New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Odds and ends: cast iron, cheap diamond, scrapers

Posts

Re: Odds and ends: cast iron, cheap diamond, scrapers

#26

Re: I'm guessing you unintentionally...

Charles

Clearly, if one brings steel into the shop that can't be cut by the honing equipment they have in place then all this hooray and who shot John makes sense. I guess.

I've polished with diamonds before. It made the steel nice and shiny and I probably got an extra ten minutes out of the average edge. That didn't impress me much and frankly I enjoy stopping ten minutes early and taking a breather.

Re: Odds and ends: cast iron, cheap diamond, scrapers

#27

Re: Odds and ends: cast iron, cheap diamond, scrap

Charles

My guess would be a rolling of the eyes.

Re: Odds and ends: cast iron, cheap diamond, scrapers

#28

Re: Charles, you still don't get it

david weaver

If I look at the argument here, Bill's making more sense.

He's talking about sharpening with about $60 of gear. It's not necessarily about refinement, it's about cheap and capable. He's going to end up with a sharper edge, faster, and probably cheaper.

I guess you could get a medium india and a translucent stone for $60, but you wouldn't have the pick of much good, and you'd be limiting yourself then.

Charles, it's starting to look like you decided you're going to be right regardless of the facts. And tage won't save you, because a coticule is a pretty fine stone, and can't even be part of the discussion due to the price of them.

Re: Odds and ends: cast iron, cheap diamond, scrapers

#29

David Barnett

Fair enough...

David Barnett

... as long as you leave room for others to choose and form their own opinion, I have no quibble. My experience differs markedly, but to each his own.

Re: Odds and ends: cast iron, cheap diamond, scrapers

#30

Re: more on cast iron

Mark Hennebury

I often sharpened my supersurfacer and handplane blades on my cast iron jointer table (before i had a straight knife grinder) does quite a nice job with a bit of lapping paste on it.

Re: Odds and ends: cast iron, cheap diamond, scrapers

#31

Hard to beat that one for pragmatic and inexpensiv