Re: Rip Saw Options? Both Japanese and Western
TomD
Other than power, which is probably cheaper than some the of options mentioned, for instance a high end Bosch jigsaw is a pretty indispensable lifetime saw. One option that has not been mentioned is a bowsaw. There is a german saw with a big tooth rip blade that is very effective. The blades are cheap, and thin, and they do a good job. The euro style blades can be filled but are cheap enough to replace. Making the saw is a fun project, but they aren't expensive. I built my first 2, and bought my last 3.
http://www.highlandwoodworking.com/continentalframesawripblade.aspx
Do not get too excited that they offer Japanese blades. For years I had hoped someone would do this, but unfortunately these blades are not nice, they are overly aggressive. So good for something, but not really for much that I do.
Myself I use a variety of saws. Really old western back from when they were beautifully made. I have japanese disposable blade saws, and they are good but mostly softwood oriented I use them a lot though, because they take up little space so I travel with them.
I had a W. dovetail saw, and I did not like how it cut. But I have not tried their larger saws. There aren't any western makers that seem to be making panel saws of the quality of the older ones, so I am not encouraged to look at them. The way I look at it is if they are right that modern day saws made on haphazard stock are as good as older saws, then the reason would seem to be that the main game is the filling, so why invest in the saw? Or the other option is that they are wrong and the older saws are better all around.