New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Rip Saw Options? Both Japanese and Western

Posts

Rip Saw Options? Both Japanese and Western

#1

Rip Saw Options?  Both Japanese and Western

Texchappy

In my initial foray into woodworking, I’ve had no problems with either my ryoba or bad axe with cross cuts.

Rips, however, turned out to be another animal all together as witnessed in my earlier thread on this. Part of the suggested solution to that was a different saw.

Here’s the options I came up with:

1. 270mm Gyokochu (sp?) ryoba

2. Keep using what I have

3. Save up for a Wenzloff or other premium rip panel or full size saw

4. Find a vintage one if I can find a good source beside the bay

5. Get a good less expensive rip saw

Open to other options but what would you do if you were me?

Thanks,

Tony

Re: Rip Saw Options? Both Japanese and Western

#2

Re: Rip Saw Options?  Both Japanese and Western

TomD

Other than power, which is probably cheaper than some the of options mentioned, for instance a high end Bosch jigsaw is a pretty indispensable lifetime saw. One option that has not been mentioned is a bowsaw. There is a german saw with a big tooth rip blade that is very effective. The blades are cheap, and thin, and they do a good job. The euro style blades can be filled but are cheap enough to replace. Making the saw is a fun project, but they aren't expensive. I built my first 2, and bought my last 3.

http://www.highlandwoodworking.com/continentalframesawripblade.aspx

Do not get too excited that they offer Japanese blades. For years I had hoped someone would do this, but unfortunately these blades are not nice, they are overly aggressive. So good for something, but not really for much that I do.

Myself I use a variety of saws. Really old western back from when they were beautifully made. I have japanese disposable blade saws, and they are good but mostly softwood oriented I use them a lot though, because they take up little space so I travel with them.

I had a W. dovetail saw, and I did not like how it cut. But I have not tried their larger saws. There aren't any western makers that seem to be making panel saws of the quality of the older ones, so I am not encouraged to look at them. The way I look at it is if they are right that modern day saws made on haphazard stock are as good as older saws, then the reason would seem to be that the main game is the filling, so why invest in the saw? Or the other option is that they are wrong and the older saws are better all around.

Re: Rip Saw Options? Both Japanese and Western

#3

Re: Rip Saw Options?  Both Japanese and Western

david weaver

I personally would find a used and sharpened vintage rip saw, and base the tooth count on the thickness of the wood you're using. (something like 7-8 tpi for wood that's on the thin side, but if you use a lot of wood 3/4ths or thicker, something like 6 or 5 1/2.

If you're making all small stuff, a ryoba in a vise should be fine.

ripping with a carpenter saw should be a breeze (technically, I mean, the competence to do it well should come quickly - physical conditioning may be another thing completely).

Re: Rip Saw Options? Both Japanese and Western

#4

Re: Rip Saw Options?  Both Japanese and Western

Texchappy

I think I'm still weak in the vise/work holding department. The problem I've had with ripping isn't endurance but wandering off the line. I think part of this is where I've tried to rip. Using a Japanese saw I've been ripping with the board clamped to the edge of my 37" tall bench. I've been using small irwin quick clamps and they tend to get in the way.

I do have a couple of those Lee Valley/Veritas clamps that clip on he bench and allow for using horizontal work holding as well as standing boards up on their ends.

****

I'm definitely open to vintage saws but don't want to go through the Ebay listings ad nauseum looking for a good one. Where is a good place to find them that I can trust?

Re: Rip Saw Options? Both Japanese and Western

#5

Re: Rip Saw Options?  Both Japanese and Western

david weaver

Well, I guess you'd have to pay a little more, but I'd watch classifieds on the forums for sharpened saws.

I'd also ask the people sharpening saws if they'd be willing to talk for about 5 minutes about the projects you do so that you can be sure you're getting what you need.

They should have an economy saw (which should still be a good saw- better than anything new in the same price range) in an affordable range (like $60 or $75 or something). You can always restore saws on your own later.

Re: Rip Saw Options? Both Japanese and Western

#6

Re: Rip Saw Options?  Both Japanese and Western

CStan

It seems that the unique tooth geometry of Japanese saws is limited to crosscut teeth. Their rip saws are basically the same as ours (chisel-tooth rips) though filed with a different rake.

Re: Rip Saw Options? Both Japanese and Western

#7

Re: Rip Saw Options?  Both Japanese and Western

TomD

That is true, except being pull saws you can have thinner plates. When I got my first good japanese ryoba it had a plate of 14 thou, dramatically better than western saws, but today we have push saws that thick. Conceptually you should be able to go thinner on Japanese saws, but I don't know whether that is actually happening.

Re: Rip Saw Options? Both Japanese and Western

#8

Re: Rip Saw Options?  Both Japanese and Western

TomD

I don't think line wander should be the result of clamping, if the piece is firm. But imperfect hold can make cutting more work. If you can't re-clamp conveniently and have more overhang and vibration, etc... Ripping is already 3 time more work than crosscutting.

Re: Rip Saw Options? Both Japanese and Western

#9

Re: Rip Saw Options?  Both Japanese and Western

Brian Anderson Gunsmith

As I have been watching the sequence of questions that you have been asking, Texchappy, it appears that you are attempting to learn by asking questions of the members of this forum.

While that will produce some interesting answers, I wonder if you wouldn't be better served by taking a class or two where they build something. That would give you an opportunity to see other tools and perhaps to try some as well.

The experts at the classes would be able to provide you with valuable input in your search for skills.

My 2 cents worth.

I wish you luck in your efforts to learn.

Re: Rip Saw Options? Both Japanese and Western

#10

Re: Rip Saw Options?  Both Japanese and Western

CStan

Thinner does seem to be better.

Re: Rip Saw Options? Both Japanese and Western

#11

Re: Rip Saw Options?  Both Japanese and Western

Texchappy

Brian, you are correct in your assessment. I would jokingly suggest that you guys are cheaper than a class but that’s really not the reason I am not taking a class. I would actually enjoy a class. However, due to physical limitations my woodworking window is about 10-20 minutes a day and I cannot predict when during the day that will be and if I will have the ability any given day.

How about something like online or video ‘classes’? One example I know of is Schwarz’s Build a Sawbench class over on Pop Woodworking.

Re: Rip Saw Options? Both Japanese and Western

#12

Great suggestion

roninkokomo

Tony, this is a great resource. But for a full goose novice who wants to learn, I am not sure that it is the best source for you. It can produce a huge amount of cognitive dissonance, until you get some experience under your belt. Your tool choices indicate that you can probably afford a weekend tool skills class. I think that would be a fantastic investment for you. Those opportunities were not so readily available when I was a total greenie.

Ron in Kokomo

Re: Rip Saw Options? Both Japanese and Western

#13

An observation

Texchappy

Really Two...

1. I just went and tried to rip another board down to size. I used my western back saw. I could follow the line really well but it is two small to get all the way across even the short board I was cutting before the back got in the way.

2. Regarding Classes. It still sounds like a great experience but I’m still not sure how it would work with my health. How does one go about finding a class? I have found the KC WW club.

Re: Rip Saw Options? Both Japanese and Western

#14

Re: An observation

cstan

Tex, the rip cuts one typically makes with a backed saw are joinery rips - dovetails and tenon cheeks. You don't typically use them to just plain rip boards. If you are trying to rip small stock then you have a misunderstanding of the order of cuts and generally how to layout stock for parts. In hand tool woodworking one strives not be have to rip small workpieces to obtain narrower workpieces (in machine tool woodworking this sort of mistake is what leads to amputations). You rip what you need off a larger board (to width) and then crosscut the ripped piece to length.

Re: Rip Saw Options? Both Japanese and Western

#15

Clarification from Cstan please

Texchappy

"Tex, the rip cuts one typically makes with a backed saw are joinery rips - dovetails and tenon cheeks. You don't typically use them to just plain rip boards.”

Roger that, I fully understand that and did when I tried this experiment. I only have two saws - this saw and a 210mm ryoba. The 12” dovetail I was using is a hybrid set saw. The limitations I’m finding in these two saws is why I asked this question. This saw obviously isn’t appropriate for anything but joinery (for which it is designed). Likewise, the ryoba (from what I gathered from Wiley) is too small for the rips I’m trying to do with it.

"If you are trying to rip small stock then you have a misunderstanding of the order of cuts and generally how to layout stock for parts.”

Very Possibly.

"In hand tool woodworking one strives not be have to rip small workpieces to obtain narrower workpieces. You rip what you need off a larger board (to width) and then crosscut the ripped piece to length.”

Digesting this. What I’ve read and been told so far is to cross cut first to minimize the amount of ripping you have to do.

Re: Rip Saw Options? Both Japanese and Western

#16

Re: Clarification from Cstan please

TomD

You always have to diagnose the particular situation. Sometimes crosscutting first will not leave as valuable stock, sometimes you can rip to the point where the crosscut would intersect, and split the rest at no risk. Sometimes you can cross cut just far enough, then rip off a full length piece, or an L shaped piece. Sometimes the piece off the side is just scrap, but too much to plane, etc... There isn't any right or wrong way unless one has all the information, and possibly not then.

Re: Rip Saw Options? Both Japanese and Western

#17

Re: Rip Saw Options?  Both Japanese and Western

Texchappy

Went out into the garage and got the handsaw I’ve used on limbs and such over the years. Bought in about 2002, it is a Stanley Sharptooth (15-087) that saws induction hardened teeth 9 tpi. Is it worth cleaning the rust off to use for woodworking down in my shop?

Re: Rip Saw Options? Both Japanese and Western

#18

Re: Rip Saw Options?  Both Japanese and Western

david weaver

It probably is. You might even be able to rip with it once you get the rust off of it, though it won't work as a dedicated rip saw would.

Re: Rip Saw Options? Both Japanese and Western

#19

Best bang for the buck western rip saw

Texchappy

Part of my poorly thought out experiment with the little western dovetail saw was testing the ergonomics of the western saw. I think it works better for me than the japanese saws.

That said, what is the best bang for the buck in a newly made western dedicated rip saw?

Still would be open to a vintage if I could find one that I would be confident I could get to use.

Re: Rip Saw Options? Both Japanese and Western

#20

Re: Best bang for the buck western rip saw

david weaver

I don't know that there's a "good buy" in a modern rip saw. The custom saws are expensive, because it is not a mass production of quality saws type of thing like there was 100 years ago.

I would think a saw sharpener is your best bet. If you can find something clean and common, like a D8, and it just needs sharpening, you can send it to a sharpener. You'd end up with at least as good of a saw as a modern saw, and still have a lot less money in it.

Ryoba ripping and kataba ripping for me have always been a rough ride, and not something I like on long boards. It's perhaps because there aren't many or any machine made tough cheap saws that are really optimized for very hard wood, and perhaps also because you're working "into the straws" or perpendicular with them if you make a long rip with a ryoba, unless you cut it from below (i haven't actually seen that, and I don't want to try it).

With a western saw, you're stripping the straws of wood off just by being in the most comfortable position, and your weight is brought to bear on the saw if you need it pretty easily - the hook of the saw doesn't have to do that for you to be aggressive like it does on a kataba or ryoba.

I keep trying to find someone ripping a medium hardwood with a ryoba as quickly as can do with a $60 disston #12 I got several years ago, and I just never see it.

Re: Rip Saw Options? Both Japanese and Western

#21

Re: Clarification from Cstan please

CStan

You don't rip for width with a backed saw. You rip workpieces off a larger board. The rip cuts made with a backed saw are stopped cuts - dovetails and tenon cheeks.

Simple as that.

Re: Rip Saw Options? Both Japanese and Western

#22

D8

roninkokomo

There are lots of them on the bay. Look for a clean one. If it is sharp great. If not send, it to Matt or Bad Axe and for an additional $30 bucks you have a saw that will be great for your grandson.

Ron

Re: Rip Saw Options? Both Japanese and Western

#23

Re: D8

roninkokomo

a bunch FS now under 40

Re: Rip Saw Options? Both Japanese and Western

#24

That is exactly true.


Re: Rip Saw Options? Both Japanese and Western

#25

Bid is in on a Rip D8