New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Stropping and Paul Sellers

Posts

Stropping and Paul Sellers

#1

Stropping and Paul Sellers

Ron in Kokomo

Have you seen his honing technique? It is on YouTube. If you have not seen it please do, and then talk to me. It looks near idiot proof. The results are evident. I have been buying chisels for more than 30 years and I have found some old ones that clearly have been honed this way. Makes a lot of sense to me.

Ron

Re: Stropping and Paul Sellers

#2

Re: Stropping and Paul Sellers

David Charlesworth

Ron,

He spends more time stropping than I do sharpening.

However his is a method which may be useful, if the fine stone is not very fine.

David Charlesworth

Re: Stropping and Paul Sellers

#3

Re: Stropping and Paul Sellers

Kees

I always wonder how he finds the edge whe he does such "wild" motions on the stones. He is rolling the edge during a stroke. How does he know at what angle to stop or continue the roll. And isn't all that metal removal on the convex bevel a waste of time?

I can't wrap my head around that tecnique. No idea what's happening. So i continue to do the coarse honing on a hollow bevel and then slightly raise the blade to polish a microbevel.

Re: Stropping and Paul Sellers

#4

Re: The next "new" wave in sharpening

david weaver

I'd imagine we'll find a bunch of people reading the sellers blog and videos / books, etc that will try this method and declare it rediscovered and superior.

What I think would work just as well but be faster for someone who doesn't want to use a grinder at all would be to work the primary bevel with a coarse stone, and then reference the edge and lift it slightly with a very fine stone (like an 8k stone or a 15k type stone). It would be faster to do.

What I see more commonly in old tools is a super shallow primary bevel with the edge itself worked steeper, presumably so it'd be easier for a cabinetmaker to work the edge many times without having to work the primary bevel.

A 6" grinder to me is still the fastest way to get a superb edge.

Re: Stropping and Paul Sellers

#5

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Stropping and Paul Sellers

#6

Re: Death knell of the 7" and 8" grinder?

david weaver

Everyone has their preference in grinders, I guess. The grinder is more important than the 6".

I'm still waiting for the "weak edge" that everyone insists will happen with a grinder.

Benefit to the 6" for the beginners is they can go to any home depot and try one for about $40 or so. And the hollow is deep enough to last a lot longer if someone likes to reference completely on the flats.

Though I don't care that much about what anyone else does, I do get a little annoyed with every "new" sharpening method somehow being any better than every other method that polishes an edge left at a certain bevel.

Re: Stropping and Paul Sellers

#7

Re: Death knell of the 7" and 8" grinder?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Mine's 10". Am I going in the wrong direction?

Actually, the wheel is about 9" by now. So I could be back in fashion in a decade.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Stropping and Paul Sellers

#8

Was this a stealth gloat??.....

roger lance

my grinder is bigger than your grinder....a sorta psychoanalytic super-ego thing??

Re: Stropping and Paul Sellers

#10

Convex sharpening?

North of the Border

Not sure which youtube vid you were referring to. I watched his sharpening DVD and his technique falls under the school of convex sharpening, resulting a convex bevel. The convex sharpening technique he demonstrates is not shown in a step-by-step manner with details. Others have tried it before Sellers' DVD appeared and have confirmed its usefulness. In the absence of published details and lack of personal experience, I can't tell how square an edge sharpened freehand that way is to the tool. I do plan to try out the convex sharpening method one day with some of my chisels.

Among all the DVDs by Sellers, the sharpening one is, in my opinion, the weakest, not because of the techniques he promotes but because he skims over the details. I heard that he is a good teacher from those who have attended his workshops in person...however, teaching through DVDs is a different animal.

Re: Stropping and Paul Sellers

#11

Re: Convex sharpening?

David Weaver

I think there's not a great reason for the details. From what I can gather on his youtube video, you start each stone at the highest angle you'll sharpen and work shallower.

If he doesn't talk about squareness or anything, you can figure it out with your own two eyes and hands (i.e, if you're off one way, make a conscious effort to hone more in the other direction).

That's about all there is to it, it works fine. It does work better with stock irons and chisels that aren't too too hard, but I guess so does every other method (unless you can use a grinder on HSS).

Re: Stropping and Paul Sellers

#12

Re: Stropping and Paul Sellers *LINK*

Russ Webb

It seems there are really two issues at play in the Sellars method.

First, he uses rather coarse stones for final finishing before stropping. If he used a final grit of, say, 8000 water stones he'd need to spend less time stropping. He's stropping on leather charged with chromium oxide (.5 microns) so, if I remember the video correctly he's going from a 1200 grit diamond stone to the strop charged with chromium oxide. Makes sense that he'd spend a good bit more time stropping than if he'd gone from a finer grit to the strop. He says in his video that he's basically moving from a 1200 grit diamond stone to a 16000 grit strop. That's a fairly large jump and essentially requires that he spend considerable time/energy stropping.

The other issue is the convex bevel that he uses. Others, notably Idaho blacksmith Barr Quarton who produces exceptional chisels and other tools, use similar methods.

Barr sharpens his chisels with a convex bevel using a method similar to that used by Paul Sellars, though Barr uses much finer grit stones. The convex bevel works just fine in my experience and can be easily re-sharpened freehand. My Ray Iles mortise chisels seem to have a somewhat similar convex bevel.

I've got both the cabinet chisels and framing chisels produced by Barr and Lie

Nielsen chisels (as well as Narex, Marples, and others).

In my experience the Barr cabinet chisels, with their convex bevel, are very sturdy. I have chipped a Lie Nielsen when chopping and now use them solely for paring. The Barr chisels have shown no signs of chipping or crumbling an edge despite chopping very hard woods.

There are, as in many endeavors, many ways to get to a result. What matters - to me at least - is the result.

Just my experience. YMMV.


Barr Tools Sharpening A Framing Chisel

Re: Stropping and Paul Sellers

#13

Convex and non-convex methods: efficiencies

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Ron

Taking the strop to be just another sharpening media ...

The convex method has been around a long time. In terms of discussion, it has been the source of debate on the UK forum for some years, long before I read of Paul Sellers using it.

Like every sharpening method, there are pros and cons.

I use this method when honing my mortice chisels. They need to be around 35 degrees, and you do not want to hollow grind and a honing guide is difficult (I have the small Kell, which works so-so). The primary bevel remains 20 degrees, and it is not too difficult to determine where 35 degrees should be. This is the primary value of convex sharpening for me.

In Paul Seller's latest blog article, he commented (on plane blades): "Another thing we cannot simply dismiss is that we want to use hand methods, thick irons have longer bevels and a large amount of steel must be removed constantly".

I have found several inaccuracies in his writings recently. This is one. I discussed another with Paul on his website, but stopped when it became apparent that we were not on the same page. He has his preferences, and I really do not know if he has explored the options. The quote above indicates that he dismisses, or does not consider, secondary bevels, microbevels, etc.

The question I would pose here is there any difference (in honing) between a thin Stanley blade and a thick infill blade if they are either hollow ground or given a secondary bevel on a flat face? If the secondary micro bevel is the same for both, then one does the same amount of honing regardless of the thickness you started with. Indeed, to hone with a rounded bevel means that one has more steel to remove as you need to lower the back of the face to avoid increasing the bevel angle.

At the end of the day one does what is comfortable.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Stropping and Paul Sellers

#14

Re: Convex and non-convex methods: efficiencies

Kees

When you use up a cm of blade in a couple of years or so you have defenitely removed more metal. Micro bevels or not. But when you use a grinder, it's kind of a moot point.

Re: Stropping and Paul Sellers

#15

follow up for Derek

roninkokomo

Derek

It is obvious to me that I can get my irons just as sharp as he does with my Tormek and oil stones and strop. My real question is does the convex bevel produce added strength behind the edge? If so, how valuable is it?

Ron in sunny Kokomo

Re: Stropping and Paul Sellers

#16

Re: follow up for Derek

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

It is obvious to me that I can get my irons just as sharp as he does with my Tormek and oil stones and strop. My real question is does the convex bevel produce added strength behind the edge? If so, how valuable is it?

Hi Ron

A counter question to you is whether you have experienced your Tormek-created hollow grind to be weak in any way? Has it let you down?

One of the reasons I like the Tormek is that the 10" wheel creates a shallow hollow. Indeed, it is a lot shallower than one realises, certainly seems much more so than even an 8" wheel, and possible to remove it with overly enthusiastic work on a 1200 waterstone. I tend to grind to the edge of a bevel, which leaves a slither of metal to hone into a microbevel. This gets the job done very quickly and I have not experienced premature chipping in hardwood as a result of this method.

So how does a thicker bevel stack up? I have no doubt that it is stronger (that is why mortice chisels are built the way they are), but is this necessary? The sensible answer is that it depends on the task at hand. In practice I do not do it differently for plane blades and bench chisels.

Does Paul Sellers use a convex bevel as it is stronger than anything else, or does he use one as he finds it quicker/easier to create without the need to first grind a hollow or flat primary bevel?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Stropping and Paul Sellers

#17

Re: follow up for Derek

Darren Brewster

Does Paul Sellers use a convex bevel as it is stronger than anything else, or does he use one as he finds it quicker/easier to create without the need to first grind a hollow or flat primary bevel?

I believe it is both of those reasons from watching his sharpening dvd. I can't speak to the strength, but it is damn fast on water stones and very easy to learn. I had success the very first time I tried it.

Re: Stropping and Paul Sellers

#18

If the edge were stronger...

david weaver

.. it would only be due to the effective angle at the cut being steeper than it would be for a flat or hollow ground bevel.

That's not really a compromise I want to make. I saw Paul's blog mention that the angle at the cut is the same for his method as it is for someone else's and that's why the argument against it makes no sense. I agree with that.

But implicit in that statement is that the remainder of the primary is less steep than a flat or hollow grind, because intead of the angle being constant or increasing after the edge, it becomes less steep.

I suspect a lot of people who use his method will make bevels that are steeper than they think they're making, but folks can figure that out on their own as they go along - if they get steep enough, they'll notice.

I haven't follwed his blog much since then, I can't get on with the promotion of class work mixed 50/50 with the railing against industrialized society and productivity. It is only the industrialized society he rails against that provides his students with enough money to go to classes and entertain themselves. In a craft economy, there would be no such thing, he'd be many times poorer and he'd have to work harder. That rubs me the wrong way, as even in a craft economy, it is the money from the wealthy searching for the best that drives innovation and the need for retention of fine skills in the craft.

Re: Stropping and Paul Sellers

#19

Re: Convex sharpening? *LINK*

Russ Webb

The video I refer to can be found by following the link below. It relates to his method for sharpening a framing chisel.

You obviously have far greater exposure to both Paul Sellars' and Barr Quarton's methods of sharpening than I. I have not seen a DVD by either. But I believe you are correct that Barr's method (and Sellars') for that matter are simply variations of convex sharpening.

Each seems to get the results he seeks, finds it reliable for his purposes, and is happy with his technique. Others get similar results with different techniques.

Sharpening seems to be a bit of an art as well as a science and what matters is getting the best result for the purpose at hand in an efficient manner. Like many other matters it is a subject for endless debate and discussion about what is "best". To me what is "best" is what gets an individual the result he or she seeks for the kind of work he or she does and which the individual can employ with confidence and efficiency.

I personally use multiple methods - different methods for different tools and tasks. Freehand, guided, etc. I sharpen my mortise chisels and Barr chisels differently that I sharpen plane blades.

Discussions ensue because different methods work "best" for different individuals and we all like to share our experience. Generally this leads to substantial sharing of useful information. Sometimes, positions harden and minds close and we try to convince others about that we are "right" or better informed.


Barr Tools Sharpening A Framing Chisel

Re: Stropping and Paul Sellers

#20

Re: follow up for Derek

roninkokomo

I suspect the latter is the reason. And, perhaps it is a valid one for him. I suppose your whole perspective on this issue could change with the amount of time you actually spend in the shop per week. For most of us amateurs, we regrettably do not get to spend enough time to make it an issue.

Ron

Re: Stropping and Paul Sellers

#21

Re: follow up for Derek

North of the Border

"For most of us amateurs, we regrettably do not get to spend enough time to make it an issue."

Agreed. That's where sharpening jigs come in, the use of which Sellers is against.

Like any woodworker here or elsewhere, Paul is entitled to his views on how sharpening should be done -- freehand for him and his followers. He took on Asa, editor of FWM who wrote an article on sharpening jigs recently. Asa could have done the same about is freehand technique. I challenge a new woodworker who thinks he can copy Paul's technique and results by simply watching his sharpening DVD. The new woodworker must put in lots of trial and error efforts, just as Paul himself did, through practices before she or he could get a proper edge. And then, unlike a proper jig, the squareness can't be ensured on every first attempt (try it freehand with convex method on a thick blade that comes with the jointer plane, if anyone does think so).

When it comes to sharpening, both schools (freehand and using jigs) are correct and one is not necessarily better than the other as it depends on the project, a user's skill level, etc. Are hand tools better than power tools or vice versa?

Many students I come across seem to avoid hand tools because sharpening skill is not in their genes and dull edges cause problems that they think are due to their techniques or skills. There are too many variables (jig designs, stones issues, the need to flatten stones, etc.) that work against a new woodworker who tries to learn sharpening. Freehand sharpening looks easy if you watch Paul (convex) or Rob Cosman (tertiary bevel) do it. The fact is getting an edge sharp (easy) and square (hard) --important for handplane blade -- at the same time isn't as simple as it looks or as it's promoted by those who practise it.

My view is both jigs and freehand method can co-exist and in fact can be used together: jigs for consistent and repeatable primary bevel and micro; freehand for honing the bevel or micro till a new primary bevel is needed. The question is what's more important to you: consistency and repeatability or speed? From there, the choice can be made.

Re: Stropping and Paul Sellers

#22

Re: If the edge were stronger...

bugbear

I suspect a lot of people who use his method will make bevels that are steeper than they think they're making, but folks can figure that out on their own as they go along - if they get steep enough, they'll notice.

Surely that's the infamous "creeping bevel angle" most every old "how to" book since the year dot warns against.

BugBear