New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Abrasive, adhesive, corrosive wear?

Posts

Abrasive, adhesive, corrosive wear?

#1

Abrasive, adhesive, corrosive wear?

Bill Tindall

Time for a new topic.

Larry has been a tireless advocate of the adhesive wear theory. I, and likely many others, have been unable to follow the argument for this hypothesis because I don't know what adhesive wear is and more importantly what is the relevance to the hand tool user?

So, could someone explain these types of wear and tell how I might use this information as a tool maker or user?

Re: Abrasive, adhesive, corrosive wear?

#2

Re: Abrasive, adhesive, corrosive wear?

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

I don't know what adhesive wear is but I am familiar with elastic wear. Elastic wear is generally the reason I condemn some crew socks and underwear to the rag bin.

Tom

Re: Abrasive, adhesive, corrosive wear?

#3

Ellis Walentine

Saw that coming. 


Re: Abrasive, adhesive, corrosive wear?

#4

Wikipedia provides some help, I guess *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I've had trouble following some of the discussion for this reason, too.

The Wikipedia article, linked below, seems to attempt definitions, but I'm having trouble following it, too. Clearly, I should be glad I didn't go into engineering.

It kind of reminds me of one of my human resources textbooks, the authors of which spent an entire chapter happily discussing different methods of performance evaluation that, to my eyes, looked identical (and unlikely to be productive).


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wear

Re: Abrasive, adhesive, corrosive wear?

#6

abrasive wear

Larry Williams

I've never been able to find a mineral commonly found in wood that's harder than hardened steel other than silica. Silica is rarely found in temperate zone hard or soft woods in anything more than trace amounts. To abrade something the abrasive has to be harder than what is being abraded. If abrasive wear was the wear mechanism involved in dulling wear to woodworking tool edges sharpening wouldn't be necessary when working most of our domestic woods.

The dulling wear is caused by something and it's not usually abrasion, what is it? All the information I'd found in a few years of looking at this pointed to adhesive wear. Even the nitride coatings commonly used on metal working tooling were designed to increase surface lubricity of the tool edges. Lubrication is the common technique used to inhibit adhesive wear.

High temperature corrosion is a new concept to me and I've got a lot of work to do in finding out about its involvement in dulling wear of woodworking cutting edges.

Re: Abrasive, adhesive, corrosive wear?

#7

Why it might be relevant

Bill Tindall

It would seem that tool sharpening is most affected by abrasion resistance of the tool's steel. But suppose the dulling that results from hand planing wood is mainly from other modes of dulling. It could be that some steel that is modestly abrasion resistant (easy sharpening) could have exceptional resistance to these other dulling modes. For this to be the case abrasion resistance would need to not correlate with adhesive and/or corrosive wear. These data are likely in the literature. Maybe we should be looking at the stainless cutlery steels.

There are data in the Kato and Kawai papers on dulling resistance for a variety of steels. If the manufacturers of these steels have data on the various modes of wear it would be a simple matter to correlate the wear observed for the plane blade with wear data for the steel and determine which mode of wear best matched the data. The least wear resistant steel they investigated was plain carbon steel (white steel or something similar).

There is anecdotal evidence that corrosive wear is important for CNC wood cutters. I was told by a person that does coating that his customers prefer a coating that is especially resistant to corrosive wear and not titanium nitride.

This is not a topic I am likely to become interested in but it does sound like a fruitful topic for someone to pursue if better edge life doesn't require more difficulty sharpening.

Re: Abrasive, adhesive, corrosive wear?

#8

an exceptional example of useless

Bill Tindall

The fact that it is materials science does not require that the material be written in such an incomprehensible manner. Pray the author is not a teacher(by job title obviously) nor has technicians dependent upon his/her instruction and training.

Re: Abrasive, adhesive, corrosive wear?

#9

Types of Wear *LINK*

Steve Elliott

To start, the link below is the best introduction I've found on the internet.

For several years I've been trying to find a source that says that the wear caused when machining wood is primarily adhesive. All the references I've found describe adhesive wear as a phenomenon of metal sticking to metal.

One other point that has been raised is whether a softer material can abrade a harder one. I believe it can, as is demonstrated when a hard blade is used to machine a softer material such as plastic, which can be made with no inclusions of silica, dirt, or whatever. The blades still wear at some rate. I don't know of any authoritative source that describes this wear as either abrasive or adhesive but wear does happen.

After doing some wear testing comparing different alloys my interest has moved on to other factors that affect the performance of cutting tools. (The cap iron stuff has kept me captivated for quite some time now.) When Lee Valley brings out their particle metallurgy plane blades I intend to do some more wear testing because their claims have piqued my interest.


Alloy Steel International Wear Factors

Re: Abrasive, adhesive, corrosive wear?

#10

Re: Abrasive, adhesive, corrosive wear?

TomD

Just to back up a step, is wear the only method by which an edge can be reduced, and what is it. Is there is a mechanical option as well?

Re: Abrasive, adhesive, corrosive wear?

#11

Re: Types of Wear *LINK*

Mark Hennebury

Although I am keanly interested You guys have obviously a lot more knowledge in this area than I.

I know Marunaka make some very large Supersurfacers for some industrial applications for slicing plastic, I dont know if the knives are any different than the normal supersurfacers. but they do make one of their regular small supersurfacers for shaving plastic. included a video link

Marunaka and many other companies offer disposable blades versions. Marunak state that the disposable blades last 3 times as long as the sharpenable blades, and I have heard that they are very fine blades.

Also the disposable blades in jointers and thicknessplaners do a lot of heavy work. They are available in several different metals. Chrome steel and HSS

Marunaka also make huge veneer slicers, basically a large high skew blade about 6' long. These are industrial machines meant to slice all species of lumber, all day long (The lumber is usually soaked first)

I would guess that they have done considerable research in the areas of this topic. I dont know how much of it is in the papers that Bill got.

Stellite tipped blades are common on some woodworking tools;

Kennametal Stellite™ is a global provider of innovative solutions to challenging wear problems. Our specialist products and manufacturing services help extend the life of components in demanding environments where heat, corrosion and abrasion limit their life. To learn more about us, our products, services and expertise click the links below to view our newest brochures.


plastic slicer video

Re: Abrasive, adhesive, corrosive wear?

#12

doesn't have to be metal to metal *LINK*

Larry Williams

The term "cold welding" is an unfortunate term used in association with adhesive wear. Cold welding implies metal to metal and too many take it as that. I believe the link in your post, Steve, oversimplifies things to the point a lot of information is lost.

http://books.google.com/books?id=iLVfNUVDLa8C&pg=SA9-PA71&lpg=SA9-PA71&dq=cold+welding+in+adhesive+wear&source=bl&ots=2cGy_7tU5N&sig=oQQS_JWnTmcEKwGfCT8qv9Dlp0s&hl=en&sa=X&ei=AJ3aT9DuGsKA2wXamviOBg&ved=0CHgQ6AEwCTgU#v=onepage&q=cold%20welding%20in%20adhesive%20wear&f=false

Re: Abrasive, adhesive, corrosive wear?

#13

Re: abrasive wear

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

Monterey cypress (cupresses macrocarpa)encapsulates silica. it is not widely avaialble comercialy but is is available from some small specialty sawyers and It is well worth seeking out even with its known propensity for encapsuating silica. Elm is another wood that is known to encapsulate silica.

The last slab of walnut I worked with I would have sworn it was full of silica from the way it was sanding, but it was also from the root ball so it may have been a bit atypical.

Robin

Re: Abrasive, adhesive, corrosive wear?

#14

Re: doesn't have to be metal to metal

Steve Elliott

I will gladly grant your point that the link oversimplifies wear processes. I would add that the link you posted, which clearly attempts not to oversimplify, offers differing opinions on the wear mechanism and mentions that the viewpoints have not yet been supported by sufficient experimental data.

While your link mentions that adhesive wear can form on non-metallic surfaces and shows data for hardened steel/polyethylene, the amount of wear is less by two orders of magnitude (if I understand the chart). The text states that adhesive wear is easily formed between surfaces of the same metal, that different metals are more resistant to adhesive wear, and that the friction pair of metallic and non-metallic materials is of higher wear-resistant ability than that composed of different metals.

Wood is not mentioned, that I could find. For me the discussion of adhesive wear might be of interest if it was established that it was the main cause of wear in woodworking blades. Until then, I find measuring the amount of wear to be more informative than discussing the type of wear it might be.

Re: Abrasive, adhesive, corrosive wear?

#15

craigd

Re: Abrasive, adhesive, corrosive wear?

craigd

I'm not convinced that metal can only be abraded by materials "harder" then the metal. The only example I can come up with that might show this are some old Stanley planes I've gotten off of ebay - the front of the mouth can worn in a V groove like chute (open end at the mouth) such that the mouth was worn by over 1/8" in the center. Nice and polished. Many of my "finds" have quite pronounced wear at the leading edge of mouth leaving it quite rounded over.

I'm assuming that steel could also show the same wear patterns as cast iron (on a much smaller scale).

I would also speculate that corrosive wear to the cutting edge is a big deal at the micro level due to the water and acids in wood (I'm pretty sure I've seen references to this but have no idea where).

Re: Abrasive, adhesive, corrosive wear?

#16

maybe yes.....

Bill Tindall

This discussion is causing me to consider moving the Kato and Kawai paper on metal evaluation up the translation priority list. I think (based on superficial translation) that one of the metals shed carbide particles which might be labeled something different than abrasion.

Re: Abrasive, adhesive, corrosive wear?

#17

Re: maybe yes.....

TomD

Thanks Bill.

Re: Abrasive, adhesive, corrosive wear?

#18

Re: doesn't have to be metal to metal *LINK*

Larry Williams

Time is in short supply here until Thursday but I do want to reply.

We can discuss what mechanism actually causes dulling wear in hand planes until one of us gets tired of the discussion. The information out there is generally proprietary and aimed at bigger and more profitable markets. I can give you a link to a coating that the company offering it claims to reduce adhesive wear on tooling when working softer materials, wood is listed as one of those, but even that's inconclusive. The link to a .pdf download is below.

We do know that it's generally not abrasive wear that causes this dulling wear. It violates the very definition of abrasion because there's nothing in the wood that's harder than the steel. Even Bill's translation of the Kato paper reports very different wear patterns on edges when abrasion is involved. Sheesh, even the wear tests and testing machines test either a pin or a ring moving on a flat surface which doesn't necessarily translate to what happens at a cutting edge. Some bronze alloys have better resistance to some of these wear tests than hardened tool steel but I don't see anyone making plane irons from bronze.

Woodworkers have been making steel choices, often driven my the information tool makers provide, based on abrasive wear resistance. Professionals will try to use hand tools if they're efficient and easy to maintain. Amateurs will try and stay with hand tools if they have continued success. Contemporary tool makers have had a lot of success populating the hand tool world with A-2 steel which has a high abrasion resistance on the flat surface but are not necessarily resistant to the dulling wear suffered in use.

Almost all the hand plane sharpening problems I see when out doing workshops originate from the wear on the flat face of the iron. Removing that flat face wear in sharpening is an abrasive process and sharpening A-2 irons is a difficult PIA.

(got a few more minutes and I'll try to finish this)

So along comes a short-cut. When David Charlesworth began participating on woodworking forums I told him I thought the ruler trick was a time bomb and people would have to do more of it creating an ever growing problem. He responded that no, he didn't ever have to do more than two or three passes over the stone and there was no growing problem. If you seen any of his videos you know he's both patient and deliberate in his work. If anyone would be removing flat face wear by working just the bevel and adding the ruler trick it's David. In the thread below, he says he's now up to 20 or more strokes on the ruler trick. I'm sorry but I don't think I very often do 20 strokes on the stones using traditional sharpening and that includes a couple strokes on a strop on each face and I'm not having to tinker with a ruler or honing guide. I'm also using oil stones which have a reputation for cutting slowly.

I've seen the frustration people experience when not being successful at sharpening. I know a lot of people just give up and return to their power tools. Even Bill Tindall recently posted that he thinks A-2 is a poor choice for chisels. I think it's an equally poor choice for plane irons and drives people away from hand tool woodworking because of its problems.

Wear is an important issue and the type of wear is equally important. If people are sold a tool steel based on increased wear resistance and that wear resistance actually only inhibits sharpening but does little or nothing to increase edge life that's a big issue to me.


Ionbond Tool Coatings

Re: Abrasive, adhesive, corrosive wear?

#19

Re: Three things

TomD

A2 is a bit of a puzzler, because it is not super clear who is really for it. Some of the makers say they prefer their O1 tools. People who do not prefer A2 to O1 or other similar simple steels, normally do say something like you have just said that it feels like more work is required to sharpen it than they prefer.

On the other hand, I'm not sure I have heard anyone who got it sharp say they thought the wear was not greater using it than one of the classic steels.

The other thing is that there are a lot of other HSSs that are pretty easy to sharpen and have better edge holding than O1. It is curious that they don't have a name brand following like A2 does, for at least those who prefer to use high edge holding steels.

Re: Abrasive, adhesive, corrosive wear?

#20

I'd focus on other things

Steve Elliott

We can discuss what mechanism actually causes dulling wear in hand planes until one of us gets tired of the discussion.

I think I reached that point some time ago.

As to the ruler trick, the small difference in clearance that results (less than 1 degree) will not cause problems no matter how wide the polished area becomes. What will cause problems is lifting the blade more and more during successive polishings of the flat face, resulting in increasing loss of clearance. (I'm thinking of bevel-up planes here.)

I have two Lie-Nielsen block plane blades that I use regularly, one in O-1 and one in A-2. Neither is marked and I've lost track of which is which. They seem to sharpen about the same and any difference in edge holding is small enough that I don't notice it without a more tightly controlled record of use. I think most woodworkers who have problems sharpening would do better to focus on their technique rather than the alloy they're using.

Re: Abrasive, adhesive, corrosive wear?

#21

Re: It's probably cost

david weaver

..the reason those HSS irons don't have more of a following. Chinese HSS must not be consistent enough to use as raw stock, and the makers are dealing with some competent users but an awful lot of incompetent users who can hardly sharpen carbon steel itself.

I personally like A2. It's not that hard to work, when it's good, it's really good, and it does work longer when you're doing something like dimensioning by hand. For smoothing, I don't have much of a preference one way or the other, though I do like the blue steel irons that tsunesaburo makes better than anything I've found in the US for a similar price.

Good A2 doesn't leave evidence on the surface, bad A2 does. Carbon steel can do the same thing if it's not right, and if it's softer (like 58 hardness or so) where it's got a better chance of having good toughness, it's not nearly as durable as A2.

For smoothing, who cares, right? If you're using a smoother for that many passes, something is wrong.

But for the steps before smoothing, being able to do an entire large panel and still having a good edge is better than stopping in the middle. To me, at least. And anything aluminum oxide or harder sharpens A2 with ease.

Re: Abrasive, adhesive, corrosive wear?

#22

Re: It's probably cost

TomD

Could be, though I use these HSS lathe tool bits, and they are absolutely awesome, they hold up well in metal cutting, but they are relatively easy to sharpen, the edge is really sharp, and they hold an edge as well as anything. I use them when the shape works, which is not very often. If they actually came in wider sizes they would be quite reasonably. Unfortunately the most practical size I can get is 1/2 x 3/8 x 4". Only works for small detail planes. That little Osage rebate plane I pictured last week was a lathe chip plane. But anyway, that is 5 bucks for .75 cubic inches which would handle a lot of roles for chisels and stuff. Since it is HSS, it would be fun to see what would happen if they were silver soldered, or tacked.

On the other side, the Japanese tools I have that are HSS are very nice quality. More overall usable than some of the Blue Steel tools I own, kinda in-between. Yet they were the bargain option. The chisels were probably 15-25% of the blue steel Ouchi, and sold in sets of 3.