New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Farmers table finish

Posts

Farmers table finish

#1

Jack Guzman from Maine

Farmers table finish

Jack Guzman from Maine

I don't know what to call this style of table. The name farmers table was used by the client. It consists of wide pine barn boards glued together with breadboard ends of red oak. The boards were milled over a hundred years ago and have an orangeish tint throughout. I had to introduce a different board into the top to reach the clients desired width and the color was slightly different. After hand planing the surface with a jack plane as the last tool to hit the top I used fruitwood danish oil to make the color more even.There are some knots that need addressing(one is loose)and a few rough spots. The client wants a wipeable surface and will use the table as her kitchen table in her old farmhouse. I thought about filling the knots and rough spots with epoxy then coat then whole thing with water based urethane. I will try this on a piece of scrap first.Does anyone have any ideas that might help me? I'm not very experienced with finishes.---Jack

Re: Farmers table finish

#2

Re: Farmers table finish

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Jack

Could it be Oregon Pine? That has a pinkish hue.

Anyway what I did with a similar table at home will raise the eyebrows of some purists, but I have never regretted the decision.

We have a Yellowwood diningroom table. This is quite a soft wood. It is very old, about 200 years, and was poorly restored by the person from whom we bought it (he belt sanded the top). Just using wax was not going to cut it. So I used a polyurethane varnish. Cut it back with 0000 steel wool until it was just an invisible, matt surface. Many cannot even tell there is a finish. It's been like this for 15 years, and has lasted wonderfully.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Farmers table finish

#3

Ellis Walentine

Depends on the customer's expectations...

Ellis Walentine

... and your helpful guidance. Polyurethane (I'd use oil-based) is a hard film finish that resists every kind of insult, and, as Derek says, can be sanded back to a nearly invisible surface. That's what I used on my birds-eye maple kitchen countertops recently and I'm very happy with the choice.

My 2¢,

Ellis

Re: Farmers table finish

#4

Re: Farmers table finish

Bob Hackett

I really like Waterlox (original formula) for things that are going to get some abuse. I`ve tried the surface film types of finish like poly but if the item is going to get used hard then the finish has to be able to be cleaned easily, repair easily, wear well and look good with only an occasional application of wax. For me that means an oil based, penetrating finish that becomes part of the wood and has some flexibility to it. I have had too many soft wood pieces topped by a hard film finish fracture and then have water migrate thru the crack to turn the wood below into a darker line or area. Once the film is broken it lets moisture thru and then holds that moisture in like plastic tarp laying on wet ground. Even if I sand back the fractured area of finish there will still be an area that`s discolored that I have to deal with before I can try to spot refinish that area.

An oil finish like Waterlox becomes part of the wood, strengthens and hardens soft wood, will dent rather than fracture and even if it has to be sanded back because of a deep scratch it can be easily spot patched to the point where the repair will disappear, even if you have to tint the finish for a good color match.

The problem with epoxy is that without a UV resistant top coat (like a gel-coat) light will break it down to the point where it becomes cloudy, brittle and crack. If your table is going to get sun on it then I`d be leery of using epoxy unless the top was going to be painted or otherwise protected from the effects of UV rays.

The only film type finish I`ve personally had any luck with applying over a soft wood base has been that pourable bar top finish as it is like a liquid glass top that is thick enough to be sanded back and then buffed out without any fear of sanding thru the finish. We built a bar in one of the NCO clubs for the National Guard. They glued unit patches and crests onto the pine top, then we applied edging and poured the stuff in till it was a quarter inch deep over the imbedded objects. After several repairs that included sanding and buffing it still looks good after 15+ years. That bar never gets any sunlight on it though.

Re: Farmers table finish

#5

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Farmers table finish

Jack Guzman from Maine

The wood is northeastern US white pine.---Jack

Re: Farmers table finish

#6

Jack Guzman from Maine

Yea but...

Jack Guzman from Maine

What about the knots? There are some pretty deep cavities in the center of a couple of them and all around the edge is a gap.One is even loose. Will poly fill those holes? That's why I was considering epoxy on the knots. I'm not sure how it will work under the poly.---Jack

Re: Farmers table finish

#7

opinions and data on a table finish

Bill Tindall

I put urethane varnish, the robust solvent kind, on our dining table around 30 years ago and it still looks good as new. I always thin varnish about 1:4 to make it flow and level better. In the case of this table I applied three coats sanding it smooth in between. The table is formal cherry so in this case I ground it flat after the 3rd coat and then then brought the gloss back up with rotten stone and oil.

A table that will be used needs to be able to endure oily foods and detergent washes, and even be somewhat what heat resistant. Either a conversion varnish, if you spray, or urethane varnish, if you brush, excels in these attributes.

I have yet to see a water based varnish that has the bright luster of the solvent based varnishes, whether it is rubbed out or not. I don't like their looks and I fail to see any advantage that they offer.

Re: Farmers table finish

#8

Re: Yea but...

John Veerkamp

Use epoxy to fill around the knots. Color the epoxy to match the knots. then sand and finish the whole top.

Re: Farmers table finish

#9

Maloof finish

roninkokomo

I would use a Maloof type finish here. The downside is it does take a while. BUT I really believe the results are worth it. Haven't had much experience patching around knots, so I really can't help there.

Ron

Re: Farmers table finish

#10

Re: opinions and data on a table finish

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

The advantage the waterbased poly's offer is that they are clearer and don't yellow nearly as much over time. They also dry much faster. I use one that has a UV inhibiter and have been getting fantastic results.

I use General HP Poly and it sands and rubs out like lacquer. I use their gloss formula and rub it out and then folow that with a coat of pate wax and it has all the brightness and depth of any top quality catalized lacquer.

I often use a hand rubbed oil finish but on high and demanding items such as tabes I use General HP poly, sometimes by itself and sometimes over the top of a coat or oil.

Re: Farmers table finish

#11

Re: opinions and data on a table finish

Bill Tindall

I need to give it a try. I like non-yellowing for light woods like ash and maple. I don't like the dull luster in the products I have tried.

Re: Farmers table finish

#12

Re: Farmers table finish

George in early Spring Lowell, Mich.

Hi Jack,

I have used water clear epoxy to lock knots in place.

Put duct tape on the underside of the table over the knot to contain the epoxy. From the top apply the epoxy to the knot and work it in with a probe (small screwdriver) to make sure it is worked down into the knot hole to lock it in place. I have even poured it into holes with 1/2 of the knot there and filled it up and then some. Let harden, sand it flush with the wood with finer and finer sandpaper and your done. I have also mixed sawdust with epoxy to fill holes with out the knots.

The only caution is make sure the epoxy is mixed well! There is usually a "generous" 4-5min. working time. This seems short but it is plenty of time if you are prepared with everything that you will need within reach.

Worked good for me. Find a scrap with a similar loose knot and experiment.

Work safe,

George

Re: Farmers table finish

#13

Jack Guzman from Maine

The table

Jack Guzman from Maine

The chairs in the pic go with the table.There are six in all and they were a flea market find. The legs are tapered ,made of cherry.There is a silver drawer and a sliding breadboard made of the same wood as the table top.

I epoxied the knots tonight.When that dries I'll figure out my next step. Thanks for all the input.---Jack

Re: Farmers table finish

#14

Re: opinions and data on a table finish *LINK*

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

The general HP poly is actually a bit too glossy for my taste. I usualy apply 2-3 coats and then sand with 220 and follow with another 2 coats. Ocasionally I get lucky and all I need to do is hit it with 0000 steel wool and other times I need to sand or sometimes on a large flat I will apply 3 coats and then hit it with a not so sharp cabinet scraper. It actually sands and rubs out more like nitrocellulose than anything else.

I have never tried spraying it and I use a 2" Raphael artists brush, which I would highly recomend for any water based finish. It holds a nice amount of finish and lays it on very smooth with a minimal amount of brush marks. You will also get nice results with a foam brush but be aware that they tend to decompose on the final coat, DAMHIKT.

Like any finish it will be a bit soft but after about a month or so it is pretty much bullet proof.

Robin


The brush I use

Re: Farmers table finish

#15

Re: Farmers table finish

Charles

We have a harvest table I built years ago. It's in the kitchen and gets used for eating and food prep. I finished it with olive oil (no stain) and refresh it from time to time after a good hot soap and water scrubbing. It has knife marks, burn marks, wine stains, you name it - a lot of general wear. In short, it's starting to look pretty good for that style of table. A plain beeswax finish, affording little 'protection,' would also be appropriate.

IMO, the style does not call for some sort of impervious finish that will look the same in twenty years as it did the day you applied it. Though, this is ultimately your customer's decision.

A farmer's table, a harvest table - these were used for everything and when the real thing is found in the wild rarely have any sort of finish left on them at all if there was ever one to begin with other than oil and/or wax.

I'd glue in some dutchmen out of a contrasting species to repair the loose knots. Use hide glue or white school glue - preferably the latter as it won't be as damaging to knife edges as is hide glue or epoxy resing which both cure glass hard.

My two cents.

Re: Farmers table finish

#16

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Farmers table finish

Jack Guzman from Maine

My thoughts exactly.I thought of dutchmen,but there's just too many knots. This board came out of her attic and it's the only one good enough for a table.So I'll fill the knots and sand them down. I tried a sample and satin water based urethane doesn't look too plastic. I'll just steel wool to dull it some. She want's it coated.If it was mine I'd oil it and call it good.Thanks---Jack

Re: Farmers table finish

#17

Re: Farmers table finish

Charles

Customer is always right I guess. Too bad. I can look at some of the marks on our table and remember who was at the table and what we were doing when the mark was made. One burn mark was from a very hot casserole dish right out of the oven from the first family Christmas dinner my wife and I hosted in the first year of our marriage. She was stressed and plopped the dish right down on the table while staging everything for the dining room. Love that mark. One wine stain was from dribbles from a bottle of Haute Brion, another dinner we hosted and a guest brought the incredible gift of such a fine bottle of wine. Great stuff. A life reflected in a table. Our three year old is still making marks on it. Wouldn't have it any other way.

Re: Farmers table finish

#18

Re: Farmers table finish

Charles

Sorry, Haut-Brion.... got carried away with the 'e.'

Re: Farmers table finish

#20

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Farmers table finish

Jack Guzman from Maine

Not quite the same thing but 30 years or so ago I installed a pine slab between my kitchen and living room as a bar. I carved a checkerboard into it and invited family and guests to sign their names on it. Not too many people can carve so we keep a woodburner close by. That bar has 30 years of history on it. Many of the names are of people since deceased.---Jack

Re: Farmers table finish

#21

Re: Farmers table finish

Charles

I love it.

Re: Farmers table finish

#22

Re: Farmers table finish

Charles

Kind of you to say so.