Re: How hard?
TomD
Once you are on the right path how hard you hit doesn't mater so much. You have to hit within your ability to hit. If you overdrive you will not hit accurately. But people often confuse working like a wimp with being careful or accurate. Quite a lot of folks are reasonably effective at chopping down trees or chopping firewood, and can hit with amazing accuracy. But you also need a certain amount of power. So while roughing I would power the cut. I prefer a heavier hammer and a shortened up grip to a wild swing.
The thing with roughing is that each cut should be parallel to the finished surface, or a try at that. It doesn't pay to just go to town, you have to have an intention that is consistent with your finishing cuts when you rough powerfully. It is the thought process that matters moreso than skill, or being weak in one's approach.
So like a broken record, let me suggest you make a trial piece and make your mistakes on a 2x4.
There is a myth that light cuts are more controlled. This can be true. But there are a lot of cases were it isn't. Often one sees someone sawing on a inch or two of saw, where a longer smoother cut is more effective, and actually easier to see any variance in pitch. With chisels, often a heavier cut holds the path better than a lighter one. Lots of different factors.
With any chisel when you give it a whack, it dives down from the bevel. You need to learn to account for that. What you don't want is for each successive tranche to dive lower. Japanese chisels are designed to hold the line better than western chisels since the load path on the handle somewhat bisects the edge of the chisel. With western chisels they are parallel and offset. But it is one of those chisel factors that people who are so clear that everything is just a mater of opinion, have probably not met. Doesn't mater what kind of chisel you use as long as you get the results you want.
Removing 2.5 cubic inches of wood is not a big deal, even if the eventual plane will be. I worked out that in making a plane one is removing the same amount of wood as in making one dovetail joint in 5.5" x 3/4" stock.
Ok off to roughly compile the video.