New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Planing with the capiron close

Posts

Planing with the capiron close

#1

Planing with the capiron close

Kees

This weekend I have been making some door sills from wallnut (they look fantastic next to our new maple floor!). So I tried the trick "capiron very close to the edge". I ran into a bit of a problem though. Up till something like .3 .4 mm everything goes fine. But a tighter set immediately leads to a jammed mouth. I have a replacement blade from Ray Iles in this plane which is rather thick. And even with the frog pulled back as far as possible I still have that tiny mouth.

So I was planing with about .4mm (didn't really meassure). Fine shavings. It is not entirely free of tear out. Around a knot and on some ripples in the grain I see something that looks like tearout, but you can't really feel it. It is very shallow and easilly removed with a scraper. With the capiron set back further it tears a lot deeper!

It was also fun to play with an old woodie on some pine. The shavings shoot out vertically from the plane with the capiron rather close. Setting the capiron on the Stanley Bailey is easier though. Like David wrote, it's just a matter of tightening the screw halfway, then sliding the caprion forward using the reflection as a guide. Finally tighten the screw all the way down. Not difficult at all when you have good vision and a light source.

Re: Planing with the capiron close

#2

craigd

Re: Planing with the capiron close

craigd

You experience mirrors mine with Stanley Bailey planes. I tweaked 5 #3's and the closest I could get the cap iron was 1/32", at which point I got very nice results (maple and oak). Also, don't set the mouth too tight, it will clog.

Re: Planing with the capiron close

#3

I`m not getting it.

Bob Hackett

Here`s what I am not understanding; why are people taking what appears to be just a narrow band of selected info from this video and trying to apply it to a completely different situation where there are many completely different variables in play?

For example; did everyone regrind their chip breaker/shaving bender to the lead angle recommended in the video?

Did they cut off the leading part of the sole of the plane they are using that serves to compresses and limit the amount the wood that can potentially tear out?

Are you using the same type of wood and duplicating the feed rate used in the video?

There is no "mouth" opening in the videos (it could perhaps be measured as extending from the cutting edge to infinity but that`s splitting hairs) ,truth be told there is no plane either. There is only a "sharp" cutting edge, securely and rigidly held at a specific angle coupled with a specially prepared "shaving bender" placed at a tightly controlled setting as measured from the edge doing the cutting.

To say something like " I adjusted my cap iron relatively close to the cutting edge of my plane iron on my XXX plane and it made some difference while planing oak" is IMO ignoring the larger percentage of the information gathered and demonstrated to be most effective in this video.

I point this out because we seem capable of debating things down to the most minute details here. Yet when it comes to actual application we seem more than ready to chuck both baby and bath water out the nearest window and then wonder if using a different brand of tub is what caused the baby in the yard to start screaming.

Re: Planing with the capiron close

#4

Re: I`m not getting it.

Kees

Nothing like that at all Bob. I'm still playing with it. Seeing if I can get better results from my trusty old UK made Stanley #4. Using the same plane but the capiron set back to about 1mm like I did in the past resulted in severe tearout on the same plank. Pushing it forward improved the results a lot. But pushing too far forward I get clogging instantly.

My capiron is allready polished and has a leading angle of about 50 degrees (hard to meassure on the curved Bailey iron). I have not yet cut off the leading part of my plane. i doubt if I will ever do that :D. But I also didn't yet take a file to the front of the mouth to create a bit more room. I am still a bit anxious about that.

So, just reporting where I am now, not trying to prove anything. I find this all very exciting (sorry).

A pic from my door sill is below.


img

Re: Planing with the capiron close

#5

clarification

Bill Tindall

The Kato and Kawai video has inspired people to try setting the shaving bender closer than they ever did before to see if there was benefit. Kees is confirming that there is merit in exploring this approach which no doubt will inspire others to try it. I think the discussion is that simple.

My ignorance in these matters was pointed out when I said that I never considered the Bailey "chipbreaker" to do anything more than hold the blade in place. I still believe that where it is often set it severs no beneficial shaving bending function and it certainly doesn't break chips. The Kato- Kawai video shows what it can do all by itself when optimally positioned. I think what people are going to find in practice is that it can provide help to provide tear-out prevention even when not optimally positioned when employed with other tear-out preventive measures.

Re: Planing with the capiron close

#6

craigd

Re: I`m not getting it.

craigd

Knowledge is good, applying knowledge is gooder. The study gave us some hard information about a [necessarily] limited situation. It appears [to me] that it might have applications to a problem I've been having: getting better results from old Stanley planes. Does it? I think so but don't have the rigor to say so. Did I learn anything new [about Stanley's]? Not really, I mostly duplicated what has been covered in books and people like Warren. On the other hand, I got a much better understanding of what is happening and planes that work. That is priceless.

Like many studies (eg in Nature), the results are not directly applicable to MY work, but the ideas are.

Regarding regrinding the cap iron - the Stanley is already pretty close to what video shows, and yes, I did put a micro flat on mine.

Cutting off the leading part of the sole - yep, tried it (in a fashion); I used a gapping mouth (1/16" & 1/8") with and without chip benders, the bender made a huge difference when the grain didn't behave.

Re: Planing with the capiron close

#7

Re: Planing with the capiron close

Charles

This whole exercise is infinitely easier with an ECE Primus smoother. Firstly, the leading edge of the chipbreaker (the business end) is angled correctly (IMO) to begin with. Secondly, the mouth opening is adjustable which makes tweaks much easier than moving around a bloody frog. Thirdly, it's pitched at 50*, the correct angle for a smooth plane.

By all means try to get better performance out of what you have, but know the inherent limitations which cannot be overcome by any amount of tweaking and fiddling.

Re: Planing with the capiron close

#8

Re: Planing with the capiron close

david weaver

It sounds like the mouth needs to be open a little bit more, and a closer set should eliminate the tearout.

Re: Planing with the capiron close

#9

What are the limitations..

david weaver

...what are the limitations of a standard bench plane?

I have never heard of a "correct" bed angle for a smoother. Is that something that comes from the secret volume "the world according to tage, and other subjective things that should be stated as fact"?

Re: Planing with the capiron close

#10

Nice

Bob Hackett

That walnut does go nicely with the maple floor. Nice contrast and way to delineate and celebrate moving from one area of your home to another.

I find the simple things (like a special touch of wood placed between rooms) can make a profound difference in my day. Every time I cross that threshold I will be influenced by the energy I put into that simple project.

Even if I don`t stop to notice it`s there (and I periodically do just that with these small projects) every time I pass it, I find that sooner or later the energy will build enough to come through during one of my life`s slower days. When that happens I`ll crouch down , admire how it`s integrated itself and become a valued part of our home, think of the time making it and smile. One of the many dividends returned on a small investment.

Thanks for sharing this.

Re: Planing with the capiron close

#11

Re: What are the limitations..

Charles

OK, how about a 'better' bed angle......???? Can you live with that?

Re: Planing with the capiron close

#12

Re: Planing with the capiron close

Charles

The lovely thing about the Primus is that you can go ahead and set your cap iron and then tweak the mouth opening very quickly - move the mouth, take a pass and check, move the mouth, take a pass and check. Could probably do twenty or thirty iterations easily in less than ten minutes (though it shouldn't take that many) - no removing the cutter, loosening the frog screws, moving the frog, making sure it's still square in the mouth after moving, tighten screws (and hope the frog doesn't move a tinge when the screws snug up), replace the cutter, then try a pass on some wood.

Ridiculous, and then you have to go through the same set of gyrations if you work on a different species.

Re: Planing with the capiron close

#13

Re: Planing with the capiron close

david weaver

I'd love to have a primus smoother, but every time I've seen one, the seller has been a bit too proud of it. Maybe someday.

What's odd is that there was a time that everyone seems to have bought them as *the have to have* premium smoother, and about 3 years ago, everyone was dumping them.

I haven't seen it lately. If I saw one in good shape for less than 100 bucks, I'd probably have it, as the muji design continental smoothers are nice planes if you can deal with the HSS irons and a cap iron that needs a little work. A bit less refined than the primus, and no adjuster.

Re: Planing with the capiron close

#14

Re: What are the limitations..

david weaver

I guess it depends on how you're using it and what you use, it seems like a good angle to me.

I see a lot of back and forth around here (not from you, your message is pretty consistent). One day, higher angles are there for a lack of skill. The next day, thicker irons are around for a lack of skill. Then it's adjusters. And during the cap iron discussion, it was brought up or implied that double irons or beds higher than an 8/10 bu japanese smoother are there to cover up a lack of skill or lack of ability to sharpen. My mind boggles.

And today the higher angle is the better smoother.

I guess at this point, I haven't seen a plane that any user shouldn't be able to work, it's just what you have to do with it. (throw out defective planes with soft irons). There's not a lot of "ghee, I could probably figure out how to make this work as well as anything, regardless of what it is and regardless of what it's against" lately....

.. as evidenced by the "marples chisels are hard to use" thread.

I guess that's what we do, niggle little bits around here without really getting into "does it actually make any difference at all to a familiar user".

(And, btw, my response was a bit over the top, but I hate to be one of those people who goes back and edits posts (or denies that it was), I'd rather own up to it. My apologies)

Re: Planing with the capiron close

#15

Limitations

Warren in Lancaster, PA

The higher the cutting angle, the more abusive the planing is to both the wood and the iron. So the lowest angle one can manage gives the best surface and is the most gentle to the edge.

Re: Planing with the capiron close

#16

Re: Planing with the capiron close

Kees

Yes I think so, but filing a nice tight mouth is quite another thing!

I'll try with the stock iron first, that one gives me a bit more room.

Re: Planing with the capiron close

#17

Re: Planing with the capiron close

david weaver

If you decide you like the stock iron thickness because it provides you some room, there is only one premium iron that I can think of in that range.

The blue steel iron that tsunesaburo makes is like the pimp dad version of a carbon steel smoother iron. It's super fine in taking an edge, but it's hard without being a booger to sharpen and it stays clean at the edge for a long time. And without tendency to develop tiny chips and leave lines like some of the no-so great for smoothing tougher alloys do. When it's dulling, you can tell that the plane has lost some keenness, but the surface is still very nice.

The tsune irons are stock thickness, stu carries them cheapest. They don't give you the feel of bulldozer power like some of the heavier ones do (like the 0.140 and 1/8" thickness irons that some push), but they make a nice match with a stock chipbreaker and you have plenty of mouth room with them.

(Premium irons aren't necessary by any stretch if the stock iron is in good shape, but some of them are novel, and so far as I can tell, the tsune one is as novel as any for smoother use).

If I had a good premium iron already and a common plane, I wouldn't hesitate to file the mouth if you can mark it cleanly. Same as woodworking, marking properly is harder than the rest of the job.

Re: Planing with the capiron close

#18

David Barnett

This is one of those stupid "me, too" posts

David Barnett

Me, too!

I agree!

The Primus improved smoother is the best thing since frozen haggis'n'neeps TV dinners.

Re: Planing with the capiron close

#19

Planing with the capiron close - more questions

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I've been following the threads on cap irons with much interest and enjoyment, but not ready yet to comment until I have experimented more.

The question I have is whether anyone has noted a difference in performance when using different types of cap irons - Stanley, LN, LV, Clifton, Hock?

This is not the same as determining whether, say, a LN cap iron is "better" than a Stanley version when it is set back on the blade.

The other area for consideration is what changes with different leading edge angles to the cap irons?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Planing with the capiron close

#20

Re: Planing with the capiron close - more question

david weaver

I can only relay what I think as opposed to what is. A month or two of this isn't enough to form absolute opinions.

* i like to use the stock stanley cap irons exactly as they are, just cleaned up and flush with the iron

* for the older style cap irons, i like the japanese method of a shallow primary bevel and a very steep very small final bevel. Like a 25 degree primary and a very small 75-80 degree bevel to actually break the chips. It makes it easier for the plane to feed, and it's easier to set up.

* the study suggests 80 degrees allows a little more leeway in distance from the edge, I think. I haven't been able to tell the difference of 80 vs anything. I can tell the cap iron is changing cut quality, especially in a heavier smoother cut, regardless of angles between 45 and 80, as long as the iron is set close enough to work.

Re: Planing with the capiron close

#21

Choking

David Charlesworth

In my experience choking is caused by bad shaping of the c/b front edge. (Front edge of throat is also a possible cause).

I have a 1970 Stanley 5 1/2, with Hock blade and L-N new improved chipbreaker.

The front edge of throat is filed and polished at 15 degrees forward.

The front edge of the C/B is honed and polished at about 42-43 degrees. Stanley were clearly aiming at 45 degrees.

The mouth is 0.004 inches. I can set the c/b front edge, as close to the blade edge as I dare, without any trace of choking. Perhaps 8 thou" and possibly even 4 thou". (Shaving thickness usually 1 to 2 thou").

Now I have been doing some drawing to establish, whether a tiny bevel (approx 0.004 to 0.008 inches wide) of 80 degrees would cause a choking problem and it seems it would not.

The research is fascinating. I have spent the last 40 years ensuring that my C/B edges were sharp and would have seen that little bit of bluntness as a problem.....

Getting round to testing these things out thoroughly is another matter!

Best wishes,

David

Re: Planing with the capiron close

#22

Re: Planing with the capiron close

Charles

The adjustable mouth, rather than an adjustable frog, just makes so much more sense. Lots of things can go wrong with a frog to body seating. Anything that goes wrong with a plane iron that beds to wood most any woodworker can take care of with his or her paring chisel.

They are an acquired taste. The feel is very different from an iron plane. Bearing down on a Primus has almost no effect. I think the wood probably flexes less than an iron plane, when you consider how thick a Primus is from handle-to-sole. You have to get used to skimming the wood, just guiding the plane. If your forearm veins are popping out and sweat beading up on brow, the plane is being used entirely incorrectly and will frustrate you at every turn. A lot of guys who've become very used to iron planes give up before making the transition.

Re: Planing with the capiron close

#23

Re: This is one of those stupid "me, too" posts

Charles

The first time I ever used one I thought "what a total piece of crap." Then I relaxed and changed my approach. As mentioned in another post - you can't run one of these like you do an iron plane.

Re: Planing with the capiron close

#24

Re: What are the limitations..

Charles

No big deal brother. Higher angles tend to work for me. If 50* won't cut it, I scrape without batting an eyelash, and sometimes I scrape anyway.

Re: Planing with the capiron close

#25

Re: What are the limitations..

Pam Niedermayer

I see a lot of back and forth around here (not from you, your message is pretty consistent). One day, higher angles are there for a lack of skill. The next day, thicker irons are around for a lack of skill. Then it's adjusters. And during the cap iron discussion, it was brought up or implied that double irons or beds higher than an 8/10 bu japanese smoother are there to cover up a lack of skill or lack of ability to sharpen. My mind boggles.

Really, David? Nobody here has ever said thicker irons accommodate a lack of skill, nor double irons nor higher bed angles nor blah, blah, blah. This is so tiresome, even having to refute such an egregious statement of intentional stupidity.

Sounds like what you're saying is that only those who wrestle with standard metal planes are doing so with skill.

Pam