New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

What draws you to a piece/style of furniture?

Posts

What draws you to a piece/style of furniture?

#1

What draws you to a piece/style of furniture?

Texchappy

Is it the lines? The Craftsmanship? The story? Personal associations?

Personally, I find my taste evolving. It's even changed some in the brief time I've been researching woodworking. I must admit that I have some Ikea and was considering buying some more (please hold the stones). I liked the clean lines of modern and mid-century. I steered away from 'early american' because of the cheap reproductions my family had growing up. As I learn more about the stories of these styles my taste are reversing. For example, I watched a documentary on Ray and Charles Eames last night when I couldn't sleep. After watching it and the philosophy behind it (i.e. mass produced) I found myself less interested in it.

So what about you?

Re: What draws you to a piece/style of furniture?

#2

Re: What draws you to a piece/style of furniture?

TomD

I grew up with Swedish Modern of reasonable quality, and the first book I remember reading about furniture was one of Krenov's. You should probably get one of those books. He has a great approach, and he is small scale which might appeal to you.

As a woodworker, I find furniture a toughie. Cause as much as I was inspired by Krenov, the reality is that fancier furniture from earlier centuries is a greater challenge to make. In particular Krenov inspired me about planes, and if you want a lot of those, molding planes and other planes of the earlier period are more interesting. But I don't really want to live with that furniture, and in most places (maybe not around Philly) reproductions are not all that highly regarded.

That is why I like making boats and other technical items. I like to design them, I like to use them, and I don't worry too much about what happens to them (landfill for most furniture) because I had so much fun using them.

Re: What draws you to a piece/style of furniture?

#3

Re: What draws you to a piece/style of furniture?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Tony

I echo Tom's comments.

It is likely that your early experiences have significant underpinings to your furniture design interests, so the pieces of your childhood exert a strong influence. (Well, what other type of answer would you expect from a psychoanalyst? :) ).

In my case the prevailing furniture in my early childhood was art deco and Swedish. My father was an architect and designed the occasional piece as well, such as these chairs in the late 1930s (which I later restored) ..


The house that we lived in from the time I was 4 years was extremely modern for the 50's, with much use of wood and glass.

During my later childhood my mother became more involved in arts-and-crafts (she sold vintage arts-and-crafts furniture) and this entered my life as well. There were a number of Edwardian and Victorian pieces at home, however these had the effect of looking too busy to my eye in comparison to the cleans lines of the more contemporary styles.

When I look closely at, for example, Georgian pieces, I find the detail overwhelming and unrelaxing. If I stand back, there are many designs that I admire. In other words, I am first drawn to the silhouette - the line of a piece.

The more contemporary designs are often mostly about silhouette. You cannot exclude detail, of course. This may take the form of grain, timber contrasts, the sweep of a curve, the emphasis from symmetry or non-symmetry.

Classic modern designers, such as Krenov, Maloof and Nakashima, embodied these principles - which is why I find their work inspiring. I appreciate the complexity of detailed moldings and carvings on 18th and 19th century designs (and try to incorporate a touch here-and-there, mainly to accent lines, and not to become a feature in their own right), but I do not desire to live with pieces like these. Give me something that I can run my hands over and stroke for its sensuousness!



Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: What draws you to a piece/style of furniture?

#4

Re: What draws you to a piece/style of furniture?

Ron in Kokomo

Craftsmanship. Careful use of grain. Tom and Derek are right. We are molded by our past. Derek will know that some of those influences are so subtle that we cannot articulate them. But they are very real. I admire lots of stuff that I could not live with. I love Arts and Crafts esp. Greene and Greene. And I love Shaker. A well done Windsor or Appalachian chair is truly a thing of beauty.

Ron

Re: What draws you to a piece/style of furniture?

#5

Re: What draws you to a piece/style of furniture?

TomD

Wow Derek. That last piece in particular is very nice, is that one of yours?

Interesting to hear about your deep roots in woodworking and furniture, that explains a lot.

Re: What draws you to a piece/style of furniture?

#6

Re: What draws you to a piece/style of furniture?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Tom

What are you doing up at this time of the day/night?! :)

Thanks for the kind words. The first piece - the chairs - was dads', and the last two, the Mission bed and the side table, are both mine.

I posted the build on the table here a while back. It table began as an entertainment centre, with coopered doors at each end, somewhat art deco in flavour. Along the journey I concluded that the curved frames for the coopered infill would not be strong enough, and changed direction. The coopered sections became sides for the table, above.

Of course I still needed an entertainment centre! I took inspiration from some traditional military (campaign) chests I saw at my sister-in-laws home, and created a modern interpretation. This is another example of using the line/silhouette first, and then adding detail with the figure/wood/asymmetry. The details are understated. This is another I built on WC, about 18 months ago. This is smaller than it looks, with the total combined length 6' and the height 2'.

Links for both the table and chest builds are here: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/Furniture/index.html


I almost like the rear as much for its gentle lines ...


Recently Chris Schwarz has taken up the Military theme. He is doing his accurately, while mine was "in the spirit of". I do enjoy seeing what he is posting as this style attracts me (minus all the brass - which makes it less than what it is meant to be, but also less busy).

I'd love to see some of the favourite stuff you have built.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: What draws you to a piece/style of furniture?

#7

Re: What draws you to a piece/style of furniture?

Texchappy

Nice furniture Derek. Your Dad's chairs are really nice. Like your entertainment center too and have to agree with you about the back - hopefully it's not against a wall ;)

Thinking about the furniture I liked as a child I always liked the places that had the English library feel. Moved to liking the more modern sleek lines when my Mom married my step-dad who had Cadovius stuff.

Re: What draws you to a piece/style of furniture?

#8

Re: What draws you to a piece/style of furniture? *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

It's taken me some days to think about how to respond to this, because I can in no way offer a coherent answer.

I like many country and Shaker pieces for their simplicity, but at the other end, I'm attracted to many of the over-the-top Art Nouveau pieces for their complex outrageousness. Much modern furniture leaves me yawning (at best), but pieces like the night tables Derek Cohen showed in his first post responding to your question intrigue and delight me.

There are some pieces with personal associations for me, but they tend to be specific pieces, not styles.

I guess, in a lot of ways, it comes back to the realization I had several years ago about music. I like many styles of music, but they all need rhythm, melody, and some hard-to-articulate quality I might call "soul" but you might call any number of other adjectives. Technically great music with no emotion in it isn't interesting; flawed music with soul is, but it can be only so flawed. Fats Domino is often singing in the neighborhood of the key, not in the key, but he's got so much soul, and his overall technical mastery is so strong, that it doesn't matter. Mrs. Miller, on the other hand (link below for those too young to recognize the reference), was so far afield from key and everything else technical that her technical flaws mattered a lot.

Similarly with furniture. But don't ask me to define "soul" in furniture. I just knows it when I sees it.


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mrs._Elva_Miller

Re: What draws you to a piece/style of furniture?

#9

Generally, a beautiful lady sitting by it.


Re: What draws you to a piece/style of furniture?

#10

Moses Yoder

Re: What draws you to a piece/style of furniture?

Moses Yoder

I have studied the Shakers extensively and visited the Shaker village at Pleasant Hill about 20 years ago on my honeymoon. The history behind their furniture interests me, and the philosophy of not have any wasted adornment appeals to me because of my simple Amish upbringing. When I met the first of Krenov's books he talked about using the subtle beauty of the wood as decoration for the object, and then it all made sense.

I think if I applied myself I could learn to make Chippendale furniture fairly easily with a little bit of carving here and there, but a big part of me wonders why I would want to spend my time carving things onto the wood that aren't really meant to be there.

Re: What draws you to a piece/style of furniture?

#11

That is interesting Moses

Texchappy

I tend to agree with you Moses about ornamentation even though I had exactly the opposite of an Amish upbringing.

I’ve found the internet is opening up new vistas in furniture styles and the history of them. I haven’t been much exposed to Shaker Furniture but really like what I’ve seen since I started this trip.

I’ve also discovered a new love that I didn’t know about before - Welsh Stick Chairs. I hope to be able to make them some day :)

Re: What draws you to a piece/style of furniture?

#12

Re: What draws you to a piece/style of furniture?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I got to thinking about this thread - which I had to move down several pages to find, things having gotten busy here!

There's a part of me attracted to over-the-top wild stuff, like Louis Majorelle's Art Nouveau pieces:


and successor designs, like Craig Nutt's pieces:


I have several designs in my round-tuit notebook that I like to think have that same exuberance.

But I've become aware in recent years that work combining apparent straight lines with subtle curves can be very attractive. Using an automotive analogy, a lot of people see the older Volvos, like the 140 series,


as very squared off. But if you look closely at the car, you'll find there are few, if any, lines on the car that are dead straight; and those that appear to be are straight in one dimension only. I've really come to appreciate how cleverly they convey a serious demeanor with subtle curves.

There are lots of furniture examples, too; I just don't know how to find them on the interweb.

Re: What draws you to a piece/style of furniture?

#13

Re: What draws you to a piece/style of furniture?

Chris

I am Chris and I am addicted to Chinese furniture.

Not just any Chinese furniture, it's the "Ming style" furniture, as opposed to the "Qing style" that is most popular in the West. Qing is the richly ornamented, highly carved furniture, that the Rococo period tried to emulate.

Ming is the style of the poet-scholar-statesmen, with "straight lines and subtle curves" (sorry Bill for shamelessly copying your description of you Volvo) can be very attractive and sophisticated joinery. That's the style that our own greats, Chippendale, G&G and many others tried to copy (or were they just "inspired"?). It's the basis of what we in the West casually call "Asian style or Japanese style". Much of the modernist designs is said to have it's roots in Ming style. In fact "Ming style" is much older than Ming Dynasty (1368–1662); joinery goes back to at least the Tang Dynasty (618–907), maybe even Lu Ban (507–440 BC), the inventor or the plane, saw and inkline.

Re: What draws you to a piece/style of furniture?

#14

Re: What draws you to a piece/style of furniture?

roger lance

Chris....I also like Orientally influenced furniture....I built this entry bench two years ago from a plan in PWW....sorry about the photos but you get the idea....



Re: What draws you to a piece/style of furniture?

#15

Re: What draws you to a piece/style of furniture?

Texchappy

Very interesting and informative Chris. Didn’t know a lot of that. With that information I’d say that I’m probably close to your tastes on that. I prefer simplicity over heavier ornamentation.

Re: What draws you to a piece/style of furniture?

#16

Neat design

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Nice aesthetically and functionally: the curve at the end keeps sitters centered over the base.

Re: What draws you to a piece/style of furniture?

#17

From PWW June 2008.


Re: What draws you to a piece/style of furniture?

#18

Re: What draws you to a piece/style of furniture?

TomD

"I prefer simplicity over heavier ornamentation."

Absolutely, though, if you read a few books on the natural order that underpins architectural ornamentation or proportions, it does disrupt the quiet satisfaction or sense of superiority over things simple. And then add in the greater skill required to make the finer designs.

The fact is a Shaker piece of furniture is a Teva sandal; a Philadelphia highboy is a dessert boot, or Clarke Wallabie; the furniture out there that is a pair of bespoke Lobb shoes we wouldn't even recognize, or in most cases have seen. So the idea that even the furniture we think is fancy, is fancy is probably overstated.

There was a great book on ornamental details and conventions that was mentioned in maybe Woodworker a few years back, and I got it. Even the simple furniture hues to the conventions of proportion in many cases so it does help to read up on it. Does anyone remember that book?

I remember going to a guitar seminar in Nashville, were there was a presentation by a guitarmaker who was so deeply into the math of guitar bodies and other musical instruments, he had a phonebook of math calcs and designs. This was not really acoustics, just design relationships. It was fascinating.

Re: What draws you to a piece/style of furniture?

#19

Ellis Walentine

Re: What draws you to a piece/style of furniture?

Ellis Walentine

Is it the lines? The Craftsmanship? The story? Personal associations?

I suspect that it is a variable relationship between all these and more. I like the philosophy of A&C furniture, but I don't care for all A&C furniture by any means. Shaker resonates because of its simplicity and functionality and lack of ornament, but the philosophy behind it amplifies the appreciation. I admire some modern furniture on its aesthetic merits, not because it is designed for mass production.

As a furniture designer, I also understand the importance of context and its relationship to the personality and tastes of the owner. Furniture is functional (usually), so it needs to do what it is intended for, regardless of how it looks.

So, for me it is not so much a particular style as a combination of qualities -- pleasing aesthetics, impeccable function, appropriate engineering, relevant craftsmanship and attention to detail, among others. This opens my appreciation to quite a range of styles and levels of execution.

Ellis