New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

A plea to understanding the planing discussions

Posts

A plea to understanding the planing discussions

#1

A plea to understanding the planing discussions

Bill Tindall

These discussions are focusing on a plane part that bends the shavings. I have seen "cap iron, chip breaker, second iron" used in these discussions. What are we talking about? Is a second iron a different device in form or function from the thingy that holds the blade in a Bailey plane?

Re: A plea to understanding the planing discussions

#2

Re: they are all the same....

david weaver

.. just different words for the same device - something that deflects the shaving as it's coming off of the cutting edge.

Re: A plea to understanding the planing discussions

#3

This is so not true.


Re: A plea to understanding the planing discussions

#4

Re: This is so not true.

david weaver

enlighten us, pam, and try to do it without making your post a veiled "japanese planes are better" post.

The biggest confusion I have seem most people have is getting cap iron and lever cap confused, but I don't think such a conflict exists on this board because there aren't many beginners.

Re: A plea to understanding the planing discussions

#5

Re: This is so not true. *LINK*

Pam Niedermayer

Can't recall making veiled threats about anything woodworking. I think I addressed this subblade vs cap iron issue sufficiently a few days ago.


Subblades

Re: A plea to understanding the planing discussions

#6

Re: That is less than definitive..

david weaver

I think Bill's response was appropriate (or maybe it was someone other than bill), that describing how it's held in place doesn't account for their being a difference.

Every stanley cap iron is made to mate with the iron, too, they just don't have to vary because there isn't variation in the cutting iron. The mechanism for holding the second iron in place varies because of the cutting iron, not because the second iron itself dictates that it should be different.

I haven't read odates book in a while, and I don't remember whether or not he says anything about second irons, but the fact that a japanese plane can be operated without them doesn't suggest that they're not intended to fold a shaving. A japanese plane certainly doesn't need a second iron for stability because of the abutment, and the fact that the plane can work fine without them only suggests more directly that their presence at all has something to do with deflecting a shaving.

Re: A plea to understanding the planing discussions

#7

Moses Yoder

Re: definitive

Moses Yoder

So on eastern planes we have sub irons and western planes have cap irons. Is that definitive? Neither of those word combinations is in the dictionary, so it is kinda hard to determine a legal definition.

Stanley irons are by no means all the same, and to say they are reveals a lack of experience in flattening the backs. I would say the biggest difference between a Stanley mass produced plane is the assumption that the parts are all the same, and a well made Japanese plane it is assumed the parts are all different.

Re: A plea to understanding the planing discussions

#8

Re: No lack of experience...

david weaver

... in flattening the backs of the stanley irons (i'm talking about stock stanley, but really any irons). I may have flattened 40 stock stanley irons (and another dozen at least of premium irons and dozen more basket case laminated woody irons), enough so that I built an iron holder a while ago.

My point is that you can take the second iron off of any stanley bench plane of the same size and put it on another stanley plane, as long as care has been taken to flatten both.

You can't necessarily do that with a second iron on a japanese plane, because the pin may not be located in the same place relative to the iron, and the dai may not be wide enough to even let a different second iron in.

We are getting off track here trying to talk about the 0.2% difference between the jobs the second irons of different planes do or esoteric differences between different stanley irons. It's not the point of Bill's question. His question was whether or not we can use the terminology interchangeably when we're discussing whether or not a plane has a second iron that is intended to mitigate tearout by deflecting a shaving.

In this case, until someone who speaks japanese (and who actually knows) comes along and says that japanese second irons are definitively not designed ever to break a chip, all of these terms are interchangeable in discussion. As bill turns out more stuff that he's translating or having translated, it'll be clear why he's setting up the discussion with as much clarity as possible.

Re: A plea to understanding the planing discussions

#9

Re: This is so not true.

Kees

You explained the constructional differences but not the functional ones. Could you explain how a japanese subblade functions differently from a western chipbreaker?

Re: A plea to understanding the planing discussions

#10

?

Bill Tindall

If I wasn't confused before I certainly am now. And it certainly was no help to bystanders to just disagree and offer no data on the opposing view.

We are talking the mechanics of shaving formation and the role of some thingy to bend the shavings. All that matters in bending shavings is the leading edge angle and maybe its profile if it is not planar over the distance it contacts the shaving. Over the distance of a shaving thickness a Stanley shaving bender is essentially flat. So it comes down to the leading edge angle. Is this materially different in something that is called chip breaker, cap iron or what ever else is employed to bend shavings?

Why this is not an irrelevant issue......If the shaving benders are all functionally the same then we can compare data generated with something someone calls a chip breaker vs what ever else someone chooses to call shaving benders.

I am not interested in surfacing Temple beams or entering planing contests. If I can diddle with a chip breaker (something any Bailey plane owner would recognize) and quickly plane a surface to remove thickness planer ripples(for example) that I otherwise would have ground away at 80 grit in a cloud of dust this is a significant improvement in my ability to make stuff. Hence, worth knowing about. Any useful details to enable success is appreciated.

Re: A plea to understanding the planing discussions

#12

Re: ?

mark Hennebury

What I did with my old Record handplanes planes in relation to the mouth section of the plane: true up the edge of the throat opening, clean, square and straight.

The leading edge of the throat is pretty much square to the base when i got them, So then I filed it to a steep angle opposite of the blade bed angle from the leading edge of the throat to give as much clearance inside for the shavings, as it gets pretty cramped when you move the chipbreaker up close.

Then honed a small 80 degree flat on the tip of the chipbreaker and moved it up very close to the cutting edge of the blade. Together with the rest of the plane trued lapped and tight. I used a relatively close throat opening and left it set for the largest shaving that i would be doing. The only thing that you have to adjust is the blade depth and chipbreaker when you are cutting different woods and shaving thicknesses. I also hollow ground lots off the sole of the planes leaving a narrow flat strip around the perimeter and in front of the blade. You can hollow grind the soles by hand with a die grinder, you just have to take a few thou off them then lap and polish the sole on a granite plate with a fine abrasive paper of 3M micro film to true and polish it. This reduces friction and increases pressure on the wood fibers just ahead of the blade. You can make most handplanes cut quite well with a bit of tinkering.

Re: A plea to understanding the planing discussions

#13

Still all the same, Bill..

david weaver

..i had to find someone somewhere describing the setup of a japanese second iron, but found suggestions on japan woodworker's site.

(we are not in debate about any other types of planes, the second iron/chipbreaker/cap iron breaks chips, and even back in the 1830s there were ads crediting its ability to mitigate tearout in difficult woods).

Japan woodworker's setup guide says something like (i don't have the link active) * Hone the bevel to 20 degrees, and then apply a small bevel at the leading edge of 85 degrees. The purpose of the chipbreaker should be to break the chip and then offer no more resistance than necessary.

Copy and paste text would be worded slightly different than that, but that is what they said - they stated right out it should break the chip.

Everyone likes to split minutiae on here, but there is no need to do it on this topic. Every single second iron on any plane we're likely to use is a "shaving bender" or "shaving breaker".

Re: A plea to understanding the planing discussions

#14

Speak Japanese?

Schtoo

Not well enough...

Read it? Well enough to scare the locals...

I've got it labelled as a 'control iron/chip breaker'. The first is roughly what osae-gane means, the second is the commonly accepted term for what it is.

What I will do is accost and hassle as many folks as I can find when I head into Miki for their 'planing party' and see what they think it does. I'm pretty sure that they'll tell me "it's to bend/break the shaving so the wood won't be torn up before the blade gets to it".

My own thoughts?

I don't care what it's called. I'm not into the semantics of it, I just know what it is and what it does and that it's another arrow in the quiver when it comes to planing wood.

Normally, I set it well back from the edge in Japanese planes and leave it in the plane so it doesn't get lost and deflects shavings away from the pin, because I'm too lazy to remove the pin. I have in the past used it for what it was meant for, and while it's not a substitute for a good eye and a sharp blade, it's often enough to make a plane that's just slightly tearing out to start behaving itself.

The reason why it's in kanna?

The widely held reason is because it's a crutch for less than excellent planing folks after many of the really good planer folk weren't able to plane away after WWII.

I think (and I can easily find out yeah or neah) that it's also because after WWII there was an awful lot of planing to be done and folks couldn't be fussy about what they were planing. The extra bit of metal with the elusive name allowed planing folks, skilled or not, to cleanly plane crap wood to a standard that was acceptable.

Or in other words, another arrow in the quiver. ;)

(Of side interest is the hollow in the back of the blade itself. Yes, it makes flattening and sharpening easier. It also allows the shaving to get out unimpeded by rubbing against anything. Sticking a great big road block in the way goes completely against that principle, and folks around here aren't inclined to make things difficult just for a larf. And no, that's not my idea. That's from the folks who make the danged things.)

Now, what might be of interest here is that 'planing party' I mentioned. I'll be attending not as a spectator, I'm supposed to be giving a presentation on Western planes.

I was asked to do it by the folks at Tsunesaburo, and for some crazy reason, they've seen fit to pay my traveling expenses to get there and are also providing lunch and an interpreter (because my spoken Japanese isn't good enough for that! 1 on 1, yes. To a crowd of salivating savages, no.)

So, if I need to know exactly what that bit of mystery material is for, I have an idea that I'll be able to find out in explicit, uncensored and gory details.

That, and Mr. T the second and I get on like a house on fire. We'll pick up on our chip breaker debate where we left off last year.

Ya'll play nice now.

Stu.

Re: A plea to understanding the planing discussions

#15

I'd imagine the timbers..

david weaver

.. at the planing party will be top quality stuff where cutting it level grain or with the grain will make the chipbreaker less than necessary.

As opposed to "production" planing here where dimensioning wood by hand (or so called wood that some of the lumberyards claim is FAS in the rough) is sort of a production activity. At least it is in my underground bunker, and must've been many years ago. Getting all manners of marks left by the jointer or panel plane (plane, of course, not machine) in short order is the object of the activity. Both of which will leave a reasonable surface for the smoother, but one that may have small tearout in them if some parts of the wood were worked on the diagonal or where the grain has changed direction.

If we had only wonderful wood here that always ran with the grain, we'd have no use for the second iron. Of course, if we had such a thing, people might find the stanley 55 much more useful.

The literature on the JWW site, not one I visit often on purpose, suggests the same regard for using the chipbreaker when needed but still having it provide as little resistance as possible once the shaving has been broken by the very steep but not very deep leading edge of the uragane.

Another little piece of interest that would suggest that it is designed to break chips would be the fact that it's laminated. Given the wear on a chipbreaker in use described by the kato study (and the same wear you'll find on western chipbreakers that are used heavily - they are thin in the middle) one would almost have to conclude the blacksmith intends that edge to sustain wear, or there would be no quality lamination on the second iron.

Re: A plea to understanding the planing discussions

#16

Moses Yoder

Re:Bender versus breaker

Moses Yoder

Bender has a different meaning from breaker. Does a shaving bender and a shaving breaker have the same purpose and meaning?

I find it amusing that you say stanley irons and cap irons are all the same if they are flat. Before, you just said they are all the same.

Why can't we all just call a cap iron a cap iron and be done with it, for western planes?

Re: A plea to understanding the planing discussions

#17

Re: This is so not true.

Pam Niedermayer

Not really, I don't use western style chip breakers enough to know anything about them. Sorry.

Pam

Re: A plea to understanding the planing discussions

#18

Re: That is less than definitive..

Pam Niedermayer

You guys are so well-intentioned and so ridiculous all at once. Subblades, often in conjunction with landings, are intended to eliminate tear out and make smoother surfaces. Usually they're not necessary. If you get tear out, pick up a plane that has a subblade. How does it get simpler? How else can I explain it so you're somehow satisfied? Not that I actually think that's possible.

My assumption is that Kato accommodates subblades in his work.

Pam

Re: A plea to understanding the planing discussions

#19

Re:Bender versus breaker

david weaver

Moses, it makes no sense to me that you're still pushing at the stanley irons. What does their spec say they should be? Should some of them be hollow (by spec) and some of them be convex by spec? I have no idea why you're trying to say all stanley irons are different in the context that all japanese irons (that are hand made and need a hand fitted second iron) are different.

The point of Bill's question was whether or not the names all represent a device that is intended mitigate tearout, and the answer is yes.

How many other pointless discussion lines do you want to send this down, what is the reason that today you're trying to trip people up with pointless arguments?

As for why we don't just use one term universally, because nobody else does. What if someone uses the term uragane, are we supposed to force them to say "cap iron?".

Even stanley doesn't call it the same thing on their parts page:

http://www.stanleytoolparts.com/cuttercap.html

http://www.stanleytoolparts.com/capiron.html

If you're not going to contribute something to the discussion other than to try to trip it up and redirect, then why bother even posting anything?

Re: A plea to understanding the planing discussions

#20

Re: No lack of experience...

Pam Niedermayer

Oh, come on, you can't even say definitively what western chipbreakers are intended for or whether they accomplish that task. And if someone who speaks adult English would like to contribute, I'd listen.

Pam

Re: A plea to understanding the planing discussions

#21

OK, let me ask you one question:

Pam Niedermayer

Do you ever use a western metal plane, a la Stanley, without a chip breaker?

Pam

Re: A plea to understanding the planing discussions

#22

Re: No lack of experience...

david weaver

They are intended to break the shaving off and prevent tearout on a western plane, it's clearly documented in literature from the early 1800s. It is so clear that it's even mentioned in an 1830s advertisement for thick irons suitable for back beveling that the double iron is a useful design to reduce tearout.

They wouldn't be on planes at extra cost when most of the users lived near starvation if they didn't do anything. There were already competent single iron planes available for less when they were introduced. If they didn't mitigate tearout, they never would've appeared.

It's extremely unlikely that they aren't intended to do the same thing on a japanese plane because they otherwise are not needed at all (they certainly aren't needed to add stability to the cutting edge, and adding a pin to a plane for no reason doesn't make a lot of sense, either).

Stu already alluded to the fact that they helped users plane subpar wood when choice materials weren't available.

Re: A plea to understanding the planing discussions

#23

Re: OK, let me ask you one question:

david weaver

What does that have to do with whether or not they are there to break shavings?

Re: A plea to understanding the planing discussions

#24

Re: No lack of experience...

Pam Niedermayer

Well, logical thought processes don't necessarily provide the answer(s) in this case. I can't begin to remember how many times the chip breaker's existence has been debated here.

Pam

Re: A plea to understanding the planing discussions

#25

Re: OK, let me ask you one question:

Pam Niedermayer

Beats the heck out of me; but you're positing equity between subblades and chipbreakers. Since subblades are seldom used, I'd say that destroys any equity.

Pam