New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Cap iron question-need data

Posts

Cap iron question-need data

#1

Cap iron question-need data

Bill Tindall

We continue to digest the boggling amount of data in the Kato publication on planing, some, or most, of which could be relevant to hand planing. When the data and conclusions from the paper are clearly understood this information will be posted here. The digestion is leading to indigestion so this task is slower than I anticipated.

One of the primary variables studied in Kato's work is the distance of the cap iron from the blade tip. Significant differences were observed for rate of dulling, forces to push the plane, shaving morphology, wear profiles on the bade, self sharpening effect, etc. depending on the position of the cap iron relative to the blade tip.

To help put Kato's results into practical perspective for practical hand planing as it is practiced it would be helpful to know how you all set the cap iron of your planes. Specifically, I would like to know how far from the blade tip is the leading edge of the cap iron along with what is your planing objective- removing wood or producing a finished surface. Estimates to the nearest 1/32" are needed, or thousandths of an inch if you speak in thousandths.

Re: Cap iron question-need data

#2

craigd

Re: Cap iron question-need data

craigd

I measured four of my Baileys; one is 0.165", the others are right around 0.050". This reflects my inability to get the chip breaker to actually deflect shavings; there always seems to be discontinuities at the juncture that catch and collect shavings.

Re: Cap iron question-need data

#3

Re: Cap iron question-need data

David Charlesworth

Bill,

If I really try maybe 8 to ten thou" from blade edge.

David

Re: Cap iron question-need data

#4

follow up

Bill Tindall

Can you detect any performance difference between about 0.008 and something much larger, say about .0050?

Re: Cap iron question-need data

#5

Re: Cap iron

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have used a cap iron to control tearout for over 35 years. It took several years of experimentation before that to get comfortable with the process. I was guided by the notion that cabinetmakers 200 years earlier knew something I did not. The ideal distance between the cap iron and the edge varies according to the thickness of shaving, the severity of the figure, and the quality of the timber. It is something one has to develop a feel for. I have never measured the distance from the edge to the cap iron, and frankly it has only been in the last two years that I ever measured a shaving. I can say that if you use a double iron on sound timber and are getting tearout, something is wrong. Maybe someone else can be more helpful.

I have intentionally avoided giving these measurements. It would be very easy for someone to say "I put it just where you said and it didn't work." An analogy I have used is that of a standard transmission. What would you say to a guy who says "Tell me what gear to use", or "I tried it in 1st and it was too slow so I tried it in 5th and it stalled". We don't consult a chart that says when going a certain speed and going up a certain slope and accelerating at a certain rate we should be in x gear. What we do is experiment and get a feel for what the appropriate gear is. To learn to shoot a basketball, we do not ask an expert what angle he uses to launch the ball or how many rpm it is spinning. It is helpful to watch others or to have a coach, but without many repetitions, success is doubtful.

I seems odd to need a scientist to validate centuries old technology. I guess it happens in other fields as well.

Re: Cap iron question-need data

#6

Re: Cap iron question-need data

TomD

As mentioned recently I set it till it shoots the shaving vertical. This is a dramatic change in shaving performance, but whether it makes for a better result is a little difficult to say. It is obviously difficult to know since one can't run the exact test over and over. It is difficult to measure the setting since it is arrived at in place, and the place is hard to access. Also the question of how far back to set it is not really relevant since it is not repeatable, but is settable to a performance level, in place.

On western planes I normally set it around 1/32". I think there are two or three different setting for western planes:

1) There is the idea that one can use it solely to stiffen the blade. Most of my blades are really thick to start with or use one of the better retention mechanisms that well supports them.

2) Then there is the chip breaking set. The idea there is that the shaving is breaking after the point of cut, but that this reduces the leverage at the point of cut. I don't so much endorce this approach, but I think my setting is in that range. This setting is reminiscent of some machine tools that use a cutting edge profile to fragment the chip as it comes free. This has a number of effects, one of which is kinda interesting in that it limits heat transfer.

3) The third approach is essentially a setting so close that it converts the plane to the simulation of a higher pitch. Since I have a lot of planes, and can make any I don't have, I am not concerned with converting pitches through the use of chipbreakers.

It will be interesting to see where you come out!

Re: Cap iron question-need data

#7

Re: Cap iron

Kees

While I agree 100% with you, I can also understand why one wants to analyze things. Especially makers of planing machines!

I am still at the bottom of the learning curve of using chipbreakers. But I get quite good results now on smoothing European soft maple, the stuff that made me grind a back bevel before, with a Stanley #4 and 0.4 mm between edge and CB-edge. No idea how thick my shavings are.

(0.4mm = 16 thou)

No idea how usefull these numbers are. Like Warren said, it probably varies too much.

Re: Cap iron question-need data

#8

Re: Cap iron question-need data

Pam Niedermayer

I find it interesting that a Japanese paper needs data about western style chip breakers? Are you sure you don't want subblade info?

Pam

Re: Cap iron question-need data

#9

Re: Cap iron question-need data

Larry Barrett

On my LN #4, cap iron is set a little less than 1/32.

On # 5 with cambered blade, it is set closer to 2/32.

Re: Cap iron question-need data

#10

Some Data

Warren in Lancaster, PA

About five years ago someone posted a link to some Japanese videos. I nosed around the site a little and found diagrams of three different planes with measurements. The text was in Japanese. The site is no longer available but here is a rough idea of the measurements to the sub blade (cap iron).

#1 medium mouth, distance to sub blade: .8 to 1.5 mm

#2 small mouth, distance .5 to 1.0 mm

#3 smaller mouth, distance .3 to .6 mm

As you can see, for each plane there is quite a range of settings, and the largest setting on the coarser plane is a good multiple of the smallest settings; not one size fits all.

Re: Cap iron question-need data

#11

data so far have been helpful

Bill Tindall

More of it would be more helpful. Simple request, how far back from the tip do you set the leading edge of the "cap iron", or what ever you choose to call the thing that bends the shavings.

Is anyone using distances as small as about 0.010", or in that neighborhood, for any planing purpose?

Re: Cap iron question-need data

#12

Re: data so far have been helpful

Pam Niedermayer

Bill, it's not "whatever you choose to call the thing." There are big differences between western cap irons and eastern sub blades. For example, in better planes the sub blades are made to mate with a particular blade, thus in a particular placement relationship with each other. They are held in place with a small rod, a blade pin, that runs from side to side. There's usually a wooden landing supporting the bevel (bevel down, always). I don't know whether the sub blade's official job is chip breaking. And often it's not necessary or helpful to use a sub blade at all.

Tom?

Pam

Re: Cap iron question-need data

#13

I need clarification

Bill Tindall

I have never seen a Japanese plane, so any response needs to consider this fact.

From the focused reading I have done the Japanese employ something to deflect the shaving. (for example, see picture in post above). Traditionally, the function of this thing is to mitigate grain tear. It has been found that in some situations this thing can have a beneficial function beyond mitigating grain tear. All I care about are the mechanics of deflecting this shaving. What ever else this thing does, or however else it is held in the plane is unimportant to the mechanics of shaving formation. In this regard whatever the Japanese use to deflect shavings must be functionally identical to a western cap iron in its function to deflect shavings, in situations where it is set to deflect shavings. If this assumption is incorrect it would be greatly helpful to know the correct story.

Re: Cap iron question-need data

#14

Re: follow up

David Charlesworth

Bill,

I always understood that close was best for fine finishing of difficult timber.

The Japanese research on the web, about the fixed blade planing machine, suggested very close indeed.

I have a slightly cambered front edge on my chipbreaker so I can set is as close as I dare.

Things work well but I regret I have done no meaningful comparisons.

David

Re: Cap iron question-need data

#15

Re: I need clarification

TomDhttp://www.buildingforhealth.com/largeimages/H

"I have never seen a Japanese plane, so any response needs to consider this fact."

http://www.city.sanjo.niigata.jp/common/000017705.gif

The combo of blade parts is very similar to what you would have if you took two western blades and put their backs together, then offset the ends by whatever set-back you were using. There is a difference in the geometry of the sub-blade, which is as the word says, a second blade, though it does not cut, and a western breaker.

"All I care about are the mechanics of deflecting this shaving. What ever else this thing does, or however else it is held in the plane is unimportant to the mechanics of shaving formation. In this regard whatever the Japanese use to deflect shavings must be functionally identical to a western cap iron in its function to deflect shavings, in situations where it is set to deflect shavings. If this assumption is incorrect it would be greatly helpful to know the correct story."

The geometry of the parts is different. How different depends mostly on what western plane one is comparing to since there seems to be more variation there. As you can see with Garrett here, the shaving formation is a little different. You can get the same tight curls, but the laid out shaving is more the objective.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h3fokzCAIPw

http://www.buildingforhealth.com/largeimages/Hida/kamijo.jpg

While I agree that how one gets the breaker in there is not relevant to the ratio itself, I would compare it to the ratios on a standard vs automatic car. At some level one could draw conclusions about ratios from either system, but because the method of achieving the ratios is so different, there is little comparison between the systems and how they are used except at high levels of generality.

Re: Cap iron question-need data

#16

Re: Cap iron question-need data

Phil Smith

Lie Nielson 4 1/2 set up for finish planing curly stuff. Chip breaker is 0.014" to 0.017" from edge of blade.

Re: Cap iron question-need data

#17

Re: Cap iron question-need data

david weaver

On finish cuts, after seeing those study pictures in the leonard lee book, I set the chipbreaker as tightly as I can and just push the plane through the moderately higher resistance if the wood is bad. I would guess that the chipbreaker on a finish cut like that is no further away than 4 thousandths of an inch, I can barely see the edge reflecting light.

I have not been able to generate tearout on anything yet (regardless of the planing direction or iron sharpness) with the iron set like that, and until a month or two ago always figured it was too much trouble to set it like that. Repetition has made setting the iron like that a lot easier and faster.

If the wood isn't bad, then I back it off some multiple of that if I expect it to actually break chips, maybe a hundredth on a light cut.

I generally haven't used a double iron to break chips in a heavier cut, instead opting for a plane with the mouth sized to the work. Same thing sometimes with a smoother. My jack plane probably has a mouth set somewhere around 1/16th or a little over, and my infill plane (which I usually use to level a board) is set around .009" (which coincidentally after not filing enough forward relief when I put it together keeps me from using the second iron with good effect - it's not necessary, though, fortunately).

Re: Cap iron question-need data

#19

Re: Cap iron question-need data

Warren in Lancaster, PA

David, I agree that putting the cap up very close like that will eliminate the tear out, but it may not yield the best surface on all woods. What I look for is sort of a sweet spot or critical point where everything works well and gives a fine surface.

Warren

Re: Cap iron question-need data

#20

Re: Cap iron question-need data

david weaver

I would imagine that it wouldn't do that well on pine, but I haven't worked anything softer than soft maple with it, and the soft maple I planed had extreme figure.

I can generally plane it fine with any plane I have (including single iron planes down to about 38 or 40 degrees) if I am willing to pay attention to sharpness and avoid doing anything other than using the utomst discretion in shaving thickness (I think this is a pain to do, though, if you have a lot of panels to smooth and they have moved a little bit before you've gotten to them.

What I marveled at setting the cap iron that close was that it was impossible to create tearout no matter what I did on a very cheap plane ($11 plus a $3 buck brothers replacement iron) and the finish was a little better than my 55 degree infill smoother (no surprise given the angle, though). Neither produces tearout, but the infill is single iron with a mouth in the neighborhood of office paper thickness, it's predictable that it won't create much shine compared to a bench plane.

Any general thoughts from wood to wood? I wouldn't set it tight for pine, because it's not necessary and there's no reason to add planing resistance. The only cherry I have that benefits that much is curly cherry, but in that case, there is a large benefit from what I've seen so far.

Re: Cap iron question-need data

#21

Re: Cap iron question-need data

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Woods like poplar (Liriodendron tulipifera), or Butternut (Juglans cinerea) or white pine can have grain reversals or figure, but scuff or cloud a bit if the cap is too close. Walnut, cherry and Honduras mahogany can have difficult grain, but probably do a little better if the distance is not extremely close. I tend to set the iron by instinct and make an adjustment if I don't like how things are working out.

Re: Cap iron question-need data

#22

This is a revelation for me, Warren

Bruce, a MN Galoot

It never once occurred to me to adjust the cap iron on my smoothers for type of wood. Next time before I complain I'll adjust that first.

Re: Cap iron question-need data

#23

Supporting data......

Bill Tindall



There are these planing machines called SuperSurfacers. Other than being powered by electricity vs human they work like a hand plane. Because all the planing variables can be precisely set and controlled they provide a dandy way to study planing. So for example if one wants to know the effect of setting the cap iron 0.002" closer to the blade tip, that is easily accomplished. Of if one wants to study the wear of this knife steel vs that knife steel it is no sweat to reproducibly plane a thousand feet with each blade and watch the effect of them getting duller(high performance steels last 3X longer). Much more on these results later.....

A person running one of these machines told me to achieve a similar surface quality that this machine's equivalent of hand plane cap-iron, shaving thickness and throat opening all had to be readjusted when the wood being planed was changed . Distance of the cap-iron from the blade tip was a very important variable to achieve surface quality.

Re: Cap iron question-need data

#24

Re: Cap iron question-need data

mark Hennebury

Hi,

I have a bit of experience with both hand planes and supersurfacers, and as I see it;

there are many wood species they have a lot of variation in structure and properties and respond differently to cutting tools, and therefore require special tool geometry to attain the best cutting results.

A plane blade is a wedge and as such will when planing against the grain, wedge the wood fibers apart ahead of the cutting edge, creating torn not cut fibers. You have several options to prevent this: If you consider first a blade with no chipbreaker. one method is to raise the angle of the blade. A low angle blade creates lots of lift and will easily tear wood fibers.The closer to perpendicular to the plane sole that you have the less lift of the shaving and more forward pushing, or scraping. So a higher angle will be less prone to tearout, but at a price, the price: it requires more effort, the scraping is harder on the blade, and the surface is not that good. The second method is to close the throat opening extremely tight, this would need to be adjustable to suit the size of the shaving and must be precisely matched to the shaving thickness to work. The third method is to use the chipbreaker. The chipbreaker is a misnomer as the purpose is to not break the chip but to put a barrier in place to control the chip from separating ahead of the knife edge,holding the chip under control until is is severed. In this third method you can have a low angle blade and an adjustable chipbreaker. The chipbreaker is adjusted precisely to match the shaving thickness. This method is what was demonstrated in the Kato experiments and is the basis of the supersurfacer design. Another variable is the skewing of the blade to the direction of cut. Skewing does two things, one is to vary the blade angle geometry and two is to cause the fibers to slide along the blade exposing the individual fibers to more of the cutting edge and will sever them much easier, kind of like slicing a soft tomato rather than chopping it. One other variable is to apply pressure at the leading edge of the throat opening to compress the fibers slightly prior to being severed. Supersurfacers have incorporated all of these variables into their design and are capable of producing extremely fine surfaces in a wide variety of wood species.


img

Re: Cap iron question-need data

#25

Re: Cap iron question-need data

mark Hennebury

I should clarify the chipbreaker geometry a little: chipbreakers on Supersurfacers and in the Kato experiment have a small or micro bevel at the tip ground at various angles up to 80 degrees to the flat surface, so in effect a rather blunt tip. This tip is very small, just big enough to interrupt the flow of the shaving up the blade and slow it down long enough for the blade to sever the fibers. Kato experimented with several angles, offsets from the blade edge and shaving thicknesses. What the effect is, is similar to the same geometry as a cabinet scraper. you have a very small cutting edge and an abrupt stop at the scraper blade, the forward tilt of the scraper blade is about the same angle as the micro bevel on the chipbreaker of a supersurfacer.

So they both function in quite the same fashion


img