New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Christian Becksvoort's Panel and Frame Backs

Posts

Christian Becksvoort's Panel and Frame Backs

#1

Christian Becksvoort's Panel and Frame Backs

Texchappy

In the midst of a discussion a week or so ago, (I believe it was about attaching molding), there was a link to Christian Becksvoort's site where he talked about using panel and frame backs.

A trip to a local furniture store with my Father in Law brought it back to mind. The Amish furniture they sold had a back that felt like cardboard when I tapped it.

Got me thinking about that design aspect again. How much does it add to the life span of a piece? How do you think he attaches the panel and frame to the back? Think this was discussed a little in the other thread but don't think it was finally resolved.

TIA,

Tony

Re: Christian Becksvoort's Panel and Frame Backs

#2

Re: Christian Becksvoort's Panel and Frame Backs

TomD

Structurally it is at best equal to plywood. Plywood is ideal for panels, while solid wood is ideal for elements, in many cases. A panel is a just a poor man's version of plywood, imagine the work that would be required to make plywood by hand. I have done it often, but normally with pre-cut veneers. F&Ps are however an interesting design element, and more likely harmonize with the rest of the piece. There are also similar details in drawer bottoms, there solid wood can be the superior choice, and can contribute to novel construction in the very best quality drawers.

As to how they are attached, they can be glued on, but it is difficult to get perfect grain performance to the point where the detail will survive without any hardware over the centuries. There are integrated frames that do not require any hardware. One is simply smaller cabinets that use a groove in the back to hold a panel, the sides acting as the frame. Krenov is a master of that. Grooves can also be used to carry frames and panels. And units that use side posts to carry panels in the side and back of the carcass. Where these strategies are used, the back floats, and there is not a ring frame effect to add massive additional strength, so one simply has to take that into account.

Re: Christian Becksvoort's Panel and Frame Backs

#3

Re: Christian Becksvoort's Panel and Frame Backs

roger lance

In the older discussion, David Barnett was hoping to see if he had the information on C. Becksvort's method of attaching frame and panel backs to his case pieces in some notes he had from a lecture or class with Christian who builds furniture in the Shaker style. Remember that Becksvort's furniture is the top of the rock in this category.....there are no short cuts taken....no incorporation of cheaper materials to keep the price of this work down (like the backing materials frequently used on most commercial furniture). His frame and panel backs are things of beauty in their own right and are carefully fitted to a rabbet on the cabinet. Since these backs are frame and panel, he could glue them in and not have to worry about wood movement.....or they could be mechanically attached to the case from the inside which would allow for the back to be removed if needed....since there would really be infrequent need to remove the back, I'm voting for glueing the panel to the case. Christian has written on various furniture builds in Fine Woodworking and perhaps someone will find the relevant information and re-state it here.

Re: Christian Becksvoort's Panel and Frame Backs

#4

Re: Christian Becksvoort's Panel and Frame Backs

Martin S.

The following quote is from a CHB article from FWW from issue 206. Article is "Shaker Chest of Drawers".

"A frame-and-panel back, although more work, gives as much diagonal racking resistance as plywood (unlike nailed ship lapped, tongue-and-groove boards) and looks much better. Once the case and all the dividers are in place, make the frame and-panel back, leaving it a little too wide so you can sneak up on the perfect fit with a block plane. I profile the four panels with a 22 1⁄2º panel-raising bit. I pin the rails and stiles for extra support and a nice design detail. Then I sand the inside face and fit the back to the case. I glue the back in place, secure it with small brads, counter sink them, and plug the holes."

Re: Christian Becksvoort's Panel and Frame Backs

#5

Re: Christian Becksvoort's Panel and Frame Backs

roger lance

Thanks Martin....I'm a little surprised by the use of brads....but there it is.

Re: Christian Becksvoort's Panel and Frame Backs

#6

an alternate opinion

Bill Tindall

If the case is so flimsy that the back panel becomes structural I think the problem is better cured with better design. A case with dovetailed drawer blades will not rack. That said, I like a frame and panel back because it uses up otherwise useless lumber (short and thin pieces) and it looks good and therefore provides versatility for how the piece can be used.

There will be occasion in the life of something like a chest of drawers where it will be handy to remove the back. Hence, I screw the panel on the back.

Re: Christian Becksvoort's Panel and Frame Backs

#7

Re: an alternate opinion

roger lance

A Becksvoort case is anything but flimsy....the drawer dividers are dovetailed into the case sides (I believe both front and back)....sides and top are, of course, dovetailed....they are well made case goods as are yours, Bill....frame and panel backs may be my next advancement of pieces I make which I've not done as yet as I expect my case work to sit against a wall....so this question of how to attach a frame and panel back is of interest to me....it seems, that if you are going to the bother of making a frame and panel back, you would want to attach it with as little "disfigurement" to the look of the back as possible which is why I'd think that securing with screws from the inside of the case would be the way to go.....but a stuck drawer or some other issue that might motivate you to remove the back might also prevent you from removing the back from the inside. These are the type of contradictions that arise in design....analyze the possibilities and make your choices/compromises.

Re: Christian Becksvoort's Panel and Frame Backs

#8

Re: an alternate opinion

TomD

It isn't always true that relying on the back panel means it was badly designed. I would argue the opposite in appropriate cases. Of course if the back needs a panel, then what about the front, in some case it has frames also. But anyway.

There are many pieces that are at a scale where weight is actually an issue, and they were designed with moving locations in mind. Today, we build a small fraction of the styles, and an even smaller fraction of the pieces within styles. But some of the pieces I saw as a child were extremely lightly built. While it is apples and oranges, I hold in mind the thought that trimarans up to around 40 feet, ocean going sailboats, use planking of the same type as is used in sock drawer bottoms. Today we vastly overbuilt.

And the other thing I have learned, having been brought up in boats and furniture to believe that glue was stronger than anything else, is that fasteners are required at times. Glue can start coming apart within 20 years with stuff like dowels, orther joints follow over time. A frame back is not dimensionally stable, it is highly stable, but not identical to the carcass, and it can work free over time. But screws will last indefinitely. There are cases were metal is an enemy of long term durability also.

The idea of screws from the inside is cool. For myself I am always patient enough to wait for the season, and then adjust the piece as required. But I guess one couldn't sell furniture like that. I have never used a pocket screw, but one of those from inside would also work.

I was joking about plywood. It would be hard to make by hand. I do vacuum bag my own for certain things. It is stronger than panels which is one of the original questions. But obviously it is not used in a lot of furniture, though there are molded plywood pieces of the highest quality.

Re: Christian Becksvoort's Panel and Frame Backs

#9

a third view

roninkokomo

Aren't we talking about something like a chest of drawers here?? and Not a bridge abutment? I am thinking Mr. Becksvoort's case work is pretty good. Maybe the back is a way of saying somebody who really cares has been here.

Just a thought

I remember Mike Speas in a class once telling us. " You guys are building some skills. You can build stuff that will last hundreds of years. Let's work on building something that somebody will want the keep that long."

Ron

Re: Christian Becksvoort's Panel and Frame Backs

#10

Re: a third view

TomD

I think everyone is saying that, Ron. Why build anything in wood with hand tools etc... if beauty isn't at the core of it. But just because it is beautiful, doesn't mean we need to circulate inaccurate structural ideas, or waste material, or overbuild. I would prefer to at the minimum, know what I was doing, then I have the choice to proceed one way or another.

Many of our aesthetic choices are based on structural needs, much of the basic language someone like CB is using, is based on structural elements like dovetails. The FP is a structural and wood movement practicality raised to an aesthetic level, when originally it was just the best way to get the job done. And the OP did ask about longevity. It isn't as easy as it sounds to make stuff that lasts 100 years, many luxurious details don't work. And fewer still are making stuff that is easy to repair.

Re: Christian Becksvoort's Panel and Frame Backs

#11

Re: a third view

roninkokomo

I'd bet on a Becksvoort chest being pretty solid. Could we make is more solid by gluing and/or screwing 3/4 MDF or plywood onto the thing? Yeah maybe. But how much strong do you need?