New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Disston Saws

Posts

Disston Saws

#1

Michael Donaldson

Disston Saws

Michael Donaldson

I have a vintage Disston D28 given to me by Bob Smalser that I love. I use it to rip all of my boards. I have a LN dovetail saw that was my dad's and now I need a tenon saw and / or a carcass saw (I want a few different backsaws some crosscut, some rip). I have been looking for vintage Disston saws because I know they are good, and have come across some new Disston saws on eBay for cheap. Are the new Disston saws good, or has the brand gone to pot over the years? Would I be better off saving up for a Pax or LN?

Re: Disston Saws

#2

Re: Disston Saws

Texchappy

I ended up shelling out some dough for a Bad Axe after Mark Harrell was so patient in me asking a bunch of questions. It also didn't hurt that he had a return that he gave me for a discount that was available immediately. Not that much more than the L-N's and way customizable.

BTW, I love my Bad Axe! It's purdy and cuts nice (even for a total novice like me).

Re: Disston Saws

#3

Re: Disston Saws

Ron in Kokomo

The quality of some of the news saws is fantastic. I do believe that top quality back saws are available all the time on eBay, for a lot less money

Ron

Re: Disston Saws

#4

Lasers . . .

steve mackay

If modern saws need to use a laser as a selling point, rather than the cutting, I'll buy old ones. I've got several and I actually TRUST them. They are also a pleasure to use (and look at !). Old Distons make us all better looking and smarter. (and, I hear, thinner !) But then , there IS "the dream". If I were saving up for a new one I'd REALLY go nuts and get my Mike Wenzloff. THEN I'd really BE somebody. (shivers up my spine ! :D )

Re: Disston Saws

#5

Re: Disston Saws *LINK*

Christopher Fitch Memphis

In my experience, any Disston post start of WWII is not really worth buying. I expect there are some but the pre WWII saws are of excellent quality.

If you don't know of the Disstonian Institute, I advise reading that site. It's very very good.

I have five pre WWII Disston saws, (Rip, two crosscuts, crosscut panel, and a carcase saw.

There's something great about finding an older Disston saw, cleaning or restoring it, and then having it sharpened (or sharpening yourself).

I could not be happier with mine...I've picked up two from estate sales, and the rest off of ebay. I think I've spent a total of $130-150 for my five saws including sharpening. That's like the cost of one of my other saws (I have two LN's and a number of Adria saws along with a Wenzloff saw).

Just my thoughts...


Disstonian Institute

Re: Disston Saws

#6

Re: Disston Saws *LINK*

Christopher Fitch Memphis

Also, (Pete Taran's) Vintage Saws site has alot of good info about old saws including how to clean and sharpen. Check under the library.


Vintage Saws

Re: Disston Saws

#7

Michael Donaldson

Thanks for the great info!  Now To get money...