New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Why is everone worried about dishing?

Posts

Why is everone worried about dishing?

#1

Why is everone worried about dishing?

eliot d

I thought the idea was to flatten the stones with your lapping plate - diamond or otherwise. In the Harrelson video, he flattens every few minutes. So unless it's stone wear that people are worried about, who cares about a little dishing among friends?

Re: Why is everone worried about dishing?

#2

Re: Why is everone worried about dishing?

James Watriss

A stone that's not flat will produce a surface that's not flat. So the back of your plane irons, for example, if you put them on a flat surface, won't touch up near the edge. And when you go to the next stone, if that stone IS flat, it won't actually touch the surface of the blade up near the edge, and you'll be left with a hazy looking area, that isn't fully touching the stone.

3 remedies: Charlesworth's ruler trick, which you'll have to use from then on. Or, flatten the stone, and then flatten the back of the blade until ir's flat all the way down to the edge. Or grind the blade back until the hazy area is gone, and start again. On a Lie-Nielsen, with a $25 blade, I think I'd grind it back and save myself the time, rather than flatten it.

So... Dishing keeps tools from being sharpened, is the moral of the story.

Re: Why is everone worried about dishing?

#3

Re: Why is everone worried about dishing?

John Pappas

My logic says that a small amount of dishing would have no effect on a hollow ground blade or iron, where only a quarter inch of metal (or so) is touching the stone. In that distance, you couldn't measure the dishing.

Re: Why is everone worried about dishing?

#4

Re: Why is everone worried about dishing?

James Watriss

It's not the hollow ground bevel you need to worry about. It's maintaining a flat back, so that the edge on the back will still contact the stone.

Re: Why is everone worried about dishing?

#5

A better reason

Bill Tindall

If the stone wears such that it has to be flattened as often as some are doing this XXX$ stone will soon wear away and XXX$ will have to be spent to replace it. So, all things otherwise equal, less dishing is less money spent on sharpening stones.

But then if one was sufficiently cheap, the diamond flattening stone would be used on the tool instead of the stone and X$ spent on a piece of cast iron and a $12 life time syringe of diamond paste.

Re: Why is everone worried about dishing?

#6

Re: Why is everone worried about dishing?

Schtoo

If a stone resists dishing, it's not wearing very quickly which means it'll last longer and often be easier to live with, because frequent flattening will not be some epic thing and you'll be cleaning the stone of slurry and swarf, keeping it's performance up.

In the video you saw with Shaptons, it's probably more a case of conditioning than flattening. I don't know about anyone else and their experience with Shapton stones, but mine is one of chronic clogging if I don't continuously freshen the surface or flush with plenty of water. Yes, there are other things I do and don't like about these stones, but the clogging is most relevant to this conversation, and repeated work with a diamond plate keeps that problem at bay.

Stu.

Re: Why is everone worried about dishing?

#7

Re: Why is everone worried about dishing?

TomD

While Harrelson is one of the nicest people, and I think a guy of great integrity, the reality is that dishing and correcting it isn't bad business.

Most sharpening stuff is related to making sharpening easier, because apparently it is hard... Flat stones make sharpening easier, because the registration from stone to stone is identical. While hollow stones might make sharpening certain shapes easier, that is only true if they preserve registration. Which they don't. Hollowed stones are a sign that the stone shape is not in control, and it is not going to be consistent either.

Re: Why is everone worried about dishing?

#8

Ruler trick

David Charlesworth

The ruler trick was not concieved as a solution for a dished stone.

I like to keep my polishing stone flat.

The advantages of the ruler trick are;

that you are polishing a much smaller area of metal.

The probability of this surface touching the stone is much higher than usual, so the wire edge floats away without further stropping.

Stiction is eliminated.

Can't think of any disadvantages ! Though no doubt the usuall objections will be mentioned.......;

The complexety of the kit.

The need to continue with something that works well....

Best wishes,

David Charlesworth

Re: Why is everone worried about dishing?

#9

Re: Why is everone worried about dishing?

david weaver

That's a pretty fair assessment. Though the 1000 can be used after it looks like it's loaded, just by shortening strokes and adding a little water (like all stones, its best cutting power is when it's freshened, though), it's not nice to have the metal swarf on the later higher grit stones because it spiderwebs the polish on a tool.

So it's a matter of conditioning the higher stones, and then they're already flat just by condition.

The same thing can be done with a nagura, but the nagura would have to be picked carefully because there aren't many that fine, and a nagura won't do any significant flattening.

Re: Why is everone worried about dishing?

#10

Re: Why is everone worried about dishing?

Warren in Lancaster, PA



I wonder, could your lapping plate could handle this stone? It would be a challenge to "flatten every few minutes". I think that in traditional work the artisans use the whole stone and overlap the edges with the tool to wear the stone evenly.

Re: Why is everone worried about dishing?

#11

Yikes, that's a STONE

Bill Tindall

I wouldn't have my toes under it. What is the container to the right?

Re: Why is everone worried about dishing?

#12

Re: Yikes, that's a STONE

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I would guess it is sandstone and water. I don't have the text right now.

Re: Why is everone worried about dishing?

#13

Re: Why is everone worried about dishing?

Larry Williams

I have no idea as to the source, context or even trade represented in Warren’s image. I seriously doubt that stone is representative of the size of rub stone found in a typical early cabinet shop. Still, flattening is flattening. I can certainly flatten a board that's bigger than my planes. Flattening the rub stone is basically the same process.

Two stone sharpening isn't new. If you read The Joiner and Cabinet Maker you'll find a workman of old, when working in a larger shop, would be subject to a fine for leaving the rub stone out of flat. Workmen also flattened their finish stones on the rub stone.

The ruler trick isn't new. I had a recent conversation with a friend, Mike Gray, who served a British apprenticeship in the 1950s. I didn’t write down his comment but he said something like; "It's an old dodge. Some people back then used veneer instead of a ruler, but the good craftsmen didn‘t have any trouble with traditional sharpening." If you find you get a some advantage in the ruler trick, you're just not removing all the edge wear on the flat face when using your coarse stone.

Flat stones offer one advantage, you can use your coarsest stone to do all the necessary corrective work and then your fine stone(s) to just remove the abrasive signatures of the coarse abrasive without having to do a bunch of work changing the surface condition of the flat face of a tool. Flat is easily repeatable and this traditional method is fast and efficient.

Abrasives are essentially a collection of small cutting edges. If your stone is slow wearing, those cutting edges get dull. Dressing exposes fresh abrasives and keeps the stone cutting quickly. The slower wearing stones, like grinding wheels, need to be dressed to maintain an effective cutting action.

Diamonds are an amazing abrasive, they'll cut anything. The trade-off is that they're slow cutting because of their shape and they're so hard they're brittle--kind of like tool steel, too hard isn't necessarily a good thing. Mounted diamonds have an additional problem. The matrix they're mounted in, whether resin or nickel doesn't stand up to the stringy swarf generated when working ferrous metals and mounted diamond stones wear quickly.

While on the topic, in an earlier thread there was a discussion of wire edges. While theoretically it's not necessary to create and remove a wire edge on each grit of stone, the wire edge is an important control mechanism to make sure you're where you should be during the honing process. A wire should be created and removed on each grit. It seems to me that many who learn to hone with honing guides don't do this. I don't know if you'd consider this a bad habit or an artifact of learning with honing guides but I know skipping the use of this control mechanism results in many of the problems I see people having when we go out to do workshops.

Re: Why is everone worried about dishing?

#14

The large stone

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I am sure you have seen this plate with the man with the grosse pierre before, Larry. I have looked at it since 1973 and only this week noticed the man in the right corner. Along with the sharpening stone one can see a real Roubo bench, up to 12 feet long. I doubt anyone was going to remove his wire edge on this type of stone. I think the technique of removing the wire with every stone is rather new, not traditional. I doubt you were doing this thirty years ago.


Re: Why is everone worried about dishing?

#15

30 years ago

Larry Williams

Actually Warren, I still have around 12 block plane irons I bought around 1981. Their package includes Stanley's sharpening instructions which discusses the wire edge. Photo below.

The first issue of Fine Woodworking (1975) has an article about bench stones that covers the wire edge but it's called a burr here.

Stanley's book How to Work with Tools and Wood, my copy is the 1971 edition, discusses the wire edge in the sharpening information.

Charles Hayward's Cabinet Making for Beginners, mine is the 1955 edition, goes into detail about creating and removing the wire edge. Hayward's great strength is that he wrote about traditional trade practices.

The concept of creating and removing a wire edge may be new to you, Warren, but it was trade practice.


Re: Why is everone worried about dishing?

#16

Corrections to diamond abrasive misconceptions

Bill Tindall

"Diamonds are an amazing abrasive, they'll cut anything". ...As a practical matter this is true.

"The trade-off is that they're slow cutting because of their shape"...This is not true. Because they are hard the particles maintain their sharp cutting edges.

"and they're so hard they're brittle".....There is a common misconception that hardness and toughness are different words for the same property, or that these properties always correlate........ Hardness is the ability to penetrate, or be penetrated. Think how Rockwell hardness is tested. Think what the testing point is made from-diamond. Diamond is one of the toughest materials known to man. It will survive boggling crushing forces. In fact diamond anvils are what are used to generate astronomical crushing forces in physics experiments.

Brittle is a description of toughness. Toughness describes a material's ability to resist fracture.

--kind of like tool steel, too hard isn't necessarily a good thing......As an illustration of how hardness and toughness do not correlate a bar of CPM 3V heat treated to a RC of 60 can be bent to 30 degrees and then straightened without fracture.....because, while it is hard, it is also tough.

"Mounted diamonds have an additional problem. The matrix they're mounted in, whether resin or nickel doesn't stand up to the stringy swarf generated when working ferrous metals"......I have no idea what this means. Use water with a bit of detergent for lubing the stones, or better water based cutting fluid from the machine shop. There are at least two companies selling lots of this kind of product designed to abrade ferrous metals. Each has been in business for many years, presumably as a result of satisfied customers.

mounted diamond stones wear quickly......Not in my hands. My fine diamond plate is going on 6 years of age and I see no decrease in its performance. It is the material I used between wheel grinding and 1 micron final edge refinement so it is the "stone" that gets the most use in my sharpening procedure.

I see an ever increasing number of professionals employing diamonds in their sharpening methods- Will Neptune(furniture) and May May(carver) for example.

Maybe this abrasive has no useful role in your situation. But I can assure anyone willing to try diamond charged plates to support their sharpening needs for making furniture that they are a cheap and convenient means to abrade the steel used for woodworking tools. My opinion is supported by the recommendation of several abrasive companies when I asked what was the best abrasive for working tool steels.

Re: Why is everone worried about dishing?

#17

Re: 30 years ago

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I was trained to deal with the burr in 1962. Yes, we called it a burr in 1962. I used the term burr on this forum on Monday. I used the "wire edge" term here to conform with your use. You wrote:

A wire should be created and removed on each grit.

I was asking specifically if you removed the burr with every grit thirty years ago.

Your Stanley instructions do not say to remove the burr on each of several grit stones, and neither does Heath (1975). Hayward says to remove the burr by stropping.

Re: Why is everone worried about dishing?

#18

Re: Corrections to diamond abrasive misconceptions

TomD

Larry can speak for himself, but I don't think he is talking about loose diamonds. I have been consistently disappointed by bonded diamond stones. It is one of those products that periodically one hears rave reviews about, then one mans up and buys a stone, and is disappointed, again. It seems reasonable that some day a great bonded stone will come out, and I will be slow to adopt, but it isn't my fault, the industry keeps tossing out very poor products.

HSS isn't a single product, so probably there are some tools that will sharpen well on bonded diamond stones. The general advice in the machinist community, which realistically is the one that industry is serving, is to avoid sharpening HSS on bonded diamonds. Here is a thread with conflicting advice for the general entertainment of those interested:

http://bbs.homeshopmachinist.net/showthread.php?t=35847

Re: Why is everone worried about dishing?

#19

More wire edge

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

I wonder if there isn't more than one way to ensure that you've not left any of the old ragged edge. Larry himself said that the method of removing wire edges after each stone was preventative, i.e., to ensure that the full effect of each stone had been gotten before moving to the next.

A little anecdote....Years ago, one of the tool gurus (might have been Scott Nehring) suggested an alternative to directly removing the primary wire edge you get off the coarse stone. And that was to just move on to the second stone. In fact, don't back off til you get late in the second stone or until the final stone.

No theory was given for this procedure. But what I noticed upon trying it, was that you weren't breaking off a primary wire edge that was still noticeably hinged to the edge--and leaving a ragged blunt place when the hinge broke. As you work through the stones (without backing off), the hinge is getting progressively thinned, and generally floats away more or less intact at some point. Further, and this was on Japanese irons, you weren't unnecessarily reworking the back that had already been flattened and polished long ago.

I still like this procedure. Because once I get down to virgin steel upon formation of the primary burr, I don't want to create another blunt end by breaking off burr, right at that moment. Seems better to just keep going, thin the hinge, save extraneous rework of the back, and let the wire just give up and fall off when its time comes.

For those using waterstones, I suggest this is a good method, because if you break off the 1000g stone's primary burr, and then follow with an 8K to 12K finish stone, you're counting on that final stone to not only remove the scratches of the 1000g stone, but also to hone away the ragged place left by breaking off the burr. Seems to me it's better to back off toward the end after the hinge has been much thinned.

Not arguing with what anyone else does. Just an alternative.

Wiley

Re: Why is everone worried about dishing?

#21

Re: A better reason

eliot d

You answer seems the most logical to me: one doesn't want to waste away an expensive stone. Some of the other comments about the benefits of a flat stone I thought were not in question. My point , following Harrelson, is that frequent use of the lapping plate will keep things flat so that the issue of dishing geometry is really not an issue.

Re: Why is everone worried about dishing?

#22

Re: More wire edge

david weaver

It is the same that I have done, too. Out of fear of the same thing - that I am tearing off a ragged edge. I also don't like to have that hard burr on my finish stones if I don't have to, though I have seen people have a dedicated very hard stone for burr removal.

Even if my (mild) fear is unfounded, I haven't found any reason to remove the wire edge under the assumption that it is improving something to do it at each step. By the time I get to the polish stone, the wire edge should be very weak and just come off leaving a clean edge.

When warren says to remove it with a strop, I think he's saying the same thing. the superfine stone I have doesn't leave a wire edge of any signficance on most edges, though admittedly if the strop is fine enough and clean, i still do get a little bit of edge improvement from a strop. If there is any shop contamination at all on the strop, though, the edge appears to go backwards.

Re: Why is everone worried about dishing?

#23

P. S.  re Waterstones

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Down at bottom in regard to 'those using waterstones', I meant to say 'those using a two-waterstone approach'. That is, not using a middle stone.

The point is, in a two-stone approach, there can't be any real metal-shaping or metal removal left to do, after the first stone. Sorry for tying up bandwidth.

Wiley

Re: Why is everone worried about dishing?

#24

David Barnett

You simply can't ignore perfect cleavage

David Barnett

I, for one, find it next to impossible.

"Diamond is one of the toughest materials known to man. It will survive boggling crushing forces. In fact diamond anvils are what are used to generate astronomical crushing forces in physics experiments."

This has little or nothing to do with diamond used as an abrasive, however, Bill. Diamond fractures quite easily. So easily, if fact, that a well-placed tap in the right place shatters diamond along its cleavage planes, its weakest planes of atomic bonding. This enables diamond cutters to get the greatest yield from natural diamonds which will then be further cut and faceted into the geometries that best show their properties of refraction and dispersion. This is why diamonds and other gems with perfect cleavage must be faceted transversely to these planes.

Other gems with perfect cleavage, such as topaz, tanzanite, and kunzite, require careful alignment before cutting to avoid exposing planes in such a way that even a mild shock, bumping a door jamb, for example, won't cleave off the top (or table) of a faceted stone. Even setting stones with perfect or excellent cleavage cut too closely on its planes can cause them to split or shatter.

Without going into the intricacies of different crystalline structures and atomic bonding strengths, diamonds, when crushed on their bases, are entirely friable, a property exploited when using diamond to cut away and abrade both diamond and non-diamond surfaces. I personally prefer friable diamond in my diamond pastes and for loose diamond grinding.

Another exploitation of alignment is found in some, not all, monocrystalline diamond products, where crystals are electrostically aligned for bonded plates and lapping films. These provide very consistent and uniform scratch patterns according to narrowly sorted particle sizes.

My preference for polycrystalline diamond, especially when using free diamond particles, is to exploit its ability to break down easily enough to give a faster, better polish, to ease from one diamond mesh size range into the next finer range. I also prefer polycrystalline diamond honing stones when they are well broken-in, although I won't go into the whys in this post.

At any rate, diamond is easily and entirely crushable for grinding, sharpening, honing, lapping or whatever we wish to do with it, whether for good or ill, depending on how it's used and the result desired.

Of course, you're mostly correct in the example you chose, Bill, but it is a rarified and highly exotic application of diamond and for real-world abrasive uses, practically irrelevant.

Re: Why is everone worried about dishing?

#25

Thoughts on finding and removing the wire edge

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Wiley

Good points.

In an earlier thread I wrote about the importance for me of the communicative aspect of the wire edge in sharpening. I noted my preference for its removal between stones so as to start the process afresh, and then repeat this for each stone.

The case for the "diminishing wire" method (as you describe), which I also (additionally) use, is no less a method of communication. The main advantage is that the edge is not subjected to removal of the wire in such a manner that it may actually damage it. This raises the question as to the safest method of wire removal. How does one go about this?

I believe that every method has advantages and disadvantages. The signal the diminishing wire method provides is more difficult to recognise. On occasions when I am demonstrating freehand sharpening methods at tool events I am struck by the difficulty most of the audience have in feeling for the wire, even a moderate sized one created on a 1000 stone. By the time we get to a 8000 they look at me as though I am nuts.

The obvious point I am making is that is is difficult enough for many to recognise the presence of the wire edge alone; that to feel for the wire diminishing may be next-to-impossible. This is not to reject the method - indeed, when one uses a honing gauge to create high angles, the small amount of projection on the blade does not enable easy removal of the wire between stones, so one must use this method.

So we look at the best method for wire removal.

The images of the wear bevel that Steve posted are relevant in deciding on the size of the wire. Too small a wire will not remove the wear bevel, and too large a wire opens the door to possible tearing of the metal at the edge on removal. I have always only used the final polishing stone to remove the wire. But this only works if the wire is not too large. Perhaps a re-think is needed for the primary bevel stage?

Essentially there are two directions the blade can travel: moving the blade back-and-forth, and moving the blade side-to-side. My understanding is that the former is aggressive (encourages the wire to bend back-and-forth) and more likely to lead to tearing, while the latter is the gentler approach and more likely to just wear the wire away. Where did I read this? Part came from Harrison and then I recall reading some research from Japan (I no longer have the reference I'm afraid).

Regards from Perth

Derek (now off to the Old Tools Preservation Society tool sale this fine Saturday morning).