New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Instructional video about the chipbreaker *LINK*

Posts

Re: Instructional video about the chipbreaker *LINK*

#26

Re: Moving the frog

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I did my experimenting in the period 1974-1977, so I am having trouble remembering my thinking. I do agree with David B that the is bedding more important and in the main mouth size does not come into play for a double iron plane.

Here is one situation where it is nice to have a fairly tight mouth: If you are using the plane as Moxon describes for a Strike Block, where the plane is in your left hand and the right hand is holding some small work piece, it is easier with not much gap. Likewise if you fasten the plane in the vise for trimming small pieces.

Re: Instructional video about the chipbreaker *LINK*

#27

Re: Instructional video about the chipbreaker

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Kees was demonstrating a double iron plane, not a block plane. There is no flaw in his presentation.

Re: Instructional video about the chipbreaker *LINK*

#28

Re: You're right, of course.

CStan

I agree completely. A 'half millimeter' is silly. Once it's less than 1MM, it's a matter of the eye and art - what looks best.

Re: Instructional video about the chipbreaker *LINK*

#29

Joining the fray...on the side of Kees

Bill Tindall

I agree with the comparison made. One variable changed, others held constant. What was done is the only way to do the experiment of exploring the effect of cap iron and and keep the experiment simple. Results simple to interpret- cap iron works. There may be other significant variables affecting tear-out but finding them was not part of the scope of this experiment/demonstration.

The only time in research when two or more variables are changed at once is when one wants to explore variable interactions. Indeed, in this case the cap iron and mouth opening are expected to interact but the exploration of this interaction requires an experimental design worthy of the University environment the Professors Kato and Kawai work at. To draw any reliable conclusions from changing two variables that interact requires both lots of experiments and a sophisticated data analysis. No conclusion could be derived from the simple experiment of doing one planing test with mouth closed cap iron back, mouth open cap iron close.

Re: Instructional video about the chipbreaker *LINK*

#31

No Good Deed Goes Unpunished

Bill Tindall

One of my many wall posters seems appropriate here.

Re: Instructional video about the chipbreaker *LINK*

#32

Re: No Good Deed Goes Unpunished

Kees

Yeah, wish I used the wooden plane in that video.

;-)

No worries. While you were all discussing, I was sleeping like an innocent child.

Re: Instructional video about the chipbreaker *LINK*

#33

For future reference?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi All,

Big, hearty congratulations to Kees! This demonstration video held my attention throughout. At 3 min 45 seconds, it has the virtues of directness and brevity. For me, the key moment was not so much the finished wood surface, but rather the setting of the chip breaker, and I was glad he took many seconds and a closeup to show what a close setting looks like.

A link to this video would be a useful addition to the repository of Kato/Kawai-iana. And where is that repository? At Wilbur's site? At Mark's site? Is something going to reside on WoodCentral?

Kees' demonstration video will be a useful reference going forward, and I am thinking we don't want it to simply scroll off the bottom of the page.

Wiley

Re: Instructional video about the chipbreaker *LINK*

#34

Improvement suggestions - More close-ups

North of the Border

We can borrow a page from the close-up photos in articles. In the video, the vid-camera was placed far away from some of the critical action shots and details could hardly be seen. For example, the polished bevel (at about 70 degrees) is not shown in a close-up. Another example is at 0:50, the view is at a distance.

Unlike in a print version, details (and they are often the devil that makes or breaks) in videos are harder to catch, even if you keep rewinding the clip. A close-up shot for each critical set-up or step will not only help people understand the technique but also allow anyone to replicate the process if she or he so desires to do so.

Re: Instructional video about the chipbreaker *LINK*

#35

Sometimes, the perfect

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

is the enemy of the good. When it forestalls useful action. Perhaps someone else will do their own video, and it can be linked too. I see no reason to place obstacles in the path of something which is good and useful right now.

I don't disagree with your technical points--they are valid IMO.

Wiley

Re: Instructional video about the chipbreaker *LINK*

#36

Or as a friend of mine once said, perfection

Bruce, a MN Galoot

is much worse than you think! :D

Re: Instructional video about the chipbreaker *LINK*

#37

Re: Not perfection, just excellence

North of the Border

Striving for excellence motivates you; striving for perfection is demoralizing. ~Harriet Braiker

In woodworking, or for that matter, offering instructions, I try to find the difference between excellence and perfection and then do my best to reach for the former. When my instructions confuse my students, my good teaching is lost in the way. The video produced by the Japanese professors was an academic effort towards better understanding of handplaning and towards excellence.

My suggestions are general comments and not meant to discredit the usefulness of the video. Its usefulness, however, will be enhanced if a viewer of its contents fully understands the instructions.

Re: Instructional video about the chipbreaker *LINK*

#38

I wasn't being critical of your comment

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I actually agree with your ideas.

My point was more general in nature, mostly that perfection is a moving target, difficult if not impossible to attain, and it can drive you nuts in the process.

Re: Instructional video about the chipbreaker *LINK*

#39

Re: I wasn't being critical of your comment

Kees

Overall I am very happy how the video was recieved. It's not perfect, not even very excelent. But this being the first time I used videoediting software (Windows Moviemaker), it didn't tirn out too bad.

For another time I hope to be able to use some of your comments.

339 views on Youtube until now. That's not really close to the millions I would like to reach. But it's still early days ;)