New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Shooting Board Plans?

Posts

Re: Shooting Board Plans?

#26

Project Plane Mallet Help?

Texchappy

I've got a fairly long piece of poplar that is an off cut so I think I may try a straight-edge out of it. It's probably too soft to be optimal but at the very least I can prototype the operation.

One of the first projects I think I can handle and probably one of the most pressing needs is for a mallet to adjust my Old Street Smoother. I noticed last time I used it I had already put a couple of small marks on it.

I figure a handle and an octagonal or square head (easy to shape) would work.

But I do need some help - how heavy would it need to be? What wood(s) for head and handle? Where's a good place to get the small amount of wood I'd need? I know you can get 'exotics' on ebay - any recommended vendors?

Re: Shooting Board Plans?

#27

I almost hate to say it...

John in NM

And this is not meant to be in any way pejorative, but you need to read less and start making stuff. Two hours spent in the shop struggling to overcome some problem is worth a weeks worth of reading on the internet. It strikes me that your ideas of what tools you need is really taken out of the context of use, and you're going to end up with stuff you don't need.

There are tons of fancy tools I'd like to have but don't, because it is so rare that they are actually needed. You know the difference when you realize that some task you've always struggled with is made comparatively easy - the tool that does that is one you need.

Don't worry for example, about how heavy the mallet head needs to be. Make one out of whatever you have around and find out if its heavy enough or not. If not, simply make a bigger one - it will take half the time the first took (ok, maybe that is exaggerating, but the first two or three of anything I make take far longer than the later ones).

I've only dealt with a couple of ebay sellers - that is almost the most expensive way of buying wood - thanks to shipping costs and well, ebay. I've bought Euro beech from Exotic Woods of the World a couple times before I found an almost local source - had to have steamed Euro beech to match existing stocks. Look for turning blocks if you want to make a few tools, those will likely be roughly the size you need and relatively reasonable.

If it comes to it, send me an email with your address and I'll see what I can scrounge up where I regularly go for scraps. Wouldn't be especially exotic, but I can probably fill a flat rate box for you.

Re: Shooting Board Plans?

#28

Re: Project Plane Mallet Help?

TomD

You may need more weight than regular wood will provide. Epoxy some lead or a brass bolt in there. Most of the heads these days are either metal and wood, or metal and plastic. Krenov had an arty little hammer. But he had access to all kinds of woods. Some like Lignum are heavier than water. But steel is about 7x heavier.

Re: Shooting Board Plans?

#29

Re: I almost hate to say it...

Texchappy

You are right John in NM and I wish my body would cooperate more. I know I'd think a lot less and do a lot more. I spoiling to get down into my workshop right now but my battered back isn't getting out of this recliner for a bit more.

Re: Shooting Board Plans?

#30

Re: I almost hate to say it...

TomD

"Don't worry for example, about how heavy the mallet head needs to be. Make one out of whatever you have around and find out if its heavy enough or not. If not, simply make a bigger one - it will take half the time the first took (ok, maybe that is exaggerating, but the first two or three of anything I make take far longer than the later ones). "

The first ama I made for my trimaran took 6 weeks, the third (there was an oops in there not related to making) took 10 hours. FK said in one of his tapes than an expert is the person who knows what steps come next. Which is a bit of an oversimplification, but probably right if you have the skills, or the job is not too skills intense.

Re: Shooting Board Plans?

#31

Re: Project Plane Mallet Help?

Texchappy

TomD, got your response about the plastic hammer after I posted. Not a woodworking solution but I do have one of those glen-drake tite-hammers (lightest one - looked cool so I bought it - d'uh) that I haven been using. I'm guessing it might help to glue some leather on the front?

Re: Shooting Board Plans?

#32

Don`t let that stop you

Bob Hackett

we have something called a "car pool" up here. We find out who lives in the general area and then we decide who is gonna drive and the rest of us pay for gas. For the two years I was going thru a series of surgeries I never had to drive myself to one of our meetings which were a little over an hour away. For close to 4 years I rarely traveled to meetings alone.

Sometimes the discussions while traveling back and forth gave me as much if not more directly applicable information than the meetings did.

Pick up the phone and call your local WWing retail store and ask about who to contact for the local club. That person can tell you who lives close to you and I`ll be surprised if you can`t wrangle a ride with someone headed that way.

Re: Shooting Board Plans?

#33

Re: Project Plane Mallet Help?

TomD

I might try drilling it out and putting epoxy in a shallow hole. It is amazing what a difference just tape can make. Leather also, though it might be too soft.

Re: Shooting Board Plans?

#34

craigd

Re: Project Plane Mallet Help?

craigd

I use a 5oz dead blow to adjust my planes. Haven't noticed any marks. Some times a small metal hammer to tap the blade deeper.

Re: Shooting Board Plans?

#35

Japanese planes and shooting boards

wilbur

Here's the link to my post on shooting boards and Japanese planes.

http://giantcypress.net/post/482930234/japanese-planes-and-shooting-boards

There are two main differences between a shooting board for western planes and a shooting board for Japanese planes. The first is obvious: with a Japanese plane shooting board, the fence is placed towards you, due to the pulling motion.

The second is not quite so obvious: the chute where the plane runs needs to be a bit deeper for a Japanese plane than for a western plane. That's because there's more distance between the side of a Japanese plane and the beginning of the cutting edge compared to a western plane (here I'm thinking of Stanleys, Lie-Nielsens, or Lee Valleys).

Otherwise, it's pretty much the same.

Re: Shooting Board Plans?

#36

Re: Consumerism and stuff I 'should' make

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

There's a list of stuff I feel I 'should' make myself...

Bench hooks (already bought from bad axe)

Shooting board (hey, I can buy a plywood one for $130 - ouch)

Marking gauge (though every time I read Schwarz I keep coming back to the tite-mark)

Panel Gauge

Saw Benches (but my two tiny saws aren't up to the task so yet another expense; then do I want low Japanese or traditional english)

mallet (could get a chester plane adjusting for $57 and a Chris Schwarz approve in-fill mallet for $185)

moxon vise

straight edge

winding sticks

square

partridge with optional pear tree

...but am intimidated because I don't feel I have the right tools yet or the skill.

Hi Tony

Yes, you can make all those tools. For some that is an important goal, while for others making tools detracts them from building furniture. So there is no "should make" in my view. My own preference is another matter, and I enjoy building a tool between furniture projects. The tools are a "quick fix" in contrast to the time for longer builds. I also have an interest in creating a set of tools that I built, but this will take time, and I place building furniture ahead of building tools.

Recognise that you are starting out in handtool woodworking. While I am not advocating that you buy cheap-and-nasty, you really must lack the experience to appreciate some of the more advanced and expensive tools, such as your Old Street smoother. It is already starting to get damaged by inappropriate hammer use. I would set it aside for now and get something else to use.

Many of the tools on your list are desirable but will not be used for the majority of your projects. Some are essential, such as squares and a basic cutting gauge. Personal preference comes into this a great deal as well, so you will read arguments for-and-against the Tite-Mark versus traditional cutting gauge. Only experience will tell you which is right for you.

At this stage I would resist the urge to buy shooting boards and other simple tools, such as a Moxon vise and mallets. These are easy to make (well, basic ones at any rate), and they are ideal first projects for you.

Look at the examples built by others and try and work out how they were done. Experiment. Fiddle. Ask questions here on "how to".

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Shooting Board Plans?

#37

Re: Consumerism and stuff I 'should' make

Texchappy

Very Well said Derek and I appreciate it (as well as all the other advice given). I have the tools to make my simple box (even if I don't use the smoother). Back or not I'm going to work on it tomorrow.

Re: Shooting Board Plans?

#38

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Shooting Board Plans?

#39

Thanks David

Texchappy

You can definitely tell from my posting habits when I can't work. I start thinking of new questions and new projects. My mind is definitely a lot more active than my body at this point and it is Frustrating! I'm doing my best to take the project at reasonable bites. One of my obstacles is that my work bench is in the basement. The next part of the box is the last really difficult part - the last long rip cut.

Re: Shooting Board Plans?

#40

Re: Shooting Board Plans?

Christopher Fitch Memphis

No plans...but I'll try to include a picture of two I just made.

Re: Shooting Board Plans?

#41

Re: Consumerism and stuff I 'should' make

TomD

Derek has a lot of wise words there. On the other hand, as far as the blade goes, if it is soft O1 up where you hit it, it is bound to suffer some denting if you hit it with a metal hammer. Some Japanese planes have forge welded inserts on three sides, so that the metal plane adjusting hammers they use will not deform the plane, though a modest amount of deformation is pretty acceptable. You want a plane to last for generations if it can, so there should not be dramatic wear all at once. But certain marks are also expected, like mushroomed butts on your chisels.

As far as adjusting wedged blades is concerned, I place my fingers over the mouth and support the edge on them, while with my other hand I snug in the wedge by hand. When you get the feel of it, the blade will almost be at correct depth from the start. Then I do the initial visual adjustment, then I snug the wedge a little more, take some shavings, and when I get the blade in perfectly, I seat the wedge. I use the lightest pressure that is necessary for all stages. It does not take a lot of pressure on a well made plane, so you should not have to use a lot of force to drop the blade to depth or hold it in place. If you get the blade just so, then bang on the wedge, you will only disturb your setting, so use minimal force. Keep in mind that OS blades can pass right through, allowing you to drop them to the floor and possibly harm you. So use care as regards that.

Re: Shooting Board Plans?

#42

Re: Shooting Board Plans?

Christopher Fitch Memphis

Here's a pic...


Re: Shooting Board Plans?

#43

Re: Shooting Board Pic?

Texchappy

Thanks for the pic Christopher. Let me see if I can dissect the construction --- there's a cleat, MDF, plywood, and then a hardwood stop. I'm assuming short one is end grain and long is for the sides.

Re: Shooting Board Plans?

#44

Re: Shooting Board Pic?

Christopher Fitch Memphis

That's correct...

Some details of interest:

1) they are they same height. This allows for using a board as support for a long board.

2) There is a small chamfer on the bottom edge of the platform that holds the board.

3) The fences are not glued but merely screwed to the board. I may change mine to work like Derek's down the road.

I spent some time digging around for other people's boards. The end grain board is patterned after the Lie Nielsen plans except that I did not make the left side.

Here's some links:

LN board

http://www.lie-nielsen.com/pdf/Shooting_Board_And_Fixtures.pdf

Alf's board

http://www.ukworkshop.co.uk/forums/as-requested-making-a-shooting-board-t4162.html

(Got the chamfer idea from her)


http://www.rpwoodwork.com/blog/2009/03/31/shooting-board/

Another - miter shooting board


and finally here is a long nice article

http://www.woodskills.com/Tutorials/ShootingBoardPlan.html

Re: Shooting Board Plans?

#45

Re: Shooting Board Pic?

Christopher Fitch Memphis

hmm..that last link *used* to go to a long article. Guess he decided to start charging for it.

Re: Shooting Board Plans?

#46

Re: Shooting Board Plans?

CStan

I sense you may not be at a level in your woodworking journey to make one of these accurately enough to serve the purpose. If you have power equipment, in excellent tune, you might consider making this a machine-tool project that will benefit your hand-tool woodworking.