New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Help with the Mallet Continued

Posts

Help with the Mallet Continued

#1

Help with the Mallet Continued

Texchappy

Ok, so I've decided to make a mallet:

I have a plan: http://www.craftsmanspace.com/Free%20projects/Wooden%20Mallet.pdf

I have a local hardwoods yard that has the basics (cherry, walnut, pecan, oak, etc) and an hour away there is one that seems pretty well stocked. I'm thinking walnut for the head and oak for the handle - are there better choices?

Also, I'm guessing I just chisel out the sloped hole for the handle?

Re: Help with the Mallet Continued

#2

Re: Help with the Mallet Continued

CStan

If you intent to apply the mallet to wooden chisels then make the mallet out of a softer species than that from which your chisel handles are made. Wood chisel handle ends are not supposed to mushroom (at least not in western woodworking). If you know how to let a chisel cut, rather than have your mallet technique imply that the chisel is a nail, then you could use a set for thirty years and have them show no more than minor scuffing on the ends. They do not require rings or any other reinforcement to prevent damage.

Lighten up your mallet work... let the business end of the chisel be a chisel and cut... not act like a nail and pry fibers apart. This applies to your mortise chisels as well. Cut the wood, don't maul it, don't nail it.

Re: Help with the Mallet Continued

#3

Re: Help with the Mallet Continued

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

Walnut would be fine for the whole mallet. it has interlocking grain so it woud be suitable for the head and it is also strong in so it would be suitable for the handle.

A deep tapered mortice can be a chanllance for a begginer but if you do take a stab at it ( pun intended) start from one side and go half way then start from the other side and finish in the middle.

An easier way of making that design would be to make it the same way as a krenov style plane by cutting you head into three slabs and then cutting the center slab in two at the appropriate angle. Then glue the four pieces back together to form the head with a tapered hole through it.

You will likely end up wanting several different sized mallets so don't get too hung up on making the perfect mallet. Once you make one you can make another to suit your needs as they change.

Robin

Re: Help with the Mallet Continued

#4

Board Feet of Walnut if I use 3/4?

Texchappy

"An easier way of making that design would be to make it the same way as a krenov style plane by cutting you head into three slabs and then cutting the center slab in two at the appropriate angle. Then glue the four pieces back together to form the head with a tapered hole through it."

I had thought about doing that way and that may be the way I go for the first go at it. If I did go that way with it and use the plan I linked above, it seems that I could use 3/4 stock and get close to the metric that is on there already. How many board feet would I need to do that?

Re: Help with the Mallet Continued

#5

Re: Board Feet of Walnut if I use 3/4?

TomD

For the head, round numbers it is 6 x 4 x 2.5, or 60 cubic inches. 60/144 board feet

Linear you need 18 x 4 x 3/4" plus.

With luck the stock will be 4/4. and you can get the full dimensions you need.

When actually ordering wood, you need some extra, and you need to see the actual pieces to determine if the wood is perfect and will yield 100% parts, or whether it is normal and may require a little overbuying.

This kind of pattern is ideal for correct construction as planned, and then you can use any piece of firewood you have lying around. I know I went through a few years of my early woodworking almost disconnected from the idea that wood was lying all around me. I don't know whether you have access to a wood pile, or fallen branches. And while it is easy to break out those pieces for some, you would have to probably get lucky to find the right piece of wood. But this piece does yield itself to wet construction, just wax it up, and it will age in your shop.

Re: Help with the Mallet Continued

#6

! . . .

steve mackay

No idea, but you've got my undivided ! ! ! Was think'n the same thing this weekend. I've got no idea where to even start. Keep us posted !

Re: Help with the Mallet Continued

#7

Re: Help with the Mallet Continued

eliot d

I hope Textchappy won't mind if I but in. What you say about taking it easy when using chisels has a ring of truth about it. But I was watching on the net one of those Japanese kanna masters chopping out a dai, and, well, he was really pounding on it with what I presume were first class. sharp, Japanese chisels. It would seem that a gentle approach would take forever.

Re: Help with the Mallet Continued

#8

Re: Help with the Mallet Continued

CStan

Chopping a plane body hard? OK, I guess. Next time you make a plane feel free to wail away.

Next time you mortise a faceframe or make a door for a cabinet, try it the easy way.

It's not slow.

Re: Help with the Mallet Continued

#9

Re: Help with the Mallet Continued

TomD

I think in general, that real professionals of the type where the food that goes in their mouths is determined by the piecework they complete, tend to hit stuff harder, or take larger cuts. Of course accuracy is the end point, so you can't use the same power throughout. But if one were to watch every step of the plane process it is likely all stages would involve bigger cuts. From roughing to fitting. You don't get to that point by practicing tiny cuts. I remember being really surprised when famous golf teacher Harvey Pennick (HP was famous for his injunction that you "taked dead aim") mentioned that he always wanted his students to develop their full power first. He said you could always get a player to hit more accurately, but that power itself was unlikely to develop as a secondary characteristic. Pretty much the opposite of what I would expect.

Of course you can take anything too far: I got laughed at by the plane teacher for having the biggest hammer!

Re: Help with the Mallet Continued

#10

Why for?

Bob Hackett

Or as they say up here in Maine "Whatsitfor".

Ask yourself this;"What will I be hitting with this?

If it`s a wooden plane body, like your Japanese plane, then you want the mallet to dent before the plane body does so get wood for the head of the mallet that is softer than the plane body yet still has enough weight to do what you`d like it to do (or add weight as someone suggested in an earlier post).

Tell us what you plan on doing with this first mallet (you`ll be making more than one, trust me) and we can then make better suggestions as to appropriate wood.

Re: Help with the Mallet Continued

#11

Re: Why for? Answer: Yes

Texchappy

I eventually will want to do two mallets. I’d like one to adjust my wooden planes. I also got a western chisel to try out - Blue Spruce (with the figured maple handle). So the answer to your question Bob is... yes ;)

Re: Help with the Mallet Continued

#12

I'd still look around for some scrap wood...

John in NM


Both of these came from scrap wood, the bigger one is ~20 oz (I weighed them for you :D ), the head is 12/4 mesquite from a shop I used to work for. Not the best wood for a mallet, being prone to chipping as you can see, but in 15 years it's done lots of work and taken lots of abuse.

The smaller one weighs about 8 oz and is made from an oak limb (they were trimming trees at Kitt Peak when I worked there) with a hickory handle. First handle was teak, because I had it, and didn't last more than a couple years. Stuff never rots, but it makes a lousy handle :D

That Arizona oak is hard as nails and really dense, nothing like what you find in the lumber yard.

While either of those mallets is a lot easier to make with power tools, both are possible with hand tools alone (though the turned head would be tricky, not a lot of spring pole lathes around anymore :D )

Re: Help with the Mallet Continued

#13

Re: Help with the Mallet Continued

Blue

A Dogwood Mallet is a good one. Just dig up a Dogwood tree that's around 3-5 in. at the base and the burl below it becomes your Mallet head.

Re: Help with the Mallet Continued

#14

Re: Help with the Mallet Continued

CStan

Tex, make one out of pine/fir and soak the head in linseed oil. The mallet will eventually look like crap. What you are striking with it, won't.

Pick up a really clean 2x4 and laminate the head, and heck, make the handle too. This will be a good dry run (that will be functional I promise) before you use a prized bit of better wood to make your masterpiece.

Email me and I'll send you a PDF of Charles Hayward's book on making tools and jigs.

CS

Re: Help with the Mallet Continued

#15

How do you email someone on here?


Re: Help with the Mallet Continued

#16

Re: How do you email someone on here?

Bruce, a MN Galoot

You will find most email addresses next to the person's name in one of their messages. Copy and paste that into your personal email program and mail away. There is no PM function in this site's software.

Re: Help with the Mallet Continued

#17

Re: How do you email someone on here?

CStan

Just sent you the file Tony.

Re: Help with the Mallet Continued

#18

Got it; Thanks very much


Re: Help with the Mallet Continued

#19

Re: Help with the Mallet Continued

eliot d

SO, for my first attempt at making a dai from fine Japanese white oak, do you recommend taking it easy or whacking away?

By the way, I got Toshio Odate's book, 'Japanese Woodworking Tools' , which has a whole section on making kanna. But I'm VERY puzzled by the following, on page 97: "Start to cut the mouth opening with a butt chisel. Work in from the top of the block, cutting only within the chipbreaker area. Constantly refer to the sides of the block for reference so that you don't overcut the angles, which would be disastrous, CUT IN ABOUT THREE QUARTERS OF THE WAY FROM THE TOP, AND THE LAST QUARTER IN FROM THE SOLE, SO YOU WON'T DAMAGE THE MOUTH ON THE SOLE AND THE KOPPA-GAESHI. I can't see how he could mean to cut the actual mouth opening, where the blade will protrude; I believe he has to mean the large opening opposite the bed -- the large opening at 90 degrees to the bed. If that's what he means, then what does he mean by the part that I wrote here in capitals about, "the last quarter in from the sole". There's no way to cut in from the sole, no? I watched that master on the net: he cut along the bed angle from the top first in one direction, then turned the block around and cut along the slope at about 90 degrees to the bed angle from the other side, always form the top of the block.

Re: Help with the Mallet Continued

#20

Re: Help with the Mallet Continued

TomD

If it is the same master, then he does cut in from top and bottom. Cutting in from both sides is critical, as I think I mentioned in the longer pieces I wrote for you a month or so ago. Because if you cut in from both ends, then you have two accurate reference point. If you cut in from only one side, then you are trying to shoot the line accurately down the ramp which is very difficult.

You will need to drill out some of the mouth area, or at least that is what I do.Then just work back carefully in whatever direction your lines describe.

OK, I went back and looked at tape A in the Inamoto youtube presentation. It appears that he does come down all the way from the top. Around 5 minutes he takes a cut from the underside, but it is not all that probing. This is not how he showed us. He did dumb down our presentation a little though, so maybe that is the difference between doing the 6 months + 6 months to get the angles right, and the method we were taught.

If I had your email I can post you the url to the youtube video I was working on. I don't think I will finish it, but the key tips are probably in the completed part.

Re: Help with the Mallet Continued

#21

Re: Help with the Mallet Continued

eliot d

My email is eliotandmax@verizon.net . Thanks for helping. I'm still having trouble thinking about cutting from the sole side. The chisel I THOUGHT I would use is a really large Sorby morticing chisel. I mean its rectangular cross section is 5/8" x1/2". So I guess I'm not getting that 1/2 " dimension through the mouth opening. Well, there are smaller chisels.

Re: Help with the Mallet Continued

#22

Re: Help with the Mallet Continued

TomD

You could be suffering from project vs. skills/technique thinking. Take a scrap of wood, draw a mouth type slot that is 1.5 x thicker than your blade at the bevel. Drill some holes at the angle you are expecting to use, or not. Take a butt chisel, and see what happens. You can do this in pine. Getting 1/4 up there is not that big a deal, could be less. The important thing is that you have a landing that represents your ramp angle once you clear out the intervening wood from either end.

As with most all chisel work, you are not hammering in nails, you are strategically undermining the wood so chips pop out. And you don't want to pop chips out of the lower, ramp, not that it would really matter, but yeah it is a delicate exercise.

Re: Help with the Mallet Continued

#23

Re: How hard?

TomD

Once you are on the right path how hard you hit doesn't mater so much. You have to hit within your ability to hit. If you overdrive you will not hit accurately. But people often confuse working like a wimp with being careful or accurate. Quite a lot of folks are reasonably effective at chopping down trees or chopping firewood, and can hit with amazing accuracy. But you also need a certain amount of power. So while roughing I would power the cut. I prefer a heavier hammer and a shortened up grip to a wild swing.

The thing with roughing is that each cut should be parallel to the finished surface, or a try at that. It doesn't pay to just go to town, you have to have an intention that is consistent with your finishing cuts when you rough powerfully. It is the thought process that matters moreso than skill, or being weak in one's approach.

So like a broken record, let me suggest you make a trial piece and make your mistakes on a 2x4.

There is a myth that light cuts are more controlled. This can be true. But there are a lot of cases were it isn't. Often one sees someone sawing on a inch or two of saw, where a longer smoother cut is more effective, and actually easier to see any variance in pitch. With chisels, often a heavier cut holds the path better than a lighter one. Lots of different factors.

With any chisel when you give it a whack, it dives down from the bevel. You need to learn to account for that. What you don't want is for each successive tranche to dive lower. Japanese chisels are designed to hold the line better than western chisels since the load path on the handle somewhat bisects the edge of the chisel. With western chisels they are parallel and offset. But it is one of those chisel factors that people who are so clear that everything is just a mater of opinion, have probably not met. Doesn't mater what kind of chisel you use as long as you get the results you want.

Removing 2.5 cubic inches of wood is not a big deal, even if the eventual plane will be. I worked out that in making a plane one is removing the same amount of wood as in making one dovetail joint in 5.5" x 3/4" stock.

Ok off to roughly compile the video.

Re: Help with the Mallet Continued

#24

Re: How hard?

eliot d

Your comments continue to give me confidence. I'm going to take your advice and try the whole thing out on something other than the good stuff from Japan. Maybe not on a pine 2 x 4 but on something that would make a good plane if I manage to get it right. I've got some nice maple lying around.

Re: Help with the Mallet Continued

#25

Re: How hard?

TomD

Sounds like a good plan. However, as you saw, it took him like 5 minutes to hack out the plane. A few minutes spent on a practice piece are still worth it. I have skills, but I don't use them every day, or even every month. A warm up is useful just to get the body moving. And it is also useful so you can plan out your cuts. A maple plane is still a project, even if it is maybe a lower stress one. Practice, not projects, make perfect. :)