Whew, what a thread
Ellis Walentine
I suppose that since I've had a lot of history with both magazines and the Internet, it might be germane to this conversation to talk some about my vision of WoodCentral and of woodworking magazine journalism, such as it is. So, here are a few shots from the hip...
First, magazines and forums are fundamentally different. A magazine talks *to* its readers; a forum is just a room where the readers talk among themselves. Both rely heavily on opinion, and it is incumbent on the readers to come to their own conclusions about the value and veracity of the information they read, and to choose to consume that information if they think it is useful to them for any reason, whether it be skill-building or project-oriented, or just random edification.
When I was at AW, we used to refer to articles as either "Geppetto" or "Pinocchio" articles -- a metaphor I first heard from my good friend John Kelsey, who was top editor at FW for something like 17 years -- depending on whether you wanted to learn carving or end up with a puppet. We had further divisions among lightweight, quickie projects that beginners might like, intermediate projects that used a variety of skills and equipment that average woodworkers had, and advanced projects that went into greater depth and involved fairly ambitious skills and objectives. Fine Woodworking, under the tutelage of John Lively, also had a rather unique, hybrid sort of project article that was more generic and informational, with more discussions of the whys and wherefores of specific furniture types, often with a variety of examples and general design and construction guidelines -- as opposed to the cookbook style (deadly parts lists, which inevitably contained dimensional mistakes that would leave readers furious about cutting their valuable lumber an inch too short, and step-by-step illustrated instructions and exploded drawings) of project articles that most magazines are still running today.
Magazines (most of them anyway) have a well-informed notion of who their readers are and what they want, so the editorial content is geared as much as possible to that reader profile, with enough excursions to interest the folks a little further out the bell curve. The suspicion that the same articles come up periodically is well founded, as, among other things the magazines have quantified and ranked reader interests and regard it as an obligation to serve those interests at a frequency proportionate to their position in the rankings. For example, we knew that our readers were into tablesaws and routers, so we'd come up with a tablesaw article and a router article at least every couple issues. We also had to be aware of the fact that subscribers began their subscriptions at different times of the year, so the cycle had to repeat itself at least every six or seven issues. This also meant that we couldn't have two-or three-part articles, as a significant percentage of subscribers (and newsstand customers) would have missed one or more of the installments.
Likewise with projects, we knew that our readers liked Arts & Crafts style and Shaker style (presumably because they are generally rectilinear and uncomplicated), so many of our projects were based on if not replicating those main interests. Whatever space was left over was dedicated to the other touchstone interests of our readers, e.g., finishing, hand tool skills, jigs and fixtures, shop improvements, and so on. That didn't leave much room for the offbeat topics, oddball personalities, and wonkier, novelty articles that we called "good reads." At AW, we probably had more of those than most mags in those days, and that was part of our personality or brand.
As I mentioned, magazines talk *to* the reader, and they have no particular heritage or continuity of content -- as Toshio Odate used to tell me, "like a child without a parent." While this is not an indictment, it does point up a basic disadvantage of the magazine format, which is that in any given year, you might get decidedly different takes from different authors on the same subject. The presumption was that each article was accepted because of the authority of the author, but sometimes it was difficult to reconcile such different approaches. Forums are like that, too.
In an online forum, the situation is different. I'm not pushing any agendas here -- you folks are in charge of starting and furthering the topics that interest you. There are distinct benefits to this colloquy model, in my opinion, notably that everyone gets the benefit of everyone else's experience on a given topic, which of course means that you've got to sort out the best answers to your questions from the opinions expressed, but it also means that we're informing each others' opinions, which can lead to some breakthroughs, even for the most advanced participants.
Another nice thing about the forum format is that you are welcome to express your ideas, questions and opinions in the most wonderful, eloquent, intellectual way you know how, and receive good answers from like-minded folks on that level. Magazines tend to write at an eighth-grade reading level. Here, if you don't understand the question, you can ask for a reprise in plain English.
Also, there are no questions too dumb to post. Any well-intentioned query is deserving of a thoughtful and cordial response. If I've tried to do anything at all here, it is to have created a place where it's okay to ask rookie questions, because I've found that there is often a benefit to all of us to hash out the answers yet again. It also encourages our better angels to reach out to those further down the ladder of woodworking experience.
If there's an upshot here, or an answer to your question, I'd say it is to skim everything and then move on if it's too boring. My founding mantra, "by and for you," is every bit as relevant today as it was fourteen years ago when I was buying the WoodCentral domain. This is an outpost, where all are welcome, where no question is too stupid, where people are treated as equals, and where the best of conversations can flourish and grow, limited only by the creativity and magnanimity of our members and guests.
This Hand Tools board has truly come of age in recent years, and I am extremely proud and happy to have such a generous, erudite and knowledgeable community of woodworkers calling it home. Whatever else I can do to foster and enable the discussion here, just let me know.
My best to you all,
Ellis