New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Cap iron Article suggestion

Posts

Cap iron Article suggestion

#1

Cap iron Article suggestion

Bill Tindall

This would be a good time for someone that is a clear writer, experienced planer and good teacher to summarize what someone new to the topic needs to do to their plane to evaluate the cap iron effect for their needs.

Topics:

1. how to prepare the blade for this kind of planing. (it would seem that something nearly straight across would be essential)

2. How to prepare the cap iron-smoothing, angles, etc.

3. How to prepare(set up) the plane

4. How to install the cap iron on the blade.

5. How to know if you got it right , or wrong. (testing)

This Article might best be done by someone offering a rough draft and then letting the WC audience review and make suggestions. I believe such an article would be of great benefit to someone wanting to try this mode of planing.

Re: Cap iron Article suggestion

#2

Re: Cap iron Article suggestion

Mark Hennebury

Hi Bill,

The short version:

1. Strip the plane down

2. Throw away the depth adjustment knob, lever and pin.

3. Throw away the lateral adjustment lever.

4. Cut the blade in half.

5. Cut the chipbreaker in half.

6. Cut the lever and thetop part ofthe lever cap off.

7. Lap the matin suface of the lever cap.

8. grind the top corners of the chipbreaker off.

9. Cut the top of the frog off.

10. Grind the top corners of the frog off.

11. Lap the frog mating face and blade contact face.

12.Clean the frog mating surface inthe plane.

13. File the throat opening straight.

14. File the inside of the throat opening on an angle oppsite to the angle of the frog.

14. Hollow grind the blade.

15. Flatten out the chipbreaker a good bit, ( a few swift belts with a hammer)

16. Lightley hollow grind the frnot bevel of the chipbreaker.

17. hone a small micro bevel at the tip of the chipbreaker.

18. Round the adjoining faces of the micro bevel and the hollow ground main bevel with a small radius.

19. reassemble everything and tighten up

20. Adjust the frog to set the throat opening, dont tighten too much, make sure that you can make some minor adjustments with the hammer.

21. file and sand the handle to fit your hand.

22. Lap the plane,( with the blade drawn back a bit)

for a minute, check, hollow grind lightley all the high spots, lap again check , hollow grind, lap repeat. lap until it looks like a mirror ( about 8 hours)

23. Remove blade assembly, dissassemble blade and chipbreaker.

24. Sharpen blade ( separate course)

25 reassemble blade and chipbreaker, tighten lightley adjust with a small hammer, use light reflection to sight, tighten.

26. place blade/chipbreaker in plane,put on the lever cap, tight screw

27. Hold plane upside down and sight along the sole, adjust blade depth with a few taps of the hammer. Tap blade for more depth. Tap top of frog for less.

Tap top corners of blade to adjust blade parallel to sole. Tap either side od the back of the frog to close or adjust the throat opening tap the plane frog seat to open throat.

Make shavings.

Dont loose your hammer,

sell all the parts that you took off on eBay.


Re: Cap iron Article suggestion

#3

Re: Cap iron Article suggestion

david weaver

gad....10% of that is necessary to get the plane to perform at the same level.

Re: Cap iron Article suggestion

#4

Re: Cap iron Article suggestion

TomD

You should write it Bill, or Steve, or both of you. If someone doesn't get on it, it will get done by people who didn't make whatever just happened, happen.

Re: Cap iron Article suggestion

#5

Re: Cap iron Article suggestion

Kees

I am afraid an article like that would shy a few people away....

Re: Cap iron Article suggestion

#6

Re: Cap iron Article suggestion

Mark Hennebury

You are probably correct; Lets call this version "optional modifications"

Throw out all the cutting and choping and do just the basic clean up for starters.

Re: Cap iron Article suggestion

#7

What is important .....

Bill Tindall

is that it gets done by someone that has the skills to communicate the information effectively and planing credibility that the information will be accepted sufficient to encourage beginners to try it. I don't have the planing experience to do it.

Re: Cap iron Article suggestion

#8

Somewhere around item 11......

Bill Tindall

....I went out and affectionately cuddled the Performix drum sander I bought this week. Its owner got "sick of woodworking", quite and is selling his stuff. He made boxes to sell. I guess one could get sick of that but I expect to be making stuff as long as I am breathing.

That is a lovely picture from of a well adjusted plane, but truthfully, the Kees video had more positive impact on me.

Re: Cap iron Article suggestion

#9

Re: What is important .....

TomD

Credibility is a public currency and none of us has that, that is why we are here. Well I guess Adam has it, and obviously Ellis if he wanted to.

If you want someone with credibility they will be along. Chris has already done a piece on it mentioning David. That will catch a lot of eyes. This, while loopy, is the biggest real thing that has happened. Diamond sharpening was awesome, but there were ways of sharpening. And there were products to add to catalogs. Breakergate strikes people as new and useful. One can argue about that, but one can't argue about the impact. So just stand back, someone will take credit for it, or further reveal it.

If you are talking about an article for a magazine, that could be added here after a decent interval, then it doesn't have to be perfect, that is why mags have editors. Ellis would know more about that. But when I had submitted articles in the past, they never got even seriously trimmed. But in theory they are willing to make major rewrites for a good piece. And certainly your writing, Bill, is good enough. Narrow focus, write it with the needs of the reader in mind and zero ego, which I think is what you do.

Basically start with the benefit: Most woodworkers would love to be able to plane a piece of wood... But are put off by the: list barriers... But what if there was a way that anyone could do, and most likely with the plane you already own.

Then a few paragraphs on the basic setting. Lots of pictures of the plane, you think readers are most likely to have and want to see in a mag, which in my mind is an LN, because it is more appealing than and old rusty job, but like the plane they already own. Maybe a screen shot from the video. Pictires sell articles, the text is not the main thing particularly since the editors can change that. The flag raising on Iwo was a great picture, you shouldn't shoot that in head office back stateside (though it was posed in country), but you can do anything to the text.

Then you just end up with a bit of colour about how this exploded on the net, and how folks who have tried it are getting great results.

Check the space an average article of this size takes up in your target mag, and write to that length. Read/revise for spelling, style, ego, and content. They will do the rest.

My guess is someone has already written this article since normally it takes quite a while to get published for it to come out during the year it may already be in the bag.

Re: Cap iron Article suggestion

#10

Re: Somewhere around item 11......

CStan

We'll all figure out how to overcomplicate this whole capiron business beyond setting the thing uber-close and opening the mouth a tad (only if necessary, hat tip to Mr. Hennebury's ability to chop down and tune to apparent perfection, an old Record plane).

Somebody has already predicted the introduction into the marketplace of some sort of jig that will allow the frustrated machinist (oops, I meant woodworker), to "set it and forget it" (capiron that is) right at three tenth's of a millimeter (isn't this the distance Kato recommended? I've forgotten) and then dial the setting it up or down with the finest machined screw known to man. NASA will want to license the technology. For something.

Remember, that this is all being applied to hand planes for hand tool woodworking. Anybody ever visited a Medieval British or Continental European cathedral? They seemed to have gotten along, right? So, it's easy to come full circle back to a Larry Williams way of thinking. And that's OK too.

It'll probably be at this point that I glaze over and go back to setting it, simply, pretty darned close and arguing that my surfaces were fine before all of this crap started anyway. I like making cob-web like shavings with a scraper anyway. See, I've already started to glaze over. ADD strikes again.

Re: Cap iron Article suggestion

#11

Just wait ..

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Charles, just wait until someone brings out a cap iron with a micrometer adjuster for depth and angle at the leading edge! :D

There will be versions for Stanley/Record (that goes without saying), and LN, and retrofitting Spier and Norris infills, and of course not forgetting your ECE! :)

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Cap iron Article suggestion

#12

And a laser


Re: Cap iron Article suggestion

#13

I nominate...

James Watriss

I'd volunteer, but I've only been loosely following the threads on this.

I've been interested in reading a boiled-down, comprehensible overview, because, to be plain, the threads do go on.

I don't like to be volunteered for something. So, I'm not generally prone to volunteer anyone else for something.

But given his extensive experience, and reputation for trying to spread the word on the topic, I'd really like to hear Warren's summary of both the subject matter under review, and his own experiences in putting it to work.

Re: Cap iron Article suggestion

#14

Re: Cap iron Article suggestion

Russell Hardy

That is a terrible waste of a perfectly good Record plane. They don't even make those anymore. If that is the type of plane you want to use why not just make one out of wood and buy a shorter and thicker plane iron. What a waste!

Re: Cap iron Article suggestion

#15

Where is the "waste"?

Bill Tindall

It is a tool. In my world a wasted plane is one that is unused for making stuff. If you go to Mark's web site you will see that he uses his tools to stunning effect. What would you have built, or done with, with this plane?

Re: Cap iron Article suggestion

#16

Right There

Russell Hardy

The waste is in perverting the intent of the original tool. I would have restored it to work the way it was intended to work, which is what the original poster was actually asking. I tune and restore tools all the time and none of my tools sit unused in my shop.

Re: Cap iron Article suggestion

#17

I'm with Bill...

John in NM

A wasted plane is one that sits unused in a box or on a shelf. Although I wouldn't personally spend the time on all those mods, I see nothing wrong with doing it if that's what the owner wants to do. Its his plane and his business what he does with it.

Another way to look at it is all the collectible Records just got a smidge more valuable, if one is into such things.

Re: Cap iron Article suggestion

#18

Re: I'm with Bill...

Russell Hardy

Sure it's his tool and whatever he does with it is his business, but he's removed the functionality that was designed into it in the first place. Everytime he wants to make an adujstment he has to stop planing and pick up his hammer. To me, that's wasting time. I can back off or advance the blade on my metal planes without lifting them off the work piece. That's the idea behind that thumb screw. If you want you can tear the injection system off your car engine and install a carburetor too. Or you can put extended forks on your Triumph motorcycle. Same thing

Re: Cap iron Article suggestion

#19

Re: I'm a little bit confused...

david weaver

... we're wringing our hands over modification of a common Record plane?

It's not like it's a dovetailed norris or a holtey A13.

There are thousands and thousands of them, and makers currently making better tools. It's a throwaway.

Re: Cap iron Article suggestion

#20

more to the point......

Bill Tindall

go to Marks web site and see the furniture he makes. Anyone that makes stuff at least this quality and design is free to criticize his tools and techniques. If you haven't seen Marks work, and/or do this quality of work, maybe it is a bit presumptuous to believe he has in some way lessened the utility of the tool to make furniture, rather than enhanced it.

Personally, I have never met anyone more knowledgeable than Mark in the field of planing and plane mechanics. .

Re: Cap iron Article suggestion

#21

Say it again Bill

Ron Harper

I certainly agree with Bill. The value of ones opinion on a Woodworking Forum is very much influenced by the quality of woodworking done by that individual.

Ron a Kokomo Galoot

Re: Cap iron Article suggestion

#22

Re: even without the furniture

david weaver

..I think he could do whatever he wants to a common plane like that, regardless of his furniture background.

It's common, a common plane, as dead common as anything except stanley. Collectors will make sure we know that the supply of a given plane is getting tight by driving up the prices.

I have a record plane. It was a friend's dad's plane, his dad was a tradesman. It came to me with some major flaws and a stanley lever cap. That was his dad's plane and the friend is a woodworker (he prefers nicer tools). He was going to throw it away if I didn't take it.

As yet, I haven't used it for anything, and it's black now instead of blue.

Re: Cap iron Article suggestion

#23

What is this cap iron effect and...

Patrick Gibbons

... Why does one need to mutilate a plane to achieve it? I guess I've been under a rock or something but I haven't got a clue. And no jokes please. (I probably wouldn't get them either.).

Re: Cap iron Article suggestion

#24

Re: What is this cap iron effect and...

david weaver

* Use cap iron to reduce tearout, despite claims of some, it works

* no need to change most planes to do it (bench planes like record or stanley need little adjustment for it to work well).

Re: Cap iron Article suggestion

#25

Re: What is this cap iron effect and...

TomD

Place cap iron close enough to edge of blade to see change in how escaping shaving leaves plane, more upright. The iron needs to be really close. The shaving may not have curl. This is the way it has always been with cap irons, but it turns out few people knew it. Those of us who knew it, thought other people did, as they did, but when I checked all the places I thought it was spoken about it turned out to be that most were on about something else. The place where you certainly would have been exposed to it is with Japanese planes since the breaker is interdependently adjusted, it floats above the blade, but is not attached to it. And these planes are naturally used this way. Though even there it turned out that breakers are possibly non-traditional so they they got onto this stuff post contact. It is also the case that this is not really a big deal when you are taking heavy shavings, or possibly was being done with heavy shavings. Is a big deal with fat finishing shavings, and is pointless with the finest finishing shavings because those shavings are so fine they are not stiff.

Big pay off is less tearout with a decent shaving thickness therefore fast finish planing in certain work.