Re: doesn't have to be metal to metal *LINK*
Larry Williams
Time is in short supply here until Thursday but I do want to reply.
We can discuss what mechanism actually causes dulling wear in hand planes until one of us gets tired of the discussion. The information out there is generally proprietary and aimed at bigger and more profitable markets. I can give you a link to a coating that the company offering it claims to reduce adhesive wear on tooling when working softer materials, wood is listed as one of those, but even that's inconclusive. The link to a .pdf download is below.
We do know that it's generally not abrasive wear that causes this dulling wear. It violates the very definition of abrasion because there's nothing in the wood that's harder than the steel. Even Bill's translation of the Kato paper reports very different wear patterns on edges when abrasion is involved. Sheesh, even the wear tests and testing machines test either a pin or a ring moving on a flat surface which doesn't necessarily translate to what happens at a cutting edge. Some bronze alloys have better resistance to some of these wear tests than hardened tool steel but I don't see anyone making plane irons from bronze.
Woodworkers have been making steel choices, often driven my the information tool makers provide, based on abrasive wear resistance. Professionals will try to use hand tools if they're efficient and easy to maintain. Amateurs will try and stay with hand tools if they have continued success. Contemporary tool makers have had a lot of success populating the hand tool world with A-2 steel which has a high abrasion resistance on the flat surface but are not necessarily resistant to the dulling wear suffered in use.
Almost all the hand plane sharpening problems I see when out doing workshops originate from the wear on the flat face of the iron. Removing that flat face wear in sharpening is an abrasive process and sharpening A-2 irons is a difficult PIA.
(got a few more minutes and I'll try to finish this)
So along comes a short-cut. When David Charlesworth began participating on woodworking forums I told him I thought the ruler trick was a time bomb and people would have to do more of it creating an ever growing problem. He responded that no, he didn't ever have to do more than two or three passes over the stone and there was no growing problem. If you seen any of his videos you know he's both patient and deliberate in his work. If anyone would be removing flat face wear by working just the bevel and adding the ruler trick it's David. In the thread below, he says he's now up to 20 or more strokes on the ruler trick. I'm sorry but I don't think I very often do 20 strokes on the stones using traditional sharpening and that includes a couple strokes on a strop on each face and I'm not having to tinker with a ruler or honing guide. I'm also using oil stones which have a reputation for cutting slowly.
I've seen the frustration people experience when not being successful at sharpening. I know a lot of people just give up and return to their power tools. Even Bill Tindall recently posted that he thinks A-2 is a poor choice for chisels. I think it's an equally poor choice for plane irons and drives people away from hand tool woodworking because of its problems.
Wear is an important issue and the type of wear is equally important. If people are sold a tool steel based on increased wear resistance and that wear resistance actually only inhibits sharpening but does little or nothing to increase edge life that's a big issue to me.
Ionbond Tool Coatings