Does anyone make a 19mm Oire Nomi?
Does anyone make a 19mm Oire Nomi?
Posts
Re: Does anyone make a 19mm Oire Nomi?
#2Re: Does anyone make a 19mm Oire Nomi?
david weaver
Not sure, but even if you could get such a thing, it'd likely vary some from its nominal designation, because they're not stamped out on a stamping press into the final shape.
Are you trying to hit dead on 3/4"?
Different people work different ways, I guess, but I have never picked up an imperial set and thought "ghee these would be just the thing if they were metric" or picked up a metric set and thought the converse.
Re: Does anyone make a 19mm Oire Nomi?
#3Re: Does anyone make a 19mm Oire Nomi?
Texchappy
More of a curiosity thing than anything but yeah, was trying to see how close you could get to 3/4". The tool slaving idea still has just enough sense to me to give me pause. That said, I haven't seen any chisels that seem as well thought out as the Japanese nomi. From the socket AND tang construction to the strike down ring, they just seem "developed".
Re: Does anyone make a 19mm Oire Nomi?
#4Re: Don't overthink it...
david weaver
...that goes for several points.
* A good tanged western chisel or socket western chisel is just as good, and because they are plentiful in vintage, also cheaper
* if you have a choice between a very good 18mm chisel and a mediocre chisel of another dimension, you want the very good chisel.
Re: Does anyone make a 19mm Oire Nomi?
#5Ditto
Bill Tindall
When I made chisels I just spaced the sizes from small to larger. I have no idea what size they actually turned out nor ever had any reason to know.
Re: Does anyone make a 19mm Oire Nomi?
#6Re: Does anyone make a 19mm Oire Nomi?
TomD
They usually have middle sizes at least at the smaller end of things, so 19.5 should probably be there. However, in most case grinding is not an option since the hollow will come out too close to the edges.
It probably tells us more than we want to know about the demographic for these things that they are only available in client state units.
Anywho, checked my chisels, and it didn't do much for my blood-pressure. I had started a set of chisels, my first, that are actually Imperial. I have 1/8, 3/8, and 5/8. I should have bought the 1/4, 1/2, and 3/4. And they were super cheap, and as good as anything I ever bought, ARGGH. But they are dead on Imperial. My other sets have a few Imperials in there. Maybe some LV mortising chisels, Iyoroi, nice chisels, and then seem dead nuts imperial.
So I would hold out for Imperial if you can, client state measures are useless in American woodworking. However, the slaving concept while good has obviously not had much effect.
Re: Does anyone make a 19mm Oire Nomi?
#7Re: Does anyone make a 19mm Oire Nomi?
TomD
Interestingly, LV sells Japanese made hollow chisel mortising bits in both Imperial, and Client State. They charge more for the Imperial ones, doubtless due to their grandeur.
Re: Does anyone make a 19mm Oire Nomi?
#8Re: Why?
TomD
Presumably if anyone hates client state measures more than americans, it would be Japanese Carpenters who were persecuted over the use of the bu. However the bu is very nearly 3 mm so I guess that helps. Still, I do wonder why they keep forcing these on us. Both Japanese and american woodworkers have traditional measures they prefer, "metric" should be about as welcome as a bus load of Japanese sex tourists in Nanking.
Re: Does anyone make a 19mm Oire Nomi?
#9Tool slaving
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
It's a cringe-worthy term, IMO. But putting that aside, can someone lay out for the group the practical problem that 'tool slaving' is going to avoid? I once argued in these pages for the concept, and now regret having done so.
The one situation I can think of where it could come into play is where you're making a frame which will be grooved to hold a panel, the frame being M&T joined. (If the frame is to be rebated and the panel or glass held by stops, the following does not apply.)
But suppose you're going to groove the rails and stiles, tenon the rails, and mortise the stiles. Since we're using hand tools for this, we want to plough the grooves from end to end (no stopped cut), and therefore the tenon will be haunched to fill the little piece of groove lying just beyond the mortise on the stile. [I will hasten to say there are many, many ways to make this joint, and many variations depending on whether there is to be a stuck molding or not, but my purpose here is purposely to construct a situation where tool slaving even arises.]
So analyzing the situation…..We want the tenon and haunch to be the same thickness, that way we only have to make the two saw cuts to define the thickness. And of course we want the tenon to match the mortise. Now if the groove can be cut exactly the width of the tenon, then everything lines up. Suppose this is a 1/4" situation. Then we have a mortise gauge set to 1/4" for both the mortise and tenon/haunch. We have a 1/4" mortise chisel. We have a 1/4" plough iron. OK. This is exactly what we would do if all the above was to be done with machine tools--why not make them all the same?
But the hand tool situation is a little more flexible. Do all my tools have to be just so? And is it even desirable? After all, many people are taught to dig out the mortise with the next smaller size chisel, then pare the sidewalls and ends to final width and thickness--so instead of using a 1/4" mortise chisel, you use a slightly smaller size (indeed, 6mm comes to mind here!), then pare to the layout lines.
However, even if you aren't going to pare your mortise, what's wrong with just picking out a likely mortise chisel (you don't even care exactly what it mic's to, as Bill Tindall said above); set your mortise gauge to the chisel width; strike out the lines for the mortise and also the tenon/haunch assembly, and proceed. Ah, but what about the groove, you ask? Well, as long as (a) we make the mortises first, and (b) pick a plough iron for the groove that is not wider than the mortise, then we're still good. If the groove is a little narrower than the mortise, no problem--it takes two licks of a chisel to slightly widen the groove outside the mortise to fit the haunch.
The above is the only situation that comes to my mind where tool slaving even arises. Does anyone else know of a practical hand tool situation where the tools need to be identical? I know Adam is a very smart guy, so I am probably missing something obvious--but what is it?
Thanks, Wiley
Re: Does anyone make a 19mm Oire Nomi?
#10Re: Tool slaving
Texchappy
Wiley, the situation you describe is what I was envisioning and wondering about. But in your description I'm a lot less worried about it. Thank you all for enduring my anxiety about wasting money on the wrong tools. I feel a lot more comfortable with what I've bought so far and where I intend to go with what I'm doing.
Re: Does anyone make a 19mm Oire Nomi?
#11Re: Tool slaving
TomD
I think that is the classic case. I don't buy the idea that the wrong size chsiels are the answer. All this paring is not the right way to go, it is the Japanese way, but not the western way.
I would add one other tool slaving thought, just the idea of overall dimensions. Obviously hand made furniture may be completely idiosyncratic, but at the same time it can also lay out in accordance with the numbers. There is a big difference between 24 MM, and 25.4. Any kind of craftsperson should be able to feel the tension even between 1/4, and 6mm. So I don't want a 6mm mortise in a 3/4 inch piece if it throws the proportions off. If I have a 3/4 " chisel in my hand I want to be able to use it to find center on a 1.5" piece of wood. Each chisel is measurement tool all it's own. Working in both systems is good for the mental agility, but I don't really see it as a good thing. I was brought up in metric, and then Canada became a metric country, client state is our measurement system. For anyone here this would make more sense for me, or other Canadians. But after 30+ years in the shop, or probably after 20, I have tossed the metric stuff.
Beyond that, what is the advantage to the metric sizes. Other than Japanese chisels what common place cabinetmaking tool in broad use is made in metric. There is the 32 mm system, but I just don't see that having pushed say LN to make all their planes in metric. This is the land of arguing tiny advantages. One could easily be the best craftsperson in the land using blue chip chisels, we arguing small increments. I don't see any advantage to using metric. There hasn't been much disadvantage to using metric either, but that isn't really sufficient.
And then further, there are Japanese chisels in imperial, I have some, so why are we even talking about this? Where are the threads bemoaning the fact that the new LV Chisels aren't currently cataloged in NA in Metric only? When metric comes up, all kinds of people jump in to argue for it, but never when imperial tools are discussed. Obviously it could be different people making the arguments, I just don't think it is consistent across the board.
Re: Does anyone make a 19mm Oire Nomi?
#12Re: Ditto
TomD
Wow Bill, I would have though you would shave them on a surface grinder.
Re: Does anyone make a 19mm Oire Nomi?
#13Re: Don't overthink it...
TomD
* if you have a choice between a very good 18mm chisel and a mediocre chisel of another dimension, you want the very good chisel.
Yeah, kinda a false choice though.
Re: Does anyone make a 19mm Oire Nomi?
#14Re: Slave to Tools
TomD
"It's a cringe-worthy term, IMO. But putting that aside, can someone lay out for the group the practical problem that 'tool slaving' is going to avoid? I once argued in these pages for the concept, and now regret having done so."
+1 on the term.
One thing one has to be aware of, and it is in the background of all these posts is the overarching shadow of CS, and HS, and big money tool advertising.
I once bought a Black Widow recurve. My best buddy had been a dealer, and I liked his so I sent away for a custom version, it arrived, and I never really shot it. It's good, and all that, but it just never suited me. I have sold off a lot of custom bows and Widows command the highest aftermarket prices of all, over time. I never sold mine though, because I know how the disease spreads. As soon as I sell mine, I will get infected all over again. So keeping this particular bow is saving me a ton of money, and I can always sell it at some point. But you said it:
"I once argued in these pages for the concept, and now regret having done so"
We are all susceptible. So what is the upside of getting metric chisels, when will the next big article come out saying you suck if you don't have metric chisels? It probably will not happen.
Re: Does anyone make a 19mm Oire Nomi?
#15Imperial Japanese Chisels?
Texchappy
@TomD - who makes good Japanese Chisels in Imperial? That would seem on the surface to be a perfect solution for my real or imagined dilemma.
Re: Does anyone make a 19mm Oire Nomi?
#16Re: Give me a "G!" for Grrr,...
TomD
I bought my stuff in 1980 ish from Masterpiece tools, which by the way, was in some strange way a predecessor to HS's stuff. They also had the chisels ground for western dovetails. And some of it was probably 1980 ish from LV. But there is a lot more available stuff today from Japan inc, nobody bought tools direct, and there were only 2 places selling full lines and 4 places selling stuff at all. So it would be passing strange if they were not currently available.
There are hollowless chisels also, that could be ground to any size, but I would probably pass on those.
http://www.grizzly.com/catalog/2012/Main/149
FWW apparently said this about them: " ". I have no idea.
Quality aside, I would also check to be sure they really are metric, not just metric sold as imperial. The machine tool guys have a long history of just putting imperial dials on metric tools...
I did however make a breakthrough in search terms. Search for 1/2" chisel, etc... Searching for imperial japanese chisels just got me a lot of threads like this one.
Re: Does anyone make a 19mm Oire Nomi?
#17Re: Don't overthink it...
david weaver
Well, not until we know what the hypothetical 19mm chisel is. Personally, if I had to buy some of the house brands sold over here, or some of the $30 hardware store chisels in japan, vs. something like koyamaichi, then I'd go with the quality chisel rather than the specific size.
I've never actually looked for a 19mm chisel, though, so I don't know so much about how common they are. They sound to me like a perfect target for someone who'd want to sell an export grade hardware store tool to people in the US, and there's definitely plenty of history of makers selling subpar export only tools for prices that someone in japan would expect it to cost for a good chisel.
Re: Does anyone make a 19mm Oire Nomi?
#18Re: Give me a "G!" for Grrr,...
TomD
http://www.amazon.com/Grizzly-G7097-4-22-Japanese-Chisel/product-reviews/B0000DD631/ref=dp_top_cm_cr_acr_txt?ie=UTF8&showViewpoints=1
And one guy said "bezel" so you know he's for real!
Apparently the review went down in '08. Maybe someone remembers it...
Re: Does anyone make a 19mm Oire Nomi?
#19Re: Give me a "G!" for Grrr,...
Texchappy
Yep, same here. I think I need to go back to the 'don't over think this' comment - as is probably apparent I'm prone to this. I can do a lot with the 6mm I already have so I will get it going into wood. If I like it then I'll keep going and get the sizes I need when I need them. If I don't then I know where to find several brands of western chisels for gosh'k sakes.
If I find I need a true 1/4" or any other exact imperial size then same deal, I can always get it.
Re: Does anyone make a 19mm Oire Nomi?
#20Re: FWW 200
TomD
http://www.finewoodworking.com/ToolGuide/ToolGuidePDF.aspx?id=31061
Apparently they want to know me better before passing the PDF along.
There is a short review, that does not mention whether they are real or reliable imperial measures. The negatives they mention are all pretty much positives, and the positives are some of the ones you would want.
Re: Does anyone make a 19mm Oire Nomi?
#21Re: Give me a "G!" for Grrr,...
TomD
At those prices and with those reviews, I would be tempted to fill out my HSS set, and buy the gouges.
I'm Guessing Grizz will take them back if you use them in your nail gun or Hilti. But what I do is fettle the blades, use them, then if I don't like them I apply the original scratch pattern to the backs, and dip in shellac, and they are good to go. Someone else will get them and think there was at least one awesome chisel in there, and that will get them started.
Re: Does anyone make a 19mm Oire Nomi?
#22Re: Tool slaving
Pam Niedermayer
It seems irrational to me that long time residents still consider this desirable. The efficiencies and ease lie with letting the chisel decide the dimensions.
Pam
Re: Does anyone make a 19mm Oire Nomi?
#23Re: Tool slaving
TomD
You can let the chisel decide the dimension either way, the question is only whether you are limited to that. Why is it better to not have the choice. Can't you lay out your joints in accordance to chisel dimensions when they are imperial?
As far as faster and better, I am not really sure that is true, when in many cases people choose undersized chisels. The idea the chisels need to fit is not something I really believe, though I realize that constitutes an argument against slaving, but I have no problem with that. I'm just reacting to a valid point you have raised.
For fun, at six minutes there is an example of the a guy using a chisel to cut some dovetails or something, and the joint is way larger than the chisel. I often find a chisel that just seems to be cutting well for the kind of wood, the amount of pressure, the sort of manipulation, and use that. I assume I can string the cuts together if it comes to that.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CNBrBM5DySc&feature=related
Re: Does anyone make a 19mm Oire Nomi?
#24Re: I like...
david weaver
...the burnishing pad! Nice.
Re: Does anyone make a 19mm Oire Nomi?
#25Re: and a laminated plane!!
david weaver
.. at about 10:40, I think.
Maybe I've seen one before, I don't know. But that's the first one I remember that has a traditional japanese iron in it.



