New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Planing with the capiron close

Posts

Re: Planing with the capiron close

#26

Re: Nice

Kees

"Nice contrast and way to delineate and celebrate moving from one area of your home to another"

I can relate to that. Often I only see the faults in my work, but sometimes you just hit the bullseye and can enjoy it for what it is. That's when it becomes a small feast just stepping over your own home made door sill.

Re: Planing with the capiron close

#27

Re: What are the limitations..

david weaver

Pam, you shouldn't even bother to involve yourself with this, because it's not going to become a post that gets directed toward japanese planes.

A quote of peter ross was made by warren (not trying to put you on the spot, warren) not very long ago at all that he suspected thin irons were replaced by thicker irons due to lack of craftsman skill.

You have really gone over the top lately jumping in on discussions and stating things that are flatly wrong.

Perhaps you could've instead just said "when did someone say thick irons were a demonstration of lack of skill?"

Try something like that next time.

Re: Planing with the capiron close

#28

Re: Choking

Kees

That's a good idea Charles, filing the mouth in a 15 degree angle, so I won't need to open the mouth, just give the shavings a bit more room.

Re: Planing with the capiron close

#29

Re: What are the limitations..

Pam Niedermayer

And how about your post? Perhaps you should have said simply that everyone who'd ever advocated any approach to better planing was unskilled. I reserve the right to play in this ground; and I will call out and label intentionally stupid remarks.

Pam

Re: Planing with the capiron close

#30

Re: Planing with the capiron close

Kees

Thanks for the tip David. I'm not sure if I am ready to BUY anything yet. But I will keep it in mind.

Re: Planing with the capiron close

#31

Re: What are the limitations..

david weaver

I guess no matter how little sense your responses make, or what lengths you'll go to to avoid whether or not they're correct, I'll just ignore them entirely from now on. I can't see how that would be suboptimal, especially in regard to the quality of the content on the board, which is foremost.

Re: Planing with the capiron close

#32

Re: Planing with the capiron close

david weaver

By all means, if you don't want to buy something, there's no functional argument that probably any of us would have to buy anything to do or improve our work :)

At least not an honest functional argument :b

Re: Planing with the capiron close

#33

Re: Planing with the capiron close

david weaver

Muji's ebony copy of the continental smoother was faithful to that (it appears to be NLA), except everything is fixed in it and the iron feels like it's made of glass and gum at the same time (hard as glass, tough as gum on sharpening stones).

The most bizarre change is the central location of the mouth. It's a plane, as you say, that you put it on wood and let it go. If you try to lean down onto it, you'll get the sensation that you're going to go right past it, because the mouth is behind.

It's a slick light-feeling plane where if you just let it go, it will take a nice heavy smoother shaving with little effort. It would make a nice scrub in a version a half inch less wide.

I'll get a primus sometime.

Re: Planing with the capiron close

#34

Re: Choking

david weaver

In a panel plane that i assembled and one where I left only about 5 degrees of relief on the front of the mouth, I used this design - the shallow primary bevel and the very steep microbevel - with good effect.

It is a common pitch plane that previously had a (came with, at least) very rounded chipbreaker that couldn't have been used no matter the relief of the mouth because it was so steep.

I have limited options with the mouth, I could open it up another 5 degrees or so, but not more, because of interference from the bun when filing, but so far it's a trick that works great.

I have set the mouth (in making it) at just less than a hundredth and at common pitch in a heavy cut, it could still tear out (but not a lot). This kind of tearout is not necessarily problematic, but it does keep you from finishing the job with the panel plane, which is sometimes a nice thing to do.

At any rate, I'd suspect a lot of sloppy castings on common planes will not provide enough relief, just like that, to allow the shavings to feed. And this trick worked well on my panel plane to get it into a shape now where it will provide a very nice finished surface with a fairly heavy shaving, a virtue in the common furniture type stuff I have been building (I don't use a power planer).

However, if the mouth is already accurately set at 4 thousandths of an inch or so, someone will probably not need a tight set of the second iron to begin with.

the one page that included instruction (japan woodworker) said something along the lines of having a tiny steep bevel and a shallow primary bevel following it to break the chip, but then otherwise be out of the way so that the flow of the shaving is not impeded further. That sounds good, I guess, it helps with feeding more than planing force, I'd think - the work is all being done on the steep bevel of the second iron. Maybe I'm wrong.

I'm just happy that all of this has allowed me to step up my panel plane a notch without any further taping off of the bun and filing more relief.

Re: Planing with the capiron close

#35

Re: Choking

David Charlesworth

What I forgot to say earlier, is that a good scaled up drawing, can be very helpful for showing what is going on ! (Approximately 1 cm to 0.1mm).

David

Re: Planing with the capiron close

#36

craigd

Re: What are the limitations..

craigd

David asks

> ...what are the limitations of a standard bench plane?

For me, the limitations of "standard" Stanley bench plane is having to adjust it for different woods. For example, mine was working very nicely with maple and oak. Then I pulled some Cocobolo for an infill and constant clogging. Pulled out the single iron plane (which just happens to also be high angle) and sweet relief (and that plane also works great with maple and oak).

Re: Planing with the capiron close

#37

Re: Planing with the capiron close - more question

TomD

"for the older style cap irons, i like the japanese method of a shallow primary bevel and a very steep very small final bevel. Like a 25 degree primary and a very small 75-80 degree bevel to actually break the chips. It makes it easier for the plane to feed, and it's easier to set up."

That comes out of the SS tests for one thing. Of the blades I have, the hand made forged ones do not have that micro bevel, and the cheap stamped ones do. I have about a dozen with breakers, though I don't have the breakers on most of the planes, and can't find the box. It's there. But anyway, now I am looking at this stuff differently, but also wondering about the roll of the high and low bevels. My original thought was that they were differet methods of manufacture and that the shell like stamped ones did not have the shape for a low angle.

Just reviewed a few books, and Odate's shows the steep micro bevel in a drawing...

Re: Planing with the capiron close

#38

Re: Planing with the capiron close - more question

david weaver

that steep second bevel is probably not on the good quality second irons (and it's on none of mine, also) probably because the guy who puts the primary bevel on the iron at a big water wheel probably does the same to the second iron, as opposed to a machine cutting them out short of the edge like they do on the cheaper second irons.