New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Iknow..a repeat...LN vs Clifton

Posts

Iknow..a repeat...LN vs Clifton

#1

Iknow..a repeat...LN vs Clifton

Brian Cameron

I am in the market for a new smooth plane and I have found that the LV # 4's

do not "feel good" and was wondering how much diff there is now brtween the LN and the Clifton... LN is a known quanlity...last rerview I could find on a Clifton is old...any directions here?

Re: Iknow..a repeat...LN vs Clifton

#2

Re: Iknow..a repeat...LN vs Clifton

joel moskowitz

See the review in FWW - clifton and LN tied for top marks

Re: Iknow..a repeat...LN vs Clifton

#3

Re: Iknow..a repeat...LN vs Clifton

Tony - Memphis

I have a Clifton shoulder plane (late model) that I really like. Nice piece - even in the hands of a rookie.

Tony

Re: Iknow..a repeat...LN vs Clifton

#4

Never tried a Clifton...

John in NM

Should be a fine tool though.

You could also try LN's 4 1/2 smoother, being a bit bigger it may have a different feel.

I suppose my solution would be to make a smoother that feels right. They're really not too hard to whittle out of a chunk of wood.

Re: Iknow..a repeat...LN vs Clifton

#5

Re: Unless you find the clifton for a discount..

david weaver

...i don't know why you'd buy one over an LN.

There have been too many posts from people saying that they got a plane that was wrong, and the manufacturer never made it right (and it wasn't the fault of the retailer that things weren't made right).

I've not heard of that ever happening with any LN.

Be different if you lived 10 miles from the clifton factory and could go knock on their door. Until they have the spotless track record that LN has in service after sale, and/or they make a functionally superior product, you should get a discount on the cliftons (and to my knowledge, the price difference that used to exist has evaporated).

Re: Iknow..a repeat...LN vs Clifton

#6

Re: Iknow..a repeat...LN vs Clifton

Michael Brady

To get a meaningful answer, you will have to find someone who has experience with both planes. That would be a very small pool of candidates, at least here in the U.S. You might try the UK Workshop hand tool forum, where many members likely have experience using these two brands side-by-side.

Re: Iknow..a repeat...LN vs Clifton

#7

Re: Iknow..a repeat...LN vs Clifton

barryvabeach

Brian, I own a Clifton 6, and had a Clifton 4 briefly. I own a LN low angle jack, but none of their smoothing planes. Clifton makes a very substantial and nice plane, and sometimes, probably depending on the exchange rate, you can get one much cheaper than the LN equivalent. The handles are bubinga, but, on the ones I have used, the rear of the handle has a much sharper edge to it - it isn't sharp, but not as rounded as the handle on the LN jack - which is one of my favorite handles. I don't think you can go wrong with either. You might end up having to scrape the rear of the Clifton if you don't like the fit. The big advantage is with LN, if you decide you don't like it, the have a very high resale value.