New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Beginners vs. Non-Beginners

Posts

Re: Beginners vs. Non-Beginners

#26

Re: categories??

david weaver

categories would be great, but it does take someone to review material and map it to categories. That's got to be pretty difficult in terms of time.

But it would be great.

Re: Beginners vs. Non-Beginners

#27

Very well said

Ron in Kokomo

In fact, it is the beginner aspect that keeps things fresh and interesting.

Re: Beginners vs. Non-Beginners

#28

Re: Exception, maybe..

TomD

We get those Furniture and Cabinetmaking ones up here. They are pretty good on how to. Or DIY as they say over there. But the old FWW had articles by the likes of Krenov, or Maloof. We don't seem to have these upper level people involved any more. It is hard to say. There was maybe more proximity between what we would call the studio furniture crowd and the teaching. I could name some great teachers today, but they don't come from the ranks of Castle, Fortune, Nakashima, Carpenter, etc... None of this is bad, even if true. A lot more people are served by the current publications.

Re: Beginners vs. Non-Beginners

#29

Re: categories??

TomD

You have to have them, but I have been on some boards where they are so explicitly broken down that they end up as an end in themselves. They are good for the person who wants to hone into an answer with minimal effort. However, as nice as that is, that is the lazy side of the equation. Someone has to provide the answers and it may not be all that much fun to have to wade through dozens of categories to get to all the questions.

Re: Beginners vs. Non-Beginners

#30

Re: Whew, what a thread

TomD

Wonderful summary Ellis.

The other deal is the business, and I don't know how that works in magazines. I read a book by outdoor writer Jack Sampson at one point, and it was a real eye opener. But I think magazines that have car ads on the covers are a whole different level.

Re: Beginners vs. Non-Beginners

#31

Ellis Walentine

Re: categories??

Ellis Walentine

I've found that some folks like categories and others don't, just as some people like archives and others prefer the here and now of the live forum. It's more a matter of preference than an objective difference. When Jim Cummins and I were laying out the foundations of this site -- and even before, back in my early days on AOL in the mid-90s -- this topic would always come up. Jim wanted more categories and I wanted fewer, but with good signposts so that readers could pick and choose the topics and posts that interested them. That's how we arrived at the threaded board format and the simple division between general woodworking, hand tools and turning that continues on WoodCentral to this day.

Ellis

Re: Beginners vs. Non-Beginners

#32

Ellis Walentine

Business models

Ellis Walentine

Magazines run on sales (subscriptions and newsstand sales) and advertising. Forums run on advertising and donations. Which reminds me, I'm overdue for a fund-raiser. :)

Ellis

Re: Beginners vs. Non-Beginners

#33

The most important tool...

Bob Hackett

is the one between your ears.

Best message I ever heard from one of my mentors.

If you keep that particular tool tuned up, sharp, and ready to use then everything else becomes another challenge that you have the ability to overcome.

Our only limits are the ones we impose upon ourselves and all information is good information. Some information we can use directly and some of it only shows it`s true value to the people we pass it on to after we find it is not meant for us.

Keep that critical and questioning mind open and don`t be afraid to use it for everything in your life, It`s not just for WWing anymore.

Re: Beginners vs. Non-Beginners

#34

The risk of sub-dividing...

John in NM

Is that it can get so specialized that there are only occasional posts in some areas, discouraging people from visiting that part (where nothing ever happens).

I think you guys hit the balance just right :D

Re: Beginners vs. Non-Beginners

#35

Re: Business models

TomD

I guess I left myself open on that one. I promise to generate even more premium content for you to host at your personal expense. I'm a prince, and I know it! :)

Re: Beginners vs. Non-Beginners

#36

Re: categories??

TomD

"and even before, back in my early days on AOL in the mid-90s"

Cool.