Re: need simplification
Pam Niedermayer
I'm not trying to convince you of anything except that 8000 equals 8000, Elliott, simply posing some questions to help you figure out how to progress.
Pam
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Re: need simplification
Pam Niedermayer
I'm not trying to convince you of anything except that 8000 equals 8000, Elliott, simply posing some questions to help you figure out how to progress.
Pam
Re: need simplification
eliot d
I do appreciate your help. This is all very exciting to me. So does this mean that , all else being equal, a higher grit equates to more sharpness? It's the scientist in me that has me wondering if --again all else is equal -- could the SHAPE of the grit-induced scratch affect sharpness? We know it affects reflection. Could it affect how it cuts?
Shape of abrasive? Possibly...
Schtoo
Eliot wrote;
It's the scientist in me that has me wondering if --again all else is equal -- could the SHAPE of the grit-induced scratch affect sharpness? We know it affects reflection. Could it affect how it cuts?
I think the shape, type and properties of the abrasive can and does affect what kind of edge you get, but perhaps not absolute sharpeness since you can just make the abrasive finer and finer until you get the 'sharp' you want/need.
But I don't have a degree in anything pertinent, don't have the time I need to do any kind of scientific-like testing so I need to base what I think on seat of the pants observations and talking with other folks in the same boat as me, no opportunity to put the puppy to rest permanently but enough hands on experience to know what works and what doesn't.
If I expanded on my thoughts around here, I'd be ridiculed endlessly and I don't want to do that to myself.
Not until there's enough cold evidence to back me up. 
Oh, FWIW, if the Spyderco ultra fine has a 3 micron rating then it is superficially equivalent to a Norton #8000. The problem is the Norton can 'bat above it's average' whereas the Spyderco wouldn't be likely to, and the Norton stones rated grit size is larger than an equivalent Japanese specification #8000 stone.
That doesn't necessarily mean the Spyderco is doing bad things to the edge, but it does mean it'll improve things only under a fairly narrow set of circumstances (which may or may not be met) and is going about it's business in a completely different way what the diamond films will do it.
Stu.
Re: wear rate of the stone..
david weaver
I'm not sure how fine the spyderco is, either, but I am going to find out soon.
One thing that is different between the spyderco and a lot of other stones is that it is hard enough that it will not release its abrasive, which should do two things:
1) make it cut slower after a while
2) make it leave a finer edge, as long as it is still cutting fast enough to be effective
As hard as it is, I think an experienced user will be able to get more out of it than its grit rating, but whether or not that's a necessary thing to worry about in the days of being able to drop chromium oxide on MDF or putting down a 0.3 or 0.1 abrasive on a substrate for a few stropping swipes after the fine stone, I don't know.
They do have their proponents in the razor and woodworking world, but because of their hardness, I think their proponents are fewer. 90% of the enthusiasts out there seem to want a stone that's point and shoot, always the same, until they see someone talking about getting more out of a stone. It's probably esoteric, though it woudln't have been 75 years ago.
I saw some strange opinions about the (spyderco) stones on a razor forum not that long ago, and the criticism from one side was that they cut too slow (nothing that never dishes at all will be that way). There were also a few proponents saying that with iron oxide or cerium oxide powder in the 0.1 range on the stone, they were getting better edges than they have ever gotten anywhere else on anything, finding that method out only by asking their favorite pro honer (something common in the razor world, where sharpening with stones need only occur once every 6 months to a year with an experienced shaver).
The attractiveness of the hardness (meaning you can sharpen anything, including carving tools) of the stone and what has to be the least maintenance of anything out there was too much for me to resist - I ordered one this morning just so I could get my wife to yell at me, I guess.
One of the best things about hard ceramic stones
David Barnett
... such as the Spyderco, is that pointy tools of high sectional density; narrow chisels, gravers, awls, divider points, gramil blades, purfling cutters, scribers and so on, will not gouge or otherwise damage the surface.
Here's what you need... *LINK*
David Barnett
...to help answer such questions on the refinement and polishing of metals, gems, glasses and the alteration of their surface properties in so doing, Sir George Thomas Beilby's seminal 400-page: "Aggregation and Flow of Solids - being the records of an experimental study of the micro-structure and physical properties of solids in various states of aggregation, 1900-1921", is just the thing. What's more, it's free.
I went with an 8" mirror kit from Edmund Science and the Jean Texereau book, where I learned to appreciate the differences in pitches (my favorite nowadays, although no longer for mirror-grinding, is the superb German burgundy chaser's pitch). Boy, was that a long time ago.
As for snake oil, I sure wouldn't run out and buy Dialube 3000 just to sharpen a plane blade, although one could, I suppose. Just use whatever's handy and if you feel the need to esotericize and maybe even eroticize, you could add any essential oil that contains the terpene linalool and with a very light hand, just a touch of civet musk, or even toddycat musk, if you can get the toddycat to cooperate, that is. All in the interest of simplification, of course.
Aggregation and Flow of Solids
Re: wear rate of the stone..
TomD
I've had two of them for decades, I'm glad I have them, but i don't really use them much. When I got them they were not even close to flat. I lapped them a bit. The same is true for the Spiderco ceramic sticks, bent like bananas, though I use them on a lot of knives and they do sharpen really sharp.
Re: wear rate of the stone..
david weaver
I have a couple of little knife sticks. I've noticed that they sharpen extremely well when they're fresh, and when they're loaded, they'll sharpen extremely fine to a super bright polish, but they do go slow at that point.
I have heard the same thing about them not being remotely close to flat. I figure the UF probably will not be close to it and I'll have to work it for a while. If I don't like it for tools, maybe I'll use it some day on razors, or maybe I'll sell it to the razor users. I used to say that I'd use stones on razors, but now that I have a good horse strop, they don't see much action on any true stones.
Re: wear rate of the stone..
TomD
In your case, with your interest in diamonds, you shouldn't have much trouble getting them flat. Back then I was concerned with wearing out the old style diamond stones.
Re: wear rate of the stone..
david weaver
Yeah, I have some things that will work it. I'm still clinging to the dream that it shows up polished smooth with no mill marks (I read somewhere that the UF is just the F with a polished surface).