New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Method with Eclipse Guide

Posts

Method with Eclipse Guide

#1

Method with Eclipse Guide

Steve Corpstein

When using an Eclipse Guide (or Veritas MK II) do you guys lift the blade edge on the push stroke and only apply light pressure on the pull stroke? Trying to get a consistent method down and obviously don't know what I'm doing. Thank you for the help, this board has got some of the most knowledgeable people I've run across.

Re: Method with Eclipse Guide

#2

Re: Method with Eclipse Guide

wilbur

With a guide, I don't worry too much about pressure on the pull or push stroke. I apply a moderate degree of pressure back and forth.

With freehand sharpening, I tend to let up when pushing the tool a little, and bear down harder a little when pulling.

Re: Method with Eclipse Guide

#3

Re: Method with Eclipse Guide

TomD

Depending how you are set up on a jig, there is always the chance that one has a relief angle and could take a cut out of the stone. If that is the situation, I will at least go lighter forward until the relief angle is closed a little. But overall I sharpen with the same pressure back and forth regardless of the kind of sharpening I am doing. With freehand, since I have full bevel contact I use even pressure.

Re: Method with Eclipse Guide

#4

Re: Method with Eclipse Guide

David Charlesworth

Steve,

I would suggest pull strokes only, particularly with narrow chisels.

Control of squareness is done with two forefingers, one on either side of the blade, as near to the bevel as possible.

You do not want downward force on the guide, just on the blade, so grip the guide really gently.

On coarse stones I use lots of force and on polishing stones just a caress.

best wishes,

David

Re: Method with Eclipse Guide

#5

Thank you for this insight

Bill Tindall

I always pull simply because I have better control of the tool presentation to the stone surface whilst pulling. If I was more coordinated I might try back and forth, but I'm not. I guess the bottom line is to do what you need to do to get a satisfactory result with the tools and skills at hand.

Re: Method with Eclipse Guide

#6

Re: Method with Eclipse Guide

Pam Niedermayer

Depends on what you're sharpening it on. For sandpaper, I only pull (actually I don't use any guides), because if I push it rumples up. For stones, it doesn't make a lot of difference. If I'm doing side to side on stones (never do this on sandpaper), I push down in both directions.

Pam

Re: Method with Eclipse Guide

#7

Re: Method with Eclipse Guide

Archie

Pam, that's a true description...and one reason why I gave up on sandpaper for sharpening.

Re: Method with Eclipse Guide

#8

Re: Method with Eclipse Guide

Pam Niedermayer

Yeah, me, too; but Steve never said what he was using.

Pam

Re: Method with Eclipse Guide

#9

Re: Thank you for this insight

TomD

It is true that it requires more skill to go in both directions, particularly if you are sharpening without a guide. There is a sticky point in transition where it wants to rock and shift angle. My approach is that I want skills as well as results. Doubtless to those who only ride trikes, the idea of a bike is unimaginable. Most people can ride a bike, particularly one with training wheels.

Re: Method with Eclipse Guide

#10

Re: Method with Eclipse Guide

Steve Corpstein

I'm using 3M adhesive backed rolls in a 80 - 180 - 220 - 400 grit sequence on a granite surface plate, but only using the pull stroke and very controlled and careful. Then I switch to Sigma Select II stones in 1000 - 3000 - 6000 - 10,000 grit sequence. Starting the whole thing by flattening the back with the Sigmas.

Re: Method with Eclipse Guide

#11

Re: Method with Eclipse Guide

Pam Niedermayer

Now that's really an interesting regimen. Why do you go through both 3m paper and Ceramic stones? For all edges?

Pam

Re: Method with Eclipse Guide

#12

Re: Method with Eclipse Guide

Steve Corpstein

The sandpaper is cheap and fast to reshape or repair a bevel (I hate grinders), the ceramics put a more defined flat edge on the blade and without a doubt, a sharper one. I am no expert by any stretch of the imagination, my method is a combination of information I gleamed from this board and techniques encouraged by Lie-Nielsen in their videos.

Re: Method with Eclipse Guide

#13

Eclipse guide video....

roger lance

Steve....you might find this interesting.......

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ojzzCXq5ook

Re: Method with Eclipse Guide

#14

Lightbulb moment!

Schtoo

Now, I finally work out why folks are busy filing away on these things to fix them.

Thanks. :)

(I use one that says "Made in Japan" on the side, no modifications required.)

Stu.

Re: Method with Eclipse Guide

#15

Re: Lightbulb moment!

Steve Corpstein

So do you sell them in your store? I'm fairly close to putting an order in for several items. :-)

Re: Method with Eclipse Guide

#16

Re: Method with Eclipse Guide

Steve Corpstein

David, I know you're a big fan of the Eclipse clones, how to you go about reshaping a bevel? Assume it is trashed and you don't want to use a grinder and you're going to completely put a new bevel on it?

Re: Method with Eclipse Guide

#17

Please leave a message...

Schtoo

... and I'll throw one at you gratis. ;)

I'd held off on them for a long time because I wasn't sure it would be worthwhile selling them for closer to $20, when everywhere else has them for $12-15.

Now I know what the difference really is, and while I don't know if the cost difference is worth it or not, at least I won't have folks asking me why the things don't work properly.

Stu.

Re: Method with Eclipse Guide

#18

Re: Method with Eclipse Guide

Steve Corpstein

Just to give an update and a due thank you to all of you that responded. I finally stepped over the edge and was able to hand sharpen/guide sharpen. I'm taking baby steps and thus far have gotten a sharper, more consistent edge than ever before.

I'm using the Eclipse clone to get the edge square and the angle I want. then I'm using my lame attempt at side sharpening per Harrelson's video. I am getting a flatter, sharper edge than I ever have and man does it feel good getting this far.

I know there are those of you that hand sharpen all the time, but this is a hobby for me so I don't get to spend much time at it between work and my first hobby, fly fishing. Thanks again for all of your help both in technique and stone choice. I will say that I have put the Shapton GS stones away for good (or knives), they are waaay to sticky and difficult to use. Stu knows what he's talking about when he says to use this stone or that.