Jarrah (3/16" tapered 3" wide Berg blade):


And a light BU infill I built from a Stanley #3 (this has a 25 degree bed)..


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Woodies

#15

Re: Woodies

TomD

As usual we are in near total agreement, except:

"I do not see extra mass as a way of compensating for a poor design. I see extra mass as aiding in planing especially hard woods."

I don't doubt you do, but it seems to help because the plane design is bad. Or if one prefers, the design such that only extra weight will help. If you could get the same increment of performance without mass, what would the mass be doing for you? Just tiring you out and slowing you down.

" Mass aids in creating momentum. This is not in place of a sharp blade, but an addition to it. While we have been discussing and advocating the chip breaker effect, mouth size also has a part to play, and mass adds to the part played by a small mouth."

Momentum is just mass times velocity so you can get it however. Let's say you had an offroad vehicle, and when you came to the nasty bits, mud holes, or tottering on the edge of clift, better still mud holes tottering on cliffs... How would you feel about the following design:

"I can't specifically control it's speed or direction, or get it started again when it stops, but at least I have a lot of momentum so once it gets going, it tends to stay in motion." To me that is an inferior design to one that just works.

Re: Woodies

#16

Re: Woodies

Kees

I totally dig wooden planes. But I find them still more difficult to use. In order to adres that shortcoming in my skill, I plan to ban the iron planes from the shop when I start with the next big project.

Re: Woodies

#17

Infill Planes

david weaver

One of my favorite planes is an 18 inch panel plane. It weighs almost 9 pounds. I don't consider it especially difficult to use, because you only have to push it forward, and not down (if you push down on it by accident, you're in for a long day with a lot of resistance from the sole).

I compare that quite often to other planes that I'd use for the same intermediate function dimensioning wood and say that the weight is a bonus in a heavy cut or in a very hard wood - the cut is smoother and it is much easier on your elbows and shoulders.

If you're pulling the planes, the issue is different, there is not the jarring force into your elbows and shoulders, you just lean harder when pulling a plane instead.

But on a push plane, in really hard wood where you're doing something other than smoothing, the extra mass is not a design flaw or evidence of anything more than the mass being present.

Sometimes I read too much on the internet and don't use the panel plane for a while (choosing instead to use a matheison plane or another similar maker) and I forget just how nice the panel plane is to use. then I come back to it hitting the gauge line on all the way around thicknessing a panel (fresh in my head, just did the same thing last night) and I remember just how lovely of a plane it is, and how I feel no less tired using the plane than I do any other plane. And certainly less jarred.

Re: Woodies

#18

Re: Infill Planes

TomD

I wouldn't really argue with the idea that extra weight is a good design feature on planes bad enough to require it. I don't like 7 pound planes, that cut no better that 1.5 pound planes because I normally end up lifting them at some point. Planing edges normally isn't too bad but on panels where it comes down to the lower back, not happy. That was hard work when I was young.

Re: Woodies

#19

Re: Infill Planes

david weaver

Panels are actually where I like the heavy plane. You don't really ever have to lift them aside from lifting the back of the plane just slightly to keep the iron from riding and wearing on the backstroke.

I don't like a 9 pound plane on edges, because you do have to lift them.

I couldn't tolerate planing hard maple or beech with a 1 1/2 pound plane on the push.

It isn't a matter of bad design, unless you believe anything that's ever pushed is a bad design by that feature alone.

I use everything I can find so far, including japanese and chinese design planes, just to get my fingers on everything, and I haven't found anything that will match a western panel plane for panels. My back doesn't complain about them, and my hands and elbows don't absorb jarring on harder woods. It isn't an inferior design for that kind of work, it's superior.

Re: Woodies

#20

Re: Infill Planes

TomD

Yeah pushing is bad because the hook effect is wrong. An anchor self sets, but if you take the hook part off you need a lot of weight to hold it down. A Japanese type plane self-sets, a push plane needs to be held down. It really isn't push vs pull, it is hook vs no hook.

Was using my infill block plane to cut a scarf joint tonight, and it is awesome.

Re: Woodies

#21

Re: Infill Planes

david weaver

I'm content to figure we're always going to have different priorities about how things should be done.

I have enjoyed every good plane design I've used, as long as the maker has properly executed it.

It's pretty rare that I don't cycle through a few different types even in a given shop session (by rule, the jack is almost always japanese, after that, it could be anything).

Re: Woodies

#22

Re: Wooden bench planes

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Ron,

Woodies are a different experience from metal. They breathe. Hammer becomes one of the most-used tools in the shop. You get into habits, like a quick sole check if you haven't used the plane in a while. I like a granite plate with fine PSA paper on it--run the sole over it as a diagnostic--mainly looking for scratches at the front of mouth, so you know the mouth is firmly on the work. Sharpen more often, because the woodie doesn't power through wood--it has to slice its way. You want it always sharp so that it is always pulling itself into the wood.

Some things woodies do better than anything else IMO. Edge-jointing comes to mind. On a piece of case goods, there's lots of edge joining. Not only the top, but also drawer bottoms and dust panels. For these internal parts, I pull out shorts and offcuts and maybe join 5 or 6 sticks for a drawer bottom. I find it very satisfying, even though plywood would get it done faster. Anyway, if you do lots of edge joining, a woodie makes it very satisfying--it's light, has a very prominent reference for 'plumb', and is every second giving feedback.

With woodies, I think narrower. Don't want to be muscling up wide shavings. Maybe slightly more camber. Much prefer a 2" smoother, or even a little less, to a 2-1/4". I think one reason people like their ECE Primus smoothers is that they are 48mm (1-7/8"). Also, the ones with the lignum soles are very stable. An all-time favorite of mine--and I mean forever--is a C&W try plane or jointer--I use it like a jointer for edges--which has a 2" blade and is 26"-27" long. So handy and maneuverable compared to a 2-1/2" jointer.

Woodies make great fore planes, or long jacks. Moxon talked about fore planes as being the sole roughing plane. The thing is, the fore plane is flattening while it's taking out high spots. It's not going to dig into any low spots and make them lower. If you want to get your feet wet, think about a woodie fore plane or edge jointer.

Japanese planes are a whole other world. But I will mention one application that anyone might benefit from. Trimming the pins on a drawer. A 60mm Japanese plane is wonderful for this job--low angle is good for end grain, and you get a long registration with the Japanese plane. And because you're pulling, fixturing can be as simple as holding the drawer against your stomach with one hand, and planing with the other hand, pulling into yourself. Skew the plane a little.

People disagree on how woodies react to climate changes. We have real moderate weather here, but I know of people in more changeable climates who've had woodies move a lot, where they kept them in garages and the like. Controlled climate is your friend, especially if the plane is not being used every day.

Wiley