New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Does anyone make a 19mm Oire Nomi?

Posts

Re: Does anyone make a 19mm Oire Nomi?

#26

Re: Tool slaving - mortise in a groove

wilbur

Making a mortise that fits in the bottom of a groove is the only situation I can think of where having tools of matched widths might be of use. But even then, there are other ways around making sure that your chisel matches your plow plane blade, which have already been mentioned: making the mortise first, then the groove in two passes, or make the groove first, then use a mortise chisel that is slightly narrower than the groove, and paring the sides of the mortise to finish it off, using the sides of the groove as a guide.

It does occur to me that if you really really really want to have your tools match in width, it's probably easier to grind a plow plane blade to match the width of your mortise chisel than the other way around.

Re: Does anyone make a 19mm Oire Nomi?

#27

Re: Tool slaving - mortise in a groove

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I built a set of panels for the rear of two carcases that used frame-and-panel construction. The frames were grooved with a LN #49. In the past I have used a plough plane with a 1/4" wide blade. I thought that the #49 would be a nice change ..


Chopping out the mortices proved to be interesting. The groove is a non-standard one third of ½” … which is … well, it is more than a 1/8” and less than a ¼” chisel. This came as a surprise, and I did not have a chisel that matched this width. Luckily the local friendly salvage yard also had a bin of unused ¼” mortice chisels ($5 each). I grabbed one and ground the sides until it was a perfect fit for the #49 groove (the sides were also relieved to a slight trapezoid). These did a great job.


I was comfortable making a mortice chisel that matched the #49 as it was anticipated that it would get use in the future.

On reflection, if you do not have a match between chisel and plough blades, a better way of creating a groove and mortice is to chop the mortice first, then run the groove. If the mortice is a little wider than the groove, it will not affect the integrity of the groove. Doing it the other way around would be tricky (involving first paring the sidewalls of the groove).

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Does anyone make a 19mm Oire Nomi?

#28

Re: Tool slaving - mortise in a groove

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Good points, yours and Derek's!

Up to this point, we've been trying to find a use for tool slaving, or perhaps we could call it 'tool matching'. It would be useful to take a step back now, and think about the uses of flexibility in design. As an entry, consider this quote from Derek:

"On reflection, if you do not have a match between chisel and plough blades, a better way of creating a groove and mortice is to chop the mortice first, then run the groove. If the mortice is a little wider than the groove, it will not affect the integrity of the groove...."

Indeed. This may be part of the reason why some English textbooks by noted authors instruct us to make the mortise first. By doing so, we have created a lot of flexibility for ourselves.

Why? It is not a given that the groove need be equal in width to the mortise, or even that the groove line up with either or both sidewalls of the mortise. Krenov speaks of using a narrow setback of the panel or glass to create an effect of lightness in the door of a small case--the groove would be offset to the mortise, for example, if you wanted a 5/32 setback for the panel, while keeping a 1/4" mortise centered in a 3/4" frame.

What about narrow panels? Suppose you wish to use a special piece of figured wood for the panel and this piece of wood is thinner than the frame members. Then you will want the groove to be narrower than the mortise. For example, suppose the frame is 3/4" and you want to take the panel out of a unique board or couple of resaws that are 3/8" thick, or perhaps this special wood is 1/2" to 5/8" thick and you want to raise the panel on both sides. In such situations, you might want to use a 1/4" mortise, but taper the panel down to 1/8" to 3/16" in order to leave yourself enough depth of wood to create full relief on the panel.

In my initial post, I posed a situation where everything was 1/4", trying to find a situation where tool matching might have appeal. But if we restrict our choices to metric, or Imperial, or 'everything has to match', don't we close ourselves off from a broader universe of design choices?

Wiley

Re: Does anyone make a 19mm Oire Nomi?

#29

Re: Tool slaving - mortise in a groove

wilbur

Not worrying about matching tool sizes doesn't just open up design choices. It also speeds up part of the woodworking process in a way that is going to be difficult with machines. For instance, a while back I made a quick and dirty 2 shelf case for my shop. After milling up the boards, some were 3/4" thick, some were 11/16", and some were 13/16". Making dovetails for the corners and grooves for the shelf and bottom was easy because I didn't have to match the width of the groove or my marking gauge for the baseline to any given tool. I just used the pieces I was using for marking. Dealing with this situation if I was using a table saw and dado stack would have been quite problematic. At the very least, I'd be spending more time feeding boards through a planer.

I also don't really remember the size of the chisel I used to chop out the grooves, except that it was a little narrower than the groove I was chopping. :D