Re: Upon returning to earth.......
eliot d
You certainly seem to be one of the more sensible workers on this site. I know just about everything you say makes good sense. You clearly put great store in practical experience . For myself, in addition to be being a long-time turner and a newbe hand tool wannabe, I also paint watercolors and mixed media. And I can say with absolute certainty that one doesn't ever learn painting from a book. And even when taking some classes the key thing is to just paint and paint every day, if you can. Still, there's not too much harm in reading and following figures and photos. Also I do find that watching the DVD's really is helpful. To take just one example from Charlesworth's book, I had no idea about the importance of marking out and how to sharpen a marking tool. Now I really CAN learn this from the book and DVD. I just never considered the importance of it before. I mean I just drew a pencil line. Now I know , at least, that that's usually not good enough. So, you see. I did learn something. I also play the piano -- classical stuff. And I can tell you that there are no good pianists who haven't spent hours and hours and hours playing scales. I had a teacher( about 60 years ago) that made me play chromatic scales in opposite directions ( right hand up, left hand down) starting at every key in the scale. Now, there is practically no music written with that in it. But it's enormously helpful in developing independence of right hand and left hand when playing real music. So my plan is to read and watch the DVDs, practice fundamentals, and gradually move on to some projects. Participating in some workshops is obviously a good idea, too. I still remember stuff I learned with David Fink in his excellent plane making weekend. Thank you for your regular advice.