New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

The Jim Tolpin Exercises

Posts

The Jim Tolpin Exercises

#1

The Jim Tolpin Exercises

Texchappy

Gone back and read The New Traditional Woodworker a second time. Makes a lot more sense now. I think I'm going to do the learning exercises from this book (as I already have it).

He takes you step by step through the following shop tools:

A Wooden Straightedge

Try Square

Winding Sticks

Face Planing Stop

Bench Hook Pair

Edge Planing Stop

Sticking Board

Work Bench Tote

Oiling Pad

Diagonal testing stick

Vise for sharpening saws and scrapers

Saw bench pair

Drawing bows

Should provide a pretty good base.

Re: The Jim Tolpin Exercises

#2

Re: The Jim Tolpin Exercises

TomD

Cool, the Woodwright shop also has a lot of interesting projects, the video for the last few years is online. There is even a CS appearance or so. While Roy hams it up, he got to what Chris has broadly done, first. There is also a good piece on Japanese tools.

Re: The Jim Tolpin Exercises

#3

Woodwright’s shop online

Texchappy

Been watching them. I think I’ve watched all of them at least twice that are available.

Re: The Jim Tolpin Exercises

#4

What wood for straight edges and squares?

Texchappy

The book says to use straight grained wood, hard enough that it won’t be easily damaged but soft enough to work easily with hand tools.

Local place has: poplar, yellow pine, walnut, cherry, red oak, and white oak. From the very little I know it sounds like walnut and cherry may be the best options out of that lot.

If I order online then more options open up, but I’m not sure that’s cost effective because I’ve never done it.

So what would your recommendations be?

TIA,

Tony

Re: The Jim Tolpin Exercises

#5

Walnut and cherry is what he recommends


Re: The Jim Tolpin Exercises

#6

Re: What wood for straight edges and squares?

TomD

White oak would be my choice, or cherry. Cherry has the finest grain. Most walnut is pretty easily dented, but more stuff works than people will say works. By the way, time to start hording local wood. Getting radial pieces for tools is easiest out of firewood.

My maple square that I did as an early slip joint exercise from a Krenov book (my design, his joint), was made of maple, and that is a great option.

ECE is the only company I know of that still sell all wooden squares, and they are hornbeam (Hmm couldn't find one). I don't like it as well as the maple, though the maple is a little hard to stop sliding around. I'm sure there are many others. Wooden squares are actually pretty great. Plus, I think they are pretty good exercises in learning to trust wood. My experience of woodworkers is for the most part they are metal tool users, not surprisingly, and don't trust wood. Learning to trust wood as a serious technical material opens up a lot of interesting options, if a person is inclined in that way.

Re: The Jim Tolpin Exercises

#7

Re: What wood for straight edges and squares?

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

Way back when we used to build lots of stuff out of cast steel and iron in this country, the pattern maker's first choice for building patterns was Prunus serotina, or black cherry. I suppose there were many other species that might have worked, but for stability, ease of carving, tight grain, and availability, cherry was most often the wood of choice, at least in the rust belt. These are all the same qualities that make it appropriate for squares and other measuring and layout tools.

More important that choosing the species is picking the right board from the right part of the right tree, and properly drying it and properly sawing it. And you definitely want to stay away from pin cherry, choke cherry, Japanese flowering cherry and cherry trees from orchards, but you won't often find them sold for anything other than firewood. Walnut is also a good choice, but you will probably not be satisfied with poplar, even though it is stable, because it is too soft, and doesn't hold crisp edges very well. Nor soft maple (again too soft, and not stable enough), nor hard maple nor beech (not stable enough, at least as usually found on the market). Pines and oaks will give you problems due to the difference in strength and hardness of their early wood vs. late wood.

Teak has many useful properties, especially stability, but is very expensive. And, there is boxwood, which has traditionally been used for planes and rules, but again is not easily acquired.

For more engineering information, ask Google to find FPL-GTR-113 for you (or buy it made from wood and ink from Lee Valley), and also read Hoadley's Understanding Wood.

Re: The Jim Tolpin Exercises

#8

Sound advice

Bob Hackett

Mark suggested starting his 1 month intensive course with an in depth study of the properties of different types of wood in order to better understand what is and is not appropriate uses for this material. I have to say that I completely agree with this. Hoadley`s books would be an excellent place to start if you want to make things that will last rather than self destruct.

That being said, for strength , durability and stability I go to the nearest boatyard and get marine plywood scraps for most of my tools,jigs and fixtures. Function trumps fashion when it comes to tools as far as I`m concerned (though the yacht yards up here use some incredible veneer faced plys on their projects and I occasionally get lucky). My battens, straight edges and other layout tools are all high grade mahogany ply of different thicknesses bonded by epoxy and I personally think they look rather nice. They work very well and most of them look good after up to a decade of heavy use.

Re: The Jim Tolpin Exercises

#9

Resawing for 1/4" & 1/2" stock

Texchappy

So the straight edge calls for 1/2" stock and the square calls for 1/4" tongue. I could plane down 3/4 to 5/4 but that seems very wasteful. Tolpin uses his bandsaw to resaw the stock down. I don't have and don't want a bandsaw.

I've done some digging and investigating. I found an episode of The Woodwright's Shop on veneering that shows using a fine tooth rip saw but all I have is a backsaw that won't work and my 5.5 TPI 26 inch Disston that I think would be too unwieldy.

Also found a Logan's Cabinet shop (amongst others) video of using a two man frame saw. Don't think that would work with my limitations.

So what can I do? What options do I have?

Re: The Jim Tolpin Exercises

#10

You use what you have, I guess

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Scribe your stock firmly and clearly for the width, and then cut wide of the line. For short pieces, you can sometimes hold the stock vertically in a vise (this assumes you have a vise*), and rip downward.

When doing this sort of cut, one critical part is getting your cut going in the right direction, for which one good approach is cutting on two lines: start your cut across the end grain, then alternate with a low-angled cut along the long grain. Go back and forth until you've got decent cut lines, then move toward a 45 degree cut. Done right, this will give you a decent kerf to guide your cut from there.

I'd rather waste away 1/4" of wood from 3/4" stock, to get to 1/2", with a plane than try to cut it off. If you don't yet own a scrub plane, grind a serious camber on a jack plane iron**. Flatten one face of your board, then scribe thickness all around from that face. Set it firmly on your bench, held so that you can plane across it and along it, then plane cross-grain with a heavy cut to waste away the stock, working around to long grain as you approach the thickness. Switch to a less-heavily-cambered iron and ultimately to a smoothing plane for final thickness.

*a phrase that works SO much better with American spelling...

**I don't recall whether you use Western metal (Bailey-type) bench planes or Japanese planes. If the former, it's easy enough to come by an extra iron; e-mail me if you need one.

Re: The Jim Tolpin Exercises

#11

Re: You use what you have, I guess

Texchappy

Thanks for the response Bill. I'm using (or headed to using) mostly western style. The blade of the used #5 I have looks to be an 8 inch bevel so it should work pretty well to get the stock down. I've watched several videos and have Tolpin's book to guide me on getting it down.

Would I want to use the same procedure to get all the way down to 1/4"?

Re: The Jim Tolpin Exercises

#12

Re: Resawing for 1/4" & 1/2" stock

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Are you starting with 3/4 or 5/4 stock? I didn't quite understand.

Wiley

Re: The Jim Tolpin Exercises

#13

@ Wiley: Haven’t got the stock yet

Texchappy

I figure I’ll probably take the best grain of what they have in the cherry or walnut they carry at the local lumberyard. I’ll go Tuesday (I hope) to get it.

Re: The Jim Tolpin Exercises

#14

Sure can

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

If it's a wide board, I'd consider using the planing method. Resawing* a wide board by hand could be a challenge for someone in the early learning** stages.

More work this way; less chance of "oh [insert dramatic word of choice]" moments, when you realize that your line on the far side, where you can't see it while cutting, has wandered into the good wood, forcing you to decide that 3/8" is thick enough.

You'll be surprised at how much wood you can remove quickly planing across the grain with a coarsely-set iron. Scrub planes are even more impressive, and, if you find you're attracted to designs with thinner-than-you-can-get-easily wood, you might put one on your someday list. That's a whole other conversation: they can be bought, but they can also be made fairly easily.

*I don't know how familiar you are with the terminology. "Resawing" is taking an existing board and making thinner board(s) out of it.

**As opposed to later learning stages, which, as best I can tell, can continue until they start shoveling dirt on the box you're in.

Re: The Jim Tolpin Exercises

#15

Re: @ Wiley: Haven’t got the stock yet

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

What I was thinking is, the main point of the exercise is to achieve straightness and flatness. Also, depending on the weather variation the straightedge is subjected to, and how it's finished, you may well need to re-true it from time to time. It may get skinnier as you go along.

So. What's magic about 1/2"? Why not pick the piece of wood you want, or a stack of it, whatever. And put your energy into straightness and flatness? I haven't read Tolpin, and also don't put myself forward as an expert. But I have used straightedges in two ways: (1) place the straightedge on the test piece and rotate it to see where it is catching--is the test piece high-centered, so that the ends of the straightedge are swinging free, or are the ends of the straightedge grabbing, indicating that the test piece is high at the ends? I like a milled-edge level for this BTW; and (2) set the straightedge down on the test piece (or the other way around), against back-lighting, and judge how much and where the light is getting through.

In case (1), the thickness doesn't matter too much--you're essentially going by feel, though you can usually eyeball the high spots as well. In case (2), a thinner edge gives you a better reading of the light--that's why there are beveled edge precision squares.

So. Let's say for the sake of discussion that the lumber yard has their 4/4 stock surfaced to 3/4" or 25/32" actual. And you find a couple three sticks that you like. Why not take a likely stick, flatten it to arrive at something a bit less than 3/4" actual; then make both edges straight, keeping one edge at the full width you've worked to, and bevel the other edge to about 3/8"? At that point, you know which edge is which. And you can use the fatter edge for the pivoting test, and the beveled edge for the leaking light test.

If 1/2" is truly what you want, get the lumber guys to mill it to 5/8", so it will finish out about 1/2", and again, put your energy into flatness and straightness, which are not at all trivial to achieve.

2 cents.

Wiley

Re: The Jim Tolpin Exercises

#16

Options ??

roger lance

stop talking....start making.

Re: The Jim Tolpin Exercises

#17

Re: @ Wiley: Haven’t got the stock yet

Warren in Lancaster, PA

The tongue for your square can easily be resawed with your Disston saw. The straight edge can be resawed also. However, as Wiley suggests, the straight edge could be left thicker. Beginners often use up quite a bit of thickness getting the stock flat and square so see what is left when you get to that point. You might also try making a straight edge from scrap just for practice. It is nice to have extras, like 1,2, 3, 4 feet. I think the big reason for making one 1/2 inch thick is so that it will be light.

It seems odd to write a book about hand tools and expect someone to use machinery for the exercises.

Re: The Jim Tolpin Exercises

#18

Re: @ Wiley: Haven’t got the stock yet

Texchappy

Reason for the dimensions of the lumber are to use the book as a guide and follow it to the “t”. I’m thinking that if I just got 4/4 or 5/4 then I could use that for the handle of the square and then resaw down for the 1/4” and probably plane down to 1/2” for the square. I’m excited about getting to work but don’t want to put too much effort into the poplar I have downstairs that is the only wood I have (and have it for another project later).

Re: The Jim Tolpin Exercises

#19

Re: The Jim Tolpin Exercises

CStan

Build the bench hook(s) first. Get busy.

Re: The Jim Tolpin Exercises

#20

Re: The Jim Tolpin Exercises

Texchappy

Wood bought and got cherry and walnut in long enough that I can do it in either or both. Now I can indeed get to work. Hopefully tomorrow I can get some good progress.