New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Why is everone worried about dishing?

Posts

Re: Why is everone worried about dishing?

#26

Re: 30 years ago

Larry Williams

Warren,

I know I was chasing wire edges for a few years before I moved to Arkansas in 1980 but I can't specifically remember how my sharpening evolved. I was more concerned about the wolf at the door than what I might want to remember in 2012.

Like others who write about this, I suppose, I was more generalizing than giving a honing schedule. What I do depends on what the tool needs. For example, when honing a plane iron with wear to the flat face I start on a medium India and first remove the wear bevel on the flat face. Then I'll raise a wire edge by honing the bevel. If I've properly maintained the size of this honed bevel, it should only take three or four strokes to raise the wire edge. No, here I don't remove the wire edge on the coarse stone.

I'll either move to a Washita or a translucent depending on the width of the iron. Starting on the flat face again, I'll first draw the iron back away from the cutting edge to lay the wire edge down and hone until both the wire edge and the abrasive signatures from the coarse stone are gone. Then I'll raise a new wire edge by honing the bevel. Again this should only take three or four strokes.

If I've used the Washita, I'll move to a translucent and repeat what I did on the Washita. The final step on the translucent is to again remove the wire edge. Each stone is dressed before it's used with an extra coarse diamond stone and the slurry is left on the stone for use.

I do strop. A 4" to 6" stroke or two on both the flat face and the bevel. This removes any remnant of the final wire edge.

My honing area takes up about a square foot and a half. Mostly because I have extra stones and slips there too. Opening the stone boxes, dressing, honing and clean-up usually takes less than a minute.

Unfortunately, most of the time we spend working on plane irons involves freshly heat treated new irons. That's more difficult and time consuming. We've tried everything I've heard of to speed the process up. I'm sure we've tried everything people have read about here.

Does that answer your questions?

Re: Why is everone worried about dishing?

#27

David Barnett

Not to put too fine a point on it, ... *LINK*

David Barnett

...pun intended.

"Diamonds are an amazing abrasive, they'll cut anything. The trade-off is that they're slow cutting because of their shape... "

Which shape is that, Larry? Cubic? Tetragonal? Orthorhombic? Hexagonal?

As I've said before, many woodworkers have unrealistic expectations about diamond hones, often concluding they're worn out at the point where they're actually just broken in. New stones cut far more harshly at first, much coarser than their rated grit sizes, until normal fracturing and conditioning has brought them into accord with their listed grit numbers.

For example, a new 600-grit stone cuts with a scratch pattern that's coarser than 600-grit, often more like a 260 or 180-grit stone, whereas a 260-grit stone will initially leave a 100 or even an 80-grit scratch pattern. When adequately broken in, a 600-grit stone will leave a 600-grit scratch pattern and keep doing so for a long time.

This has been an ongoing problem for diamond hone manufacturers who seem to have given up trying to get this through to their retailers and end-users. Early diamond stones had accompanying sheets explaining this, but it's been awhile since I've seen one. Of course, I could be wrong. Such information still exists on various websites, at any rate.

I've collected a number of stones discarded by those who would not be disabused of the mistaken notion that their hones had lost their cutting mojo. My favorite hone is the 600-grit 11 3/4" x 2 3/4" EZE-LAP polycrystalline workhorse that's still going strong well after a decade.

Another point, if your assumption on shape is correct, would it not invalidate the widely-used friable diamond for lapping and polishing, a fast-cutting highly desirable and more expensive grade of loose diamond and diamond paste, quite capable of exposing fresh, sharp cutting edges "even as the diamond particles wear down" to quote the catalog description? "So, less diamond is needed and it lasts longer."

Seems to me evidence to the contrary is fairly overwhelming.

Now, about "slow"...

Really?

Really??

" ...and they're so hard they're brittle--kind of like tool steel, too hard isn't necessarily a good thing."

That something is extremely hard doesn't make it brittle. The two can be quite unrelated, actually, as something can be soft and brittle, soft and not brittle, hard and brittle, and of course, hard and not brittle. In fact, there can be hard tool steels that are brittle and even harder tool steels that are not. In the case of diamond, it can be both hard and brittle in one plane, and as Bill Tindall put it, astronomically resistant to crushing transverse to its cleavage plane. Oh... I would agree that too hard is not a good thing, nor is too anything, for that matter. :)

"Mounted diamonds have an additional problem. The matrix they're mounted in, whether resin or nickel doesn't stand up to the stringy swarf generated when working ferrous metals and mounted diamond stones wear quickly."

I think this is not entirely right, especially in the newer electrostatically aligned monocrystalline resin-bonded polyester lapping technologies developed by 3M. Also, my rotating diamond laps are quite long-wearing, both the resin and nickle bonded versions, and I am talking not about gem material but high-carbon tool steel and HSS.

I suspect this is another example of misconceptions I've already addressed. Doesn't seem to bother engravers who routinely sharpen on rotating diamond laps, and for that matter, mostly on dry laps, which should wear even faster than wet.

As I previously alluded, diamond crystals can be cubic, tetragonal, orthorhombic and hexagonal, retaining sharpness when fractured and thereby speeding lapping and sharpening due to the exposing of fresh cutting edges, anything but slow; another reason I generally prefer polycrystalline bonded honing stones.

As for the rest of your post, I have no quibble whatsoever. Besides, Biil Tindall's done a thoughtful job of addressing the same things with which I take issue, and well before me. Anyway, I've said what I had to say, so... "Talk amongst yourselves."

Perhaps it's wishful and jejune, but I would like to think some of us, like diamonds, gracefully retain our sharpness as we wear. :)


For anyone who wants to try it...

Re: Why is everone worried about dishing?

#28

data on diamond wear

Bill Tindall


The black particles are the diamonds.

Shown is an image of my fine diamond plate (EZ-Lap fine). It is nearly 6 years old. I use it to refine the edge after hollow grinding with a grinder and this step is followed by 1 micron on cast iron. You can judge for yourself whether the diamonds have been crushed to oblivion or otherwise made un-useful. In my hands it is still capable of quickly removing the entire hollow left by a 7" wheel, which is plenty adequate for my purposes.

Disclaimer- I use this plate for sharpening bevels, period. I am not using it to restore old tools or manufacture new ones where the results could be different.

Re: Why is everone worried about dishing?

#29

David Barnett

Looks about right to me

David Barnett

Apparently (I had to consult my memory, which lives in another head), I bought my first EZE-LAP fine hone in the mid-nineties, so I guess that'd make it about fifteen plus years old. It's still going strong and I don't see why that should change. The oldest hone gets frequent use on my two favorite food prep knives and just about everything else including garden tools. If a diamond stone has been through hell, it's this one. I've added two more just like it so I won't have to carry it from shop to shop.

Really, with all the diamond I have; loose, paste, spray and whatever, you'd think contamination would be a problem, but it really never has except when three vials got crushed during Hurricane Floyd. Threw 'em out. Problem solved.

Kind of hard to identify a single shape for diamonds, especially on a polycrystalline stone, which is why I have trouble with generalizations such as "...they're slow cutting because of their shape...". I mean which shape? Maybe it's that cute little hexagon crystal in the upper left, or that tetragonal number to its right. You have to wonder.

Re: Why is everone worried about dishing?

#30

The cutting process

Larry Williams

The matrix that mounts the diamonds is intentionally soft. Both the nickel and resin bonds are intended to wear away as the diamonds fracture along David's cleavage lines and spall away in use to expose fresh edges. This is how the life of the diamond stones or wheels have an extended life.

If you have a dry grinder try this. If you've done much grinding of steel you'll have some grinding swarf around your grinder. Pick some swarf up, pinch it between your thumb and index finger. It'll looks like it's a powder but it will lift in a clump. This is because it's actually tiny shavings. If you look closely the swarf looks line very fine steel wool.

Stones cut ferrous metals the same way, they make little shavings. Some of those shavings go around the diamonds but some are directed into the soft matrix. This undermines the diamonds quickly, much faster than when working material that generates a granular swarf which is what the diamond mounting system was designed for. Diamond wheels and stones were designed for things like carbides, stone, or glass. Using them on ferrous metals greatly shortens their life.

At least, this is how the tech rep for the company that makes the diamond wheels for the diamond grinder we have in our shop explained it to me. It's also why I follow the instructions found in most machinist texts and grind away the steel backing on brazed carbide tool bits before sharpening on the diamond grinder.

On edit: The tech rep's comments agree with my experience. A diamond stone lasts me a lot longer dressing oil stones than working tool steel.

Re: Why is everone worried about dishing?

#31

Question for Bill, David, and others

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

When using diamond stones (fixed diamond plates) to shape or hone steel, do you use any kind of cutting fluid? Apologies if you have covered this question many times before. It strikes me this should make a difference in the longevity of a stone.

Wiley

Re: Why is everone worried about dishing?

#32

Re: Question for Bill, David, and others

Chuck Bjorgen

Hey Wiley -- I've been using a four stone diamond set for about a month now and have been using water only. I'm thinking about adding a bit of dish detergent to the spray bottle to help. I've also seen online one diamond user who uses a Windex type product as a cutting fluid. I learned the hard way that after use it's good to flush off the stones or they will develop rust from the metal residue. The manufacturer of these stones also recommends an occasional cleaning with a kitchen cleanser. I've been using Barkeepers Friend and a small hand brush for that.

Re: Why is everone worried about dishing?

#33

Re: Question for Bill, David, and others

Schtoo

I've found a drop or three of dishwashing liquid on a wetted down plate works very nicely, and seems to prevent clogging.

For cleaning, I use a scotch brite type pad when it's needed. I also dry off the cleaned plate before I put it away.

Seems to work well enough.

Stu.

Re: Why is everone worried about dishing?

#34

look at the picture

Bill Tindall

No metal shavings to be seen and I certainly didn't clean this up before photographing it. Also, the diamond density is high suggesting few if any were undermined and lost.

I was on the way to a class where I thought I might need to sharpen so I dropped the plate into my tool bag. Had opportunity to get its picture and seized it. So what you see is typical.

I lube with about a 10% solution of some water soluble cutting fluid that remained in a huge plastic cube I bought from a metal fabricator. The fluid makes a slippery solution and it just "feels" right on the plate.

The bottom line is that this plate has experienced several years of use sharpening CPM 3V tools. Furthermore, the class was with Will Neptune who uses a similar plate for similar sharpening. And, Will said they used diamond plates at the North Bennett school. And when Mary May taught the carving class she used a diamond plate for sharpening.

While "your" results may vary using these plates for other tasks, many people are finding a diamond plate an effective, inexpensive means of sharpening in that intermediate range of edge preparation.

Re: Why is everone worried about dishing?

#35

David Barnett

Lubrication and other issues

David Barnett

"When using diamond stones (fixed diamond plates) to shape or hone steel, do you use any kind of cutting fluid? ... It strikes me this should make a difference in the longevity of a stone."

I generally do not use lubricants on my diamond stones, Wiley, unless I'm doing a lot of work on one blade or sharpening several at once, and then, only to periodically wash away the swarf, the characteristics of which are well-described by Larry in his post, although I think his description better applies to the coarser grades of diamond than I use to sharpen steel, and more so for monocrystalline than polycrystalline diamond. Most of the time I just wait until I notice enough build-up to bother rinsing it away with tap water and maybe a drop of detergent or a finger-tip full of cleansing powder or a non-woven pad.

I don't think lubricant really does much to impart greater stone longevity, especially after it's well broken in. In a too-soft bonding resin or plating, diamond can be dislodged, pulled loose by the tug of either ferrous or nonferrous metals, although this is far more an issue with powered rotating wheels and discs than static stones. Some of the earliest stones did display this tendency and some of the current shoddier imports still do.

Lubricant is used on lapping with loose diamond grit or paste on cast iron and other laps, of course, but that's not part of your question.

Lubrication on diamond stones may enhance cutting action on new stones and uniform monocrystalline diamond filmsOn well broken-in stones I really don't see the need. It isn't absolutely imperative to lubricate diamond films, although it's usually best to do so.

A few other issues (about things you didn't ask, but I don't feel like starting another post and it's all running together in my head, so...) ...

I strongly feel it's necessary to differentiate between resin matrix and nickel plating, as Larry kind of lumps them together, as he lumps together powered diamond systems with stationary, as well. Resin-bonded wheels and discs and sintered diamond wheels/discs are designed to be soft enough to wear in the way Larry describes, to continually expose fresh diamond. Nickel plating, however, is designed to wear only at first, below the topmost layer, but once the stone is broken in, it nickel matrix should remain relatively immune to further wear. This is so for both nickel plated static stones and rotating discs; not so much for wheels.

Larry is also dead right that wheels and discs were originally designed and intended to cut harder, more granular materials than tool steels, and for the most part, still are, although there are exceptions. Even so, the exceptional uses, such as grinding, honing and polishing gravers on rotating discs, while still faster, more convenient and cheaper than not using diamond discs, can cause more rapid wear than if they were used on harder materials -- especially with clumsy or heavy-handed technique.

Interestingly, the accepted technique for grinding and sharpening gravers, whether HSS or specially-formulated graver steels, is to sharpen with no lubricant, no water drip.

Another point, when Larry says:

"... a granular swarf which is what the diamond mounting system was designed for.", ...

... I would agree this is so for powered wheels/discs and not so for static diamond stones. Even though nickel plating is employed on wheels, discs (resin-bonded, sintered ceramic-bonded, and nickel plated) and static sharpening stones, the latter are intended for tool steel use.

I do think Larry has taken what's true for powered wheels, discs, and burrs intended for cutting hard materials other than tool steel and applied it less correctly to diamond sharpening stones; the kind that sit still on one's bench.

Furthermore, when Larry says:

"Stones cut ferrous metals the same way, they make little shavings. Some of those shavings go around the diamonds but some are directed into the soft matrix. This undermines the diamonds quickly, much faster than when working material that generates a granular swarf which is what the diamond mounting system was designed for.", ...

... I would contend this is not correct for diamond stones. Undermining can be a problem with powered rotating diamond wheels and discs when applied to some steels, but less so to others, whether used with lubricants or not. Look at Bill's photograph again; see any egregious undermining?

As a longtime user of diamond for cutting and polishing gem material, stone, glass and metals, failure to draw or admit these distinctions only leads to confusion and inaccurate conclusions. It's easy to assume that some phenomena are bidirectional when they are not, and in this case, they are not. What is true for coarse diamond on powered systems does not make it so for fine (600-grit and up) diamond stones.

The simple fact that many of us have used diamond to sharpen and maintain tool edges and have done so for years without having to constantly or frequently or in many cases, ever upgrading or replacing our equipment is refutation enough.

Lastly (and back to your original question, Wiley), while I do not personally use lubrication on my diamond stones, there's little harm in doing so, a spritz or squirt with water (soapy or plain), WD40, light olive (subsequent pressings -- not EVOO) or mineral oil, glycerine-based lube/extender or whatever one prefers is fine. If your experience is that it is enhancing the cutting or extending stone life, by all means do so. I do things differently now than before, when I first started using diamond in its several forms, and have settled into what works best for me, or what I think works best for me.

Further lastly, I'm sorry if any, most, or all of the above is confusing, garbled, or otherwise incoherent. I'm having vision issues and can't proof, revise or effectively edit what I've written.

Re: Why is everone worried about dishing?

#36

David Barnett

Diamond plates are forever

David Barnett

So far, so good.

Re: Why is everone worried about dishing?

#37

David Barnett

Diamond plates are forever  -- Part II

David Barnett

The more I think about it, it's amazing how many woodworkers and carvers, amateur and professional alike, have switched to diamond in the last few years. More beginning woodworkers and carvers are starting out with diamond, too, as recommended by their teachers.

Ceramic files and slips are pretty popular with carvers, of course, but more and finer diamond files seem to be filling the catalogs lately and are usually less expensive than ceramics; more shapes, too.

With better steels hitting the market and prices becoming absurd for non-diamond products; quality natural American stones and higher end Japanese man-mades, I think this trend will increase.

While not nearly so popular in the culinary schools as ceramic and the harder water stones, diamond is showing up more than before, although I think the water stones are likely to hold the lead for some time to come.

When you have woodworkers of Will Neptune's caliber going with diamond, it's pretty clear that attitudes are changing and resistance is crumbling. There is a learning curve and it takes awhile to get used to what's going on when you've been brought up using older methods, but once the switch is made I just don't see people going back. Folks just want to get the job done; no fuss no muss without spreading around a lot of lettuce.

So in my opinion, there's not much need to convince others to try diamond anymore, Bill -- just continue to debunk misconceptions and myths. I have absolutely no quarrel with preference for other methods and technologies, though -- none whatsoever. To each his own.

From Jeff Greef's Sharpening Tools:

DMT Duo-Sharp Diamond Stones

Diamond stones are more expensive, but diamond is the hardest of all abrasive materials, so these stones will last forever. As well, diamond is known to cut metal fast. Precision flatness, durable construction.

Re: Why is everone worried about dishing?

#38

Re: Question for Bill, David, and others

Darren Brewster

I use baby oil on my Duosharp. I like it much more than water. I find it gives a better feel (yeah, hard to quantify feel, but there it is).

Re: Why is everone worried about dishing?

#39

David provides an excellent summary of situation

Bill Tindall

If you are unsatisfied with what you are doing, or just starting, there is no reason not to try coated diamond plates for the intermediate steps in a sharpening.