New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Beginners vs. Non-Beginners

Posts

Beginners vs. Non-Beginners

#1

Beginners vs. Non-Beginners

david weaver

I left a post that ran on and didn't get to the point below, I guess this probably has a good chance of becoming the same thing.

But along the same lines of the post below, it seems a lot of stuff we're given ("we're" being amateurs) is of the "it's guaranteed to work the first time" variety, and stuff that comes out that's not guaranteed to be easy is either glossed over or missed.

Which makes sourcing general material (magazines, etc) that are interesting almost impossible. My subscriptions dropped a long time ago. Especially if you expect the information to be tasteful (and not something describing ways to hide screws and show as much end grain as possible on a piece via displaying routine joinery that would've been hidden by a maker with taste).

So what's the solution? We have esoteric discussions here all the time, and sometimes we stumble on something that's more widely useful that a few people alredy know, but a lot seem not to.

I don't know how we'd even solve it when I can't say exactly what it is I'd rather see, I'd know it when I saw it, I guess. Most of my woodworking and tool building problems are never addressed exactly, but maybe that's OK, because I'd rather put my face down into the bench and figure things out - they stick better that way.

But I sure would like if posts for beginners were marked so that I could avoid them. I always get stuck in them even though I know I shouldn't even open them. Maybe if I didn't spend so much time trying to bust the idea that there's something new under the sun with sharpening vs. 10 years ago, I wouldn't be so surprised to find that a cap iron is as useful as it is. I probably wouldn't have 2 high angle smoothers, either (that at this point, i wouldn't miss if I didn't have them, but 3 months ago I would've).

Maybe the biggest contribution we could make (if we're not learning anything) is emphasizing simple things that take a little repetition are just fine (or better, cheaper, etc) even though they wouldn't play that well at a tool show where a huckster wants to show you the next "set it and forget it" tool.

Re: Beginners vs. Non-Beginners

#2

Re: Beginners vs. Non-Beginners

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

I do not mean to offend. I have read your post 3 times and I am having a hard time understanding it. Maybe I have too much sawdust clogging my brain so can you please help me understand your main point?

Thanks!

T.

Re: Beginners vs. Non-Beginners

#3

The trick to writing...

John in NM

Is to make your point quickly and concisely, and with any kind of luck, keeping the subject matter interesting.

I'm afraid I'm at a loss to figure out what the subject line had to do with your post. I'm sure the fault is mine, lacking the patience to pay closer attention.

So what's the problem? Say it in one sentence.

Re: Beginners vs. Non-Beginners

#4

Re: A quicker summary..

david weaver

Part of the problem is I'm not even sure I can define what I think a lot of us would like to get out of boards/publications/literature after we're no longer beginners.

I didn't have room in the title to write what I was getting to, which is the conondrum of finding a source of information and discourse when you're not a beginner vs. finding it when you are.

When you're a beginner, (based on publications) you want:

* opinions given as rules

* methods that work right away without skill development

* things that communicate easily

* (from a vendor's point of view) something that makes it easy to push goods (this isn't necessarily a bad thing) and demonstrate their worth

When you're not (let's say charles and warren), then there seems to be a level of frustration that cuts them from sharing in detail what it is a lot of us would benefit from.

So how do we better communicate information that is no longer for a beginner? The magazines don't seem to do it (there's no money in it, I guess) and when they do, It's my opinion that it's often not worth more than a paragraph (enough to tell you it's something you might want to learn about).

And how do we navigate around the fact that as soon as you describe something that is subtle but worth learning, you will deal with 2 detractors for everyone who has a lightbulb that turns on?

It's as if (for me) it's a matter of not getting much more out of the forum, and I can say that my answer would be "I don't know exactly what I want for sure and how it would be communicated, but most of the discussions aren't it".

Re: Beginners vs. Non-Beginners

#5

BUT..

david weaver

.. I do know for sure that the discussion on second irons has been very beneficial, and it hasn't pinned us into a situation where it's only beneficial to beginners.

Re: Beginners vs. Non-Beginners

#6

Perhaps the question should be this...

John in NM

What do you put into a forum more than what you get out of it?

Part of what I like about forums like this one is that they are inherently interactive, and that is likely why I dropped my one WW magazine subscription about the time the internet became easily accessible to me.

If a forum is not engaging your interests, you can either try to start discussions that interest you, or find another forum - though I think the great thing about forums is that most people follow the first route. Can't really do that with a magazine, that's probably why I've hardly picked one up in 10 years.

I often skip entire discussions where the subject lines do not engage me quickly, only to come back and read them later when I hear more about them through other posts (this cap iron business is a prime example of that).

Re: Beginners vs. Non-Beginners

#7

Re: Perhaps the question should be this...

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Thank you for clarifying.

I am now a professional furniture maker. I understand your thoughts about repetition of subjects and content for beginners vs. experienced craftsman. But I think the nature of a forum is to serve a community of folks with all levels of knowledge.

Maybe I don't learn as much as I used to but from time to time I still find something new that I did not know.

Sometimes it just takes the right question to elicit the info you seek. But I also find that forums have their limitations. For that reason I think it helps to network with other people who are at or above your skill level. The interpersonal connections can be helpful when you want to discuss topics in depth.

T.

Re: Beginners vs. Non-Beginners

#8

Re: BUT..

Texchappy

Big caveat that I am a beginner so I might not be getting what you're really after. However, I do see what you are saying about repetition of basic info. My take: if someone is always seeking to learn and get better then the way then the approach to this information evolves. I would think that you go from taking opinions as rules to critically evaluating the information and looking for nuances. For instance, even as a beginner, as I was watching sawing videos yesterday on youtube I noticed differences in starting a kerf and began weighing how I thought they worked.

Just my 2p.

Re: Beginners vs. Non-Beginners

#9

Re: Beginners vs. Non-Beginners

JMOHNIKE

Problem is we are all beginners, no matter how long we have been doing woodworking. If I spent my life cutting box/finger joints and never attempted a dove tail, I will be a beginner when I cut my first dove tail. The only difference between a professional and non professional is one has found someone who is willing to purchase and has nothing to do with the quality of the product. Just my 2 cents worth.

Re: Beginners vs. Non-Beginners

#10

Re: Perhaps the question should be this...

david weaver

I definitely agree that forums >> magazines. Not to down magazines, because I was both a FWW and PWW subscriber for a little while.

I always got more out of forums. I shouldn't suggest that I put more into the forums than I get out of them, it's sort of an implicit thing - if I really felt that way subliminally, I wouldn't be on them nearly as much. At the same time, 90% of the time I get more out of time at the bench than I do the forums - maybe I lack discipline about which threads to read. I think hogan's description of where you find your swing ("in the dirt") applies to woodworking, especially once you get past very general topic material on a topic. The only exception being if you work with a group of skilled craftspeople or a mentor who is a true expert. (I don't work with anyone on anything, but I know I can call George Wilson and get the straight poop on anything that is remotely related to woodworking or tool making).

What I don't see a lot of is the division of: "that's probably not a good method for a rank beginner, vs. here's one that is". That discussion has its own barbs can devolve into "this method is better because it's harder".

Beginners tend to find stuff like that divisive, and the need to have a social club feeling, which definitely exists on some forums (this one doesn't have that feel), drives the discussion toward everyone agreeing. Nobody learns much with that kind of behavior.

There's certainly not enough traffic for a subforum, but those of us who are an intermediate level sometimes are still wondering just how much we don't know that it is important for us to learn. And where should we learn it? My default is "in the dirt" first and then the forums, unless i have no idea what to even use in the dirt.

Re: Beginners vs. Non-Beginners

#11

categories??

roninkokomo

One of the things that I find terrific about several sites that I visit, Derek Cohen's high among them, is categories of posts. He has taken the time and effort to divide his site into sections. A section on techniques, a section on shop and tools, a section on furniture projects, etc. You can quickly scan to what may be helpful to you today.

I like it.

Ron

Re: Beginners vs. Non-Beginners

#12

Re: Sawing is one of those things..

david weaver

... that to me is "in the dirt". You get a few basic ideas, learn marking and where you want your cut to be, and two hours in the shop is probably better than 5 hours of reading time. Same with starting a saw, it's something that you can't expect to do as easily as you'd like the first time you ever put a saw to a board, but you learn quickly after that when hard starting is because of (lack of) practice and when it's because a saw just isn't filed right to start as easy as you'd like.

Some of these things are maybe easier to learn if you rough dimension lumber with your saws, because you have some room to cut it loose, and you can plane to the line afterwards. When you're working half fatigued, you definitely start figuring out the easier ways to do things, and when you overshoot a line, you learn quickly by that, too, just the same as you do when you get too cautious, cut far from a line and then have to plane a lot off.

There's nothing wrong with being a beginner, there's never been a better time to be one than now with as much as there is on the internet, and as easy as it is to get proper tools from all over the world.

Re: Beginners vs. Non-Beginners

#13

I agree ...mostly

roninkokomo

For my money, I'll take time in the shop and do most of my learning that way. But there are some things that "the dirt" will NEVER teach you. Charlesworth's ruler trick comes to mind. Learning to start a plow plane at the "wrong" end of the board is another. I am no0t sure you will ever figure out how to use dividers "in the dirt" As I said before, and was slightly mis-understood, the challenge is knowing who to listen to. The internet allows a lot of folks to be "expert" without demonstrating any credentials. So, you gotta be careful. A guy whose expertise comes from reading 4 books on dovetails and being on an internet forum for ten years may not be as valuable to you as a guy who has actually cut several dozen dovetail joints. We are blessed on this forum to have some wonderful artisans who will tell you anything they know about the craft.

Ellis has provided a huge service to the craft with this site.

Re: Beginners vs. Non-Beginners

#14

Re: A quicker summary..

TomD

It is a question as to whether either magazines or boards should be consumed for ever. If you take the competent person, who does not need to come here all the time to protect his brand, or to learn the long since obvious, what are they doing here anyway? I do ask myself that, and I know the answer. Basically I have probably an encyclopedia brit of contributions here, and if I stop coming, I lose whatever foothold I have. Also periodically the craft takes a minor pivot, like German benches to Roubo; breaker, no breaker, breaker. And while most of that stuff is risible, I don't want to be the only guy who didn't get the memo.

The breakers research was substantive, but also weird. The one guy on the board, who normally berates us on not doing more woodwork, and who says he has little use for planes, goes off on a tangent, that is largely meaningless by any standard. Though it was actually at a purely technical level one of the better ones in a while. I now know more, but it will have zero effect on my woodwork for a variety of reason.

Re: Beginners vs. Non-Beginners

#15

Re: I agree ...mostly

Guillaume Dery

I agree with Ron and will add this:

Critical skimming of all posts and putting 2 and 2 together will often generate new lines of thought and or show the limitations of some methods.

As an example, Ron mentions the ruler trick... well, if you are following the chipbreaker discussion, you should put 2 and 2 together and realize that the ruler trick precludes setting the chipbreaker as close as possible. You are faced with an either/or situation and you should decide for yourself (although I understand the speed gains, I was never a proponent of the ruler trick as lapping the back of an iron is a one time exercise).

So through this forum you glean enough info both to learn new things and then to piece together differing perspectives to adjust your methods accordingly.

As a matter of fact, I would go further and say that this forum is most beneficial to intermediate WW-ers like myself rather than to beginners. A certain level of hands-on experience is needed to make heads or tails, much less get practical applicability of some of the discussions here.

Now if we could just get a discussion going on the body mechanics of various hand-tool operations and their whys and wherefores....

Re: Beginners vs. Non-Beginners

#16

Re: The Project VS The Skill

TomD

Actually it has little to do with beginners, vs not so beginners. The main thing that separates the mags (and Ellis probably really knows this), is between people who are project oriented, and people who are skill oriented. In theory, when you become a runner you want to get more fit, ie build your skill. But in fact a lot of people want to do a marathon. Or in our case build a table. There is the practical desire to own a table, but more important by far is the self-change that comes from being the person who can make the table. As Red Green said, "at least she can find you handy". I actually joke that I think my wife fell in love with me when she saw me using a Japanese plane. She had visited our farm, and I was in fact planing something for non-show off reasons. That's my story...

In running if you hop the bus it is cheating, but for the most part nobody cares or to quote Lincoln "will long remember" how you made the table, certainly not if there are no shortcuts in the final result, and even then...

So what happened was that FWW created the modern woodworking mag, but they did it in a way that was based mostly on achieving skills. This is know as "elitism". And people hated them for it. Though only after they had created the genre, that more commercial people realized needed to be project oriented. Eventually FWW sold out, and so now everyone hates them.

So what does a mature mag look like? If it tries to sell elitism, it looks like the first hundred or so issues of FWW, American Woodworker at times, and certain issues of Woodworker.

There are several other options. There is the trade journal in which the breaker article would be cool. There is the WoodenBoat approach, the single most successful mag of our age. They can write about history, design, etc... as well as the purely technical, and projects. Unfortunately most woodworkers are not interested in those historical or design topics so a WoodenBoat would not work. Though there is CS who has very cleverly combined several strands, of project, skill, tools, and history.

The real world though, is that the apprenticeship is supposed to end. You get kicked out on your feet as a journeyman, and you wander the world until you find your place, actually making stuff. The education is not supposed to continue for ever, like those perennial, students working on their third doctorate.

Re: Beginners vs. Non-Beginners

#17

Re: Exception, maybe..

david weaver

..i'm not sure that you can't do the ruler trick and use a cap iron. If the standard type stanley iron is undercut from the back is it usually is when you're tuning a plane, it's usually undercut at a much greater angle than the angle at which the ruler trick is performed (at least if you follow DC's suggestion of a 1/2 mil shim, etc).

I haven't tried it, though. Most of my irons are polished far up the length from the edge, and I've got no great need to do it with fast cutting polish stones.

It is a GREAT trick for beginners (the ruler trick), though, and one useful to people who aren't beginners. The whole video is excellent for someone new to watch, it is the first video I ever watched, and I watched it right before I sharpened my first edge. It worked to perfection the first time.

Re: Beginners vs. Non-Beginners

#18

Re: BUT..  Repetition

TomD

Repetition... Most magazines have some kind of cycle. The most obvious being a mag like Bride. People get engaged, then they reach out for Bride, within a year or two they reach out for a magazine on babies. A lot of activities are on a 3 year cycle. people who get into cycling, climbing, etc... cycle through in 3 years. I have a friend down the road who has the money and ability to cycle through a new sport about every year. So it is entirely normal that mags reprint the same exact article every few years. It gets a little annoying when they don't even see to realize it. I find it odd that editors of FWW don't seem to have read any back issues.... But if you are into any of these things for the long haul, you are out of step. I remember reading in a trade journal that climbers averaged 3.5 years in the sport, at a time when I had been in it for 10 years or so, and so have quite a few people I knew, but that's the way it is.

Re: Beginners vs. Non-Beginners

#19

Re: Exception, maybe..

TomD

If you have only been around a few years, you would probably enjoy the old issues of FWW.

Re: Beginners vs. Non-Beginners

#20

Re: BUT..  Repetition

Kees

You're still a climber Tom? I'm too, for 20 years now. At the start I would buy all the magazines and read everything. But now, while still being passionate about climbing, I don't even read the forums anymore, which seem to have the same cycle as the magazines.

In woodworking the forums are still giving me lots of info and inspiration. I guess the lifecycle is a bit longer.

Re: Beginners vs. Non-Beginners

#21

Re: Beginners vs. Non-Beginners

Curt Putnam

For me, the issue is the shape of learning curve. The steeper the curve, the more voracious the information intake. A flatter curve tends to have one focus on nuance or picking nits or simply ignoring the forums & mags and going fishing instead.

However, most folks are not equally expert at all things. Shifting from router cut DTs to hand cut DTs makes one a beginner in an instant. I'm not sure what the cure for your ennui is. Perhaps you should build something you've never before attempted using techniques new to you. Remember too, that God does not subtract from man's allotted time that which is spent in fishing.

Re: Beginners vs. Non-Beginners

#22

Re: Exception, maybe..

david weaver

I have some of them, at least on loan :)

There seems to have been a large dedicated following of folks who tried to get every single issue. A buddy of mine is one of those, I can go through his library. It does seem like the earlier issues were better. I have off and on had a subscription to FWW online, but i notice that look at it one or two times in a year, and then not again.

I lost interest in FWW when I realized you could get taunton stuff used on amazon, and it was a lot more useful at that point when the articles were combined and put in a book that would clearance or show up used for $7 (the big hardback taunton books). One of those is a lot more useful to me than 3 years of magazines, as long as they're on a subject I'd do.

There are some english magazines that are maybe better, too, isn't there one called furniture and cabinetmaking or something? (english friend raves about one of them, I can't remember if that's it).

Re: Beginners vs. Non-Beginners

#23

I am continually a beginner, my Forum contract

Bill Tindall

Each project I push into a different area. While I have built something approaching 100 pieces of furniture and dozens if not hundreds of "trinkets" my next project will involve line and berry inlay which I have never done anything like before. It will be a learning experience but with some help I can do it successfully.

On the other hand, the piece will be a chest of drawers. Having built many chests of drawers of various quality and complexity I am no longer a beginner looking for basic construction advice. However, I can offer basic construction advice to beginners.

The Forum deal is simple. I'll help beginners in areas where I have experience and others will help me in areas where I am a beginner.

Re: Beginners vs. Non-Beginners

#24

Ellis Walentine

Whew, what a thread

Ellis Walentine

I suppose that since I've had a lot of history with both magazines and the Internet, it might be germane to this conversation to talk some about my vision of WoodCentral and of woodworking magazine journalism, such as it is. So, here are a few shots from the hip...

First, magazines and forums are fundamentally different. A magazine talks *to* its readers; a forum is just a room where the readers talk among themselves. Both rely heavily on opinion, and it is incumbent on the readers to come to their own conclusions about the value and veracity of the information they read, and to choose to consume that information if they think it is useful to them for any reason, whether it be skill-building or project-oriented, or just random edification.

When I was at AW, we used to refer to articles as either "Geppetto" or "Pinocchio" articles -- a metaphor I first heard from my good friend John Kelsey, who was top editor at FW for something like 17 years -- depending on whether you wanted to learn carving or end up with a puppet. We had further divisions among lightweight, quickie projects that beginners might like, intermediate projects that used a variety of skills and equipment that average woodworkers had, and advanced projects that went into greater depth and involved fairly ambitious skills and objectives. Fine Woodworking, under the tutelage of John Lively, also had a rather unique, hybrid sort of project article that was more generic and informational, with more discussions of the whys and wherefores of specific furniture types, often with a variety of examples and general design and construction guidelines -- as opposed to the cookbook style (deadly parts lists, which inevitably contained dimensional mistakes that would leave readers furious about cutting their valuable lumber an inch too short, and step-by-step illustrated instructions and exploded drawings) of project articles that most magazines are still running today.

Magazines (most of them anyway) have a well-informed notion of who their readers are and what they want, so the editorial content is geared as much as possible to that reader profile, with enough excursions to interest the folks a little further out the bell curve. The suspicion that the same articles come up periodically is well founded, as, among other things the magazines have quantified and ranked reader interests and regard it as an obligation to serve those interests at a frequency proportionate to their position in the rankings. For example, we knew that our readers were into tablesaws and routers, so we'd come up with a tablesaw article and a router article at least every couple issues. We also had to be aware of the fact that subscribers began their subscriptions at different times of the year, so the cycle had to repeat itself at least every six or seven issues. This also meant that we couldn't have two-or three-part articles, as a significant percentage of subscribers (and newsstand customers) would have missed one or more of the installments.

Likewise with projects, we knew that our readers liked Arts & Crafts style and Shaker style (presumably because they are generally rectilinear and uncomplicated), so many of our projects were based on if not replicating those main interests. Whatever space was left over was dedicated to the other touchstone interests of our readers, e.g., finishing, hand tool skills, jigs and fixtures, shop improvements, and so on. That didn't leave much room for the offbeat topics, oddball personalities, and wonkier, novelty articles that we called "good reads." At AW, we probably had more of those than most mags in those days, and that was part of our personality or brand.

As I mentioned, magazines talk *to* the reader, and they have no particular heritage or continuity of content -- as Toshio Odate used to tell me, "like a child without a parent." While this is not an indictment, it does point up a basic disadvantage of the magazine format, which is that in any given year, you might get decidedly different takes from different authors on the same subject. The presumption was that each article was accepted because of the authority of the author, but sometimes it was difficult to reconcile such different approaches. Forums are like that, too.

In an online forum, the situation is different. I'm not pushing any agendas here -- you folks are in charge of starting and furthering the topics that interest you. There are distinct benefits to this colloquy model, in my opinion, notably that everyone gets the benefit of everyone else's experience on a given topic, which of course means that you've got to sort out the best answers to your questions from the opinions expressed, but it also means that we're informing each others' opinions, which can lead to some breakthroughs, even for the most advanced participants.

Another nice thing about the forum format is that you are welcome to express your ideas, questions and opinions in the most wonderful, eloquent, intellectual way you know how, and receive good answers from like-minded folks on that level. Magazines tend to write at an eighth-grade reading level. Here, if you don't understand the question, you can ask for a reprise in plain English.

Also, there are no questions too dumb to post. Any well-intentioned query is deserving of a thoughtful and cordial response. If I've tried to do anything at all here, it is to have created a place where it's okay to ask rookie questions, because I've found that there is often a benefit to all of us to hash out the answers yet again. It also encourages our better angels to reach out to those further down the ladder of woodworking experience.

If there's an upshot here, or an answer to your question, I'd say it is to skim everything and then move on if it's too boring. My founding mantra, "by and for you," is every bit as relevant today as it was fourteen years ago when I was buying the WoodCentral domain. This is an outpost, where all are welcome, where no question is too stupid, where people are treated as equals, and where the best of conversations can flourish and grow, limited only by the creativity and magnanimity of our members and guests.

This Hand Tools board has truly come of age in recent years, and I am extremely proud and happy to have such a generous, erudite and knowledgeable community of woodworkers calling it home. Whatever else I can do to foster and enable the discussion here, just let me know.

My best to you all,

Ellis

Re: Beginners vs. Non-Beginners

#25

Re: Whew, what a thread

david weaver

Ellis, I think you've done a great job. This is definitely the best forum for serious discussion, and even if it gets esoteric sometimes, that's better than just skipping difficult to communicate stuff altogether.