New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Woo Woo! *LINK*

Posts

Re: Woo Woo! *LINK*

#26

Re: True enough, in that context

Mark Hennebury

Maybe its just frustration on my part, but i have seen many good woodworkers struggle and go out of business because of a lack of public appreciation of the incredible work that they do, and I have seen so many people with little knowledge and skill promoting themselves as the best craftsmen. I no longer do furniture for a living but it still bothers me lot. I would like to think that the trade would gain a wider understanding and appreciation for the good people that put so much effort into it. I know how hard that I worked to learn my trade and how much effort I put in to my work, and there is no recognition or acknowledgement and certainly no financial benefit, so at the end of the day there is no reason to do good work other than a hobby, which I find quite depressing. I know a lot make a living teaching, and the chosen few become famous, but It would be nice if you could earn living just doing good honest woodwork. Just to be able to have an honest evaluation system and say this work is good and this work is not and you choose what you want to make and the customers can choose what they want to buy. It may be an over simplification and just wishful thinking. but many other parts of our lifes have standards, not saying any of them work perfectly, but thought this might be a good place to get some input. Like you say, could be some kind of voluntary thing. Just thought I would throw it out there.

Re: Woo Woo! *LINK*

#28

Re: In the world of fads that change in a year..

david weaver

... I guess it's not surprising to find out a word catches on in some other region, and then gets used everywhere someone thinks they want to cater to a cohort that uses it.

I wonder how much of that artisan bread is made by artisans, vs. how much is made by "bakers". I heard a fast food place mentioning artisan bread not that long ago (I can't remember who, i guess it didn't make enough of an impression). I'm going to guess they didn't hire artisans to make it, nor did the bakery that supplied it.

Re: Woo Woo! *LINK*

#29

David Barnett

Ah... I see where you're coming from

David Barnett

I can totally appreciate your thoughtful, heartfelt and revealing statement and can certainly understand and share how you feel. While there are groups that celebrate and promote high standards in furniture construction, such as the SAPFM and The Furniture Society, the focus is more on traditional furniture makers and construction and less so on furniture from industrial designers and manufacturers. Consensus naturally varies from differing furniture backgrounds, contexts, and real-world applicability.

For example, I personally choose not to live with period furniture, no matter how well it's constructed as it's not to my taste. I simply detest most anything preceding the Art Nouveau, and can far better appreciate mid-century modern, for example, much which would probably fall short of period furniture construction standards. Furniture covers too much ground, is often too personal, too contextual within a particular cultural or design milieu to submit it to a consensus of construction standards. What's more, sometimes construction becomes legitimately secondary to style.

I've known several period makers, very good at what they did, who've given up trying to make livings due to market challenges. One very talented designer and maker now owns a video and game rental store in a small New England town. I understand their disappointment when they see others get huge prices for sculpted MDF covered in veneer. I've watched buyers in a major NYC craft show walk by beautifully crafted satinwood writing desks without a glance, heading for glass-topped tables resting on aesthetically and geometrically questionable bases covered in garish kewazinga, so I do understand.

In another field, art metalsmithing, the schools are turning out scores of graduates with substandard skills and immeasurably worse artistic inclinations, where "saying something" rarely comes across in the work itself but only in the droning blah-blah artist statements in their CVs or brochures.

So yes, it's discouraging, and not just for woodworkers, but I'm dubious whether promoting standards really has the desired broad and uplifting effect, especially in fields so variegated as the crafts. Sure, one can buy a GIA certified diamond, but again, that has nothing to do with color cut by the best of Idar-Oberstein, not to mention the superb gem carvers now producing heretofore unseen wonders. Standards lag.

You're right, though; it is an interesting problem and one that deserves to be discussed, although I'll admit it makes me not a little dizzy when I look too deeply into it.

I really want to say one more thing. It's so gratifying to find you share common ground with someone whom you initially suspect has little in common. It's often overlooked, but the main reason this so often takes place on Wood Central is overwhelmingly due to Ellis Walentine, who has fostered such open and free discussion, not without some risk, keeping Wood Central a space with plenty of room to breathe and share and learn, and for this, I wish to once again say thank you.

Re: Woo Woo! *LINK*

#30

David Barnett

Thanks! I need that.   


Re: Woo Woo! *LINK*

#31

Re: Ah... I see where you're coming from

Mark Hennebury

I am sure that we all have big egos and are opinionated so its easy to create friction, but if we can get past that we all have a common interest in woodworking, a lot to learn and share and a great place to discuss it here on woodcentral. And I am sure that we would like to see woodworking as a thriveing respected and a well paid career, but In all conscience I couldn't recomend it to anyone as a career, and that bothers me. I taught woodworking classes 25 years ago, and loved showing students how to tune up handplanes and got great enjoyment watching their excitment and fascination at making magnificient shavings, I taught them about understanding wood structure and principles of joinery design, so that they had a basis to learn. but if I were teaching in a college today to students looking to make a career of woodworking, i would fail the best ones simply because I would want to spare them the hardship ahead. I would like not to feel that way.

My father was a carpenter and joiner and did very good work. He impressed upon me the importance of doing your best, and being honest. I distinctly remember when i was a small child my father let me use his handsaw to rip a peice of wood that he was working on. He told me not to cut over the line and I was very nervous and cut 1/8" or more away from the line, he didn't say anything when i had finished but took the saw and cut the1/8" strip off. another pivotal moment in my life was when my Dad and I returned to a store to take back a few pennies because the girl at the checkout had given him too much change. These two moments from long ago have cost me a fortune ever since. Although its noble concept to be an honest, hardworking and highly skilled craftsman, it simply doesnt fit that well in this day and age. The only place that I feel at home is when i go in some of the great churches and am humbled by the workmanship, I wonder where the culture that inspired and supported that mindset went. I walk around and look at the carpentry around town and its is embarrissing, its not carpentry its something else, something alien and ugly. Its 2x4s nails and screws, decks and hand rails that look like if you lent on them they would collapse. Yet people pay for this, and people do this work, it must be acceptable to most everyone or it wouldnt exist.

I would love to see high standards demanded and achieved in woodworking, I would like to see the craft pushed to new heights. It could be done, we have the best most efficient machinery and equipment and all the knowledge at our fingertips, at no time in the history of mankind have we been able to efficiently produce such high quality work and make it available to everyone. Yet I have to go into a 200 year old church or an old barn to see good woodwork. We have house and stores filled with melamine, particle board and fake solidwood furniture when a good beautiful solidwood table that can be made quite efficiently can last for hundreds of years. We live in a supply and demand world, so unless the demand changes I guess the supply wont.

Re: Woo Woo! *LINK*

#32

Re: Ah... I see where you're coming from

TomD

Mark, when I get you regular ads in my inbox, I wonder who the heck is buying those multi thousand dollar japanese industrial machines in Ontario. I had hope...

Re: Woo Woo! *LINK*

#33

Re: Woo Woo!

TomD

My favourite example of a guy revealing the form within was, I kid you not, two gigantic tree sized logs pictured on the back page of FWW (back when it mattered). They had been steamed and twisted into pretzels. Not sure where they found that in the logs, but they sure got it out.

Re: Woo Woo! *LINK*

#34

Re: Ah... I see where you're coming from

Kees

Man that is so true! We live in a strange time. Very wealthy but low quality is all around us.

The basis of our wealty is cheapness.

Re: Woo Woo! *LINK*

#35

Re: How about a Design Czar!

TomD

"The general public don't have the same background to make that determination. "

There have always been style setters out there. These days, though, they have discovered the process can be undertaken without quality as part of the equation. In fact a necessary component seems to be to wring the quality and cost out. A lot more money can be made selling T-shirts than a hand woven tweed jacket.

I think we also have to look ourselves in the mirror. Very few people wear good clothes for instance. Up until a few years back the US was the richest society perhaps to ever have existed, and yet the standards of dress are abysmal. People will not pay for properly fitted clothes, or shoes. Yet hundreds are spent on crap like Nikes. There is quality being overlooked in some sector by just about everyone.

It would be an interesting question to determine what furniture means to people. It has an immediate functionality, but furniture is clearly really important to people, but how is that. If you are in the woodworking furniture thing, there are a bunch of words that one could associate. For instance quality. Lets say we had a focus group on furniture, what would be the five terms people would most associate with furniture in a positive way that would make then buy it.

Re: Woo Woo! *LINK*

#36

David Barnett

Not exactly your focus group... *LINK*

David Barnett

...but studies on furniture perception do pop up, such as these on wood "character".

Understanding perception of wood household furniture

http://nrs.fs.fed.us/pubs/jrnl/2007/nrs_2007_brinberg_001.pdf

Market potential for fine furniture manufactured from low-grade hardwood

http://www.thefreelibrary.com/Market+potential+for+fine+furniture+manufactured+from+low-grade...-a0117776294


Custom Cabinetry Trends (search the archives)

Re: Woo Woo! *LINK*

#37

Re: Ah... I see where you're coming from *LINK*

Mark Hennebury

As for who buys the Supersurfacers... Not many people. They are incredibly hard to sell, the same as the Maka mortisers. I find it puzzeling that here is some of the finest most efficient machinery that for a business would give them better quality work and save them a ton of time, and yet they wont purchase them. From a hobby standpoint they are very expensive, but if you are a busines doing windows or doors or furniture why would you not want to do it efficiently, " the best that it can be done in the fastest time" Sure these machines are expensive , but so is paying a worker to waste time cutting mortices with a hollow chisel mortiser, or sanding wood by hand or with an expensive wide belt sander. The fact is the supersurfacer do incredible work, and so do the Maka style mortisers. Buying machinery is simple math it should not be anything else, yet I feel that a lack of education, prejudice, fear of the unfamiiar or some such predjudice is at play. In Germany Marunaka have sold over 1000 supersurfacers, they also all use Maka style mortisers extensively, yet in North America, most have never heard of them. This i find puzzling, its not like the machines or information is hidden. This is the first time that I have actually seen Superurfacers even discussed in thirty years since they were first introduced in North America. I have introduced Maka mortisers to a few companies who are just blown away at what a great job they do, They never heard of them or seen them before, yet Makas were first made in the 50's There seems to be something wrong with that. How can you expect to be competetive in some kind of manufacturing or production these days using old inefficient equipment and worse not even knowing what better technology is out there available to you. I remeber a few years back talking to to a rep from a large machine dealership in the US, he had just go back from one of the big machinery shows in Europe and was telling that he saw some incredible high tech machinery while there, but that it wouldnt sell in North America.

Watch the Maka mortiser video and tell why any business would do mortising any other way.


Maka mortiser video

Re: Woo Woo! *LINK*

#38

Moses Yoder

Re: Why is it

Moses Yoder

When you build a house, you need a permit and a number of inspections. Cars are government regulated out the ying-yang. We are told we have to put our babies in car seats (that would be regulations on what we can do with our children). Air planes are government regulated. Real estate and banking are government regulated. But all I need to foist a $20 table on someone for $7000 is a tax id number, a Skilsaw, and a screw gun. Just wondering.

Re: Woo Woo! *LINK*

#39

Re: Why is it

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

If more people died when that $20 table collapsed during dinner, there'd be regulations. The regulations you mention all have to do with consumer/citizen safety, not consumers being overcharged.

Re: Woo Woo! *LINK*

#40

Cool video...

John in NM

The link is to a smaller supersurfacer, that thing is really cool!

I've seen the Maka videos on your site, they do make you wonder why anyone would bother with heavy hollow chisel machines or chain mortisers.

Re: Woo Woo! *LINK*

#41

Re: Ah... I see where you're coming from *LINK*

Mark Hennebury

Sorry about the wrong link

Try this one: http://youtu.be/KJUJ796jxls

Thanks.


Maka link

Re: Woo Woo! *LINK*

#42

Ellis Walentine

Back at you, David

Ellis Walentine

I really want to say one more thing. It's so gratifying to find you share common ground with someone whom you initially suspect has little in common. It's often overlooked, but the main reason this so often takes place on Wood Central is overwhelmingly due to Ellis Walentine, who has fostered such open and free discussion, not without some risk, keeping Wood Central a space with plenty of room to breathe and share and learn, and for this, I wish to once again say thank you.

I appreciate your kind words, and I certainly do what I can to encourage and facilitate collegial discussions here; but, I only keep the doors open. You, the esteemed visitors, are the sine qua non of this place, and the reason I carry on -- "by and for you" and all that...

All the best,

Ellis

Re: Woo Woo! *LINK*

#43

My Pop said

Ron in Kokomo

95% of the public cannot tell the difference between quality furniture and "prettied up" crap, and of the 5% remaining far less than half of them will pay for the difference.

I think he was right

Re: Woo Woo! *LINK*

#44

Re: My Pop said

david weaver

He's definitely right.

I either pay for quality 100% or garbage. I won't wade around in the middle price range of crap that is more stylish looking. Of course, I don't have enough money to have 100% quality all the way around for everything.

Re: Woo Woo! *LINK*

#46

Re: Will you be at IWF-Atlanta?

Mark Hennebury

Much as i would like to, I dont plan on going,why?

Re: Woo Woo! *LINK*

#47

Re: Ah... I see where you're coming from

TomD

I would pay that for a tool in a heartbeat if I was in production. I have a few tools that cost that much in my shop, and I am not.

I think it is significant that these tools sell well in Germany. The land of continued wood working education, and high quality tool manufacture. The NA market is still flogging power saws that are 100 year old in design. There is a shortage of sophisticated buyers and workers over here.

Re: Woo Woo! *LINK*

#48

Moses Yoder

Re: My Pop said

Moses Yoder

Sounds like your pop was a wise man. I wondered what percentage of the population I was working for, looks like maybe 2.5%. We recently quoted a job where the customer said we were $50,000 higher than the next bid, and they ended up buying our cabinets mainly because the salesperson exhibited expertise in his knowledge of cabinetry.

Re: Woo Woo! *LINK*

#49

Why I like Schwarz

roninkokomo

One of the major reasons that I resonate so well with Chris Schwarz is his strong urging to make something and break the chain of mass produced throw away crap. I really do believe that a lot of woodworkers are challenged in the aesthetics department, but in terms of structural integrity, even most newbies will make better product than mid range furniture that you buy in stores.

I remember taking a class with Mike Speas once and he said, "you guys make stuff that will last 400 years, why don't you work on making it so people will want to keep it for 400 years" :)

. I recognize my own limitations here. It is one of the reasons that the rectilinear Shaker and Arts and Crafts pieces call out to me. I am trying to stretch a little