New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Woo Woo! *LINK*

Posts

Woo Woo! *LINK*

#1

David Barnett

Woo Woo! *LINK*

David Barnett

So color me philistine, but...

Design Milk gushed:

"Crafted from sustainably harvested hardwoods and finished with hand rubbed oils, each piece is lovingly made with a deep knowledge and understanding of the wood being used. I could regurgitate his gushing bio but honestly the proof is in the pudding ..."


Christian Woo angled steel based dining table

Re: Woo Woo! *LINK*

#2

What does sustainable mean?..

david weaver

...does it mean that it's second growth wood of questionable density and really widely spaced growth rings?

Re: Woo Woo! *LINK*

#3

David Barnett

Could be

David Barnett

But maybe it means if someone buys this table, there's plenty more what that came from.

Re: Woo Woo! *LINK*

#4

Re: Could be

david weaver

Looking at the table and the price, I'd say it looks like a sustainable business :)

At least if there are buyers.

Re: Woo Woo! *LINK*

#5

Re: Could be

Mark Hennebury

This is interesting that you bring this up: although it is both pathetic and funny, it is also quite serious.

In industrial products there are grades, specifications ,and reams of data to differentiate quality levels.So customs can order what grade they want and pay accordingly.

The problem with making furniture is that it is made for the general public and they cant tell the difference. There is no grading system, so the best bullshitter wins. The guys that do the worst work will often have the best websites and they wax eloquent about how great their work is using all the key buzzwords. The public buys on presentation, promotion, brand name, reputation, fashion etc. not knowledge! That is largely our fault, knowledge is our department and we should have some way to expose these slugs for what they are. We should have a peer generated grading system, maybe a five star rating like restaurants.Where you would have to have the work evaluated and rated every so many years to attain and maintain you star rating. That way the public can buy what level of quality they want and expect to pay for what its worth.

Re: Woo Woo! *LINK*

#6

Ellis Walentine

Now isn't that an interesting idea

Ellis Walentine

Peer review for designer furniture. Hmm.

Ellis

Re: Woo Woo! *LINK*

#7

Re: Peer?

TomD

There has to be another word for what is happening when a tire manufacturer reviews food. Maybe for fast food... :)

Re: Woo Woo! *LINK*

#8

Re: Woo Woo!

TomD

Made me think when I first saw it, that if he could make that hold together it might be worth the money. :)

But I guess he got fully in touch with his material and scabbed it all to metal.

Re: Woo Woo! *LINK*

#9

Re: Use of the word bespoke ....

david weaver

In the pacific northwest is bizarre. Is there a big UK influence in vancouver? I've never seen it used outside of England, but when I read the "about" from that place, they look like their underpants are a bit tight as seriously as they take thesmelves.

Re: Woo Woo! *LINK*

#10

Re: the oversell..

david weaver

.. a friend of mine, a while ago, was seriously considering a change of profession, contingent on his ability to find someone who would buy his stuff.

What he wanted to do was make ultra-precise woodworking stuff, or perhaps tools if he could figure out something to sell.

I told him that if he wanted to make money selling stuff made out of wood, that he was going in the wrong direction....that instead, he needed to figure out how to get his work categorized as artwork (where you can peddle any kind of BS you want, because a plain table with a few metal fixtures is "art" then and not woodworking that can be compared by feature to other competent woodworking).

Making furniture and tools for someone who is absolutely nuts about 10 thousandths of an inch is a good way to be hungry, especially when they have high income wants and demands.

He dropped that idea, he's not capable of bloviating BS about something and fishing it off on someone unsuspecting.

Re: Woo Woo! *LINK*

#11

Re: the oversell..

mark Hennebury

I made furniture for a "living" for 25 years and it seemed to me that the better work I did the less I got paid. Doing joinery was like sticking hundred dollar bills in the joints, it cost me a fortune. I am not sure if that can ever change, maybe the business of woodworking is best left to businessmen and fine woodworking is best as a hobby. As a business you only have to do enough to get your customers to give you the check, any more and you leave money on the table. I started off doing handcut joinery then progressed through many machines to find machines that did the best work the most efficient way, but at the end of the day I could have made a lot more money doing a lot less with just screws, dowels, plugs and a good finish. The reality is the joinery was done for me, not my customers. It would be nice to think that there was some grading system that raised the level and understanding on the trade, that provided incentive and reward to those who put in the effort and made the grade. I understand that there are competitions and there are famous woodworkers that make good money, but there are many many more great woodworkers that struggle to survive. There are also a lot of terribly bad woodworkers that don't know squat about their trade and they mingle amongst the good ones indistinguishable to the public.

Would it not be something for all to aspire to, to finally "make the grade" and have a five star rating posted on your workshop. A proud moment for all the years of hard work and study.

Re: Woo Woo! *LINK*

#12

Re: Woo Woo!

Kees

Well, all the hyperbole set aside, I do like the design.

Designing something that pleases the eye and at the same is still strong enough and functional, isn't easy. You could always go back to the traditional styles of course. But when you want to make something truly new, that's another thing all together. At the moment I am trying to design a table along modern lines, but I'm not happy yet.

Re: Woo Woo! *LINK*

#13

David Barnett

Bespoke sandwiches on artisan bread

David Barnett

David Weaver on Vancouver: "...they look like their underpants are a bit tight as seriously as they take thesmelves."

Diction (choice of words, not how they're pronounced) gets ever stretchier these days. I can understand Savile Row shoes hand stretched to lasts carved for one particular person's feet are "bespoke", or that an individually fit prosthesis might be termed "bespoke", and I can even accept (less comfortably) a chair made to one's individual body measurements as "bespoke", but when a clerk calls a customer's choice of ready-made designer frames fitted with their eyeglass prescription "bespoke", or when "bespoke" extends to deciding from a menu to have Ammerländer over Westphalian Schinken on one's brochen, the word has lost its meaning.

As for Vancouverites, I'm just glad to learn they actually wear underpants.

Re: Woo Woo! *LINK*

#14

David Barnett

Hyperbole set aside, I agree with you

David Barnett

Although I'd be hard-pressed not to find something derivative about it. But it is clean.

Even the pricing wouldn't offend me if the top hadn't been elevated by considerably more than the legs.

Re: Woo Woo! *LINK*

#15

David Barnett

Re: Woo Woo!

David Barnett

It's good to get in touch with your material. It can apparently add thousands to the asking price.

I've got a log of hard maple I've long neglected, but seeing the error of my ways, I will name him George, and I will hug him, and pet him, and squeeze him.

Re: Woo Woo! *LINK*

#16

David Barnett

How about a Design Czar!

David Barnett

I rather still like voting with our dollars over having things graded by concensus of a design panel. Yikes! Sounds like something Finland would do if they haven't already. I can think of nothing worse than artists and designers deciding on the value of art and design.

Re: Woo Woo! *LINK*

#17

Re: How about a Design Czar!

mark Hennebury

Good furniture is far more than artistic design, it consists of structural engineering based on knowledge of wood structure and engineering principles, it requires precision cut and fitted parts etc. I never mentioned anything about "artists and designers deciding on the value of art and design." What i said was that I thought it might be important to be able to determine the quality of work. Those are things are measurable. I have no interest in someones opinion as to whether or not they like the look of it or for them to determine the price. What I spoke of was not artists and designers at all, I spoke of furniture makers setting up a grading system to establish standards and give credibility and consistency to the trade. The only people that i see suffering from this are those who do bad work and are a disservice to the trade, and a disservice to those that have worked hard to attain a high standard of knowledge and quality.

Re: Woo Woo! *LINK*

#18

Re: How about a Design Czar!

mark Hennebury

You may like voting with your dollars, but you probably would be able to better decide on what was good furniture and what wasn't. I am sure that a lot of people on this website can upon close inspection determine good from bad furniture, but then again most on this website don't buy furniture but rather make it themselves. The general public don't have the same background to make that determination.

Re: Woo Woo! *LINK*

#19

Because "they" said it is so . . .

steve mackay

In reading that piece I would be hard pressed to think of a "buzz word" they missed.

If "they" say something is stylish, inovative, sustainable, hand rubbed or "art", well, it must be so.

Kinda looks like a high school shop project that was running out of time and the legs weren't on yet. Forget a joint, theres some angle iron outside in the bin. If I call it "art" it'll be OK.

Re: Woo Woo! *LINK*

#20

David Barnett

I'm always queasy...

David Barnett

...when I encounter regulatory urges, or those who wish to organize for the good or for that matter, for anything more agenda-laden than fellowship or shared interests such as woodworking.

"...knowledge is our department and we should have some way to expose these slugs for what they are. We should have a peer generated grading system..."

I think such urges should invariably be resisted, but while this is my personal aversion, it also begins to skirt issues politic, so I'll say no more here. :)

Re: Woo Woo! *LINK*

#21

David Barnett

I prefer to decide for myself...

David Barnett

...and I prefer others to decide for themselves, too.

"The general public don't have the same background to make that determination."

Maybe not. But do they really need someone else; a regulatory agency or industry group or peer review panel or bureaucracy or any other body who supposedly knows better to determine that for them? I just don't see a need for a furniture nanny.

Re: Woo Woo! *LINK*

#22

Re: I prefer to decide for myself...

Mark Hennebury

I have no interest in any regulatory control either, I think that you, me and everyone should make their own choices, just saying it would be nice to know what we are choosing from.

Re: Woo Woo! *LINK*

#23

David Barnett

True enough, in that context

David Barnett

A few years ago I had a contractor ask about an unusual dining table to which he and his wife were strongly attracted. It was made by a famous high-end company and sold exclusively through the interior trades. They wanted to know what I thought, aesthetically and structurally, as it had a highly dissonant angularity to the base. I immediately understood the thick wooden leg elements to be incapable of standalone support, and sure enough, they were reinforced artfully with steel, making the whole thing possible. While it wasn't my design aesthetic, I gave it a go-ahead.

Unfortunately, knock-offs soon appeared without the same structural soundness and were blithely sold to unsuspecting and unsophisticated buyers who assumed they were responsibly made.

It's a squirrely problem and too often people get taken in. And while there are after-the-fact legal remedies, the outcomes are usually less than satisfactory. Perhaps a reasonable course is to promote some sort of industry certification or seal, something non-binding, if you will. I would find this more palatable personally. It's hard to cover the breadth of furniture buying, of course. One man's Ikea is another man's junk, and so on. Some persons are lucky to have someone who knows they can ask.

But people fall for all manner of gimmicks and approaches, from the artsy-touchy-feely "deep knowledge and understanding of the wood" buncombe to often less than truthful green-and-sustainable ploys to "this is made from only AAA-grade particle board with the best vinylized wood-grain covering" hucksterism. It's hard to educate that price is not always a determinant of quality, that is, unless it's too low.

Imperfect? Absolutely. But I prefer the up-to-the-buyer-not-to-get-taken haphazardness with all its pitfalls to protectionist intervention. But that's just me.

Re: Woo Woo! *LINK*

#24

Ellis Walentine

I'm with you


Re: Woo Woo! *LINK*

#25

David Barnett

I should clarify

David Barnett

I offered this not in derogation or disdain for Loo's designs, which I sometimes like very much, nor his prices, but for Design Milk's slobbering, emetic quotation in the original post.