New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

need simplification

Posts

need simplification

#1

need simplification

eliot d

I'm having trouble filtering all the information about diamond powers, pastes, films, etc. Perhaps someone can give me some fairly straightforward advice: let's say I want to go ONE step beyond where I am in sharpening a plane iron, and I currently use Nortons 1000 and 8000 followed by the Spyderco ultra sharp; and I follow Harrelson's Side Sharpening video. Please suggest a diamond substance in this realm along with a proper substrate. I thought balsa might be a good idea.

Re: need simplification

#2

Re: need simplification

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

One substance - 0.5 micron diamond film from Lee Valley. Use it on glass or a granite tile.

Two substances - the above, followed by 0.01 micron diamond film.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: need simplification

#3

Re: need simplification *LINK*

John in NM

I would say you're making it too complicated. If you want to go with diamond, Bill's post below has all you need to know.

You could substitute an appropriate loose grit for the mounted stone, but I don't see why you'd want to do so. Maybe something in the 15 micron range or smaller (bear in mind, I use diamond grit for rock, not for chisels, so I'll defer to Bill's expertise).

Soft materials are horrible diamond substrates. Cast iron is best, steel or copper are adequate - I would favor copper over steel, but you might need more of a charge, copper can have a grabby feel to it. Avoid all wood substrates - you'll end up using far too much grit with them and that defeats the purpose of using diamond in the first place.

I once made a strop out of a block of wood and some polishing compound, it worked really well - hard wood is better than soft for that.

All that said, I still just tend to use a few oil stones that were given to me years ago. Its just simpler than tracking down some cast iron or a bar of copper. If I was faced with buying stones of any kind, I'd find myself a couple iron plates instead.


Bill's post

Re: need simplification

#4

Let us start at the beginning....

Bill Tindall

What are you going to do with the sharpened tool after sharpening?

If the answer is fitting a drawer or otherwise removing wood in small controllable increments for fitting purposes then the answer to your question is that you are already sharpening beyond what is necessary and further refinements will have no practical benefit. Because you already own all you need, buying anything else to sharpen, including diamonds, is unnecessary.

If you have other sharpening objectives then be certain that the providers of advice are sharpening to achieve the same objective or you may get advice that is irrelevant to your needs. You will spend money on stuff that you don't need and render complicated something that may not be.

Re: need simplification

#5

Re: Let us start at the beginning....

eliot d

I feel like fooling with the diamond film. But I suspect you're absolutely right in what you say. Then again, although I may waste some money ($22), there's no chance that things will get too complicated. I mean, if I don't like it, I just won't use it.

Re: need simplification

#6

Re: need simplification

eliot d

I have great respect for the others who responded, but I guess I just had to have a go at it; so I just ordered the set of four films from LV. It cost all of $22 . I happen to have this large, heavy granite block that's supposed to be flat, measured by .001mm/ meter. Not sure if I believe it's this flat, but how bad could it be? What I thought I would do is stick each of the four films along each of the four edges of this granite block. And as I said, if it doesn't seem to do any good, I'll just put it aside and forget about it. Thanks for responding so directly to my direct question.

Re: need simplification

#7

another use

Bill Tindall

wind it around a cylinder, chuck it in the drill press and you will have a world beater set up for grinding away at hollow tools.

Re: need simplification

#8

David Barnett

A couple hints

David Barnett

Although I don't use these films for sharpening, they're amazingly high quality and produce truly consistent scratch patterns. Lee Valley makes it easy and cheap to try them out. I had to originally purchase mine from electronics suppliers in bulk.

I know LV suggests a light oil, and while this will work, if you can find a glycerin-based (not ethelyne glycol) lube such as Dialube 3000 or similar, it can significantly increase the life of these films. Dialube 3000 claims 10 to 50 times improvement in film life for aluminum-titanium-carbon swarf, so for hardened tool steels, I'd expect improvements in the lowest range, which are likely worthwhile for applications that cover a lot of surface area at once like plane blades.

Another thing, because these are PSA-backed, you should try to use each sheet until it loses its cutting abilities. Remounting the PSA films exposes them to contamination. At any rate, you absolutely must make sure your mounting substrates are thoroughly clean and dust-free.

If you have a non-oily static-resistant fast evaporative fluid or spray such as those sold for cleaning optics, use it. On the thinner films, especially in the finer diamond mesh sizes (0.5μ, 0.3μ, 0.1μ), you don't want anything telegraphing through the polyester. As I use plain-backed discs and rarely remount them, this is less a problem.

Re: need simplification

#9

Re: A couple hints

eliot d

How good of you to clue me in to some of the finer points! I'm afraid, though, that I don't understand the second to last paragraph. Why wouldn't one use the film until it has lost it's cutting ability? What contamination do you mean?

Re: need simplification

#10

David Barnett

Sorry, eliot

David Barnett

What I meant was once you affix the sheet to its substrate, don't peel it up to move or remount it. It only takes a tiny bit of balled adhesive or grit to make a bump when you reattach the sheet to a backing. On some very thin PSA polyester films, even extremely fine airborne particles can cause bumps. Also, some film can stretch, which does them no good at all. In simpler words; once you put it down use it up then throw it away.

I don't use PSA films for several reasons. Two of the most important reasons: contamination issues, and the thickness of the adhesive and film together increase cushioning, rounding the flat surfaces and sharp edges of faceted stones.

Hope this makes it clear.

Re: need simplification

#11

Re: Sorry, eliot

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi David

Just to use what is available in the average shop, let me run these past you ...

To ensure that the film is flat and without bumps (e.g. dust), float the film onto a suitable surface (e.g. float glass or granite tile) with soapy water. Allow water to evaporate.

To lubricate the film so as to float away swarf, I use Camillia Oil. How do you rate this?

The PSA backing is tough and hard - harder than many waterstones. I agree that it ideally should not be re-used once removed. It may stretch a little. However I have done this successfully on a number of occasions. Perhaps woodworking tolerances are different from jewellery.

The question associated with the above observation is whether you have attempted to "re-new" the film by charging it with diamond paste and, if so, what was your verdict? I plan to do this when my current film is worn and no longer cutting. Could be a while yet.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: need simplification

#12

David Barnett

For the average shop

David Barnett

"To ensure that the film is flat and without bumps (e.g. dust), float the film onto a suitable surface (e.g. float glass or granite tile) with soapy water. Allow water to evaporate."

If the tile is well-cleaned and free of larger particles, a spritz of water with a drop or two of soap or some other surfactant should work fine. I'd want it completely dry before attaching the adhesive, however. As these sheets are affordable, if a technique falls short of satisfactory, improvements aren't going to set one back much.

"To lubricate the film so as to float away swarf, I use Camillia Oil. How do you rate this?"

Excellent, I'd say, considering our constraint is what's to be found in a home shop. It shares many of the properties of olive oil, which has long been used with boart as a lubricant and cutting extender.

"The PSA backing is tough and hard - harder than many waterstones. I agree that it ideally should not be re-used once removed. It may stretch a little. However I have done this successfully on a number of occasions."\

Even the hardest PSA-backed sheets are subject to more deformation during pressure under motion than their plain-backed counterparts, but I wouldn't consider this a problem for the coarser sheets. I've repositioned PSA-backed sheets and discs without problems, as well, but there were instances where problems did occur. As I consider these films, whether PVA or plain, as consumables, when I even suspect less than stellar performance, out they go.

"Perhaps woodworking tolerances are different from jewellery."

You're right, Derek, and I'll be the first to admit that my gem faceting experiences color my personal tolerances for tolerances when switching from one context to the other. Tool edges for woodworking are considerably more forgiving and easily corrected than the metalographic and gemological applications where I use these films.

I'd think your experiences with these films in your woodshop are more germane and realistic for woodworking tools than mine, as I've only tried four grades on tools; 1.0μ, 0.5μ, 0.3μ and 0.1μ. As I already have oodles of 1μ paste, I'll stick with that. The 0.5μ film produced a more uniform-looking result under magnification than the corresponding paste, but I noticed no real cutting difference or edge longevity, not that there isn't an advantage. I wasn't methodically testing them, of course, and just didn't notice a difference.

The 0.3μ (which LV doesn't offer) and the 0.1μ did produce a noticeably higher and amazingly uniform polish on a 3/4" flat-ground chisel, but again, I was unable to detect any cutting or longevity gains, which again, for the edge connoisseur should mean next to nothing.

"The question associated with the above observation is whether you have attempted to "re-new" the film by charging it with diamond paste and, if so, what was your verdict? I plan to do this when my current film is worn and no longer cutting. Could be a while yet."

Great question. I have recharged polishing films, but not so much to renew them as to simply reuse the backings for other diamond, but never with expectation of remotely similar results one gets from these films. What I mean is, the monocrystalline diamond in these films has highly-controlled distribution of particles, micro-grading of crystal sizes, homogeneity of crystal habit, alignment, and presentation depth in the resin bond. It's truly remarkable and absolutely cannot be duplicated or recharged. These films cut more aggressively for their crystal sizes than other diamond of comparable size.

To get more use from the backings, one could charge them with a coarser mesh, but they will certainly not produce the same class of results. Besides, the fresh diamond will not embed properly into the resin layer. Not a chance. These diamond lapping film technologies are simply in a class by themselves and if you need them, they're another affordable diamond breakthrough godsend.

The films I have recharged and reused successfully with diamond are Ultra-lap, Dia-film and various non-diamond 3M films. Most of these films were factory charged with cerium, tin, chrome, and Linde A and B oxides. Although these will never produce facets as flat as other hard lap substrates, they're very clean when new, fast and convenient, just not for your best competition cuts. Charge with 3μ (8,000 mesh) or finer diamond paste, loose diamond with a thin smear of olive oil paste or mutton tallow and you're good to go. I haven't totally switched context here; these same films come in sheets as well as discs, and can be treated similarly. The CrO sheets are great for woodworking tools, by the way.

Really good questions, Derek. I enjoyed this.

Re: need simplification

#13

Re: need simplification

Pam Niedermayer

One step? That's a tough question. Woodcraft rates the Spyderco ultrafine as 2000 grit, which is substantially coarser than 8000; but I don't know what 2000 means or if it's on the same scale as waterstones, whether ceramic or not. The only Spyderco stones I use are a small set of files and slipstones to renew the edges of carving tools; and they work great for that. But if I have to reform an edge, I take it through a series of waterstones and it doesn't touch a Spyderco until after use. Again, Spyderco only or not at all.

So the question is: when you use the Spyderco last are you removing some sharp? I honestly don't know, but it seems possible based on grit ratings. This is a question you can fairly easily answer.

Pam

Re: need simplification

#14

That is interesting......

Bill Tindall

I found propylene glycol (I use in in sheep to fight ketosis during lambing) to be efficacious an lub for diamonds, especially on plastic substrates like acrylic. Then I blundered into the remains of some water soluble cutting fluid left in a huge container I bought for storing and carrying water on the farm. Diluted 1/10 it provided exceptional performance on my diamond plates.

I think some effort on determining the bet lub for these new abrasive formats would be beneficial. It is not at all clear to me what prorperties the lub should have.

Re: need simplification

#15

David Barnett

According to Sal Glesser, ...

David Barnett

... founder of Spyderco, the ceramics are:

3μ Ultra Fine (equiv. 8,000 grit diamond)

6μ Fine (equiv. 3,000 grit diamond)

15μ Medium (equiv. 1,200 grit diamond)

Re: need simplification

#16

For what it is worth......

Bill Tindall

What is now become many years ago when we were researching abrasives to use on long wearing tool steels, among the various abrasive formats I was given for trial were the 3M diamond films. Simultaneously, we were evaluating the recommended diamond paste on cast iron. The diamond paste on cast iron was so cheap and convenient that the diamond films were no longer considered an efficacious alternative. I have a stack of these films in a drawer and I never use them except to abrade concave curved surfaces.

I don't consider the LV product useless, but the small sheet length makes them less useful for sharpening than I would have recommended for hand held sharpening.

Re: need simplification

#17

Re: For what it is worth......

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I don't consider the LV product useless, but the small sheet length makes them less useful for sharpening than I would have recommended for hand held sharpening.

Hi Bill

My waterstones are 8" long. The diamond stone that gets the most use is 6".

As I understand, the 6" x 3" sheet is a standard size from the manufacturer.

When I was evaluating these films, the sheets I had to use were slightly smaller still. I sharpened plane and chisel blades on them them both freehand and with a honing guide. At no time did I feel disadvantaged by the size.

I think that the next size up from the manufacturer is 12" x 12". This would place the cost of the film in a different category.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: need simplification

#18

Re: According to Sal Glesser, ...

Pam Niedermayer

Thanks, David, very good info, which implies that Elliot is duplicating effort at the 8000 level. So, Elliot, you don't need the Norton 8000 and the Spyderco UF. You could sell one of them to help purchase a step improvement, probably something more along the lines of a 12-15,000 grit, or whatever those PSA diamond films offer (I'm not real crazy about sheets, but so what).

Pam

Re: need simplification

#19

Why I demand long abrasive formats prefer

Bill Tindall

would be to slit the films to 3 x 12. Why.....

When sharpening freehand, once I get the bevel precisely registered on the abrasive surface I want to pull the tool for as many miles as I have abrasive. I can not go back and forth, round and round, loop d'loop, etc. and keep the bevel precisely registered on an abrasive surface. It is these complicated motions that lead to loss of precise registration, and on to rounded bevels, followed by frustrations with hand held sharpening. About 3 pulls down 12" of diamond abrasive is all one needs and most anyone can keep the tool bevel on the surface for this much motion.

Other's results may vary and that is why I know I would be useless in marketing.

Re: need simplification

#20

Re: need simplification

eliot d

Pam, the only thing I can say based on a little experience is that the final use of the Spyderco adds a kind of polish look that I don't get with the 8000 Norton. I don't know if that means the edge is sharper or not. (It looks better!)

Re: need simplification

#21

polish vs sharp

Bill Tindall

There is little correlation between the reflection off the surface(appearance) and sharpness. Diamonds can leave a sharp vee shaped scratch which acts like a light trap leaving the surface dull looking or even dark looking. This appearance has no correlation with how sharp the edge is or whether the edge is formed by two flat intersecting planes.

Indeed to make a mirror one needs scratches of some small size but the mirror can be made with relatively broad U shaped scratches that can result from a less aggressive abrasive.

Re: need simplification

#22

Re: need simplification

Pam Niedermayer

What Bill said, plus all I'm saying is you can let go of one of the 8000 grit stones, you're wasting time using two of them.

Pam

Re: need simplification

#23

Re: need simplification

eliot d

Sorry I didn't answer sooner: I can say, definitely, that when I use the ultra fine Spyderco last, the object gets more mirror -like. But I've read here that that doesn't necessarily translate into sharper. It's going to be difficult to convince me, though, that it's not sharper. (It seems a bit sharper to me.) I just got the four grit combo of diamond films from LV, but I haven't affixed them to my granite plate yet and haven't gotten that snake oil that Dave Barnett suggests. When I try it out, I will post my observations.

Re: need simplification

#24

Re: According to Sal Glesser, ...

eliot d

O.K. But at least I'm probably not dulling anything after the 8000 Norton.

Re: need simplification

#25

Re: polish vs sharp

eliot d

You know, about 60 years back I actually did make a 6 in dia. mirror -- for a telescope. It took me an entire summer, working every day. It was ground from glass using successively finer grades of abrasives. The polishing was done with a pitch lap and a kind of powder -- something like rouge. Quite an experience!

As for your point about reflectiveness not being correlated with sharpness, I suppose I could see your point. It's well known, for example, that garnet sandpaper produces more shine in wood than other sandpapers because the scratch marks are more U-shaped; so they reflect light better. But that doesn't necessarily mean that more shine DOESN't equate to more sharpness. I have read that it doesn't, but I'd like to play around more with my Spyderco's to see for myself.