Re: Consumerism and stuff I 'should' make
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
There's a list of stuff I feel I 'should' make myself...
Bench hooks (already bought from bad axe)
Shooting board (hey, I can buy a plywood one for $130 - ouch)
Marking gauge (though every time I read Schwarz I keep coming back to the tite-mark)
Panel Gauge
Saw Benches (but my two tiny saws aren't up to the task so yet another expense; then do I want low Japanese or traditional english)
mallet (could get a chester plane adjusting for $57 and a Chris Schwarz approve in-fill mallet for $185)
moxon vise
straight edge
winding sticks
square
partridge with optional pear tree
...but am intimidated because I don't feel I have the right tools yet or the skill.
Hi Tony
Yes, you can make all those tools. For some that is an important goal, while for others making tools detracts them from building furniture. So there is no "should make" in my view. My own preference is another matter, and I enjoy building a tool between furniture projects. The tools are a "quick fix" in contrast to the time for longer builds. I also have an interest in creating a set of tools that I built, but this will take time, and I place building furniture ahead of building tools.
Recognise that you are starting out in handtool woodworking. While I am not advocating that you buy cheap-and-nasty, you really must lack the experience to appreciate some of the more advanced and expensive tools, such as your Old Street smoother. It is already starting to get damaged by inappropriate hammer use. I would set it aside for now and get something else to use.
Many of the tools on your list are desirable but will not be used for the majority of your projects. Some are essential, such as squares and a basic cutting gauge. Personal preference comes into this a great deal as well, so you will read arguments for-and-against the Tite-Mark versus traditional cutting gauge. Only experience will tell you which is right for you.
At this stage I would resist the urge to buy shooting boards and other simple tools, such as a Moxon vise and mallets. These are easy to make (well, basic ones at any rate), and they are ideal first projects for you.
Look at the examples built by others and try and work out how they were done. Experiment. Fiddle. Ask questions here on "how to".
Regards from Perth
Derek