New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Cap iron Article suggestion

Posts

Re: Cap iron Article suggestion

#26

Re: What is this cap iron effect and...

Patrick Gibbons

I learned about this when I first started using planes. I thought this was common wisdom. Must admit, I've never really found the sweet spot. There is a constant adjustment of thickness of shavings depending on what is being done. I don't adjust the cap iron with each shaving adjustment. What am I missing?

Re: Cap iron Article suggestion

#27

I think that Russell's main protest....

Bill Tindall

... is that the plane was seemingly modified for no useful purpose. I don't know enough plane mechanics to judge, but given Mark's knowledge, skill and experience in planing I am willing to believe that the modified plane does things that were useful to Mark that an unmodified plane would not. It would be presumptuous to criticize the modifications, even if it was a more valuable plane, unless one understood the details of why it was modified and how it was to be used in its modified state.

Maybe Mark was simply experimenting with the modifications to see if they offered benefit. In such a case using a common plane made good sense.

Re: Cap iron Article suggestion

#29

Re: Cap iron Article suggestion

William Duffield

Question for Mark: Is your cap screw loose enough that you can adjust the blade and chip breaker separately with your hammer while everything is screwed together in the plane?

Re: Cap iron Article suggestion

#30

Re: Cap iron Article suggestion

Mark Hennebury

Hi,

In the past 30 plus years this $50 hand plane has planed thousands of board feet of lumber, it has edge jointed hundreds of boards for glue-up to within .001" for tables and cabinets, and finished planed table tops to a beautiful smoothness and clarity. It has made countless thousands of incredibly delicate and fascinating shavings. It is comfortable to use, accurate and precise, and easy and fast to adjust to with absolute precision with a delicate tap of a small hammer.

I am a woodworker:The value of a tool is in what it can do.

My goal was always: to achieve the best results in the most efficient way.

I have no other interest in tools. I have no bias, no preconceived concept of what a tool should or should not be; whether or not it is old or new, original or modified.

Function, first and foremost.

Re: Cap iron Article suggestion

#31

Re: Where is the "waste"?

Mark Hennebury

Hi Bill,

Thanks for your kind words.

Sorry for being absent for so long. I will make an effort to keep in touch.

Re: Cap iron Article suggestion

#32

Re: Cap iron Article suggestion

Mark Hennebury

Hi William,

while the screw is fairly snug, they can still be adjusted with a sharp tap. You may notice that the chipbreaker has the top corners clipped off so that i can tap either the chipbreaker or the blade.

Re: Cap iron Article suggestion

#33

Re: Cap iron Article suggestion

William Duffield

Oh, yes, I noticed. That's way I asked the question. :D …Just to be sure, and just in case someone else who's trying to figure out what's going on here hadn't figured it out yet.

It would seem to me to be an improvement if L-N, Clifton and the others provided a snecked "improved" chip breaker.

http://www.lie-nielsen.com/images/cb_lg.jpg

If so, there might be just enough play in their depth adjuster mechanisms to allow you to adjust the chip breaker setting on the fly, without resorting to the major surgery you've done to your Record, thereby totally wiping out any residual "collector" value of the plane. ;)

Re: Cap iron Article suggestion

#34

More on the  Cap Iron effect, history and employed

Bill Tindall

Further evidence that this technique was well known in the past and apparently then lapsed, I got this note from Will Neptune after he saw the video...

"You sent me a link to it earlier. It did confirm exactly what the old-timer at North Bennet St School said, though that was lore, intuition and experience."

It makes one wonder what else was known back then that hasn't been successfully passed along.

I used this technique tonight for an edge. Normally I edge joint on the jointer. However in this case I was joining two boards (cut from a single board) for the top of daughter's chest of drawers. This board was very special as evidenced that it was sawed from a walnut veneer log back in 1970 and kept till a special occasion arose. Edge to edge it is barely wide enough for the top so I could not afford to loose much from edge jointing. One edge that needed jointing was convex and these edges are difficult to render straight on the jointer without sacrificing considerable width fiddling to get straightness.

I got it somewhat straighter on the jointer and then refined the edge to perfectly mate using the hand plane. There were several grain reversals along the length. Planing would have been risky for me had I not had the benefit of the cap iron effect to make these grain reversals irrelevant. It looks so strange to see shavings rising straight up from the plane mouth. All done with a $50 plane.

Re: Cap iron Article suggestion

#35

Re: Say it again Bill

TomD

There was a well known canoeist who used to give style demos with a beat to heck Grumman canoe and a shovel. He could make that canoe do stuff most people at the time could not approach. But that does not make a shovel or a trashed canoe state of the art equipment. I am sure that whatever I can do, I can do it with a Blue Chip chisel, any old steel plane, saws are a little more iffy... Not the relevant criterion. What is the saying? "It is a poor craftsman who blames his tool" I have always thought that a little silly, but it does apply at some level.

Re: Cap iron Article suggestion

#36

Re: Japanese planes

TomD

Cool. Does beg the question for me though, at what point, do people in general, not people like Mark who have been there and done that, just try a Japanese plane. It is years of watching people sneak closer and closer as they try one new thing, then another, and yet at the end of the day, no takers. At seminars when I have pulled one out, people are pretty interested, but it seems some huge barrier unless people come face to face.

Re: Cap iron Article suggestion

#37

Why do they need to?

david weaver

Seriously, not a snarking troll question, but why does everyone even have to try one? For a lot of people, trying one would solve a problem they don't have.

Re: Cap iron Article suggestion

#38

Re: I think that Russell's main protest....

david weaver

Well, most of us know better than to think that anything of Mark's isn't used, but my point was even more broad than that. Even if mark had made nothing but a pine bench that he intended to let rot over the course of 5 years in his garden, it's his plane, it's a common one, and he can do whatever he wants as long as he doesn't come on here is a rank beginner and tell everyone his design works better if it in fact doesn't.

We know mark's not a rank beginner, so that's a strawman.

But we wring our hands about $40 tools a lot on here, and quite often the people wringing their hands may think nothing of spending $50 on dinner.

There will be no tool that collectors will not drive up the price on when the supply gets limited. At least no desirable tool. We'll never "use them all up" with the last one being bought for 10 cents, gone like the the passenger pigeon.

Re: Cap iron Article suggestion

#39

Re: What is this cap iron effect and...

david weaver

The sweet spot is one where it's almost impossible to generate tearout and where the surface finish is still bright and clean with no evidence of fibers being crushed back into it.

If you're there, then you're there. If not, there's still some tinkering that can be done.

I guess a lot of us knew the cap iron worked, but we thought it was too fiddly to set it properly to do work. You can set it in a general area so that varying thickness of shavings within a range won't make it necessary to make any adjustments. For example, if you're think of taking shavings from nothing to 4 thousandths of an inch with a smoother, that's taken care of pretty easily by one setting.

Re: Cap iron Article suggestion

#40

Re: Oh, reason not the need

TomD

Which are you talking about the breakers or the planes. In any case, the idea that people should only buy tools to solve problems they have is:

a) going to come as a serious reversal of fortune to the people who sell tools, since that describes an awful lot of stuff

b) if they had tried these tools early enough in their careers, they would have had a lot less problems to solve.

But the point of my anecdote was that to see them was pretty much to love them. And the folks who show up at seminars are pretty average sensible in my experience. They liked what they saw, so it was not going to take much to get them to try them.