New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Died and gone to heaven!

Posts

Died and gone to heaven!

#1

Died and gone to heaven!

eliot d

O.K , I know I'm a mere beginner here -- but not forever! I'm just getting into my combo set by David Charlesworth: two DVDs, one on plane sharpening , the other on hand planing; and Two book volumes on furniture making. Volume I already knocks my socks off. I can't believe where this stuff has been all my life. Honestly, I don't know the man, nor am I on his payroll; but for anyone at my stage of the game, this is it.

Re: Died and gone to heaven!

#2

But wait, there's more!

Bruce, a MN Galoot

You get to talk to David Charlesworth right here, live (so to speak) on WC! What a place!

Re: Died and gone to heaven!

#3

Moses Yoder

Re: Died and gone to heaven!

Moses Yoder

I would hesitate to read one man's version of woodworking and call it complete. I would also suggest reading Tage Frid, although it is more practical type stuff and maybe not as detailed as Charlesworth. And Krenov is a must. I may be lacking a bit because the only wood video I have is by Brian Boggs on spokeshaves, but I like books. But then I also have some scraps of wood from Boggs, in my shrine.

Re: Died and gone to heaven!

#4

Re: Died and gone to heaven!

eliot d

I didn't claim it was complete; how would I know? I do have Tage Frid's books. Right now I'm reading David Fink's book on hand planes and these I just mentioned. What I realize is how little I know, how much to learn, and, unfortunately, that there are not enough decades left. Having a great time, though!

Re: Died and gone to heaven!

#5

Moses is right

ron in Kokomo

Roy Underhill, Christopher Schwarz, David Charlesworth, Paul Sellers, Rob Cosman, Graham Blackburn, Garret Haack, Follansbee, Cherubini, Don McConnell.

These are just some of the wonderful craftsmen/teachers that you can access on the internet right now. At no other time in history has it been this easy to learn.

They all have something to teach you. In addition to that there are folks here and a half a dozen other sites that will tell you anything that they know about the craft... FREE..

Enjoy

Ron a Kokomo Galoot

Re: Died and gone to heaven!

#6

Re: Died and gone to heaven!

roger lance

Eliot....In addition to numerous books on woodworking, I would also suggest that you look at various videos including those of Norm Abram, David Marks, and Tommy MacDonald. At New Yankee.com, they are running an old episode of The New Yankee Workshop each week....the current episode deals with steam bending and has a segment with Michael Dunbar where you will be getting excellent advise/education on steam bending from one of the great Windsor chair makers and also a chance to see interiors of two great workshops (there was a recent discussion on another forum about the value of a Record 53E bench vise....note Dunbar's use of them). For more hand tool use, David Marks' videos are findable on the net....and Tommy Mac (PBS's Rough Cut) is starting to improve his shows as well. Often it is not what is made on these shows but the techniques used or how their shops are organized....etc...etc....that is of interest. Also, many....and maybe you, like Roy Underhill's approach....you can't have a successful show for over 30 seasons without a solid following. The point is there are many sources of learning....expose yourself to them.

Re: Died and gone to heaven!

#7

Upon returning to earth.......

Bill Tindall

Some stay on cloud nine while others return to earth and start making stuff. Woodworking can be a spectator sport, or anyone can play.

Likely not till you start making stuff will the profound differences and difficiencies in these books and videos (and might as well add classes) begin to reveal which, or if any, of these inspirations is suitable for one's personal style of making stuff.

I might add that the journey back to earth is often greatly aided by a class geared toward making something of interest.

Re: Died and gone to heaven!

#8

Correction

James Watriss

At no other time in history has it been this easy to get instruction, for free.

Learning still takes time and effort at the bench.

Re: Died and gone to heaven!

#9

Too much information

Bill Tindall

One could spend much money and countless hours digesting just the books and videos available on dovetailing a drawer. How to choose which way to make your first drawer?

It would not be till one actually tried making the drawer that it would become apparent that it was a big step from the book to the drawer. Further experience would reveal that these techniques all have their advantages and disadvantages and finding what is "right for you" ain't easy, or quick. My shelf of no longer used stuff is a reminder of this fact.

Personally, I think a class in tune with the student's needs are the best way to learn. (or apprentice in a neighbor's shop)

Re: Died and gone to heaven!

#10

Re: Upon returning to earth.......

eliot d

You certainly seem to be one of the more sensible workers on this site. I know just about everything you say makes good sense. You clearly put great store in practical experience . For myself, in addition to be being a long-time turner and a newbe hand tool wannabe, I also paint watercolors and mixed media. And I can say with absolute certainty that one doesn't ever learn painting from a book. And even when taking some classes the key thing is to just paint and paint every day, if you can. Still, there's not too much harm in reading and following figures and photos. Also I do find that watching the DVD's really is helpful. To take just one example from Charlesworth's book, I had no idea about the importance of marking out and how to sharpen a marking tool. Now I really CAN learn this from the book and DVD. I just never considered the importance of it before. I mean I just drew a pencil line. Now I know , at least, that that's usually not good enough. So, you see. I did learn something. I also play the piano -- classical stuff. And I can tell you that there are no good pianists who haven't spent hours and hours and hours playing scales. I had a teacher( about 60 years ago) that made me play chromatic scales in opposite directions ( right hand up, left hand down) starting at every key in the scale. Now, there is practically no music written with that in it. But it's enormously helpful in developing independence of right hand and left hand when playing real music. So my plan is to read and watch the DVDs, practice fundamentals, and gradually move on to some projects. Participating in some workshops is obviously a good idea, too. I still remember stuff I learned with David Fink in his excellent plane making weekend. Thank you for your regular advice.

Re: Died and gone to heaven!

#11

Re: Upon returning to earth.......

eliot d

Now, here's a place where I have to admit that I better take your advice. After watching the Harrelson Stanley DVD on side sharpening a plane iron, I did it free hand that way and got fine results. (And there's no micro bevel there.) Now I just watched the David Charlesworth DVD, who advocates using an angle-fixing jig and a micro bevel. So you're absolutely right: I'm going to have to try it both ways to see which works better for me. ( BUT ... I did learn both methods from a DVD! Ha, ha!)