For the average shop
David Barnett
"To ensure that the film is flat and without bumps (e.g. dust), float the film onto a suitable surface (e.g. float glass or granite tile) with soapy water. Allow water to evaporate."
If the tile is well-cleaned and free of larger particles, a spritz of water with a drop or two of soap or some other surfactant should work fine. I'd want it completely dry before attaching the adhesive, however. As these sheets are affordable, if a technique falls short of satisfactory, improvements aren't going to set one back much.
"To lubricate the film so as to float away swarf, I use Camillia Oil. How do you rate this?"
Excellent, I'd say, considering our constraint is what's to be found in a home shop. It shares many of the properties of olive oil, which has long been used with boart as a lubricant and cutting extender.
"The PSA backing is tough and hard - harder than many waterstones. I agree that it ideally should not be re-used once removed. It may stretch a little. However I have done this successfully on a number of occasions."\
Even the hardest PSA-backed sheets are subject to more deformation during pressure under motion than their plain-backed counterparts, but I wouldn't consider this a problem for the coarser sheets. I've repositioned PSA-backed sheets and discs without problems, as well, but there were instances where problems did occur. As I consider these films, whether PVA or plain, as consumables, when I even suspect less than stellar performance, out they go.
"Perhaps woodworking tolerances are different from jewellery."
You're right, Derek, and I'll be the first to admit that my gem faceting experiences color my personal tolerances for tolerances when switching from one context to the other. Tool edges for woodworking are considerably more forgiving and easily corrected than the metalographic and gemological applications where I use these films.
I'd think your experiences with these films in your woodshop are more germane and realistic for woodworking tools than mine, as I've only tried four grades on tools; 1.0μ, 0.5μ, 0.3μ and 0.1μ. As I already have oodles of 1μ paste, I'll stick with that. The 0.5μ film produced a more uniform-looking result under magnification than the corresponding paste, but I noticed no real cutting difference or edge longevity, not that there isn't an advantage. I wasn't methodically testing them, of course, and just didn't notice a difference.
The 0.3μ (which LV doesn't offer) and the 0.1μ did produce a noticeably higher and amazingly uniform polish on a 3/4" flat-ground chisel, but again, I was unable to detect any cutting or longevity gains, which again, for the edge connoisseur should mean next to nothing.
"The question associated with the above observation is whether you have attempted to "re-new" the film by charging it with diamond paste and, if so, what was your verdict? I plan to do this when my current film is worn and no longer cutting. Could be a while yet."
Great question. I have recharged polishing films, but not so much to renew them as to simply reuse the backings for other diamond, but never with expectation of remotely similar results one gets from these films. What I mean is, the monocrystalline diamond in these films has highly-controlled distribution of particles, micro-grading of crystal sizes, homogeneity of crystal habit, alignment, and presentation depth in the resin bond. It's truly remarkable and absolutely cannot be duplicated or recharged. These films cut more aggressively for their crystal sizes than other diamond of comparable size.
To get more use from the backings, one could charge them with a coarser mesh, but they will certainly not produce the same class of results. Besides, the fresh diamond will not embed properly into the resin layer. Not a chance. These diamond lapping film technologies are simply in a class by themselves and if you need them, they're another affordable diamond breakthrough godsend.
The films I have recharged and reused successfully with diamond are Ultra-lap, Dia-film and various non-diamond 3M films. Most of these films were factory charged with cerium, tin, chrome, and Linde A and B oxides. Although these will never produce facets as flat as other hard lap substrates, they're very clean when new, fast and convenient, just not for your best competition cuts. Charge with 3μ (8,000 mesh) or finer diamond paste, loose diamond with a thin smear of olive oil paste or mutton tallow and you're good to go. I haven't totally switched context here; these same films come in sheets as well as discs, and can be treated similarly. The CrO sheets are great for woodworking tools, by the way.
Really good questions, Derek. I enjoyed this.