New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

The plane truth.

Posts

Re: The plane truth.

#26

Re: asking again.....

Mark Hennebury

As some have already stated: A planed surface is quite different than sanded surface. Whether or not it is noticable to the average person , i cannot say.

The planed surface, will display more depth, clarity and brightness, it will absorb and reflect light as you move around due to the properties of the open cells, so it will feel more alive. And all without drugs.

Plus its smooth and flat. real flat, people will want to rub it.

Is this not enough for you Bill?

It would seem to me that most of this will still be experienced through a finish.

I have done Lacquer , shellac and varnish finishes, but prefer oil finishes, which work very nicely with planed surfaces.

The Germans mostly use supersurfacers for making windows, I am told.

I would guess that they finish them, but dont know with what material.

I do know that the German Wood institute or some such organization did studies on supersurfaced wood and stain/ finish applications and found them better than sanded surfaces.

The fact is supersurfacers are great to use and once you get used to them you wouldn't think of not using them. Sanding just doesn't seem right after you have seen planed wood. Its crisp and sharp and clean and bright.

As to whether or not its worth it... thats a harder question to answer.

Re: The plane truth.

#27

Re: In all fairness...

Larry Williams

Also "in all fairness" we've just about come full circle. As you and I went around with this before, the more viscoelastic compression of the wood fibers you introduce the more wood fibers are held in place for severing. It viscoelastic compression also generates heat so the more compression the more heat and the shorter the edge life. Heat is a catalyst to adhesive wear but has little effect on abrasive wear.

It wasn't long after our last discussion of this I had a phone conversation with Konrad Sauer and I explained to him that the higher the bed angle a shaving was taken with, the more the wood was compressed and the shorter the shaving would be relative to the original length of the board. I believe I read someone puzzling over this same thing appearing in the Kato paper.

Re: The plane truth.

#28

What would you advice your neighbour?

Kees

Larry,

When your friendly neighbour walks over to your shop with his trusty old Stanley and a piece of curly cherry, asking: "I've always had great luck with this plane, but now this piece of wood beats me. What should I do?"

Would you tell him:

A: To throw that piece of junk away and buy one of your planes.

B: Advice him about the proper use of the capiron.

Re: The plane truth.

#29

Re: Woodcraft seems to have stopped printing it

les winter

You can find a copy on ebay for $13 or at abebooks.com for around $5.

Re: The plane truth.

#30

Dubbed corners

Kees

When you sand a surface with a Ros, it's difficult to keep it from dubbing over the corners. Especially with a glossy finish you can see how the light reflects differently overthere. It just looks cheesy to me. With a plane it's a lot easier to keep the surface flat.

Re: The plane truth.

#31

Unfriendly greeting for new kid on block

Bill Tindall

Visit Mark's web site and get blown away by some of the best designed and executed furniture you have ever seen. Conclusion-this guy walks the walk and has a lot to teach.

Then visit the most unique machinery web site I have ever seen. My jaw hit the floor when I saw all the links to related woodworking including studies by Steve Elliot.

I posted a question about Supersurfacers on the web site one Sunday evening. I wanted to know if the Kato-Kawai work wound up having any practical significance. I hoped for a reply in a few days. I got a detailed reply in an hour and the source clearly had an in depth understanding of the topic.

Bottom line- Mark is the most valuable resource for someone making furniture that has come along on this site for a long time. Don't run him off with your crankiness.