New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Instructional video about the chipbreaker *LINK*

Posts

Instructional video about the chipbreaker *LINK*

#1

Instructional video about the chipbreaker *LINK*

Kees

Today I took some time to make a video about the use of the chipbreaker/capiron/shaving bender. I think it is kind of important to reach the masses. And where do the masses look these days? On youtube of course! There must be millions of people around who don't know how to use the chipbreaker to good effect.

It was a bit of a spur of the moment thing. So I didn't ask my wife how to dress in front of rest of the world.


Chipbreaker tuning against tearout

Re: Instructional video about the chipbreaker *LINK*

#3

Re: Instructional video about the chipbreaker

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Kees

That was a great idea. Nothing like seeing it happen.

There are a few changes I'd like to see, if you can edit the video: the sequence should be (1) showing the chip breaker set at 1mm, then planing with it, (2) then setting the chip breaker to 2-3mm, and planing with it. In the video you start by showing the 2-3mm setting, then jump back to planing at 1mm.

The flaw in the comparison is that you used a wide mouth for the 1mm setting as well. You referred to the 1mm setting as more typical. If so, you should have closed up the mouth. The comparison would have been 1mm/closed mouth versus 0.2-.3mm/open mouth.

Do it again. It will be a classic!

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Instructional video about the chipbreaker *LINK*

#4

PS

Bill Tindall

Tweed jacket next time and sultry voiced female narration.

Re: Instructional video about the chipbreaker *LINK*

#5

Re: Instructional video about the chipbreaker

Kees

First i must get myself a tweed jacket, Derek. :D

Re: Instructional video about the chipbreaker *LINK*

#6

Re: Instructions on making instructional materials

North of the Border

That's sound advice from someone who has done countless reviews or instructional writings.

How-to videos or articles are easy to produce from the videographer's or author's perspective but are equally easy to misunderstand from the viewer's or reader's position.

Anyone who sets out to produce an instructional vid will do a better job if she or he puts all the steps on paper first and read them to make sure they are in proper order and the desired details are there. We can learn a lot from Norm Abram's discontinued show because each episode was carefully scripted, time-controlled, task-sequenced, skills-highlighted, and professionally produced.

The worst amateur or semi-professionally produced woodworking videos out there are those that take 10 minutes to cover something that requires only a minute or two. We can find them all over the Internet/woodworking sites and blogs -- including some that you have to pay to watch. Unknowingly to the presenters, the videos become being more about them rather than about the woodworking subjects or projects.

Re: Instructional video about the chipbreaker *LINK*

#7

Re: Instructional video about the chipbreaker

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I don't see any flaw in the comparison. Kees changed one variable and displayed the result. This is science. If he changed the mouth as well it would have muddied the waters.

Re: Instructional video about the chipbreaker *LINK*

#8

Re: Instructional video about the chipbreaker

CStan

Good point, because one of the advantages of this technique is that the woodworker can quit fooling with frog position. Set if level with the mouth and the action that follows is all chipbreaker, which is what I believe Kees portrayed and what should be portrayed.

I dont' think setting the capiron back a sixteenth or more with a tight mouth is representative of any orthodoxy of which I'm aware... unless I'm misunderstanding Derek's post.

In my measly operation if I have a capiron set back a sixteenth you can bet the mouth is not tight. I'm going for a rank cut for sure.

Re: Instructional video about the chipbreaker *LINK*

#9

Re: Instructional video about the chipbreaker

david weaver

I think the new age folks, those starting in the era of the internet often try to solve their problems with double iron planes by narrowing the mouth and moving the chipbreaker out of the way.

I have never done that, though, the precision is not there in the mouths of a lot of planes to be able to do that and not threaten the edge of the iron, etc putting them in.

The best thing about this whole chipbreaker take-up lately is that you don't have to move the frog around to eliminate tearout (which it never did as far as I could tell, rather it might've reduced it, but "less tearout" isn't very useful if you're going for none).

Re: Instructional video about the chipbreaker *LINK*

#10

Re: Instructional video about the chipbreaker

CStan

That's my understanding, and when I revisited this last week I definitely had to move the frog back to prevent the plane from choking with the uber-close chipbreaker setting.

Re: Instructional video about the chipbreaker *LINK*

#11

Moving the frog

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I don't think I have moved a frog in thirty years.

Re: Instructional video about the chipbreaker *LINK*

#12

Re: Moving the frog

david weaver

When I had first posted the message in mid march and said that I'd eliminated tearout in my shop and made "I think you're right" kind of statements, I had already moved the frogs on subject planes right back to be flush with the castings. One of the best things at that point, and still was that I knew I would never diddle with the frog again or worry about whether or not the mouth was laser crisp like it is on my infill (which is important on that plane because of its use there).

I had moved them back right away, knowing that if it worked, I wouldn't have to worry about a mouth that was a 16th of an inch or whatever.

The only thing I can think of where having that laser tight mouth is nice on a plane that's not single iron is for a plane that is going to be used to bevel the ends of exposed tenons, etc. But that can be done easily with a chisel or a block plane.

Re: Instructional video about the chipbreaker *LINK*

#13

Re: Instructional video about the chipbreaker

Kees

Hi Derek,

Thanks for the idea. It's great to see critical comments.

That said, after thinking it over a bit more, I tend not to agree with you.

The message of this little video is not to proof anything. It's to demonstrate how to tune up your chipbreaker and to demonstrate the effect of the chipbreaker.

I know there are other methods to prevent tearout and a closed mouth is one of them. But I wanted to get the message across that you really need a wider mouth and that you sure don't need a tight one.

Re: Instructional video about the chipbreaker *LINK*

#14

Re: Instructions on making instructional materials

Kees

I sure hope you could see that I did have a carefull plan in my head! It's not a long rambling sequence full of repetitions, like you see on some video blogs.

Re: Instructional video about the chipbreaker *LINK*

#15

Re: Instructional video about the chipbreaker

TomD

Yeah, the change only one variable at a time idea is valid, but if changing one variable forces the change of others then you might as well get on with it.

Re: Instructional video about the chipbreaker *LINK*

#16

Re: Instructions on making instructional materials

North of the Border

Yours, of course, is not one of those long-winded videos. Mine was just a general observation on those that, by the nature of their off-the-point comments and verbal add-ons, do not do justice to their otherwise good contents. Sorry if it cast a wrong impression that yours was an unorganized and long speech (which you didn't make).

Re: Instructional video about the chipbreaker *LINK*

#17

Re: Instructions on making instructional materials

Kees

Allright, no bad feelings overhere ;)

Re: Instructional video about the chipbreaker *LINK*

#18

Re: Instructions on making instructional materials

TomD

Yeah you have a point. There are plenty of "amateur" folks on youtube who produce better than professional results. I think it is one of the oddities of video that while it can be the format with the lowest barriers to use, that isn't a functional feature given how critical people are. Another thing to take away from Norm Abrams is that it doesn't matter to your popularity that you know (initially) nothing about the subject.

I was just taping the layout video for Japanese planes, but I am not really happy with it. I think my basic video skills are OK. But I don't have anything to hold the camera where I need it, and the camera isn't HD (as my eyes age I can see where that would help a lot of people), and for sure someone will say they can't see the lines on the block. etc...

Most people can judge whether a video is entertaining to them, while virtually nobody knows or cares about setting out Japanese planes. The people that care enough to persevere with a "bad" video, have probably already figured it out for themselves. It's really about entertaining people, I think that is a legitimate expectation that most people have.

Re: Instructional video about the chipbreaker *LINK*

#19

We are parsing minutiae a little bit..

david weaver

.. what kees did is exactly what someone needs to see to get themselves on the path to using the cap iron to clean up their surfaces.

It's not a formulaic comparison for beginners, because it does take some judgement to set the thing properly, and the longer you do it, the better you get at mitigating tearout and still preserving surface quality.

If this became an exercise in combinatorics to try to compare everything, then you're just going to lose people who flat out need to see what it looks like with the cap iron set close so they know "am I off by 3x or am i close?"

I would've done the same thing if I made a video. Exactly the same thing. I don't know anyone who successfully controls tearout with a common pitch plane with the mouth size. You can reduce it, but it is not a good strategy and as others have stated, it keeps you from doing what you really need to do to mitigate tearout. I also think this moving the frog all over the place business is a measure of trying to work with bevel down bench plane the same way you'd work with a plane that has an adjustable mouth.

There are very few older planes that are going to have a mouth clean enough to worry about it, anyway, especially when the cap iron itself is much more effective and easier to adjust.

So hopefully, people will watch kees video and use it as a step to get themselves into figuring out how to work the cap iron to their advantage in different situations. If a beginner can't adjust it by formula perfectly on the first try, that's not really the point. I gather that most folks won't be able to make a qualified statement on how well it works unless they do it exclusively for a month or two, anyway, and at two weeks when I brought it up to warren, I figured, I don't know that much about this yet, but I can't seem to cross it up.

And if there is another impractical setup or another plane type that could reduce or mitigate tearout, that's fine, but that's not the point of the video. It does what it's supposed to do - it shows that the cap iron is effective by itself on wood that you would actually use to build something, but that has a marginal spot or two in it.

Re: Instructional video about the chipbreaker *LINK*

#20

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Instructional video about the chipbreaker *LINK*

#21

Re: Moving the frog

CStan

You might want to just to make sure it's not frozen in place.

Re: Instructional video about the chipbreaker *LINK*

#22

Re: We eat our own, too

CStan

I believe this is precisely why my favorite British writers just say "as close as you can get" instead of quoting a measurement less than that available on a standard metric rule - i.e. one millimeter.

Anybody 'needing' a distance quoted of less than 1MM is not really getting the art of this whole thing.

Re: Instructional video about the chipbreaker *LINK*

#23

Re: Moving the frog

CStan

I'd also be fascinated to know how you arrived at the setting you'd keep for 30 years. Any thought go into this? Did you just set it at the back edge of the mouth and never think about it again? Leave it where it was set when the plane(s) were purchased and brought into your shop? Ever get the least bit curious? On a rainy day with not much to do?

Re: Instructional video about the chipbreaker *LINK*

#24

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Instructional video about the chipbreaker *LINK*

#25

Re: Instructional video about the chipbreaker

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I don't see any flaw in the comparison. Kees changed one variable and displayed the result. This is science. If he changed the mouth as well it would have muddied the waters.


Warren, while you may not move the frog, for many years all the popular texts have (while largely ignoring the chip breaker) advocated closing up the mouth to reduce tearout. This is still the popular conception. Therefore leaving the mouth open, which advantages the close-up-chipbreaker, disadvantages the set-back-chipbreaker. You end up with apples and oranges.

Regards from Perth

Derek