Greenlee chisel
eliot d
Has anyone heard of Greenlee chisels? I bought a bunch of cheap craftsman at an antique country store last year. But one of them turned out to be this Greelee. It says made in Illinois, USA.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Greenlee chisel
eliot d
Has anyone heard of Greenlee chisels? I bought a bunch of cheap craftsman at an antique country store last year. But one of them turned out to be this Greelee. It says made in Illinois, USA.
Re: Greenlee chisel
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
Greenlee is a respected name. I've heard comments from people whose chisels were harder than average old chisels, but they held a good edge. I own three of their drawknives, and I think one chisel, but (shuffling my feet and looking embarrassed) have not had occasion to use most of them while I'm in carpentry mode. I've used my Greenlee folding-handle drawknife and really like it.
Greenlee is still in business, now owned by Textron, but focused on electrician's tools. The "Greenlee punch" is an extremely useful tool for knockouts in electrical boxes, whether making one where you need it or enlarging an existing one.
Re: Greenlee chisel
Michael Brady
I have a few Greenlee chisels and a couple are NOS. They were among the last chisels made in the U.S. that had the leather washer on the end. I like them better than any modern chisel, except Lie-Nielsen. For some reason, most of the Greenlees are very long. The company was in Rockford, Il.
Good stuff!
Bob Hackett
They found favor in the shipyards here in Maine. That should tell you something about their usefulness and ability to withstand abuse.
I have a number of their tools from the 50`s and 60`s as well (NOS). Top notch tools.
Re: Good stuff!
eliot d
I guess I lucked out because the other chisels in the lot were cheap Craftsman. This one slipped through, I suppose. I thought it was a cut above(no pun intended) because it sharpened so well and cut well on a test piece. It indeed has a kind of beat up end at the handle where I suppose there used to be a leather striking disk or whatever you call it. Any ideas about how to fix that up ?
Re: Good stuff!
Bob Hackett
Go to a shoe repair shop and get a leather sole or scrap of one cut what you need and glue it on. You can stack the leather discs to make up the thickness you need.
Re: Good stuff!
Patrick Gibbons
Some of my favorite chisels are Greenlee. I have them mostly with the plastic hardwear (green) handles.
Re: Good stuff!
eliot d
so is there any way to get a set of these any more?
Just get in your time travel machine
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
or haunt eBay. Or get really lucky at garage sales.
Re: Just get in your time travel machine
eliot d
O.K. so I not going to find a set of these. What would be a comparable -- or reasonably comparable -- brand that is available if wanted a decent set? I only have Craftsman and Marples now.
I have to ask
Bob Hackett
Why is it that people seem to think they have to have a matched set of anything in order to do decent work? Other than being visually pleasing while being stored, what does a matched set of something do for you?
Re: I have to ask
eliot d
Oh, it's not so much that I have to have a matched set. My issue is that I'm getting the impression that my Craftsman and Marples are not so good. Apparently, the one good one I have is the Greenlee; and these are no longer available. So I'm still asking what's a good alternative? And won't I need a range of sizes? If the answer is ,'yes' , then I may as well have a matched set. What am I missing?
Depends on how you get your chisels
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
If you're getting new, then sure, a matched set is nice. I hear people say nice things about Ashley Iles.
If you get your chisels as I do (and I suspect Bob Hackett does), when you find them in the wild at garage sales and the like - then what you need is the sizes/lengths you'll use with the features that matter to you, without regard to make except as an indicator of quality. I have Stanleys, Pextos, and one each Witherby and Winchester - plus a whole bunch of chisels in reserve of various makes.
Curiosity and a caveat
David Barnett
"I'm getting the impression that my Craftsman and Marples are not so good."
From whom or what are you getting this impression, Eliot? Have your chisels somehow let you down in some way? Perhaps the edges have chipped or rolled over while you were paring dovetails or fitting a tenon? Or perhaps they won't take an edge?
And why do you say "Apparently, the one good one I have is the Greenlee..."? Why is this apparent to you?
I ask because I've got both orphans and sets of chisels from vintage and contemporary makers. One of my favorite chisels is a wide Craftsman with a clear plastic handle from the 1970s that takes and holds a terrific edge. I bought it to trim books in a lying press when a plough would be inappropriate. It's hell on chisel corners to use one this way but the Craftsman did the job for years before I began working wood, had something to compare it to which made me appreciate my good fortune in buying it.
If it's your experience that would lead you to buy chisels from a different maker, that's one thing. If it's the reputation or the name that's off-putting, I'd give what you have a chance before deciding. Greenlee's are fine, of course, but they're hardly the only good chisels. I'm not saying you're rushing things, but sometimes it's instructive to become very familiar with what's at hand, pushing tools to their and your limits before deciding what you'll need. This goes for chisels, saws, planes, stones and just about every other category of hand tools.
Don't take me wrong. I'll spread considerable spondulicks on tools I've learned work better for me than others, but it took awhile to learn what and why. For example, my absolute favorite hand tool bar none is the discontinued Starrett 277-2 spring dividers, a little round-leg 2" wonder. I use several of these, often on the same object, and have paid well over... well, let's not even go there.
If your just jonesing to buy stuff, have it real bad, I can fully appreciate that. I think most of us have been there. One neat thing about buying assorted tools, whether from trusted and knowledgeable vintage tool sellers, garage sales, eBay or wherever, is the variety. I have several 1/2" chisels from different makers; long and short, older, newer, thicker, thinner, and so on. I now know what I'd look for in a chisel if I ever needed to buy another, which I don't. Same for saws.
I'm just sharing my viewpoint not to pass judgement but to warn of early obsessions, having bought damned near a hundred moulding planes before I discovered I don't like mouldings and furniture that has them. I so wanted to like period furniture because I was fascinated with moulding planes, especially English cabinet pitch moulding planes. I simply can't live in a house with Queen Ann furniture, a piecrust table or a Chippendale secretary. I can appreciate period furniture, but I loathe it for myself, so it was off to the auction house with all the family heirlooms. The cartharsis will only be complete when I get rid of several shelves of accursed moulders. Granted, I or whomever I leave them to will likely profit from them, but that's hardly the point.
Re: Curiosity and a caveat
eliot d
Wow, what a response! You're obviously right: I'll have to try more things myself. Bill Tindall has been telling me the same thing. I think Pam , too. As for where I got the impressions, it was here. Let's face it ( you more experienced workers do go on and on about very subtle stuff). I guess I caught the bug -- not from experience -- but from hanging out here. I'll get there, though. My sharpening is getting pretty good! Now that I think about it, all I've made recently were a couple of hand clamps.
Color me old school
David Barnett
"I guess I caught the bug -- not from experience -- but from hanging out here."
Happens.
I guess I'm lucky I took up woodworking pre-WWW, and had formed most of my opinions, preferences and methods from books, magazines and some very fine teachers. I've learned a lot since then, of course, but I'd already gained sufficient design and woodworking exposure to not become irreparably befuddled.
All my major tool purchases, power and hand, were actually from brick-and-mortars, catalogs, ads and used tool vendors. As I alluded in my previous post, my tool acquisitions exploded when I got to see all those pretty tools and order them online, but that's well under control these last few years. For woodworking tools, anyway.