New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Odds and ends: cast iron, cheap diamond, scrapers

Posts

Odds and ends: cast iron, cheap diamond, scrapers

#1

David Barnett

Odds and ends: cast iron, cheap diamond, scrapers

David Barnett

I know I promised at least two persons a couple weeks back I'd post where to buy cast iron for making laps and cheap diamond. Rather than go through my email backlog, let me just post it here before I put it off any longer.

If you're not going to look for scrap cast iron, new will cost you more, but it's handier for some folks to just order it and get going.

I suggest if you want just one lap big enough to do most sharpening work, a 6" diameter x 1" thick round will work nicely for freehand honing. For those who simply must use a guide, a rectangular lap is more what you'd want, but the following source only carries 24" long plate. This means you'd end up with three 8" x 4" laps, or two very nice 12" x 4" laps. Problem is, you're out more money initially, may end up with one or two extra laps, and if you should be unhappy with diamond on iron (you won't be), you'll have spent more than you probably intended to try out the process.

A straddle might be to purchase an 8" diameter round and work with that, as most who use honing guides are accustomed to 8" long stones, so this shouldn't present a problem.

The price for 6" or 8" diameter rounds will run $23.81 and $37.58, respectively.

The catch? These aren't laps. Not yet. They come rough sawn to to 1" thickness from a 6" or 8" rod. You'll have to flatten them yourself or have them flattened. If you know a machinist or can locate a machine shop who will help you grind your iron blank flat, you're ready to go. If not, you can do it yourself with very simple hand tools and some time and effort. This is how I flattened mine and I found it entirely enjoyable. It's a good way to flatten iron plane soles, too. Really, you can do this.

The first thing you'll need is a large file to take down the highest spots and work below the saw marks. The edges of these rounds or rectangles will get sharp, so break the edges frequently with the file as you progress. You can also wear Kevlar gloves, which are cheap and do a good job of protecting you. After getting your blank roughly flat, checking with a straight edge or ruler, you'll move on to scraping.

For scraping, you'll need three things; a flat reference surface such as a cheap granite surface plate or slab of glass, a tube of thick oil paint (Prussian blue is traditional, Dykem is a machinist's brand name), and a machinist's scraper, which you'll learn more about later. By the way, if you want to scrape both sides you could have a double lap although I don't recommend it to start. Contamination can become an issue, so begin with one lapping surface and one diamond grit (14,000).

As I said in one of my email replies, I won't be teaching you to how to scrape but I will give you some sources that should do that.

Again, my suggestion is to go with a round blank for sharpening. I use 6" rounds myself. If you intend to flatten wide plane blades, you'll probably want to go with 8" round or rectangular, and ideally, 12" laps. But for a 6" round lap, if you order from these links to MSC, you'd need:

6" cast iron round at $23.81

http://www1.mscdirect.com/CGI/NNSRIT2?PMPXNO=1986352&PMTERM=63379879

Size 8 machinist's scraper (13" overall) at $5.92

http://www1.mscdirect.com/CGI/NNSRIT2?PMPXNO=1747076&PMTERM=05844154

and a tube of Dykem Hi-Spot Blue at $7.05

http://www1.mscdirect.com/CGI/NNSRIT2?PMPXNO=1658978&PMTERM=00264101

Alternatively, you could substitute:

8" cast iron round at $37.58

http://www1.mscdirect.com/CGI/NNSRIT2?PMPXNO=1986353&PMTERM=63379887

...or a 3/8" thick 4" wide by 24" long cast iron plate at $116.46

http://www1.mscdirect.com/CGI/NNSRIT2?PMPXNO=1986373&PMTERM=63380083

...which would give you three 8" x 4" plates at $38.82 each, or two 12" x 4" plates at $58.23 each.

Diamond compound is expensive from MSC, a 5-gram syringe of 14,000-grit medium concentration at $18.35 each. To some, it may be more convenient to order everything from one supplier, so here's the link.

http://www1.mscdirect.com/CGI/NNSRIT2?PMPXNO=1745043&PMTERM=05652441

Cheaper is diamond from Daniel Lopacki, with any 5-gram syringe costing $5.95 each, in 360, 600, 1200, 3000, 14000, 50000 grits.

http://www.lopacki.com/polishes/

Kevlar gloves with rubber palms for secure grip such as these can be had for under $10.

http://www1.mscdirect.com/CGI/NNSRIT2?PMPXNO=20837399&PMTERM=84491208

Basic instruction.

http://www.schsm.org/SCRAPING.pdf

http://www.oocities.org/plybench/scrape_posts.html

Lastly, keep in mind shipping is apt to be non-trivial when cast iron is involved.

Hope this helps.

Re: Odds and ends: cast iron, cheap diamond, scrapers

#2

Thanks David, a question

Denis Chenard in Ottawa

Lots of info here, much appreciate your taking your time to post this :)

Question, is the Lopaki paste oil- or water-based? Is one better than the other? Is there a risk of developing rust on the plate if using water-based paste?

Thansk again!

DC

Re: Odds and ends: cast iron, cheap diamond, scrapers

#3

craigd

Re: Thanks David, a question

craigd

I have the Lopaki diamond pastes and use mineral spirits to thin them so I assume they are oil based. Rust hasn't been an issue.

Re: Odds and ends: cast iron, cheap diamond, scrapers

#4

You're An Enormous Help, David.


Re: Odds and ends: cast iron, cheap diamond, scrapers

#5

David Barnett

You're welcome, Denis.

David Barnett

As Craig said, they're oil based, which I've always preferred. I just have never had any use for water based diamond pastes, especially at the prices some charge for them. Most of my pastes are vegetable based (olive and other) unless I mix my own for higher diamond concentrations, where I use kaolin with petroleum jelly.

Re: Odds and ends: cast iron, cheap diamond, scrapers

#6

David Barnett

More for folks new to scraping ... *LINK*

David Barnett

... who may've missed this thread from 2011, here are a few more resources that go into greater depth on scraping history and technique.

You don't need to read these before you scrape your iron into a lap, however, so don't get overwhelmed or sidetracked. They're simply here for anyone who wants to know more.

At any rate, to give you a feel for it now, here's three videos that show hand scraping.

http://tinyurl.com/ImantsGorbants

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PQEUScJvRNU

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CpbVLNqC5fw


So you've got a slab of iron. Now what? *LINK*

Re: Odds and ends: cast iron, cheap diamond, scrapers

#7

Re: Odds and ends: cast iron, cheap diamond, scrap

Charles

One wishes Tage Frid were alive to respond to this.

Re: Odds and ends: cast iron, cheap diamond, scrapers

#8

Re: Odds and ends: cast iron, cheap diamond, scrap

TomD

Frid? How so?

Re: Odds and ends: cast iron, cheap diamond, scrapers

#9

Re: What did he say?

David Weaver

Two belt sanders? Something like that?

Re: Odds and ends: cast iron, cheap diamond, scrapers

#10

more on cast iron

Bill Tindall

Cast iron is often fabricated into structural shapes by continuously casting. If 6 x 6" bar stock is needed a 6 x 6" rod is extruded from the melted cast iron and the rod cut to length. We were told that thin bars can not be cast. The thinnest we could find manufactured was 1.25". We bought 2 .25" x 1.25" x 12" ( a common cast size) pieces from a metal supply business and had a machine shop saw them in half to yield a 1/2" plate, and then Blanchard grind them. Because the plates are best used with blades skewed the narrow plates are no a disadvantage for wider plane blades and hand held sharpening.

Re: Odds and ends: cast iron, cheap diamond, scrapers

#11

Re: What did he say?

Charles

If I knew as much about woodworking as you guys know about metal I'd be set.

Re: Odds and ends: cast iron, cheap diamond, scrapers

#12

David Barnett

It's not exclusionary, Charles, ...

David Barnett

... complementary even. Consider this; most of us on Wood Central who talk about metalworking knew a hell of a lot more about woodworking. We 'evolved', in today's parlance.

Metal; it's what woodworking tools are made of! :)

Re: Odds and ends: cast iron, cheap diamond, scrapers

#13

Re: I think...

David Weaver

... that might've been an answer to a different question.

Didn't tage frid say something about using two sanders or something? Or a sander and a loaded belt?

Re: Odds and ends: cast iron, cheap diamond, scrapers

#14

Re: It's not exclusionary, Charles, ...

Charles

I understand. I meant my comment quite literally. There's so much to know and learn about woodworking I cannot fathom the duality of adding all the intricacies of metallurgy to the task. I appreciate what metals and steels do for me in the shop but I guess I'm just 'trusting Jesus' as it were, just leaving it all to the manufacturers to put out a reasonably serviceable product.

Re: Odds and ends: cast iron, cheap diamond, scrapers

#15

Re: I think...

Charles

He used a sander to produce an intersection of two planes, i.e. a 'sharp edge' He polished with Belgian waterstones as he saw fit.

Re: Odds and ends: cast iron, cheap diamond, scrapers

#16

Re: It's not exclusionary, Charles, ...

Charles

Fill in the gaps for me - we're now, in essence, machining our own surface plates in order to act as a backer for lapping with diamond paste, right? Is that what all of this is about?

Re: Odds and ends: cast iron, cheap diamond, scrapers

#17

David Barnett

Not exactly. Close. But there are distinctions.

David Barnett

"Fill in the gaps for me - we're now, in essence, machining our own surface plates in order to act as a backer for lapping with diamond paste, right? Is that what all of this is about?"

Yes. And no.

We're a long way from making a surface plate, which generally requires a much flatter surface than a lap referenced off of a surface plate.

Iron surface plates have stability issues that require careful design, casting and fabrication, quality control, controlled seasoning of the iron (webbed or solid), calibration and maintenence to flatness and surface standards, often requiring optical flats. You wouldn't charge the surface of your iron surface plate with diamond grit unless you didn't want it for a surface plate any longer.

No, we're just flattening a piece of cast gray iron into a lap; something flat to hold diamond really well, using a surface plate or other flat reference surface to expose the distribution of high points as we refine the lap surface. Once done, it can be used to further flatten plane blade and chisel backs with a coarser grit of diamond or other hard, blocky abrasive, or more for our everyday sharpening purposes, charged with fine diamond grit to quickly hone plane blade and chisel edges to an acceptable degree of sharpness.

Our reason to scrape iron, whether repurposed, scrap, or commercial stock, is mainly to, for whatever reason, not engage a machinist with a surface grinder to do that work for us. Also, scraping has other uses around the woodworker's shop, such as flattening iron plane soles, improving the fit of frog to plane body, and occasionally to true or restore ways, tables and fences on woodworking machines. And if you find it enjoyable, you can make really flat, accurate straightedges, too.

It's not for everyone, obviously, but adds another skill to our toolkit, is terribly cheap, especially if you make your scraper from an old file and have a tube of oil paint or even lipstick lying about, and means you don't have to go outside your shop to a machinist to do things for you.

Bill Tindall has done that very thing; engaged a machine shop and is very satisfied with his results. This is the fastest, most direct way to get your plate flat. Even so, I'm apt to scrape what comes from the surface grinder, but that's just me. Some have had less satisfactory experiences with machine shops. One highly skilled woodworking teacher had plane soles and sides ground unacceptably thin. Sometimes it's hard to get a machine shop to bother with woodworking tools for a reasonable price, or at all, for that matter. So under these circumstances, scraping is a viable workaround.

You may not realize that lapping plates have been used for sharpening woodworking hand tools for years, not a new thing ("we're now"). Harris made a lapping kit for woodworkers that gained a following a couple decades back. I encountered it during my first woodworking school experience and loved how fast a blade got flat with SiC and sharp with diamond paste. With the advent of truly cheap industrial diamond, lapping has become more popular for putting that final edge on a blade, handling the toughest, hardest tool steels with ease.

By the way, one woodworker/designer who studied under Tage Frid and Seth Stem at RISD swore by the Harris System. No, not Frid's style. It's my understanding that Frid was far more focused on instilling pragmatic business survival practices in his students than fussing about details as to how one got something done. You got it done. Period.

So, to answer your original question, no, we're not making surface plates, won't be using our laps as reference surfaces other than to flatten a blade face (or back) and get a good edge. We're making iron laps as an optimal substrate for diamond sharpening. Cheap, doesn't take long, is kind of fun, and works really well.

"Metalworking in the cause of woodworking is no vice!"
(My apologies to Barry Goldwater)

Re: Odds and ends: cast iron, cheap diamond, scrapers

#18

David Barnett

Again, it's not exclusionary, Charles, ...

David Barnett

"There's so much to know and learn about woodworking I cannot fathom the duality of adding all the intricacies of metallurgy to the task."

Perhaps from hubris, perhaps from how I learn or how long I've been at it, but there's little I need to or wish to know about woodworking these days. There is certainly plenty I don't know but little remaining that I care to learn. To some that may sound arrogant, but to me it's simply so. I have all the tools I'll ever need, a good place to use them and can make anything I wish. Will I cut perfect dovetails after a couple years of not doing so? No. But a little practice and I'm back in the game.

So I'm saying that once you get where you need to be in one craft, you can move to another, and another. For me, woodworking came after hand bookbinding, gilding, document restoration, and other book arts. No, I'm not some flittering dilletante or part-time poseur. I simply don't buy into jack-of-all-master-of-none limited thinking. Maybe that's for some, just not for me.

Besides, what you bring from one craft to another can reap benefits. I enjoy combining wood, metal, glass, leathers, gems and other materials into my work. For example, I like to cover wood furniture in parchment, vellum, or shagreen (book arts + woodworking). Even if you only add some rudimentary metalworking skills to your woodworking, you can design and form your own unique and satisfying hardware or make decent tools tailored to your needs. So go ahead, "fathom the duality". You might surprise yourself. Works for me.

Re: Odds and ends: cast iron, cheap diamond, scrapers

#19

Re: Again, it's not exclusionary, Charles, ...

Charles

It is exclusionary if one's time is not unlimited. Time has to be spent either woodworking or machining surface plates. Or spent talking about it on these forums, like you and I are now.

Still wondering how all the great woodworking of the past got done with nothing but an old rag-wrapped oilstone or two kept in a bucket.

Now, we need half micron diamond paste and surface plates that we machine ourselves?

Have fun with it!

Re: Odds and ends: cast iron, cheap diamond, scrapers

#20

David Barnett

Yeah, I thought so.     


Re: Odds and ends: cast iron, cheap diamond, scrapers

#21

Re: Again, it's not exclusionary, Charles, ...

David Weaver

Not all, Charles. As you've pointed out, a lot got done with coticules, japanese waterstones (which were available in the west more than a hundred years ago), thuringians, welsh slate, silk stones and all manners of fine natural stones from europe and asia.

I would not be surprised if the finest woodworkers had access to edges as fine as any that we're used to.

This goes on with the razor forum, too, where folks claim that people did more with less 100+ years ago, but when you actually get a hold of the barbering texts and trade guides, they say stuff like for professionals to avoid anything other than thuringians and fine japanese waterstones.

And old catalogs are filled with fine leathers for strops, and compounds to put in them.

Chasing the edge isn't new.

Re: Odds and ends: cast iron, cheap diamond, scrapers

#22

Re: Not exactly. Close. But there are distinctions

Charles

I appreciate your thoroughness and thoughtfulness though I must admit the whole exercise seems to me to be a bit far removed from what is necessary to get an edge ready for woodworking. Theoretically, I suppose, there is not end to the amount of polish that can result from the compulsive and obsessive rubbing of steel on ever more highly engineered media.

The compounds keep getting finer, the substrates a little flatter. At some point, enough should be enough. The alternative seems to be an ongoing and never ending investment of both time and money into sharpening gear and consumables like diamond paste and abrasive sheets in an array of grit measured in microns (in the "old" days it was Sorby diamond slurry in an aerosol can, remember that?) Chasing the sharpening tail is as old as the craft itself. I think everybody has done it at one point. Most simply tire of it.

Re: Odds and ends: cast iron, cheap diamond, scrapers

#23

Charles, you still don't get it

Bill Tindall

There is no one on this Forum more pragmatic than I am and I use diamonds. I didn't arrive here because it was the cool thing to do, or provided the highest degree of edge refinement. It was simply the easiest and cheapest. If you don't understand that diamond sharpening is easy and cheap David and I need to improve our communication skills, or you need to advocate what is cheaper and easier, or what ever metric you think important so we can compare.

How I got there:

Initially I used high quality oil stones. Oil stones are too slow for typical tools and uselessly slow for my CPM 3V tools.

Then I used abrasive sheets on glass- Cheap and effective and it is where I recommend beginners to begin. But abrasive life is short and I needed a jig to be effective across the several grits involved.

Then I tried the combination of grinder, fixed diamond plate and loose diamond on cast iron. Cheap, easy, lightning fast and I can free hand easily, not messy.

I have never tried water stones. They appear to be expensive, fiddly to keep flat and involve water which I don't have in the shop. If you have water stones and water and are satisfied I would not recommend trying anything else

Re: Odds and ends: cast iron, cheap diamond, scrapers

#24

David Barnett

I'm guessing you unintentionally... *LINK*

David Barnett

...stepped into this minefield. :)

I'm also guessing you weren't following the discussions on this subject that proceeded this current thread -- a subject nearly beat to death over the last few years and especially these last two, so your opinion is largely water under the bridge for those who've participated in this topic. Check the archives. You'll find plenty.

That said, I'd rather clarify now than wait for misunderstandings to develop or resurface, so please let me address your misgivings in a brief, albeit somewhat terse manner, as patience wears thin, more so about the subject than your coming late to it.

The point was never to supplant the old with the new, to say older technologies and methods were not good enough for older steels, but that newer technologies offered some advantages for newer, harder and tougher steels. Additional advantages were also presented, such as cost and speed.

If one already has oil or water stones that work for the steels from which their tools are made, there is no advantage or reason to change. For others using newer powder steels, different metallurigies altogether, and for those starting out who've not already invested in sharpening equipment, diamond sharpening is worth considering. Nothing more, nothing less. And you know, just because woodworkers from a different era produced superb work doesn't mean improvements aren't advantageous.

There were those who vociferously resisted such changes, but diamond has now become firmly ensconced as a viable and affordable medium and is now more widely available than ever. Misinformation and arguments have been met and the viability of diamond sharpening has prevailed, so I, for one, am unable to appreciate your arguments and attitudes to the contrary.

"At some point, enough should be enough. The alternative seems to be an ongoing and never ending investment of both time and money into sharpening gear and consumables ... "

I don't disagree. There are diminishing returns when one gets into the sub-micron diamond particle sizes. But the alternative is not as you say, "...an ongoing and never ending investment of both time and money...". Firstly, no one is advocating for woodworkers to migrate from the sharpening systems they already own unless these fall short where newer tool steels are involved, and secondly, diamond is in most cases cheaper than quality non-diamond solutions.

So there really is no valid argument against diamond other than it's not the way we used to do things, and again, no one is saying not to do things in the manner to which you are accustomed. So if you don't need diamond, fine, but don't be so quick to judge others who may not have stopped where you apparently have ("Most simply tire of it.").

I don't intend to be flippant, but I have to ask, if the above stance is unsatisfactory, "what's it to you?"

Consider, in your original response you mentioned Tage Frid. Frid famously sharpened on his belt sander (more to make a point than anything else). Why wouldn't your argument for rag-wrapped stones in a bucket apply to him? And really, who cares how Tage Frid sharpened his tools? You never did answer TomD's "How so?". I'll guess we'll never know.

In your last response to me, you said:

"It is exclusionary if one's time is not unlimited. Time has to be spent either woodworking or machining surface plates."

Well, your time management issues are your own. I can appreciate the difficulties involved, however, but they're personal and less than germane to the validity of non-traditional sharpening technologies. I did try to differentiate between laps and surface plates but apparently the distinction was lost on you. Also, I never advocated for "machining surface plates"; only flattening laps by hand.

"Now, we need half micron diamond paste and surface plates that we machine ourselves?"

No one said this. I surely didn't. Perhaps you're more confused than ingenuine, as this would make a fairly refutable 'straw man' rhetorical argument. And again, I never advocated for "machining surface plates"; only flattening laps by hand.

If you have remaining issues regarding diamond sharpening, really feel you have something to add, perhaps you could start a separate thread, as this was merely intended as a resource for those who wished to acquire a lap for diamond sharpening, not to argue on the efficacy of diamond for sharpening, which, as you can see, has become something of a "ho-hum" around here.


About diamond plates, same goes for lapping

Re: Odds and ends: cast iron, cheap diamond, scrapers

#25

Re: Charles, you still don't get it

Charles

I actually don't think you get it.

I have you beat, Bill. I've used diamonds out of an aerosol can, diamond stones, waterstones, sandpaper on glass, oilstones, the gamut. I look back on all of this (my search for a 'better way') as the grab-ass phase of my woodworking. Boy and how. I just knew every problem I ever had in the shop was going to be solved by a more polished cutting edge. I was sure my edges were the issue holding me back. 'Twas wrong.

The additional refinement doesn't result in anything except a slightly longer time between honings. I'm quite sure of it.