New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

A plea to understanding the planing discussions

Posts

Re: A plea to understanding the planing discussions

#26

Re: OK, let me ask you one question:

david weaver

Gather yourself, pam, the only reason for the discussion about any of them is whether or not the kato study information can be applied to all of them equivalently.

And the answer to that is still yes, it appears that all of them were designed to do what the machinery in the kato study does.

How this otherwise became an argument about who makes what and whether or not stanley blades are equivalently flat, I have no idea, it's purely to find out if every term represents a plane part that was installed in the design to break a shaving.

Re: A plea to understanding the planing discussions

#27

I suppose then that...

david weaver

... this is just going to be another of many. Except this time we're going to have a lot more study data and video showing exactly how, why and when it works.

Re: A plea to understanding the planing discussions

#28

That might be kind of hard

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

The cap iron (odd term used deliberately) serves at least three functions on a Stanley plane: chipbreaking*, mating with the depth of cut/coarseness of shaving adjuster so that it can work on the iron, and providing somewhere for the cam on the lever cap to work against since said cam would otherwise fall into the slot in the plane iron**.

Some literature I've seen also argues that the two irons together are stiffer than one alone; I've never seen any reference to a definitive study of that.

I don't see how you COULD use a Stanley bench plane without the cap iron.

*I am stipulating here that it does fulfill that, while being ready to find out that it doesn't.

**Which slot exists, of course, both to accommodate the screw that holds the cap iron on and as somewhere for the lateral adjuster to fit, so it can do its work.

Re: A plea to understanding the planing discussions

#29

Re: A plea to understanding the planing discussion

TomD

"What are we talking about? Is a second iron a different device in form or function from the thingy that holds the blade in a Bailey plane?"

Yes it is, but probably not too much relative to the video. I take the small "I" imperialist view that I am not required to learn a whole bunch of someone else's language, and pronunciation in order to speak English. The exception being Latin. So I do not care what the whole raft of Japanese words are for plane parts, though broadly I know them. But the Japanese sub-blade probably is different enough that it does deserve a different name, just so as not to get lost in the confusion. If there is a different name for an infill, or a transitional, etc... I don't see why this part should not have a different name

Form: It is a laminated tool steel, wedge, held by a pin it is sharpened like the main blade. Or with a micro bevel.

Function: It probably should not be called a breaker since in most cases the shavings are not broken, though there are a variety of reasons for that that have nothing to do with the plane, such as the materials normally planed, their condition, and the fineness of shavings taken.

Functionally it does not hold the blade in, and neither does the Stanley CB it allows the blade to be adjusted while the cap holds it in. The SB probably affects the main blade, but it is independently adjusted from it.

I think you guys are all about the minutia until you are not. Why is that?

Re: A plea to understanding the planing discussions

#30

Re: OK, let me ask you one question:

TomD

I do have one LV plane I converted to work without the CB, it is completely optional, all one needs is a hole in the blade where the lever screw thing can be inserted, or in the case I have, it is a noris kind of adjuster. I really like the alteration. But I get what you are saying.

Re: A plea to understanding the planing discussions

#31

Re: That might be kind of hard

TomD

"I don't see how you COULD use a Stanley bench plane without the cap iron. "

That is the point. Therefore form and functional differences at some level

However, though not so easy for the classic, the variant with a Norris adjuster, and a screw cap, is a piece of cake to modify.

Re: A plea to understanding the planing discussions

#32

Moses Yoder

Re:Tearout

Moses Yoder

The point of Bill's question was whether or not the names all represent a device that is intended mitigate tearout, and the answer is yes.

I also participate in an online debate forum, and there if you make a claim and someone challenges that claim you have to provide a reference to a scientific study that backs your statement, or some form of strong evidence. You can post an opinion without having to reinforce it with evidence. In the post I just quoted, you make two claims. One is that Bill's post has something to do with mitigating tearout. I don't see the word tearout in his post, so I have to assume this is an assumption on your part. Two, you claim that all cap irons, sub irons, second irons, chipbreakers, etc. are designed to reduce tearout. Can you please link me to a scientific study that backs this claim? What if my opinion is different from yours? Is it then invalid?

Re: A plea to understanding the planing discussions

#33

Re: This is so not true.

Kees

Ouch the thread derails quickly! Let's keep it reasonable here.

The chipbreaker on western planes was invented to prevent tearout in unrully kinds of wood. And with a bit of skill it even functions reasonably well

Why was the japanese subiron invented and does it work?

Re: A plea to understanding the planing discussions

#34

Re: This is so not true.

TomD

There are functional differences. I would break these into catagories:

Functional differences not related to the shaving. These are of two types:

a) outright differences like independant adjustment

b) similar but different, for instance the way it supports the main blade

Functional difference related to the shaving. These could also be subdivided:

a) those that are different. Not the expert on this stuff, but the shaving comes off Japanese planes typically used, differently than it does on western planes. That is probably not something that couldn't be mimicked by other planes, as it is with super surfacers. I have learned a few things in the last few days that I did not know before like the low angle and 80 degree stuff. I was aware it existed, but thought it was structural, and there are some inconsistencies there...

b) Then I think there probably are some differences that we do not know the origin of, what they are for, any more than as Pam says, we know what the western stuff is for. There is a common misconception that by going back and figuring things out, we are coming up with the reasons stuff is there, this is often not the case. However it is a useful technical exercise so long as we don't over apply the results.

Then there is a category of other stuff. I am not a big believer in a number of Japanese tool dictums, Stuff like sharpening on different stones ruins a blade, or that the hollow has a proximity effect on the cut, etc... There are quite a long list of things. I don't know of any that affect the SB, but there are others more into this than me. I keep my mind open when real Japanese carpenters who can work circles around any of us talk about stuff, but I am not blind to the traditional elements. Probably people who are deeper in this shouldn't waste their time talking about it to those who haven't even bothered to try out the tools. Around here it just leads to conflict.

Re: A plea to understanding the planing discussions

#35

Re: This is so not true.

Kees

When the chipbreaker was invented it was still woodie time. That means it wasn't invented to stiffen the blade (the thick laminated blades were stiff enough) or for adjusting the cutting depth (wedge and hammer were used). It was only invented to prevent tearout. I suspect the same goes for the japanese subblades.

Re: A plea to understanding the planing discussions

#36

Re: This is so not true.

TomD

I never said it was invented for those reasons, the question is what are the differences. And there are functional differences even when something is doing the same thing. The hammer used in a piano is both identical to a framing hammer, and completely different, depending.

Re: A plea to understanding the planing discussions

#37

Re: A plea to understanding the planing discussion

david weaver

I guess the idea of wanting little minutiae in this part of the discussion is that the topic revolves around the kato video, and not the virtues of different cap irons, second irons, chipbreakers subblades in their shapes, materials, making, etc.

It is all about whether or not every one of them refers to a plane part that came about due to the desire to mitigate tearout.

I used to think that data describing the origin of the double iron as tearout use was scant, and i guess it is ...until you go to google books and look at literature from 1824 on (that's the earliest I could find, though it referenced double irons as though they had been around for some time and were accepted as *the* way for cabinetmakers to mitigate tearout by then), by searching the word double iron.

Understandably, literature about japanese planes in the period they did most of the work is going to be scarce since it's not going to be written in our alphabet.

The old writings describe the cap iron as being used to mitigate tearout, and attribute no other qualities to it. Even the stuff in pop-mechanics describes (in different words, though) the ability of it to break a chip so that the wood doesn't break out ahead of the cut, though their description of how to set it is a bit lacking.

Anyway, that's the reason for the clarification - will everything by those names do the trick in the kato video. And the answer is yes. I can't see why else, even in a japanese plane, that they'd exist. I originally had some thoughts that in the 1800s they may have been added to allow chatter reduction on an easy to sharpen thin iron, but I haven't seen anything written about that, while the explanation of reducing the tearout ahead of the cut is in abundance. Just not recent abundance, which is why I also said below why is it that this literature was so prevalent 200-50 years ago, and now it's never mentioned. Is it the inability of anyone to learn to set the thing, or is that inability just because nobody is told about it?

Re: A plea to understanding the planing discussions

#38

Terms

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I well remember the first time I heard the term "chip breaker". I visited a fellow who was a collector and plane expert around 1981. When he said " the name chip breaker is a misnomer because it's really just a blade stiffener", I almost fell over. I was so shocked I did not know what to say. He went on to demonstrate how his wonderful plane gave a rather poor surface. I had abandoned single iron planes, high angle planes, scrapers, and sand paper some years before.

I think the term "chip breaker" was historically used for both a machinist's lathe tool and for part of a planing machine. I think it a poor term because we use the word shaving (not chip) to denote the discharge from planes, and we have for hundred of years. I prefer the terms cap iron or top iron.

The term double iron plane has been used here in Pennsylvania at least since 1767. I think I have seen references using this term from every decade since that time.

Re: A plea to understanding the planing discussions

#39

Warren and the Japanese professors agree

Bill Tindall

Technical papers typically have abstracts in other relevant languages, in this case English. In the English abstract the professors translate the Japanese word for shaving bender as "cap iron". In their work its function is to prevent tear-out and it provides a subordinate function of causing the shavings to self sharpen the blade tip, a function that will be more fully described when the review is completed.

Re: A plea to understanding the planing discussions

#40

Maybe so.


Re: A plea to understanding the planing discussions

#41

Re: OK, let me ask you one question:

Pam Niedermayer

Geesh, and I say that you haven't a clue as to the intent of subblades and could not possibly have; and I don't know about chipbreakers.

Pam

Re: A plea to understanding the planing discussions

#42

Re: This is so not true.

Pam Niedermayer

I assume that the subirons were invented to mitigate tearout, but there's no way I could know that. Also, most of the time subirons aren't needed since the main blade alone doesn't produce tearout.

Pam

Re: A plea to understanding the planing discussions

#43

craigd

Re: That might be kind of hard

craigd

I have #2 sized Stanley-like plane that doesn't use a sub blade shaving bender device (ie just one blade). It works great (it should, it is basically a infill like plane with a Stanley like blade & lever).

Not hard to do.