New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Cap iron question-need data

Posts

Re: Cap iron question-need data

#26

Re: Cap iron question-need data

mark Hennebury

I have included a picture of the Supersurfacer blade and back-knife (chipbreaker) setting gauge, so that you can see how important it is to precisely set the distance of the back-knife to the cutting edge of the knife. as you can see they are set with micrometers. The cutting knife is on the bottom and the back-knife is on top. You will also note that both the knife and back-knife have laminated tips. The offset is varied depending on the shaving size and the hardness of the wood. Also the skew angle is adjusted for different species.


img

Re: Cap iron question-need data

#27

Re: Cap iron question-need data

mark Hennebury

For those of you not familiar with supersurfacers; They are basically like a very large upside down hand-plane with a power feeder to shove the wood over the stationary blade. The blade is set in a blade block and that is set in a turntable to vary the skew angle.


img

Re: Cap iron question-need data

#28

Re: Cap iron question-need data *LINK*

mark Hennebury

I have included a link to a short supersurfacer videos. If you wish to see more you can visit my youtube channel at solidwoodmachinery or my website www.solidwoodmachinery.com

There is a lot of information on the Marunaka supersurfacer pages including the Kato study


img

Youtube video

Re: Cap iron question-need data

#29

craigd

Re: Cap iron question-need data

craigd

Thanks for the wonderful exposition! Those supersurfacers are soo cool (and informative).

I find it interesting that I've arrived at several of the same findings through trial and error (lots of that), and while confirmation is nice, having the information earlier would have been nicer.

Re: Cap iron question-need data

#30

Re: Cap iron question-need data

mark Hennebury

Hi Craig, your welcome. like you I experimented with handplanes for many years tweaking them and fussing with them trying to coax the best from them, and much of this info you tend to find on your own. One very important thing that I didn't figure out on my own and learned from the supersurfacers was to put the small 80 degree micro bevel at the front of the back-knife (chip-breaker) This helps tremendously in preventing tearout. I always used to sharpen the the chip-breaker to a fine edge so that the shaving would flow up over it. The small 80 degree micro bevel puts the brakes on that shaving allowing the knife edge to work. Also the Japanese style of traditional wooden hand planes have a hollowed out sole which puts a pressure line on the leading edge of the throat opening which helps keep things under control. The supersurfacer manufactures have combined a lot of research to making these machines work so well. Keep in mind also that the super tight tolerances are held on knives and back-knives that are over 13" long! some of these machines have much larger knives of around 28" long. It is quite incredible to use one of these machine and run ten foot long, foot wide Walnut or Cherry boards through them and see these beautiful full length and width shavings floating off, and to see and touch the super-slick bright, vibrant surface left behind. The hardest thing is to end up a some point having to throw out all the shavings.


img

Re: Cap iron question-need data

#31

Re: Cap iron question-need data

david weaver

Very cool, Mark. Very cool!

Re: Cap iron question-need data

#32

Re: Cap iron question-need data

James Watriss

That is really remarkable.

And I wouldn't have thought of putting an 80 degree bevel on my planes either.

I think it's gonna be an interesting day or 3 in the shop...

Re: Cap iron question-need data

#34

Thanks for yet another great thread, Bill.

Bruce, a MN Galoot

You sure have a knack for asking good questions.

Re: Cap iron question-need data

#35

craigd

Re: Cap iron question-need data

craigd

Mark - question on super surfacers - what is a typical cutting angle and clearance angle?

In general, clearance angles are something I'd like to know about; Larry, L. Lee (and others) have discussed it, 12.5º seems like an "agreed" upon min, I'm wondering how dependent it is on wood species, long vs end grain, etc. A very low angle plane combined with a SS style "chip breaker" that doesn't care about grain direction is pretty appealing (which may already be realized in Japanese [hand] planes).

Re: Cap iron question-need data

#36

Re: Cap iron question-need data

Mark Hennebury

Hi Craig,

The bed angle is about 35.5 Degrees and the knife is ground to 31deg wth a small honed bevel at 32deg..

I have all of the grinding and setup info on the following webpage;

http://www.solidwoodmachinery.com/supersurfacers.htm


img

Re: Cap iron question-need data

#37

Re: Cap iron question-need data

Bill Tindall

The clearance angle in Kato's work was 10 degrees. But, a flat develops on the bevel face(back face) that renders the clearance angle zero as the blade wears. This development has a profound effect on the mechanics of the balde. As soon as this flat develops the forces on the blade perpendicular to the planed surface go from pulling the blade into the board to pushing away. I'll bet this change is something that can be felt when hand planing.

Re: Cap iron question-need data

#38

craigd

Re: Cap iron question-need data

craigd

Thanks! That video was wonderful, answered so many questions AND provided numbers (I somehow missed it when I watched the videos on your site). Actually seeing tearout in action was very enlightening.

Now to put on my thinking toque and try to figure how to apply it to hand tools.

Re: Cap iron question-need data

#39

Re: Cap iron question-need data

mark Hennebury

The Kato video is a great tool, and provides us all a chance to really observe what takes place. This study and video provides us all with lots of information and gives valuable insight into cutting on the scale where all the action is taking place, it is however not a comprehensive study in terms of handplane function. As you can see from the video there is no handplane involved, just the blade and chipbreaker. For handplanes with a wide throat opening or without an accurate and easily adjustable throat opening the chip breaker is of critical importance, not so much for planes with an accurate an easily adjusted throat opening, as a tight opening also prevents tear-out. So with handplanes you have a several ways to avoid tearout when planing against the grain; Blade bed angle, Chipbreaker adjustment, Throat opening, and you can employ one or more in combination to achieve the goal. The supersurfacers use all together and have precise adjustments for all.

You can learn a lot from whats in the Video and just as much from whats not in the video.

If you want to see the videos I have put them on my website. If you go to the one on the supersurfacer page and scroll down to the bottom of the page the Prof Kato study with pics and English translation is posted.

http://www.solidwoodmachinery.com/flashvideopage.htm

http://www.solidwoodmachinery.com/supersurfacers.htm