New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

turning chsiel handles

Posts

turning chsiel handles

#1

turning chsiel handles

eliot d

Is there anywhere to buy fine chisels without handles? I turn a lot and can easily make my own.

Re: turning chsiel handles

#2

It is very easy to make them

Bill Tindall

If you would be satisfied with the Blue Spruce patterns they are simply cut from annealed bar stock, shaped, heat treated and sharpened. I have information in Articles section on the process. The Article is for a CPM 3V chisel but the approach would be the same for O-1. You can likely get O-1 from some place local if you are in a city and most cities have heat treatment shops. Or mail order the steel and heat treatment. Cost is a few dollars per chisel.

Re: turning chsiel handles

#3

Alternatively ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Look for vintage chisels of decent blade length without handles or with much abused handles, and then turn replacements.

I put together a great set of Stanley 750s this way. This included grinding the shoulders to create minimal lands. I have done this with others before - Witherbys and Bergs, all of which ended up being sold.

The bottom line is that one can get excellent chisels cheaply because they are seen to be too much work to restore for the average individual.

As Bill notes, one can grind a blade from scratch. In addition to O1 steel, consider HSS (M2), since this would not require heat treating.

Grinding shoulders and turning handles for socket chisels: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ShopMadeTools/Soyouwanttomakeadovetailchisel.html

Low tech blade heat treating: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ShopMadeTools/LowTechHeatTreating.html

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: turning chsiel handles

#4

What?!

Bill Tindall

M2 doesn't require heat treatment? There is a misprint here somewhere. Maybe not if you employ a used jointer blade (done that) but anything that can be fabricated must be fabricated from annealed material to be sawed or filed.

Re: turning chsiel handles

#5

Re: What?!

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Bill

The HSS I have access to, and I assume you do as well, is for turners wanting to shape their own lathe chisels. These come ready to use, that is, fully heat treated. The fear when grinding treated steel is that the heat will affect its temper, and you will need to re-heat treat the blade. The advantage of HSS is that one can grind the steel without fear of affecting the existing temper. Therefore heat treating is no longer a factor. By contrast, steels such as O1 will likely need to be heat treated. This is doable in the home shop. A2 is not.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: turning chsiel handles

#6

Re: What?!

John in NM

Many of the tool steel suppliers here, at least the ones us cheapskates utilize, sell annealed steel because it is vastly easier to grind and cut to shape that way. The bulk of their customers are well used to sending parts out to be treated, so annealed stock is seen as preferable to pre-hardened.

Re: turning chsiel handles

#7

  Your post could be misleading

Bill Tindall

The steel most people will have access to will be annealed steel of this or that variety, including M2. This steel typically can be sawed, filed , milled and otherwise fabricated into shapes. It must then be heat treated to some greater hardness depending on use. There are many sources- metal supply places(local or mail order), tool room supply places, your local machine shop, knife maker suppliers, etc. Personally, I don't know of any source of hardened tool steel shapes other than lathe tool bits and these are not of a size useful for a chisel. I have used jointer and planer blades to make a specialized tool.

Heat treating is cheap and readily available. Any machine shop can supply a source for heat treating and may even let you add a chisel or two to their next batch. Last I did was $50/25 pounds but it is more now.

High Speed Steel just means that the heat treatment normally used involves tempering at very high temperature, for example 1100 F. Many tool steels fit this description. HSS does not mean the steel is already hardened. Nothing means the steel is already hardened unless a hardness value is given, for example "hardened to Rc60-62". Once hardened to alter the shape the piece must be ground. It can not be sawed, filed, or milled. M2 is very abrasion resistant and tedious to alter its shape by grinding.

In my hands M2 made poor chisels. Not tough enough at the hardness it is normally taken to. Its main benefit is abrasion resistance- good for plane blades and lathe tools.

Re: turning chsiel handles

#8

David Barnett

I dunno, Bill...

David Barnett

...I've bought M2 and M35 rectangle blanks up to 200mm long hardened to RC63. Trust me, these weren't annealed. I think Carba-Tec used to stock these in 12" lengths, so maybe that's what Derek meant. Some folks would actually grind a tang and add a handle. Not me. I made a hefty shot-loaded rubber-coated aluminum handle, inserted all but a few inches held with cross-pins or set screws and freehanded 12L14. Fun.

By the way, I've always bought all my HSS rounds, squares and rectangles hardened.

Re: turning chsiel handles

#9

Re: turning chisel handles

TomD

Used to be you could buy just about anything without handles. But alas no more.

While my chisels are mostly Japanese, My second choice would be "cast steel" meaning old antique stuff, you can get almost anything at antique tool sales without handles.

Third, I make my own chisels at times for certain uses. I can make a chisel faster than I can get to Lee Valley, and I live only 13 km away. This assumes all the stuff required has been set up. My shop does not allow me to keep all categories of work set up all the time. I'm talking about chisels that look as good/identical to commercial ones costing 57.25. I use that figure because I have only once copied a commercial chisel when I wanted more options than were offered. In fact the handles take longer than the blades. At least the work is longer, heat treating takes while, but I have my feet up.

Re: turning chsiel handles

#10

Yes ..

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

... to both Bill and David.

Bill, on reflection my post is indeed confusing for those in the USA. As David correctly notes, here in Oz we can get ready-to-grind HSS from Carba-tec (which is the local woodworking chain with the most comprehensive quality gear).

I have made some really decent chisels from the HSS bars. One example was in the link I provided. Another is below example of a HSS chisel. These were made for morticing. I have a number of oval bolstered types, which have relieved sides. I wanted a couple of chisels with square sides that could do duty as corner chisels. All that was required was to grind the bevel and add a handle.


http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ShopMadeTools/SquaringChisels.html

These blades hold an edge pretty well (for my purposes anyway). The point being that HSS can make a decent blade. But it depends on what you are looking for.

A point I must make is that the HSS topic is sidetracking the thread and is out of the context of my first post. The comment I made then to making chisels out of HSS was almost a throw away line (I had focussed on rehandling old chisels), and was picked up by Bill and - I think - somewhat blown out of perspective. I was wrong to assume that you get heat treated HSS lengths as we do, and this is where the confusion started. Hopefully this is clear.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: turning chsiel handles

#11

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: turning chsiel handles

Jack Guzman from Maine

Eliot,I don't know where you are but around here(southern maine)I have found decent chisels without handles to be cheap and readily available at almost any flea market. You have to weed through the ones with the back hopelessly ground out of usefulness and the ones pitted from rust.---Jack

Re: turning chsiel handles

#12

clarification

Bill Tindall

Ok so somewhere there is a source of hardened steels that I am unfamiliar with. However, if Eliot asks for M2 in the likely places- local metal supplier, most mail order suppliers, local machine shop, "tool room" catalogs such as MSC, Travers, ENCO, or knife blank suppliers- this M2 will not be annealed, not hardened.

In your original post you suggested simply buying M2 and it would be ready to use. Had Elliot, or more likely anyone else, followed this suggestion and bought from the likely sources listed above the tool would have failed because they would have been using annealed steel. This is not a trivial point to make to the audience.

Bottom line- The metal code (M2 for example) tells what the composition is. High Speed Steel (HSS) denotes that the steel will not loose its hardness at high temperature after it is heat treated. Only a hardness designation (Rc 60-62, for example) provides information on whether the material is heat treated and to what degree. Again, this is essential information to anyone contemplating making a chisel.

Re: turning chsiel handles

#13

David Barnett

Actually... *LINK*

David Barnett

I hate to differ, Bill, but I don't think hardened HSS stock in sizes other than standard tool bits is as rare as you might think. I have had no trouble finding it in all manner of widths, lengths, and thicknesses. Some small and specialist machine grinding and fab shops buy it hardened without bevels for making jointer and planer knives to avoid in-house heat treating. (I bought a pile of it at one time from a surplus outlet in Central Florida that had aerospace industry overruns from Orlando and the Cape.)

These days, for example, Arthur R. Warner carries a narrower selection of thin flats in various HSS alloys, including one PM, hardened and precision ground in 6" lengths (below). Several other metals companies stock narrower and wider in longer sizes. No, you won't find it at your general purpose indy suppliers you listed. You do have to look around for it, but it's out there.

By the way, a couple of those indy suppliers you named will special order, and some smaller shops will, too. There just isn't as much call for it as annealed stock.

Ready-to-go blanks intended for turning chisels/gouges have always been available in the U.K. and Australia, often with tangs. Don't know why, but I've seen them in the catalogs. At least one U.S. supplier offered them a few years ago but it's been awhile since I've seen any.

I suppose if someone is ignorant of the difference between annealed and hardened stock, they could make a mistake, but the same would go for someone that didn't realize O1 is almost always sold annealed and needs to be hardened and tempered. It's hard to cover for ignorance, so many things not to know.

Funny though; if I were to walk into a tool room supplier in Tampa and say I needed M2, they'd likely ask whether I wanted hardened blanks or annealed stock. Springfield, Mass? Not a chance.


Arthur R. Warner thin flats

Re: turning chsiel handles

#14

Re: turning chsiel handles

eliot d

Thanks, I wasn't asking about fabricating my chisel blades. In my post I asked only about finding chisel blades without handles because I would like to turn my own handles. What I actually had in mind was a place where I could purchase new chisel blades, without handles. Lather turners often get there gauges that way and make their own handles.

Re: turning chsiel handles

#15

Re: Alternatively ...

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

I'm curious why you prefer the stanley's over the berg's. I have a 1" berg that I like so much I put together a set of them.

To the OP's question: as others have said the used market has some great deals. There seems to be a rprefrence for socket chisels on this board but I actually prefer tang handled chisels. I have yet to have one with a good ferule come loose or fail, unlike a socket handle. My stated prefrence for the bergs which have socket handels is, in my opinion a testament to the quality of the steel they used.

Robin

Re: turning chsiel handles

#16

Re: Alternatively ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I'm curious why you prefer the stanley's over the berg's. I have a 1" berg that I like so much I put together a set of them.

Hi Robin

The Bergs were excellent chisels. These were tanged chisels since this style was dominant in Australia - I do not recall seeing a socket version here. I had put together the set (1/8" through 1 1/4") over several years, buying the longest blades I could find with the worst handles. I liked this design ...


The Bergs held an edge so much better than the Witherbys I had (and sold).

However, I found that they were sitting in the cabinet much of the time as I tended to turn to a set of Blue Spruce dovetail chisels. Then a three year wait for a set of Kiyohesi slicks came to an end, and these turned out to be pretty pricy. The Bergs were sold to fund the slicks. I do not regret this for one moment since I just love using these chisels.


The Stanley 750 set were put together the same way as the Bergs. I find that their edge holding is on a par with the Bergs. Perhaps I have been lucky - again these were near full length blades with poor or missing handles, which received ones of my own design. The She-oak is an extremely hard wood that accepts blows from brass mallets ...


I really like these chisels. They are much modified over the originals, however, so not quite comparible. In addition to new handles, I ground the shoulders to minimal lands at the front ends ..


The Bergs were never this fine. The Stanleys are the chisels I have tended to take with me when I do dovetail demonstrations at woodshows.

A striking feature of the tanged Bergs was their lightness in the hand. The Stanleys, however, are nearly as light, but have a a wider range of use. Of the two chisels I actually prefer the Stanleys. Now the new Veritas chisels have come along, and their similarity to the Stanley (in balance) is one of the reasons I like them.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: turning chsiel handles

#17

thanks

Bill Tindall

If I need a 1/2, 3/4 or 1" x 4" long chisel (2" tang) now I know where to find it and for only about $10.

Re: turning chsiel handles

#18

David Barnett

Hahaha... yeah, you're right...

David Barnett

...not much selection there. Of course one never knows when one might need a .093" thick 1" wide butt chisel. :)

Re: turning chsiel handles

#20

Re: turning chsiel handles

TomD

Jack, does Maine still have those tool barns? There were three that advertised together. That was a long time ago.

Re: turning chsiel handles

#21

To answer your question

Bill Tindall

Likely any of the custom Boutique chisel makers will sell a chisel unhandled. I agree it does make sense coming from the lathe too side. Check with Blue Spruce or ask Derek who it was that sent him the 3V chisels for evaluation. I lost the persons name but I am sure he would provide what ever you desired.

Re: turning chsiel handles

#22

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: turning chsiel handles

Jack Guzman from Maine

I'm not sure which "tool barns" you are referring to but a few miles from here is a guy that collects and sells used hand tools of all kinds out of his barn.He is well known in the area(Limington,Maine)and has a large selection. On the coast north of Portland was another such seller that I visited on a trip to Warren to see Lie Nielsen's shop. I think there are a few like that in that area. Probably what you are referring to.---Jack

Re: turning chsiel handles

#23

The tools barns

Bob Hackett

If you mean Liberty Tool, Hulls Cove Tool Barn and Captain Tinkum`s Tool Emporium (all owned by the same person) then the answer is yes.

The prices have been climbing over the years but good deals can still be found there to include a run of NOS James Swan chisels (without handles) recently. :D

Re: turning chsiel handles

#24

Re: The tools barns

Bruce, a MN Galoot

We hit all three a few years back on a leaf-peeping trip. I had never seen such a place that catered exclusively to me! What a joy.

Re: turning chsiel handles

#25

So that is where all the chisels are at

Bill Tindall

One might visit flea markets 20 times in these parts and never see a chisel of any sort, never mind one that is worth salvage. I didn't even see any at the huge market in Hillsville, VA last Labor Day. In fact I have only once bought good chisel in usable condition at a flea market in more than 10 years. I think for many of us that equipping a shop with used chisels is unrealistic/impossible.