Re: Tool slaving - mortise in a groove
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
Good points, yours and Derek's!
Up to this point, we've been trying to find a use for tool slaving, or perhaps we could call it 'tool matching'. It would be useful to take a step back now, and think about the uses of flexibility in design. As an entry, consider this quote from Derek:
"On reflection, if you do not have a match between chisel and plough blades, a better way of creating a groove and mortice is to chop the mortice first, then run the groove. If the mortice is a little wider than the groove, it will not affect the integrity of the groove...."
Indeed. This may be part of the reason why some English textbooks by noted authors instruct us to make the mortise first. By doing so, we have created a lot of flexibility for ourselves.
Why? It is not a given that the groove need be equal in width to the mortise, or even that the groove line up with either or both sidewalls of the mortise. Krenov speaks of using a narrow setback of the panel or glass to create an effect of lightness in the door of a small case--the groove would be offset to the mortise, for example, if you wanted a 5/32 setback for the panel, while keeping a 1/4" mortise centered in a 3/4" frame.
What about narrow panels? Suppose you wish to use a special piece of figured wood for the panel and this piece of wood is thinner than the frame members. Then you will want the groove to be narrower than the mortise. For example, suppose the frame is 3/4" and you want to take the panel out of a unique board or couple of resaws that are 3/8" thick, or perhaps this special wood is 1/2" to 5/8" thick and you want to raise the panel on both sides. In such situations, you might want to use a 1/4" mortise, but taper the panel down to 1/8" to 3/16" in order to leave yourself enough depth of wood to create full relief on the panel.
In my initial post, I posed a situation where everything was 1/4", trying to find a situation where tool matching might have appeal. But if we restrict our choices to metric, or Imperial, or 'everything has to match', don't we close ourselves off from a broader universe of design choices?
Wiley