New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

The plane truth.

Posts

The plane truth.

#1

The plane truth.

Mark Hennebury

The plane truth.

I have been involved in this discussion about chipbreakers for the past few weeks; I have supplied a lot of information and offered my opinions and insight the best that I can. I have followed much of the discussions

And have a couple of things I think that should be stated;

The facts:

1. Chipbreakers work.

2. Some people have known that chipbreakers work.

3. Some people have not.

4. The information has been around for a long time.

5. The information was not hidden or secret.

6. Some of you didn’t do your homework.

I can understand how nobody wants to admit it but, that’s the simple truth.

Those that didn’t know it, either didn’t look hard enough, or refused to see or recognize the evidence.

Those of us that did know it had no special access code, no secret library or internet to use.

There are many sources to have found this information; One source for the information was supersurfacers:

Marunaka made their first supersurfacer in 1970, by 1976 they had sold 10,000, They have sold over 1000 in Germany alone. The North American wood industry is considerably larger than the German wood industry.

So why have supersurfacers been ignored in North America. Makita, Hitachi and Ryobi tried very hard to promote supersurfacers in North America in the 80’s, check your Fine woodworking magazines.

I have had supersurfacers in my shop that were made as early as 1973, so they have been in North America for a while.

Supersurfacers are nothing more than a powered handplane, but they are the finest planing tool on the planet, with the most sophisticated engineering based on scientific knowledge of cutting principles. I would have thought that anyone interested in planing would have at least been curious enough to examine them.

Bill Tindall found the Kato video because he went looking, he found me because he went looking for information on supersurfacers.

I had all the Kato information on my website for years, nobody bothered looking.

I have had all of the blade and chipbreaker setup information on my website for years, anyone could have accessed it, I even had the link to the Kato video (they at some point removed the video, so the link didn’t work but all of the photos and English translation were there.)

I found out about supersurfacers because I went looking, long before I had computers and internet access.

Whatever your hobby, passion, trade or profession, you simple do not have any excuse not to know, not these days, every bit of information is available at your fingertips 24/7 …..GTS

Re: The plane truth.

#2

How do you use the Supersurfacer?

Bill Tindall

The question is from two angles and a boat load of ignorance.

1. Given that it only does moderate widths is it any use for making panels?

Even if I used the machine to prepare say a drawer front, handling the front will invariably scuff it up such that in my case I do a final sanding just before finishing. At least for the way I build I can't see where this planed surface would carry to, or survive to, the final piece before finishing.

2. Then a more global question, how are these spectacularly planed surfaces used where they make any difference in the finished furniture? Is there an apparent difference in a planed surface with two coats of rubbed shellac or lacquer vs one sanded? I don't see any difference in the appearance of the finished surface between 180 and 600 grit so I was never motivated to learn to use a hand planed surface believing I would never see the difference from a typical observation distance.

3. I have never been able to control stain take up on a planed surface. The open pores drink up stain like a sponge and the surface goes way darker than I prefer. Can planed surfaces be stained in a controlled way?

Re: The plane truth.

#3

Re: How do you use the Supersurfacer?

Mark Hennebury

Hi Bill,

interesting points;

Using Supersurfacers requires that you are very carefull about how you handle your material. You have to develop a consciousness about not damaging your wood, not laying it on the floor etc. A tiny piece of grit from the floor can damage your knife pretty quick. So you have to develop very good workhabits, and be quite organised and well disciplined.

Supersurfacers are available up to 1050mm (41.3")width of cut, although those are not at all common.

The more common ones have 13.25" knife in them, They will cut 10" at a 40 degree skew, and are open sided, so you can actually cut boards double the cutting width, by turning the board around.

On finishing:

Supersurfacers slice the wood cells, so that they are all cleanly severed and open.

This gives a very brilliant depth and clarity to the color and cell structure. a glass smooth surface, a flat surface, even over woods with great variations in earlywood and latewood, or opening such as mortises and grooves.

The open clean cells make a better glue, stain and finish surface as compared to sanding.(The Germans did studies to back this up)

Sanding scratches up the cells, leaving them ragged, dull, filled with dirt, and not flat, not the best for glueing or finishing.

I am not an expert on staining, i did some: i experiemented with chemicals and dyes, but for the most part did not stain much if I could avoid it.

I would think that you could control the stain with a size if you were having a problem.

Re: The plane truth.

#4

Ouch, that hurts!

Kees

:D

Re: The plane truth.

#5

Re: Ouch, that hurts!

Mark Hennebury

I am just calling it as i see it.

I think that this forum is a good place to deal with some of the issues and attitudes in the woodworking industry.

I have had many concerns with what i have seen over the past 40years of woodworking and maybe this would be a good chance to get some things of my chest and get some opinions.

Re: The plane truth.

#6

Re: let it rip, maybe we'll learn something!! 


Re: The plane truth.

#7

not common knowledge

Chris Friesen

While the information may have been available to those who went looking, it certainly wasn't common knowledge. Most old handplanes I've seen have cap irons that aren't well mated to the iron and irons that weren't particularly well-sharpened so there's no way you could set the cap iron within a few thou of the end of the iron.

It seems that if very tight cap iron settings were the norm at some point then as machine tools became more common this information became less well known.

Also, the early texts that I've seen (mostly as part of this discussion) aren't very precise. Something like "..so that its edge lies against the iron at a very small distance from, and parallel to, the cutting edge..." is not particularly precise. "a very small distance" could easily be 1/32, or 0.02", or I suppose even 0.002" but it's difficult to know for sure.

Re: The plane truth.

#8

Re: not common knowledge

John Pappas

I have a book, "The Use of Hand Woodworking Tools" published in 1962, Delmar Publishers, in which it says, "Place the plane iron cap 1/16" back of the cutting edge for general work. On cross-grained or curly wood it should be about 1/32" from the cutting edge." Not a lot of detail, but specific nevertheless. Now, in those days (mid 60's) I could not properly sharpen a plane blade, and my plane was not well tuned, but I did know about setting the cap close to the edge for those special situations.

Re: The plane truth.

#9

asking again.....

Bill Tindall

Not sure this part of the question was answered.....

I get it that a surface from the Supersurfacer looks better than a sanded surface while lying on the bench. However, surfaces in furniture have finish applied to them. If I am going to use a planed surface to be finished vs a sanded surface I want to see a benefit in the piece of furniture sitting in the living room. What finishing schedules will, or will not, reveal a difference. If two coats of shellac or lacquer rubbed out don't show a difference the potential market shrinks.

Re: The plane truth.

#10

Re: not common knowledge

david weaver

The trouble with the instruction of 1/32nd is it doesn't do anything. It's probably advice based on a guess, but a person who took it literally would find the cap iron didn't do much unless the shaving was extremely thick, thicker than anyone would take for a finished surface.

Re: The plane truth.

#11

Re: asking again.....

david weaver

Bill, you will see a difference with that kind of surface, there will be more depth to the hand planed surface even with finish on it.

However, it's unlikely that anyone else who is not a woodworker will notice.

If you have some scrap cherry around, give it a rip vs a surface run up to 220 or 320 grit.

Re: The plane truth.

#12

Re: not common knowledge

Christopher Fitch Memphis

Just an FYI more than anything...

Planecraft...Record's educational advertisement book that has been in print since 1934 has the following info on page 41 (from the Chapter 4: Adjustment of the Plane:

For rough work Cap iron 1/32 in to 1/16in from edge

For finishing work Cap iron 1/64 from edge

For hard woods with irregular grain cap iron as close as you can get it to cutting edge.

Re: The plane truth.

#13

Re: not common knowledge

david weaver

LN should get rights to print that and sell it with their planes.

I wish I would've had the foresight to read it!

Re: The plane truth.

#14

Re: The plane truth.

Larry Williams

The facts:

1. Chipbreakers work.

I don't think that's the debate. The issue is whether cap irons are the most effective and efficient way to deal with difficult grain with a hand plane.

2. Some people have known that chipbreakers work.

Again, not much debate here.

3. Some people have not.

In most cases cap irons cause more problems than they cure. I certainly understand why any hand plane user would give up on them.

4. The information has been around for a long time.

Yep. I was at your site a long time ago and watched your video. I followed a link on Steve Elliot's page. He does a lot better job of explaining things and has tried a lot of different stuff without trying to sell anything. His information is a lot more applicable to hand planes.

5. The information was not hidden or secret.

No, I've pointed people to Steve's site for a lot of years.

6. Some of you didn’t do your homework.

You mean like notice that this is a hand tool woodworking site. Why come here promoting a machine that's most efficient at putting a finish surface on full-length stock that then must be reduced to usable lengths? Isn't this best done with automated CNC equipment that eliminates shop and bench wear that would spoil the finish left by the machine?

Or maybe that homework could be a working knowledge of steeper pitched planes which you don't seem to have any experience with. You even seem puzzled by the depth adjustment of the Super Surfacer that actually changes the effective pitch of the blade to a higher cutting angle.

Are you aware that with judicial burnishing one can very nearly duplicate the cutting geometry of the Super Surfacer and the 80º cap iron bevel with a Stanley #80? The heat generated makes for a short edge life. My guess is those irons for the Super Surfacer have a high speed steel lamination for the edge to withstand the heat generated by that configuration.

Hand planes have issues the Super Surfacer doesn't. The mouth and shaving clearance is one. I read your post about back beveling the mouth and it suggests to me you haven't used a hand plane enough to experience the common mouth wear issues. Back beveling makes the wear quicker to open the mouth and the wear will happen quicker because there isn't as much mass to dissipate the heat at the edge you create. This doesn't even get into the issues of wooden planes where the iron is secured by a wedge. The horns or points of the wedge, the abutments, and the high spot on the cap iron all need to line up at the same point when the wedge is set or you create a shaving trap that chokes the plane. This complicates the set up a lot and this includes almost all planes made before the mid 19th Century. The most common cure was to camber the iron so that it only cut in the center section of the iron leaving the user wielding a plane that was a lot bigger, heavier, and more clumsy than necessary.

Thanks for the lecture, BTW.

Re: The plane truth.

#15

Re: asking again.....

Schtoo

Bill,

If you ever manage to get a piece of highly figured wood planed smooth and clean, and then add a clear finish to that surface and can then compare a similar piece of wood that's been sanded (even to a very high grit), the difference in appearance is so obvious it's painful.

And anyone can see the difference.

But in regular, well behaved woods, the difference isn't so great. In those cases, you'd have to ask an experienced eye to spot which was which.

Kind of ironic that the stuff that's more difficult to get planed cleanly and is more likely to be sanded for safety is where the biggest benefit to planing smooth lies.

I'm not saying a sanded surface is inherently ugly or lacking. I've sanded more show surface area than I've planed by a large factor, and have even sanded a planed surface to balance the appearance of the pieces even though the visual difference was small (plain wood).

I don't think that the wonder and amazement of the chip breaker (I don't give a ^&%$%^ what you want to call it, it's a chip breaker to me) is going to be the magic bullet for planing that many seem to want it to be. It's another arrow in the quiver for sure, but there's some wood that no matter how technically perfect the equipment might be, you still need an experienced eye, head and hands to get the stuff planed with any success.

Or in other words, I'd not be selling any stock in sandpaper companies just yet. ;)

Just my take on it.

Stu.

Re: The plane truth.

#16

Re: not common knowledge

Christopher Fitch Memphis

I'm not sure when I bought my copy (at least six or seven years ago). I'm pretty certain I first heard about it somewhere on here.

For such an inexpensive book, it's loaded with alot of info. It's certainly does not present anything in perhaps the best manner and it's not an exhaustive reference, but it's still pretty decent. However, I think Woodcraft stopped carrying it so it's more difficult to find.

Re: The plane truth.

#17

David Barnett

In all fairness...

David Barnett

"You mean like notice that this is a hand tool woodworking site. Why come here promoting a machine that's most efficient at putting a finish surface on full-length stock that then must be reduced to usable lengths? Isn't this best done with automated CNC equipment that eliminates shop and bench wear that would spoil the finish left by the machine?"

I don't recall Mr. Hennebury promoting his Super Surfacer on this website nor would it seem a logical venue to do so. I've only seen him respond to questions posed here by those interested in its workings germane to the Kato-Kawai studies. In fact, I believe it was through Bill Tindall's curiosity about the Super Surfacer that Mr. Hennebury was led to WC Hand Tools.

Re: The plane truth.

#18

Woodcraft seems to have stopped printing it

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Woodcraft acquired reprint rights at some point, years and years ago. I can't remember when I bought mine*, but it was a looong time ago.

I looked about a year ago on half.com, and used copies were selling for $6. Now that it's out of print, new copies are suddenly going for $80 and up. Someone should acquire reprint rights from Woodcraft and crank up the presses again. I consider it an essential text on hand planing; not the only one, and not exhaustive, but essential.

*Not that this proves anything; there are days when remembering what I had for lunch at 4 p.m. is an impossible task.

Re: The plane truth.

#19

Re: In all fairness...

Mark Hennebury

Thanks Dave,

as you said I came here after speaking with Bill out of curiosity and am quite happy to discuss and share my knowledge and experience with you, and see what I can learn from you.

Re: The plane truth.

#20

Re: not common knowledge

Mark Hennebury

All that I can tell you is that I have known about adjusting the chipbreaker for as long as I can remember, I am talking late sixties.

My father was carpenter and joiner in England and i did woodworking at school.

I have never measured chipbreaker settings and always just adjusted it with a few taps of a small hammer, i judged it by a thin line of light relflection as others have said, and was always at the boundry of too close, and jamming the shavings.

I dont know where i learned it but that was the way that i learned it.

Re: The plane truth.

#21

Re: not common knowledge - wrong

TomD

Given that all Japanese planes with breakers have them adjustable, and apparently they are used to the same settings as here, but those settings are not numerically controlled, I don't see how two out of three of the issues could even be in doubt. Breakers affect plane cutting performance, they are adjusted till they work, though having a number in your head is not relevant in this use. But I don't think I knew any of this solely as a result of Japanese tools. Super surfacers are designed to power up traditional hand woodworking. They did not create the need.

Re: The plane truth.

#22

Re: asking again.....

TomD

I think you are onto something there. For me, super planes, and this has come up in many other threads, produce a finish that is great for that segment of woodwork that needs an all natural finish, like some Japanese timber frames. The finish is left unfinished. Or planing is a great way to get to the point where you then hit the surface with sandpaper, and finish it with your favourite stuff. That is still a great use for handplaning//SS, but the final surface is not going to get seen, it had to be evened with 360 or some such. I would far rather super surface a surface if I could get equal results to say an abrassive planer, with a lot less burning and dust.

There is also the waste, not sure how often the SS waste can be used. Dust is difficult to safely burn. In the FWW magazine article that compared Hitachi and Makita products, I think, they gave one commercial user who was making, call it, bespoke bedding for livestock, I think. The point being that he was interested in the shavings side of the equation, not the boards. I remember thinking about that when my young daughter, at the time, tried hand planing, and it was clear she did not understand that it was about the boards, it seemed to her to be about the shavings.

Re: The plane truth.

#23

Re: The plane truth.

Mark Hennebury

Seems to me that i detect a hint of hostility in your tone.

I posted the thread to point out a problem: Simple hand tools should be understood. They obviously are not.

I am happy to discuss it and even argue it, but stay on topic. I really dont care what you think of me. Discuss the topic, argue the points and I will stay to the end. Make it personal and we wont get far, i am sure I can get as personal as you.

"I followed a link on Steve Elliot's page. He does a lot better job of explaining things and has tried a lot of different stuff without trying to sell anything"

Give me a break.

"You mean like notice that this is a hand tool woodworking site. You mean like notice that this is a hand tool woodworking site. Why come here promoting a machine that's most efficient at putting a finish surface on full-length stock that then must be reduced to usable lengths? Isn't this best done with automated CNC equipment that eliminates shop and bench wear that would spoil the finish left by the machine?"

What the hell is that about?

Supersurfacers can plane short stock 4" long by the way

"Or maybe that homework could be a working knowledge of steeper pitched planes which you don't seem to have any experience with."

I will give you that one,

"You even seem puzzled by the depth adjustment of the Super Surfacer that actually changes the effective pitch of the blade to a higher cutting angle."

Thats just nonsense. At least put something sensible in the rant.

"Are you aware that with judicial burnishing one can very nearly duplicate the cutting geometry of the Super Surfacer and the 80º cap iron bevel with a Stanley #80?"

No, i wasn't.

"The heat generated makes for a short edge life. My guess is those irons for the Super Surfacer have a high speed steel lamination for the edge to withstand the heat generated by that configuration. "

That sounds like a reasonable assumption.

"Hand planes have issues the Super Surfacer doesn't. The mouth and shaving clearance is one"

Supersurfacers make shavings, pretty much the same way handplanes do, so dont see what the difference would be.

"I read your post about back beveling the mouth and it suggests to me you haven't used a hand plane enough to experience the common mouth wear issues."

You go ahead and jump to the wrong assumptions if you like. I have made enough shavings to satisfy me and I am quite willing to go head to head with anyone about handplanes.

"This doesn't even get into the issues of wooden planes where the iron is secured by a wedge. The horns or points of the wedge, the abutments, and the high spot on the cap iron all need to line up at the same point when the wedge is set or you create a shaving trap that chokes the plane. This complicates the set up a lot and this includes almost all planes made before the mid 19th Century. The most common cure was to camber the iron so that it only cut in the center section of the iron leaving the user wielding a plane that was a lot bigger, heavier, and more clumsy than necessary. "

For a moment i thought we were on the history channel, I could give a crap about old stuff... or new stuff for that matter. I like tools that work efficiently.

Re: The plane truth.

#24

Bob

Re: The plane truth.

bob

Mark,

Your web site sounds interesting. What is the address?

Re: The plane truth.

#25

Re: The plane truth.

Mark Hennebury

Hi Bob,

www.solidwoodmachinery.com