We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
..misunderstanding that drove me to a relevant conclusion, anyway.
I thought it was a surface quality issue, and I think I even responded to it as such. I recall adam cherubini brought it up, and I had a rude response because I thought it would be common knowledge that the bench plane at 45 degrees would leave a brighter surface than a 55 degree infill.
Of course, George Wilson plainly saying "it's not hard" to set a cap iron close when needed pushed me to do it a little, too.
Not that I'll ever accumulate 1/50th of the skills george has, but he let me know i was off the mark.
"And the clear question that still comes to me is that double iron planes were not "cheap and common" when they took over, and they weren't even cheaper than a steeper pitch plane once they were, but most craftsmen still seem to have chosen them, anyway. They were more expensive. Why then was everyone willing to pay more for them in a time when craftsmen had very little disposable income. "
for the same reason - power sanders were more expensive than planes.
Less skill. less cost. For the average workman - doing joiner's work, the plane will last a lot longer as the mouth opens with wear but the plane still works pretty darn well for the type of work it is supposed to do. There is no evidence to suggest one way or another that on the super high end of work double iron planes replaced single iron planes before the 1820's. Not enough people did super high end work and there is not enough evidence.
Andre Roubo in the 1780's BTW asks a different question. He wants to know why iron mitre planes were not generally used in general cabinetry instead of marquetry. Of course he was just addressing himself to high end cabinetmakers not joiners. 10 years later English makers started making iron mitre planes in more common quantities so they began to be used for high end cabinetry.
Duncan Phyfe had an iron mitre plane in his toolbox from the 1820's although how important it was in the actual workshop isn't known.
I can't agree with the conclusion of less cost for a less skilled user for a double iron plane. As larry has pointed out in his video, you can use a properly made single iron plane for a long time without the mouth opening becoming an issue.
It is likely that the mouth in most single iron smoothers is/was never tight enough to eliminate tearout (though it could mitigate the worst of it perhaps somewhat, but not completely), but instead the angle was the overall mitigating factor with tearout.
I'd have to see documentation that proved that was the case. In order to use a double iron plane with good effect, a user still has to have skill (which has been part of the argument with all of this to start, that a double iron plane is fiddly and harder to use for a novice), but for a sander one does not.
do you have any documentation that asserts that double iron planes were more durable long-term and easier for a lesser skilled user?
In the Krenov book Fine Art of Cabinet Making he recommends setting the chip breaker (his words) 1/32" behind the edge for fine work and 1/16 for "general use"(p.94). In David Finck's book on plane making he recommends setting the "chip breaker" 1/32 behind the blade tip.
Krenov describes scraping and sanding "rowed woods", what I would call ribbon stripe(p 51).
If someone could show that ribbon stripe (rowed) Padouk can be planed with an optimally set chip breaker it would demonstrate that the cap iron effect was not known to Krenov, presuming he would have used it instead of scraping and sanding. Of course finding some situation where the cap iron effect doesn't prevent torn grain does not means it a generally useless.
We are talking about the very very top end of performance here.
it is 1770. You are a joiner what makes more sense? buying a double iron plane that will work consistently well in a plane body for a long time doing well or buying a single iron plane, that is capable for incredible performance that you don't need- (you don't want a very fine shaving most of the time, and you aren't planing difficult woods most of the time) and then as the mouth opens up - in daily work it works less well. Where's the single iron value?
"It is likely that the mouth in most single iron smoothers is/was never tight enough to eliminate tearout (though it could mitigate the worst of it perhaps somewhat, but not completely), but instead the angle was the overall mitigating factor with tearout."
probably true. Larry has said that the decline in plane quality was one reason single iron planes disappeared. What we are talking about here is the absolute best performance that can be squeezed out of a tool design - not if there was enough need for the performance to justify the continued existence of the design.
All I am saying is that in the 18th century double irons made a lot of sense for a lot of people - and coupled with the skill it takes to make a worthwhile single iron plane - it makes sense that double irons were popular back then and the equation is far more complicated than can a double iron plane be made to work really really well.
I know warren has mentioned before that ribboned wood is a very good reason to use a double iron.
I sometimes can't differentiate between ribboned and quartered if quartered wood is not perfectly straight, but the cocobolo I planed last week was as bad as any ribboned wood as I've seen anywhere (including a horrible piece of wood wilbur sent me once), and I was able to plane it with similar effect with both a 55 degree infill and a common bench plane. I would consider myself no expert, but more competent than I was a year or two ago when wilbur sent me that piece of wood.
In the past, I would have been sent home crying if I'd have used a bench plane on that cocobolo. For certain, and I would've assumed it was the plane.
I guess the first time someone showed me a brighter surface with the same or better tearout mitigation, I would've gone for the double iron. Someone would have to prove something like that to me to get me to pay extra for it.
I'd have to see period proof of the scenario you provide to believe it, because I just haven't seen it and if larry doesn't produce written proof, then it's supposition, also.
I don't agree with the sentiment that a single iron plane with a tight mouth performs better than a double iron plane with a less tight mouth. I've seen otherwise with my own two eyes in the last two months, that's the part I'm hung up on, the supposition that there is some sort of superior performance from a single iron plane even if both designs are made perfectly or both are mediocre. That's just not the case.
But we're at a point that we're going to go in circles unless someone can show us definite written proof of the reasons.
". Larry has said that the decline in plane quality was one reason single iron planes disappeared."
I respect his opinion, but I never believed that. I think that over time in our culture, until woodworking of the type we are describing essentially disappeared, tools largely matched declining wood quality, or expanding wood challenge. Double blades came in to make planing more difficult grain easier. That is how it has been reported in some texts, like the Carpenter's Way, which is not western, but that was almost the point, even in their culture tools are seen to have followed the quality of wood down.
I`m gob-smacked at the suggestion that there is anything new about double blades. What I experienced as new was being permitted not to use them. Both from my expanding sloth, and from attending the plane making seminar, or reading what C&W had on their website.
+1, though Krenov was not the person I would have most expected to go that route. I remember once tracking down his edge treatment, because I could not see how his hand planed surfaces and broken edges could be blended.
Bill, I don`t think the logic is there. He was writing for others, a lot more goes unsaid than said. There are people on the boards who went to CR when he was active, who might be able to say more. Well you have access to Fink. I will look at the tape I have, but he does not say enough directly. Setting is one thing, if the point is a lot of tuning probably correct.
The other factor is that the modern players are far more into planing than ever before. The Japanese planes were an astonishment to most when they first were seen. Now Rob Cosman has some ad on Youtube where one of those Chinese made planes he reps is taking a very beautiful shaving. Nobody was doing that in general work in the west. Standards are way up.
I wish I had time to explore the extent of this blind alley but it's busy here.
Saturday morning Don and I need to have about $30,000 worth of tools and materials ready for a couple workshops, loaded in the truck, and be on the road. On my return I'll have only a couple days before a lot of family from around the country descend on my house in preparation for my daughter's wedding. This stuff is necessarily low on my list of priorities right now and doesn't even rank consideration on my wife's list. I try to keep her happy.
Charles Hayward writing in his book The Junior Woodworker published in 1973 by Drake:
"Back Iron Setting."
"Why then do we not set the back iron as close as we can to the edge? The fact is that it makes the plane much harder to push and it is therefore better to set it back a little way and put up with a little roughness. It all depends upon the sort of work you are going to do and the sort of wood you are planing. For the jack plane used to take medium shavings in straight-grained wood not liable to be rough, the back iron can be about 1.5MM (1/16 in.) from the edge. When you use the smoothing plane set fine to take thin shavings on difficult wood, you can bring the back iron up to much less than 1.5MM - in fact almost as close as you can get it. If, however, you are taking thicker shavings with the smoother plane, you can set the back iron rather farther back." [presumably somewhere between 'as close as you can get it and the aforementioned sixteenth of an inch.]
Charles Hayward was born in 1898. A short bio can be found here:
Toshio Odate published "Japanese Woodworking Tools'in 1984. He covers the subject very concisely.
One thing he brings up that no one has mentioned is that around 1800 when the chip breaker was introduced most of the high quality wood had been used and a method of working with lesser quality woods was necessary, the chip breaker helped the woodworker.
Japan, but I think he said it came from Korea. No one is home to help me get the book down so I am going on memory. If I made any major errors I'll post the corrections as soon as I can reference the book.
Toshio Odate stated in his book that the double iron became popular in Japan around 1900. He gave declining quality of material and declining skills of workers (because of war) as possible reasons.
The great rise in popularity of the double iron in the U S coincided somewhat with the great interest in figured woods at the beginning of the Federal period in the late 18th century. You can call figured wood lower quality or higher quality depending on your perspective.