Re: @ Wiley: Haven’t got the stock yet
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
What I was thinking is, the main point of the exercise is to achieve straightness and flatness. Also, depending on the weather variation the straightedge is subjected to, and how it's finished, you may well need to re-true it from time to time. It may get skinnier as you go along.
So. What's magic about 1/2"? Why not pick the piece of wood you want, or a stack of it, whatever. And put your energy into straightness and flatness? I haven't read Tolpin, and also don't put myself forward as an expert. But I have used straightedges in two ways: (1) place the straightedge on the test piece and rotate it to see where it is catching--is the test piece high-centered, so that the ends of the straightedge are swinging free, or are the ends of the straightedge grabbing, indicating that the test piece is high at the ends? I like a milled-edge level for this BTW; and (2) set the straightedge down on the test piece (or the other way around), against back-lighting, and judge how much and where the light is getting through.
In case (1), the thickness doesn't matter too much--you're essentially going by feel, though you can usually eyeball the high spots as well. In case (2), a thinner edge gives you a better reading of the light--that's why there are beveled edge precision squares.
So. Let's say for the sake of discussion that the lumber yard has their 4/4 stock surfaced to 3/4" or 25/32" actual. And you find a couple three sticks that you like. Why not take a likely stick, flatten it to arrive at something a bit less than 3/4" actual; then make both edges straight, keeping one edge at the full width you've worked to, and bevel the other edge to about 3/8"? At that point, you know which edge is which. And you can use the fatter edge for the pivoting test, and the beveled edge for the leaking light test.
If 1/2" is truly what you want, get the lumber guys to mill it to 5/8", so it will finish out about 1/2", and again, put your energy into flatness and straightness, which are not at all trivial to achieve.
2 cents.
Wiley