Re: A plea to understanding the planing discussion
david weaver
I guess the idea of wanting little minutiae in this part of the discussion is that the topic revolves around the kato video, and not the virtues of different cap irons, second irons, chipbreakers subblades in their shapes, materials, making, etc.
It is all about whether or not every one of them refers to a plane part that came about due to the desire to mitigate tearout.
I used to think that data describing the origin of the double iron as tearout use was scant, and i guess it is ...until you go to google books and look at literature from 1824 on (that's the earliest I could find, though it referenced double irons as though they had been around for some time and were accepted as *the* way for cabinetmakers to mitigate tearout by then), by searching the word double iron.
Understandably, literature about japanese planes in the period they did most of the work is going to be scarce since it's not going to be written in our alphabet.
The old writings describe the cap iron as being used to mitigate tearout, and attribute no other qualities to it. Even the stuff in pop-mechanics describes (in different words, though) the ability of it to break a chip so that the wood doesn't break out ahead of the cut, though their description of how to set it is a bit lacking.
Anyway, that's the reason for the clarification - will everything by those names do the trick in the kato video. And the answer is yes. I can't see why else, even in a japanese plane, that they'd exist. I originally had some thoughts that in the 1800s they may have been added to allow chatter reduction on an easy to sharpen thin iron, but I haven't seen anything written about that, while the explanation of reducing the tearout ahead of the cut is in abundance. Just not recent abundance, which is why I also said below why is it that this literature was so prevalent 200-50 years ago, and now it's never mentioned. Is it the inability of anyone to learn to set the thing, or is that inability just because nobody is told about it?