We are parsing minutiae a little bit..
david weaver
.. what kees did is exactly what someone needs to see to get themselves on the path to using the cap iron to clean up their surfaces.
It's not a formulaic comparison for beginners, because it does take some judgement to set the thing properly, and the longer you do it, the better you get at mitigating tearout and still preserving surface quality.
If this became an exercise in combinatorics to try to compare everything, then you're just going to lose people who flat out need to see what it looks like with the cap iron set close so they know "am I off by 3x or am i close?"
I would've done the same thing if I made a video. Exactly the same thing. I don't know anyone who successfully controls tearout with a common pitch plane with the mouth size. You can reduce it, but it is not a good strategy and as others have stated, it keeps you from doing what you really need to do to mitigate tearout. I also think this moving the frog all over the place business is a measure of trying to work with bevel down bench plane the same way you'd work with a plane that has an adjustable mouth.
There are very few older planes that are going to have a mouth clean enough to worry about it, anyway, especially when the cap iron itself is much more effective and easier to adjust.
So hopefully, people will watch kees video and use it as a step to get themselves into figuring out how to work the cap iron to their advantage in different situations. If a beginner can't adjust it by formula perfectly on the first try, that's not really the point. I gather that most folks won't be able to make a qualified statement on how well it works unless they do it exclusively for a month or two, anyway, and at two weeks when I brought it up to warren, I figured, I don't know that much about this yet, but I can't seem to cross it up.
And if there is another impractical setup or another plane type that could reduce or mitigate tearout, that's fine, but that's not the point of the video. It does what it's supposed to do - it shows that the cap iron is effective by itself on wood that you would actually use to build something, but that has a marginal spot or two in it.