Historical Evidence for the double iron
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
This topic has a way to run yet. There are issues to still discuss (for me at any rate). One is the issue of wood dependence and its limitations, another is the relationship with cutting angle and how they may work together, and a third is the historical significance and lessons that were learned - and lost. It is the latter area I will touch on here.
I should say "return to" since it was Warren who has been researching this, and he posted below in reply to Larry.
Well Warren, I for one am convinced that the double iron has a role in tuning the performance of a plane. My own trials support this. I would even go so far as to say that it is entirely feasible - probable? - that the double iron was introduced for that reason, or became used for that reason early on.
The question is why was this knowledge seemingly lost or ignored in recent history? There are some, no doubt, who will argue that it wasn't lost, that "we always knew to move the chip breaker as close as possible". Perhaps this is so, but then why was this not a part of handplaning lore?
I was looking through old FWW mags. There is an article in the October 2000 edition, "Planing Difficult Grain". The author goes to pains to describe the tuning required: flat sole, sharp cambered blade, small mouth, etc. But of the chip breaker he says: "The chip breaker stiffens the blade, reducing vibration and chatter. For the chipbreaker to function, shavings coming off the board must travel smoothly along the back of the blade, over the chipbreaker, and up through the throat .... Or if the chipbreaker's edge is blunted, the shaving won't travel up through the throat... The first step is to feather the leading edge with a flat file ... once the chipbreaker is in good shape, set it 1/16" from the edge of the blade". (1/16" is approximately 1.6mm, which takes it completely out of the range for effecting the planing result).
I looked up plane tuning with a couple of well known woodworking experts. I shall not name names as I do not wish this to cause embarrassment. One I consider to be the doyen of teaching. It turns out that he has also never adjusted the chip breaker to increase the performance of a smoother. His focus was on filing the leading edge at a low angle, basically getting the chip breaker out of the way.
Another I looked up also has a couple of classic books to his name. I was interested what he would recommend to tune a Stanley #4. Once again there wasn't any tuning with the chip breaker proximity. Instead it is the mouth size that was described as the vital ingredient, along with a effort made to take fine shaving.
One name I shall mention is one of my heros. Some of you are aware that I have a smoother from Jim Krenov. When I received it some years ago I made note of the settings, etc. Jim had used this plane to make fine shavings. The plane came with a Hock iron and chip breaker. Of relevance, the chip breaker was set 1/16" from the blade.
It is important to record that all of the above are masters of furniture making, masters of hand planing, and well beyond any criticism that could be levelled at them for the method they set up their smoothers. The point is - they either did not see this as important, or they did not know to do so. And if they did not know, how could we? So where did the chip breaker information go to?
Regards from Perth
Derek




