A beginners question
eliot d
I'm convinced, based on just a bit of experience, that planing a board by hand gives a better surface than you can get by any other method available to the home woodworker. Is the same true of sawing by hand?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
A beginners question
eliot d
I'm convinced, based on just a bit of experience, that planing a board by hand gives a better surface than you can get by any other method available to the home woodworker. Is the same true of sawing by hand?
A very experienced answer....
roger lance
not everything is better by hand.
Re: A beginners question
Schtoo
I can get cuts off the saw that are 'finish ready'. Smooth, clean and look like they're planed.
But the saw needs to be sharp, the wood needs to be co-operative and I need to do my part as well.
My table saw will do the same things when it's in tune, but doesn't need co-operative wood nor do I need to do anything more than shove the wood into the spinning blade.
It's possible, but not always probable that a handsawn surface will be excellent. Much more likely for a circular blade saw to do a cleaner job of it.
Stu.
YUP ! . . .
steve mackay
And hand saws make us smarter and better looking ! HONEST !
It is not just about the finish.
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
Hi Eliot
There are many times I would prefer to trust my hand skills than my tablesaw.

Handsaws are as much about making saw cuts that cannot be made without a great deal of rigmarole. Point and shoot.
Regards from Perth
Derek
You forgot two Steve...
John in NM
They make us thinner and younger too

Agree
roninkokomo
I certainly am not to Derek's level in saw skills. I do aspire to that, and am working on it. But I can completely understand his comment. There is no question that for big jobs a good, well set up table saw is a ripping machine that is very hard to beat. It does carry a lot of initial cost compared to my $12 D8. It also carries with it a lot of danger. Each time. All the time. You forget that at considerable peril. Noise. Shop space are also other considerations.
Ron who had and used a table saw for years with only minor blood loss.
And it takes a LOT of effort to saw off your digit
Re: A beginners question - Yes and No
North of the Border
For small jobs, I find handsawing quick and clean...ripping a 6-feet long 2" wide oak board freehand with a saw into half, is a different story.
Re: And it takes a LOT of effort to saw off your d
TomD
Really, it ought to be hard to cut your fingers off on a saw. I accept that the whole subject has enough moving parts that you can be non-stupid, and hurt yourself. In the small shop environment, and the hand tools environment one ought to be able to avoid the blade.
- One should only work when not tired (risk is amateurs grab time when they have it and they could be tired);
- Never under any circumstances put your hands in the cut zone. This means not doing some things that might seem common, and/or always using, jigs, pushsticks;
- Don't over use the power saw. This should be easy for us since we don't want to use them at all theoretically. There is a kind of woodworker who cleverly works out how to even weld a battle ship on the table saw, but maybe all these associations end up with some less than safe procedures.
- There is a thing that happens when you automate a part of your work where it gets done so fast, it tends to lead to more automation. But learn to say "no". But there is a lot to be said for ripping 4" cauls of wood on a bandsaw. I might spend a few percent of the time in a job running it through the saw, and it saves a lot of wear and tear.
What all this stuff has in common is that it involves some element of discipline. Over one's state; not doing dangerous stuff.
Re: Agree
TomD
I bought a great cast Iron Beaver saw for 45 bucks, or 60, depending on how you measure it. There are deals like that all over the net. People who do rough work want the light saws, so some great saws are ridiculous cheap.
I prefer bandsaws for most breaking down of wood jobs, though they can really cut you if you aren't smart about it. Never been hurt though.
While I know smart people get cut... How many people getting hurt, are labourers in some terrible job, or drunks, etc...
With table saws I have sworn off through cutting. I rip a lot on saws because I makes strips for boats. I always reverse and cut, never do my hands get near the saw. Through ripping can be safely done, in many ways. I just don't do it myself, because I use too many different set-ups. I know I would push it at some point. My deal is if I don't want to get hurt, don't do stuff where you can get hurt. I don't mind getting hurt in some situations, but the table saw does not produce a high enough added value part, and isn't enough fun to use. bandsaw, really big bowl on lathe. Yeah, if it takes me I am ready. Not happening on a table saw, making a repetitive cut for a 2 cent piece.
Re: A beginners question
Brian Anderson Gunsmith
The table saw is designed to cut good straight lines with little effort all day long.
Whether you can cut long rips all day long to the volume and speed a table saw does is up to the fisherman in you.
Either the hand rip cut or the machine cut will most likely need some form of "smoothing" before it can be used in final form. Smoothing here is meant by me to mean that I would want at least a pass or two with a tuned smooth plane.
Give a man a fish and he is fed for a day, teach a man to fish and you have created another liar.
Re: A beginners question
eliot d
Even a beginner knows that it's easier to USE a power saw. (It's also easier to use a power jointer.) I was asking only about the quality of the cut.
Re: A beginners question
TomD
It is actually questionable whether it is easier to use a power tool, but to answer your actual question is would virtually never be true that quality of a handsaw cut was better. It can be better in use because I think there are cases when it is pretty perfect for gluing.
Power saws, work at a level of cutting power fairly equivalent to what you get when using a razor sharp tool, most hand saws are poorly sharpened. In lumberjack games they actually stone every tooth. Don't see that yet in the hand tool world, though I have done a little of it (all rights reserved).
Power saws are jigged, so every cur lines up with the one before.
Power saws work at a much higher rate. The teeth in a handsaw track a fair distance apart.