New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Historical Evidence for the double iron

Posts

Historical Evidence for the double iron

#1

Historical Evidence for the double iron

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

This topic has a way to run yet. There are issues to still discuss (for me at any rate). One is the issue of wood dependence and its limitations, another is the relationship with cutting angle and how they may work together, and a third is the historical significance and lessons that were learned - and lost. It is the latter area I will touch on here.

I should say "return to" since it was Warren who has been researching this, and he posted below in reply to Larry.

Larry: http://www.woodcentral.com/woodworking/forum/handtools.pl/page/1/md/read/id/448615/sbj/my-beginner-and-non-beginner-meltdown/

Warren: http://www.woodcentral.com/woodworking/forum/handtools.pl/page/1/md/read/id/448926/sbj/historical-evidence/

Well Warren, I for one am convinced that the double iron has a role in tuning the performance of a plane. My own trials support this. I would even go so far as to say that it is entirely feasible - probable? - that the double iron was introduced for that reason, or became used for that reason early on.

The question is why was this knowledge seemingly lost or ignored in recent history? There are some, no doubt, who will argue that it wasn't lost, that "we always knew to move the chip breaker as close as possible". Perhaps this is so, but then why was this not a part of handplaning lore?

I was looking through old FWW mags. There is an article in the October 2000 edition, "Planing Difficult Grain". The author goes to pains to describe the tuning required: flat sole, sharp cambered blade, small mouth, etc. But of the chip breaker he says: "The chip breaker stiffens the blade, reducing vibration and chatter. For the chipbreaker to function, shavings coming off the board must travel smoothly along the back of the blade, over the chipbreaker, and up through the throat .... Or if the chipbreaker's edge is blunted, the shaving won't travel up through the throat... The first step is to feather the leading edge with a flat file ... once the chipbreaker is in good shape, set it 1/16" from the edge of the blade". (1/16" is approximately 1.6mm, which takes it completely out of the range for effecting the planing result).

I looked up plane tuning with a couple of well known woodworking experts. I shall not name names as I do not wish this to cause embarrassment. One I consider to be the doyen of teaching. It turns out that he has also never adjusted the chip breaker to increase the performance of a smoother. His focus was on filing the leading edge at a low angle, basically getting the chip breaker out of the way.

Another I looked up also has a couple of classic books to his name. I was interested what he would recommend to tune a Stanley #4. Once again there wasn't any tuning with the chip breaker proximity. Instead it is the mouth size that was described as the vital ingredient, along with a effort made to take fine shaving.

One name I shall mention is one of my heros. Some of you are aware that I have a smoother from Jim Krenov. When I received it some years ago I made note of the settings, etc. Jim had used this plane to make fine shavings. The plane came with a Hock iron and chip breaker. Of relevance, the chip breaker was set 1/16" from the blade.

It is important to record that all of the above are masters of furniture making, masters of hand planing, and well beyond any criticism that could be levelled at them for the method they set up their smoothers. The point is - they either did not see this as important, or they did not know to do so. And if they did not know, how could we? So where did the chip breaker information go to?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Historical Evidence for the double iron

#2

Re: Historical Evidence for the double iron

david weaver

Maybe it lost some sigifnicance when people stopped dimensioning wood by hand. In my opinion, it is a lot easier to smooth 5 boards that are fresh out of a machine planer than it is to do the greater amount of work that is involved in removing hand jointer marks *and* planing for smoothness, especially on the 5th board or so when you're pooped.

And *especially* if you're a gentleman woodworker like some of us (and not a "real" woodworker) who may joint those panels or jack those panels and then get called out of the shop only to come back to finish them 3 days later after they've moved. The significance of being able to take a heavy shaving but with no tearout is really magnified.

I don't know if any of those folks are david charlesworth, but I'm sure you saw his response on SMC to the whole thing, if he wasn't converted, he was at least convinced, and with some surprise on his part.

Many of the other folks seem to not know. I didn't know. I wish I would've, though I don't think it would've stopped me from making planes.

This whole thing is yet part of my beginner vs. non-beginner rant, but maybe I'm missing the mark with that, and it's really almost universally unknown vs. just being a beginner vs. non-beginner kind of thing.

I don't think it'll be that long before someone writes an article about it for one of the woodworking magazines, but the trick is who feels like they've done it long enough to actually write an article? It sure isn't me with 2 months of experience, though I feel now like I could give someone a 10 minute primer in person and have them matching or exceeding a 55 degree plane for every piece of wood I have in my shop, even if they have to fiddle a week or two.

The historical aspect will be a harder thing, I guess, but I don't know how much more plainly it can be stated than it is in the text warren showed. We'd love to have a 200 page techincal document from 1760 that described the merits in today's english with today's terms, but i won't hold my breath for anyone finding something like that.

It's clear to me that even LN probably didn't have a great idea of the ability of the cap iron, because they never directed people to use it when folks demanded a steeper frog. And at least in my case on my #7, the cap iron just barely gets to the place where it needs to be set before it runs into the screw that retains the lever cap and runs out of adjustment. At this point, I'm not even sure why they offer the "improved" chipbreaker, because I don't think it's an improvement at all over the stanley type, and I actually get a little bit better performance from the stamped stanley type in my millers falls smoothers (they might be stanley if I could've found a stanley for as cheap as the MFs).

Re: Historical Evidence for the double iron

#3

Re: Historical Evidence for the double iron

joel moskowitz

I don't understand any of this.

The overwhelming number of planes that were used before 1840 were used to dimension stock for various joinery tasks. The goal was to be able to take a heavy shaving with little or no tearout. Why a heavy shaving means less strokes than a thin shaving.

A double iron makes it possible to have a thicker shaving with few repercussions. There is no need to set a cap iron so close to the cutting edge if you are taking thin shavings.

For cabinetmaking, the final smoothing cuts you want to have your best foot forward. You can set a cap iron really really close to the edge - which might work or might make the plane clog. Or you can have a really really fine mouth, a sharp iron, and not worry about this at all. In both situations not having a sharp iron is deadly. Remember of course with a standard carbon steel iron, used all day it would be sharpened a fair number of times, each time requiring a set and reset of a cap iron. (and then setting the iron for a fine cut). With a single iron, you still need to sharpen it, you still need to set the iron but that's it. The tradeoff of course is that the mouth of the plane will wear and eventually - sooner than you would like - the mouth of that smoother would be too wide to get the uber performance you want for your best work.

Certainly a fine mouth and a single iron is easier to use because you don't have to worry that the cap iron is set perfectly, but you also have to prepare yourself for replacing the plane body more frequently as the mouth wears open.

For a joiner or the rougher stages of cabinetmaking - the vast bulk of the plane buying public, with less fussy cap iron setting requirements it's a no brainer - get a double iron plane. For the rareifield number of cabinetmakeing operations where surface quality was key, and tool replacement cost was secondary, it's a no brainer also. Get the single iron smoother, it won't clog, no fussy setting of a cap iron every time it needs sharpening, and only use it for fine fine work. Or if you can afford it, get a metal mitre plane, which solves the mouth wear problem.

Re: Historical Evidence for the double iron

#4

Re: Question

david weaver

Why then, did infill planes often get made with double irons, and why did most smoothers get made with double irons?

This is what's always puzzled me. I've tried both courses of action now, and it seems to me that setting the cap iron so that it's just out of range for thin shavings on a smoother is the most practical compromise I've found. It's quick to set it that way, it offers a backstop if you take a heavy shaving by need or by accident, and it allows the use of a plane that's got less precision around the mouth.

I can't settle on the immediate superiority of the single iron plane for a smoother when almost every plane made as a smoother since the early/mid 1800s seems to have a double iron in it, despite the fact that it cost more to get it that way.

Re: Historical Evidence for the double iron

#5

Lost knowledge

Bob Hackett

IMO there are some major contributing factors at work with things like this.

The first is the disappearance of things like apprenticeship programs and the passing from experienced hand to new generation all the nuances of tool use in favor of the "self discovery" form of learning.

The second is the rush to mass produce cheaper tools with little understanding of what makes the real differences are between a high quality tool and low priced tool. A plane is a plane ,right? Why do I need a version of a seemingly simple that costs several hundred (0r thousand) dollars when the Borg has one that ought to work for $20?

Another is the idea that unless you pay a rather hefty price tag for a "simple tool" you need to have a very good understanding of how that tool is supposed to work so you can fettle and adjust it to get even satisfactory, never mind outstanding, results.

One of the more simple tools out there is a slick. Just an oversize paring chisel right? That line of thinking and approach to both the making and initial prep of these tools completely ignores most of what makes the old, tested, and true versions so effective and a joy to use instead of a chore or disappointment. Every time I see a video or slide show of someone who is supposed to be an "expert" making a "slick" for sale to the unsuspecting public (timber framers and cabin builders mostly) I end up with my face planted in the keyboard moaning "no,no,no".

Just cause you can make something that looks like a slick doesn`t mean it`s gonna perform like one. Just like those " high quality planes" at the Borg. :(

Re: Historical Evidence for the double iron

#6

Myth

Kees

The idea that it's difficult to set the capiron in the proper place, is a myth. It's pretty easy in fact. Just another skill to learn.

And today the number of high angle special purpose planes is miniscule, when compared to the number of 45 degree double iron planes. It's a sound and practical idea to make the best of your humble Stanley #4, before you're going to throw money around. And making the best of that humble plane means learning how to use the capiron.

Re: Historical Evidence for the double iron

#7

Re: Question

joel moskowitz

1 - iron ( or infill to use the modern term) smoothers first show up in the 1850's Their makers were used to making iron panel planes which are double ironed. By this time we are already a generation away from common use of hand sawn veneers and mechanical planing had been around for 20 years.

2- a double iron does give you an effectively thicker iron which in 1850 was a lot cheaper to make to make than harden and grind and flatten one thick piece of tool steel.

3 - most iron planes didn't have uber fine mouths - fine mouths - a 1/64 or a 1/32 but not the ridiculously fine mouths of modern infills and the best wooden planes. If you set the cap iron of a Norris for example as close as you need to to have an effect the plane will clog.

4 - the iron plane that is contemporary with the late hand tool error is the mitre plane, bevel up, single iron, and with a mouth around a 1/32 or less if the plane is to be considered new and top notch.

5 - Even if you are not smoothing fine hardwood as a cabinetmaker wood, a joiner, doing far rougher work, in construction, would still need to leave a good surface, if not a perfect surface, on all the visible paneling and other boards in a house. A double iron smooth plane, which can take a decent thickness shaving, leave a pretty good surface as long as the wood cooperates, and is a lot less expensive to purchase is a far more useful tool in this context than a single iron tight mouth plane that cannot take a thicker shaving at all, even if you want to.

6 - incidentally there are a fair number of surviving iron planes where have had their mouths widened.

Re: Historical Evidence for the double iron

#8

Re: Myth

joel moskowitz

You are obviously better at this than I. I cannot set a cap iron on any of my planes consistently closer than a 1/32" without a lot of fussing and even that close the cap iron makes no difference in performance. With a cambered iron I am at a lot to set it close at all. So I don't worry about it and trust a sharp iron and a tight mouth. One of the great things about stanley planes is that you can set the mouth to whatever opening you want. Oh - and I get much better performance with this irons like Hock or other aftermarket makers.

Re: Historical Evidence for the double iron

#9

Re: Myth

Kees

Keep practising Joel ;-) 1/32" is 0.8mm. You can do better then that!

The trick is to use the light reflected from the back of the cutting iron. First you tighten the screw a little with your hand. Then you move the capiron into poistion. The narrow reflecing line indicates very well where you are. Then fully tighten the screw.

Re: Historical Evidence for the double iron

#10

Re: Myth

Kees

Oh, and it's easier with the Stanleys then the thick capirons of the Woodies or Infills. But very doable on these too.

Re: Historical Evidence for the double iron

#11

Re: Myth

joel moskowitz

Then my planes clog.

And that doesn't work on a cambered iron for a panel plane - if the iron is a few thou from the edge at the sides of the iron, the center of the iron is 1/32" away

Re: Historical Evidence for the double iron

#12

Re: Question

david weaver

Just a few responses to these

1 - why were the panel planes double ironed and why did that flow over to the smoothers? A lot of those were wedged, and it wouldn't be any harder for a maker to use a single tapered iron and a wedge, and if a lever cap is used, no harder to make a single parallel iron - actually easier, no slot is required and no cap iron.

2- Most older planes (including wooden planes in this), the vast majority still had laminated irons. All of the maker price lists I've seen show a single and double iron price if a plane is available with either, and in all cases, the double iron is more expensive. I don't think it was cheaper for anyone to make a double iron than a somewhat thicker single iron. By the time tool steel was common for all planes, steel was cheap.

3 - I have an infill panel plane that has the mouth filed at 9 thousandths (I put it together). I was so in the dark at the time that I didn't even file the top of the mouth toward the bun "away", so it essentially perpendicular - I consciously did that because I thought I would improve the plane by allowing the mouth to open less if the plane were lapped heavily by some future user (boy did I find out how unlikely that is when I lapped it to finish it). I did have to remove some material from the cap iron (which was fat and totally blunt), but it actually feeds very well and performs much better than it did before - it now has a 30 degree primary bevel and a fat 80 degree blunt about a hundredth or two, it is a common pitch plane. Not many older planes are that close, and I'm convinced that users would've known how to set them up. Most of the work I had to do to my cap iron was because the shepherd cap iron was crap, and my work to make it more gradual just makes it closer to the classic designs I've gotten as I've accumulated more parallel iron sets (I don't buy the whole plane, I'd rather make it). If I file the mouth away a little bit, then it will feed even better, but there is no need at this point.

6 - I've seen this. I'd love to have a talk with someone who did it, but they're probably all dead. It is pure guess, but I'd bet they'd tell us that they didn't need a mouth that tight for most work, and they could move the cap iron in close if they decided that they needed surface improvement.

Re: Historical Evidence for the double iron

#13

Re: Myth

david weaver

I used to have the same idea, that setting the iron was too fiddly. And built the planes with mouths tight. It makes for a nice working single-purpose plane, but few people seem to be that interested in making a plane like that - rather they want to buy planes they don't need because nobody has told them they have the solution in their hands.

I told george wilson somewhere around one of the times that I was arguing with warren that I thought setting a cap iron really close was unreasonable and fiddly, and george (who was by rule using single iron planes at CW) said "it's not hard to set them that close". I've seen little that george is ultimately wrong on, and it took probably 10 repetitions to set the cap iron close, and in another 10 it was a 15 second process at most. Other people who have tried it have said the same thing, I've not gotten a message yet from anyone who said they couldn't get the iron close. The balance of messages are from people who set the irons too close, and from folks who were ecstatic when they realized how useful their planes were.

I was also confused by the cambered iron at first, but in practice setting the cap iron on a cambered plane at 1/32nd while it's basically set at nothing along the edges of the camber isn't really a problem, because the edges where the cap iron is right on top of the iron isn't actually cutting wood.

But that kind of heavy work is probably not something where it matters so much unless someone is picking particularly torturous wood.

I'm guessing that the reason so many old planes had double irons and not-so-tight mouths is because the people who used them knew they didn't need a tight mouth to eliminate surface problems. Just a guess, we're all guessing some.

There are no feed problems with a stanley if the frog is backed up a hundredth or two, which is far less fiddly and more versatile than shimming a mouth with a piece of paper or cardstock and tightening the frog or some such thing. I've not yet seen a stanley frog that doesn't move a little when you tighten the frog screws (i haven't tried my bedrock yet, maybe it doesn't - but that's a jack and I'm unlikely to move the frog much).

Re: Historical Evidence for the double iron

#14

Re: Myth

Kees

Then the mouth is too tight. When the capiron is in the sweet spot, the shavings are straightened out, and then you can get away with a somewhat tight mouth, while still using the capiron to full effect.

And when your irons are too much cambered, then you could make them a bit straighter. It's not like it's a dogma to have your panel plane at 1/32" camber.

Re: Historical Evidence for the double iron

#15

Re: The thick iron issue..

david weaver

Stated up in Joel's remarks included his preference for a thicker replacement iron.

I'm starting to think from experience that even this is up in the air. A harder replacement iron is nice, but I haven't seen anything since learning to set the cap that suggests that I need a thicker iron, and I might go so far to say that I don't prefer the thicker iron.

For a long time, I avoided tsunesaburo's blue steel iron because it's so thin, I think it might be thinner than stock.

But this whole cap iron thing has changed my thoughts, and the tsunesaburo iron (and the $3 home depot iron) has not shown any chatter yet, not even in an extremely heavy cut. It is my favorite of all of the replacement irons now, and its thinness (and lamination) make it so that it's easy to maintain with two stones, nothing coarse is even required to grind it. The other virtue of it is that its edge holding is very similar to A2, but there is almost no degredation in the surface as it dulls. It exceeds my steep infill angle smoother's surface even as it is most of the way to dull, and doesn't fail leaving little lines everywhere like most A2 irons.

(neither doesn't the home depot iron fail like that, but it doesn't hold its edge very long either - though it too worked fine in a pretty heavy cut in cocobolo).

Of course, this doesn't apply to single irons, I still haven't found the virtue of thin single irons, especially if the cut is heavy at all.

Re: Historical Evidence for the double iron

#16

Re: Question

joel moskowitz

1 - why were the panel planes double ironed and why did that flow over to the smoothers? A lot of those were wedged, and it wouldn't be any harder for a maker to use a single tapered iron and a wedge, and if a lever cap is used, no harder to make a single parallel iron - actually easier, no slot is required and no cap iron.

Iron Panel planes make sense because of the wear and tear on a wooden plane sole if planing very hard wood. Iron plane planes date from the 1830's a full generation and a half from the peak of the single iron smoother. Who knows exactly why. Maybe the idea of a single bevel down iron was lost? It could be that Towell and others were simply coping existing wooden patterns, it could be that double irons were by then ubiquitous, it could be that since you can easily set the cap iron back and not worry about clogging, it wasn't given much thought. A thicker cap iron/ cutting iron combo performs better than a single iron of the same thickness of a regular iron and regular irons were ubiquitous by this time. It also could be an version of Gresham's law.

I get selter delivered by Walter the Selterman http://mediastorm.com/training/remember-these-days and it is a seriously better product than what I can buy in a store or get using a seltzer machine. But the worse product (seltzer in disposable bottles) drove out the seltzerman 50 years ago. Why? Because not all seltzerman were as good as Walter, and most people don't care one way or another.

In planes it's pretty easy to see that an Old Street single iron planes perform just about better than just about any plane you can buy. But that doesn't mean every single iron plane made in the 18th century was anywhere near as good. As a matter of fact I would bet that mostly they weren't. It's hard to make a top notch single iron plane or iron plane. A moderately well made single iron plane or iron plane might perform releasably well, but it is far far easier to make a moderately well double iron plane that will perform reasonably well too. Suddenly the critical areas are in the iron and cap iron and that's the users problem, not the makers. The additional cost to the user of the double iron gives the user a more consistent product that cannot be matched except by the most skilled planemakers.

2- Most older planes (including wooden planes in this), the vast majority still had laminated irons. All of the maker price lists I've seen show a single and double iron price if a plane is available with either, and in all cases, the double iron is more expensive. I don't think it was cheaper for anyone to make a double iron than a somewhat thicker single iron. By the time tool steel was common for all planes, steel was cheap.

The forging of thick steel and hardening of thick steel excpeially on a taper is harder than a thinner iron.

3 - I have an infill panel plane that has the mouth filed at 9 thousandths (I put it together). I was so in the dark at the time that I didn't even file the top of the mouth toward the bun "away", so it essentially perpendicular - I consciously did that because I thought I would improve the plane by allowing the mouth to open less if the plane were lapped heavily by some future user (boy did I find out how unlikely that is when I lapped it to finish it). I did have to remove some material from the cap iron (which was fat and totally blunt), but it actually feeds very well and performs much better than it did before - it now has a 30 degree primary bevel and a fat 80 degree blunt about a hundredth or two, it is a common pitch plane. Not many older planes are that close, and I'm convinced that users would've known how to set them up. Most of the work I had to do to my cap iron was because the shepherd cap iron was crap, and my work to make it more gradual just makes it closer to the classic designs I've gotten as I've accumulated more parallel iron sets (I don't buy the whole plane, I'd rather make it). If I file the mouth away a little bit, then it will feed even better, but there is no need at this point.

6 - I've seen this. I'd love to have a talk with someone who did it, but they're probably all dead. It is pure guess, but I'd bet they'd tell us that they didn't need a mouth that tight for most work, and they could move the cap iron in close if they decided that they needed surface improvement.

More likely they were second or third hand users - using the plane for rougher work than originally anticipated, or needing to fit a thicker iron at some point.

Re: Historical Evidence for the double iron

#17

Re: Question

david weaver

1) i'm not convinced that the reason that double iron planes took over is just because of being ubiquitous. They somehow got to that point, despite the fact that they were always more expensive.

I haven't used one of larry's planes. I have used a single iron plane that works well, though, and I wouldn't say they work better than almost all other planes. Rather I'd say that a good one works as well as many other planes. But the simple fact so far is that neither works any better than the $11 millers falls #9 that I purchased solely to experiment with this in the first place. If thin irons would've been a problem, leonard bailey probably wouldn't have gotten away with using them.

2) despite the fact that a thick iron is harder to forge, harden and temper than a thin iron, it doesn't change that it must've been easier than making a double iron, because the double irons still cost more than a single iron in every plane listing I've seen. There must be a reason for that. This change occurred long before planemakers in the united states were making lots of subpar wooden planes, so I'm not sure i believe that it was a skill issue. Even when very good single iron planes were being made, say 1820s to 1840s, the double iron planes were becoming more common despite the fact that they were more expensive.

I can't be convinced with what I've seen so far that a quality single iron plane is better than a capable or quality double iron plane as a smoother. One of the things sticking in the back of my mind even when I was a fan of the single iron plane exclusively was that warren won the planing contest at WIA with a cheap bench plane, despite the presence of very expensive planes.

(none of this is to suggest I won't use single iron planes going forward, or that I will forego making my own copies of the expensive planes, i'm just trying to get to the facts).

Re: Historical Evidence for the double iron

#18

Re: Question

joel moskowitz

So much of this is subjective.

I have a few questions:

1- how important is single/double iron advantage/disadvantage compared to sole flatness or iron bedding?

2- For run of the mill typicial work - real work not performance testing, how much from perfect plane performance is still fine?

3- How much performance of planes is basically a function of how well they are sharpened?

4- how well does different styles of plane perform say after 200 or 400 passes with an iron that is getting duller?

5- Of the number of professional cabinetmakers in the US today how many use a hand plane for finishing versus a powered sanding device? In two hundred years will that be interpreted as the powered sanding method was superior to hand planing and finishing?

Re: Historical Evidence for the double iron

#19

Re: Question

david weaver

1) sole flatness isn't even a straightforward issue, because a lot of older planes that have a lot of use haven't been flattened. Perfection in that arena is also a somewhat new thing. It's nice to have on a smoother, but out of flatness is bad for an experienced user only if it's out of flat in a bad way (like concave bottoms, or twist).

I'm not sure you can start changing variables and have a relevant discussion. You'd have to assume any plane is bedded properly, or at least reasonably close. We're not comparing defective planes, there's no need to given that a properly bedded smoother can be had for $10, it just takes a little bit of skill.

2) It seems to me (and other folks may have different standards) that I ought to be able to get a surface free of tearout and felt fuzziness with a smoother. That includes the back sides of knots and other things that are often uneven in otherwise well planed surfaces. I have seen some work passed off as fine that I would consider inexcusable, I don't want to call it "fine" just because someone was willing to display it. The level of fineness in the surface to me has to correspond with the finish.

3) what's the sharpening range. Upon initial passes of a plane that is not set up well, sharpness is critical. If the plane is a good quality plane (like a tight mouthed infill or a properly set up bench plane with the cap iron set close), you can still get a good surface even as an iron is dulling. Good sharpening is a basic gatekeeping skill, it is assumed that anyone involved in this discussion can do it. I don't feel, though, as I need to have a smoothing plane within 40 passes of a freshly sharpened 1/2 micron abrasive range to get a very bright surface - if someone feels perfect sharpness is that important for smoothing, they are doing something wrong or something is wrong with their setup.

4) Sort of a carry over from above - a tight mouthed infill and a properly set bench plane or any plane with a second iron will continue to perform well even with a dulling (not chipped or damaged) iron. A single iron plane that isn't as good will be more dependent on sharpening unless it has a very steep pitch, and at that point it would be leaving an unacceptable surface because as you're forced to take a heavier shaving to keep cutting, it'll be more likely to tear out. A bench plane set up with the chipbreaker back will do the same thing. (I did actually count shavings once and record surface quality - but only with A2 irons when I was testing an iron for someone).

5) A more relevant discussion will be whether someone concludes DA sanders are better than rotary or straight line sanders. We are comparing planes when we talk about double vs. single iron, not planes vs. sharkskin. I would bet some folks might accurately determine though that users lost the skill to sharpen and use a plane and went to sanders, or that sanding became popular because it is unskilled work (which it is, it is very low wage work where I grew up in PA, where there were until a decade and a half ago people who worked full time hand sanding furniture).

Re: Historical Evidence for the double iron

#20

Re: Question

joel moskowitz

On point 5 that wasn't my question. I'm not asking why power sanding replaced planing I am asking will it be considered a better tool for finishing.

It's exactly the same question as the one vs two iron argument. We have no clear factual idea why there was a drift to double irons - just a lot of theories. Chances are it was a bunch of things. Lower levels of skill, harder to maintain tools, most people might not care one way or another. We don't know.

Is one method better than the other? With modern sanding vs planing when you take into the total package of time, money, skill and result, the power sander wins. But on a onesy twosey case of absolute best possible finish - a combination of wood smoothing methods and top coats - depending on the top coat a planed surface can be spectacular - if highly skilled to achieve.

With a single vs double iron. the single iron in certain special high end cases might pass a top level 18th century sniff test - Larry has posed some material that suggests that. And his planes prove it out. but the masses certainly didn't see it that way or care and these days it might not make a practical bit of difference. I just don't know.

Re: Historical Evidence for the double iron

#21

Re: Question

Warren in Lancaster, PA

4- how well does different styles of plane perform say after 200 or 400 passes with an iron that is getting duller?

Joel, you once said on this forum that a Bailey plane (as opposed to an infill) would start having tear out as soon as the iron was the least bit dull. I went to the trouble to take 200 strokes without sharpening and reported deteriorating surface, but still no tear out. Maybe if you had gone to this much trouble you would have remembered it as well.

David, I did once win a planing contest at WIA, but it was a speed contest and everyone was required to use the same plane.

Re: Historical Evidence for the double iron

#22

Re: Question

joel moskowitz

I am a terrible tester and can't count higher than 3 or 4 pints.

I picked 200 or 400 strokes out of a hat. No idea what the actual number it.

But it has been my experience that when a plane is sharp it largely doesn't matter what it is but as they dull my bedrocks eventually start chattering and stuttering and tearing out (the iron after all is left by a tensioned leaf spring) but my infills planes just take more work to push. Which means that since I am not good at sharpening before I need to, with a bedrock I find I get a poorer surface and maybe a little tearout and I have to stop and switch blade/sharpen. With my infill planes I just realize that the plane seems harder to push - at which time I sharpen or swap irons - but there is no damage to the work to be planes out later.

Re: Historical Evidence for the double iron

#23

Re: Historical Evidence for the double iron

Charles

As to Krenov: I'm sure he preferred to end matters with a smoothing plane but I'm doubtful he had any compunction at all in going to the one-two punch of scraper then sandpaper if the plane was tearing the grain. Why he never fiddled wih the breaker and then subsequently imparted that wisdom in his several books is probably a point lost to history.

Setting a breaker close works, but it is a fiddly adjustment.

Re: Historical Evidence for the double iron

#24

Re: Question

david weaver

I guess we'll probably not ever know exactly why, though will have bits of stuff printed here and there that are clues. It won't be as clear as why the horse disappeared for transportation (not that that is even a similar argument).

My whole point in all of this is that I can't find a reason that it wouldn't have had something to do with surface quality, and i'm not sure that I agree that it takes less skill to use a double ironed plane - especially in difficult wood - if that were the case, they'd be the most popular thing for difficult wood, but as woodworking magazines and blogs go, most folks have been told plane it, plane it steeper, scrape it, sand it as a progression of things to do as wood gets more difficult.

And when I brought this up orginally before the kato and kawai stuff came up, I thought it was at the time at the very least novel and very effective, and an excellent option for someone who wants to learn the skill of planing but doesn't necessarily want to dump lots of money to get flawless or even good results.

I didn't bring it up to try to tell people that they shouldn't use single iron planes or shouldn't make their own infills or shouldn't buy premium infills. All of those planes work well, the point is more that a common inexpensive plane that was seen as a mediocre performer or something that took a lot of skill to use to get great results is actually much much better than that when it is set up properly, and other folks seem to be realizing that, too, and that the setup isn't that hard.

One wonders why, then, that knowledge was lost to a great proportion of users. Because it's clear that the double iron was recognized as a surface improvement device, regardless of whether or not that's the reason it was put on a plane in the first place. it's my opinion that the issue at least recently, is that most stuff is targeted toward beginners, and everything has to work on the first stroke out of the box or people will return it.

And the clear question that still comes to me is that double iron planes were not "cheap and common" when they took over, and they weren't even cheaper than a steeper pitch plane once they were, but most craftsmen still seem to have chosen them, anyway. They were more expensive. Why then was everyone willing to pay more for them in a time when craftsmen had very little disposable income.

The same question could be asked of infills. I noticed I think on your blog where you put up some text where someone was lamenting the social pressure to purchase an infill at great cost because it was expected of them.

I've never seen anything similar describing social pressure to purchase a double iron, though, and I guess I won't see anything as fact as long as double irons were more expensive, just like I can't prove that what I suspect is true. I can suppose what I think was likely, though, and that is that I think that skilled users (the only people who would've bought planes back then) found merit in paying more for a plane with two irons than they would've for a plane with one, pretty much universally.

If I want a more certain answer than that, I guess I'm going to have to call Bill and Ted.

Re: Historical Evidence for the double iron

#25

Re: Question

david weaver

My experience is similar with infills, but it is now the same with bench planes. No chatter. When the surface quality declines to where I don't like it, then I sharpen. The only way the bench plane will tear out in something that an infill won't tear out is if the cap iron isn't set properly. Same story with chatter.

I drove two irons in the last two weeks to completely dull on a #4 style bailey copy smoother on beech and cocobolo, a couple of times, actually, and the surface was still pretty good (certainly good for anything that needs a finish).

200 -400 is a good guess for a newer iron that's hard. It's somewhere between there that a *good* a2 iron will leave a surface finish that isn't pleasing on most woods that aren't abrasive. A bad a2 iron will leave lines on the work earlier. Carbon steel without a properly set cap iron will dull a little faster. With the cap iron set, you can keep planing and get fairly good results even as it's dulling as long as it doesn't chip.

If you got 400 passes of 2 feet out of any carbon steel iron, though, and could still get a uniform smoother shaving, that'd really be pushing it. that being the case for something like a hock carbon steel iron. The vintage and low-dollar irons (like the $3 iron at home depot) won't go that far, but they are definitely easier to use to find the point of dullness and examine the result, maybe because they are soft enough that they fail with what appears to be uniform wear.