New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Sigma Power Select II stones

Posts

Sigma Power Select II stones

#1

Sigma Power Select II stones

Steve Corpstein

Do those of you that use the Sigma Select II stones, soak the 3000 and 6000 for use? Also do you get a slurry on them to use?

Re: Sigma Power Select II stones

#2

Re: Sigma Power Select II stones

Schtoo

Soaked if I have some heavy work to do, dry and spritzed if not and I want to milk some polish off the 6K.

The 3K is a middle stone for me (when I use it) so I soak it a little.

Slurry comes with soaking if the steel is moderately hard/tough (normal steel, softer HSS), but if left dry you should get loading (not quite clogging) which will then polish. If the steel is especially hard, then you'll likely get very little slurry at all to work with and may have to create some.

I've been using the 6K and 10K Select II a little of late as I've got a chisel that's off the planet tough (10V is play dough compared to this thing) and initially I soaked to get the back de-scratched, but on maintenance sharpening, just a quick squirt of water, get the edge bevel cleaned up and then use the soft laminated part of the chisel to break loose a little of the stone and then sharpen on that metal/stone/water mix. Seems to work ok, although it's tough going to even get the dang chisel properly sharp. Even with the Select II stones, it's taking a lot longer to get the edge decent than I like.

I hope that's not over your head with gizmosity there. Try them both ways and see what works best for you in a given situation. ;)

Stu.

Re: Sigma Power Select II stones

#3

Re: Sigma Power Select II stones

Pam Niedermayer

I've got an idea, why not change the names of the SP/SII stones, for obvious reasons?

Pam

Re: Sigma Power Select II stones

#4

Re: Sigma Power Select II stones

Schtoo

I call the AlOx 'ceramic' and the Sintered 'Select II' because that's what they originally were.

Now, Sigma Power calls every new stone a 'Select II' because of brand recognition.

Frustrating, but I can't change it now. Most folks think 'Sigma Power' means the Select II and that's it, there's nothing else because they don't know any better.

(Heck, most folks don't know there are 11 different Select II stones.)

Stu.

Re: Sigma Power Select II stones

#5

Re: Sigma Power Select II stones

Pam Niedermayer

Are you saying that Sigma Power is the name of the manufacturer? And that both Select II and SP ceramics are ceramic? Then I say they're confusing their message. If they're all ceramic, do they all have the same composition? I guess not, being AlOx vs sintered. So when you say SP ceramic 1200 (SII), what do you intend? Is this AlOx or sintered? Or are they the same composition but heated differently?

Pam

Re: Sigma Power Select II stones

#6

Could they...

david weaver

...be convinced to call the SPII range that is not similar to the sintered friable stones "SPII Hard"

?

I haven't been able to figure out what a lot of japanese stone makers are doing, and i guess it has to do with branding and inability to decipher what they intended because the majority of us over here can't read japanese and the retailers just pass the stones along.

Case study in that is the bester 1000 and the bester 1200. They don't seem similar to me. Maybe it's a batch thing, but the 1000 feels to me like a common stone and it doesn't feel that aggressive compared to a lot of other stones. the 1200 (who would make a 1200 when they already have a 1000 stone if they weren't different?) seems a lot harder and more aggressive, between my two, it cuts faster. In fact, I can't figure out why anyone would buy the 1000 if the 1200 is available, but i'll bet a lot of people do and then figure the 1200 is alike. Nobody tells us ahead of time on stuff like that.

So for the SPIIs, I think the branding is important because the forums don't really reach that many people aside from the lot of us who like to toss usesless facts around. It's like the set, most people don't want to think - they want something that's labeled clearly and packaged for them so that they can feel like they won't make a mistake buying it even if they don't fully understand what it is. I'll bet a few of those 1/6/13 sets have sold to people who wouldn't have the fortitude to navigate the individual stones and put their own setup together.

Re: Sigma Power Select II stones

#7

Re: Could they...

Pam Niedermayer

I'll bet a few of those 1/6/13 sets have sold to people who wouldn't have the fortitude to navigate the individual stones and put their own setup together.

Yeah, well how exactly do you "navigate" a stone without using it first with edges of different metals you have? And how do you use it first without buying it, aside from the odd travelling show? So you're suggesting that everyone who wants to be cool has to buy lots of stones. Right?

But, you also advocate some sort of silly 2-stone solution. Wow, that really gets it down to it. Now you've got to find the 2 stones perfect for all your edges. If that doesn't add some mystery I don't know what would. :)

Pam

Re: Sigma Power Select II stones

#8

Re: Could they...

david weaver

You missed the point, pam.

My point was that rather than looking through a listing of a bunch of stones and trying to figure out what goes with what, most people would like for a retailer or manufacturer to put a general use set together for them so that they can get a good set of stones without having to learn the nuances. And without having to navigate through descriptions and try to decide what the descriptions mean to them.

Stone are not easy to sell used, so buying them to try them out, unless it's a novelty, is not a good way to go. It's a novelty to me, i don't mind losing some time and a few bucks, but there are other things in life where I am the "set buyer" that I'm describing. As in, be a reputable seller, put something together for me, I don't want to learn every single detail to be able to get something good. That's what stu has done with the SP sets. They're great stones, and great as a set, no arduous overthinking or buying and selling required.

From stu's point of view, offering the set gets that market segment. If 100 people go to the site without the set available and get confused and don't buy, he'll never know, just like SP will never know if someone gets confused by the SPII branding and doesn't buy, because most non-buyers move on without ever saying "hey, I was going to buy from you, but someone else made it easier for me to figure out what i wanted".

Being a good father or mother or provider or giver makes you cool. Stones have nothing to do with it, whether you work with one or play with 100.

Re: Sigma Power Select II stones

#9

Re: Could they...

roger lance

David....trying to learn about different stones before purchase is what I've been trying to do....and I know it can be tiresome but I do appreciate all this input....people are learning here.

Re: Sigma Power Select II stones

#10

Re: Sigma Power Select II stones

Schtoo

The 'maker' is a company called 'Saicom', and most of their manufactured stones are labelled 'Sigma Power'.

For a time, that's pretty much all there were when they were vitrified stones predominantly using AlOx abrasive and a ceramic binder to hold the abrasive together.

Then, they worked out how to fuse Silicon Carbide without needing any binder in the finished product. A really hard abrasive and no binder in the way, great for tough steels!

A year and change ago, they expanded the number of sintered SiC stones from 2 to 5, then switched the labelling on the 13K to Select II as well. The 13K isn't a SiC stone at all, but it's got that box/label for brand recognition. Just recently, they've added 2 new stones, both AlOx types, but as they're new (and work with HSS well), they got called Select II too. Takes the number to 8. Add in 3 combo stones, and we're up to 11 with the Select II name, only 5 full stones and 2 combos are sintered SiC type stones.

It's confusing, and a bit of a mess for me since I'm doing both. For stores selling just Select II, it's easy and why most folks are completely unaware of any difference.

It's enough that I'd really like to re-brand the 'older' ceramic AlOx stones with their own unique (and tidy!) packaging. Next visit with Mr. Saito (Hence Sai-com), I'll be bringing that up. But at the same time, all of the recognition attached to the ceramic stones might turn into smoke and dust, which would be really painful for me.

Stu.

Re: Sigma Power Select II stones

#11

Re: I like having options

Archie

First, how many stones and which grits are pure preference! Stone sellers love buyers like me cause I'm curious, like incremental steps, and like to do comparative studies.

Second, Sigma stones come either "bonded" or "sintered" (I think bonded is the correct term). At the 1000 range, both are relatively soft but with different cutting, dishing, polishing, and slurry characteristics. The ones I've bought are bonded. At the upper range, there's apparently less, little, or no difference in performance. My Sigma Power 6k stone is fantastic, superative, beyond compare, incredible...have I mentioned how much I like it? Though I've tried other similar competitors, the SP 6k is the best--for my preferences.

Third, my counsel for those just wading further into the waterstone pond is this, learn to flatten whatever lower grit stones you use and buy quality harder ceramics from 6k up. A 6k or 8k stone is usually enough for most all sharpening tasks, but my 10k & 13k are awefully great to use for difficult grain or particularly on end grain! It's the lower grits that struggle--all of them in one way or another. So don't expect a magic bullet in the 800-1200 range, despite the fact that there are several excellent stones available in that range....particularly the Chosera, Sigma 1k & 1200, and the Bester 1200. One day I'll borrow some Shaptons to compare; until then I'm satisfied that I've got a great sampling of high quality producers.

Re: Sigma Power Select II stones

#12

Re: I like having options

roger lance

Archie....is your Sigma Power ceramic with a base or without a base?? I read somewhere (I believe from Stu) that there was a possible difference (of performance) in these two stones (which doesn't make much sense to me....but). That was perhaps the first real endorsement of an "intermediate" stone I've seen....thanks.

Re: Sigma Power Select II stones

#13

No great reason to buy any shaptons..

david weaver

.. with that spread. It sounds like stu's been pushing SP to make harder stones, anyway, and as they get harder, they'll work better splash and go even if they're not intended to.

Stone sellers probably love both of us.

The choices can certainly all be there while still selling the sets. Tinkerers like us always interfere with the free time of sellers and bend their ears, so they'll never be at a loss to know what we think like they will be about the set buyer who pops up one day, buys 3 stones, and then never comes back. They only buy one place, if you're a retailer, you want them clicking the "complete order" button on your page.

Maybe instead of calling that type a set buyer, the FWW review reader buyer is more appropriate. I have a buddy who is that type, as are probably the majority. When he wants something, he goes through an FWW review, finds the ratings, looks for the name of the attached retailer to the winning product and buys.

That's a good kind of buyer for a business to have.

Re: Sigma Power Select II stones

#14

Re: I like having options

Archie

All but my 6k are baseless, which I prefer.

Re: Sigma Power Select II stones

#15

Another view

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Third, my counsel for those just wading further into the waterstone pond is this, learn to flatten whatever lower grit stones you use and buy quality harder ceramics from 6k up. A 6k or 8k stone is usually enough for most all sharpening tasks, but my 10k & 13k are awefully great to use for difficult grain or particularly on end grain! It's the lower grits that struggle--all of them in one way or another. So don't expect a magic bullet in the 800-1200 range, despite the fact that there are several excellent stones available in that range....particularly the Chosera, Sigma 1k & 1200, and the Bester 1200. One day I'll borrow some Shaptons to compare; until then I'm satisfied that I've got a great sampling of high quality producers.

Hi Archie

It struck me that a comment was needed about choosing waterstones as it has a bearing on "sets".

First of all I believe that the most important stone is the 1000. This is the foundation stone as it needs to create a flat surface for the other stones. The 1000 is designed to remove metal, while the other stone(s) polish and take considerably more effort to alter the geometry of the blade.

If the 1000 is slow in cutting, the danger is that when it goes out of flat, the blade will go out of flat as well. The ideal is a hard stone that cuts fast. Generally we get one but not always the other. Softer stones may cut fast by design as they need to expose fresh grit. What I particularly like about the Shapton Pro 1000 is that it cuts everything I have thrown at it, and stays flat. And it can do this with a minimal amount of water. The Sigma Power II 1200 (aside: Stu, is this sintered or not? I am now confused!!!) is harder still, and it removes metal faster than the Shapton. This could very well be the "magic bullet" you mention.

The next step is to polish this surface. So the question that needs to be answered is "what is efficient to do this?". I was polishing the 1000 with stones that worked well with O1, reasonably with A2, but slowly with PM steels. Let me emphasise that they worked with PM, but oh so slowly that the danger was I would stop short of the desired polish. When choosing the next stone up one has to ask whether the waterstone is suited to the steel(s). The problem with reducing the stones to 2 or even 3 is that the spacing of the grits may not be efficient. Working with a microbevel reduces the obviousness of this factor, but it remains nevertheless, and will become a factor as the microbevel expands in size. So far I am knocked out by the Sigma IIs from 6K through 10K and 13K. In the future I really do not want to be using them all. I would like to reduce them to 1 or 2 (that follow the 1200). I just do not know enough about them as yet to make that decision when it comes to the more abrasion-resistant steels (the O1 and A2 steels no doubt would be no challenge with a jump from 1200 to 13000 on a microbevel).

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Sigma Power Select II stones

#16

Re: Another view

Archie

Thanks for emphasizing the beneficial role of a harder stone, especially at the 1k level. And, I agree!

I spent a few hours last evening comparing the new Sigmas (400& 1200) to my King 300, Cho 400, 600, & 1000. The new Sigmas are excellent. First, the Sig 1200 equals the Cho 1000 in every task I threw at it. Blades were prepped on 400 & 600 stones first; then put on the 1k & 1200 stones. It appears that the 1200 is truly dish resistant, as well as more durable (wears down less). I still got a better polish & perhaps a tad bit sharper off the Cho 1000, but it's really too close to call. The Sigma 1200 is a serious contender for the best "magic bullet"! Well done, Stu!!!

The Sigma 400 is wonderfully fast! Though it's results aren't much better than the King 300, but way better than the Cho 400, it's a great stone that's hard, swarfy, messy, and seriously effective on tough blade backs. It laughs at the bevel! This stone works well, quickly.

Re: Sigma Power Select II stones

#17

Re: Another view

wilbur

Archie, how are your King 300 and Sigma 400 at staying flat compared to your good 1000-1200 grit waterstones?

I haven't done extensive waterstone testing. The only waterstones that I have deliberately compared are the Shapton Pro 1000 and the Sigma Power 1000. All I'll say that it's like comparing Mercedes and Audi. In my hands, both are really excellent, the differences between the two are minor, and there are going to be big fans of one or the other.

Re: Sigma Power Select II stones

#18

Re: Another view

Archie

The King 300 is one amazingly, stay-flat stone; better than any other I've used.!!!! However, the Sigma 400 has had only slight dishing during a 2-hr session. The Cho 1000 barely dishes; so far I've seen hardly any dish from the Sigma 1200. And, the Sigma 1200 is hard, responsive, and works a massive blade back without breaking a sweat! The Sig 400 is faster and a bit more effective than the king 300. Both are good stones; IMO, the Sigma is better! I've been using a used bester 1200, too, and it stays flat really well! It's a coarser, aggressive stone that quickly cuts bevels but lacks the edge and polish of the Sigma 1k, 1200, or Cho 1000. Though the Bester 1200 is faster than the Sigma 1000 (but not as good), it's not near the speed of the Sigma 1200--unless you're sharpening knives. The less metal on the Bester, the faster it cuts. Hence, I don't think those who hollow grind will benefit from a Sigma 1200 over a Bester 1200. But, turn over to the blade back, and the clear winner is the Sigma!

Re: Sigma Power Select II stones

#19

Re: Another view

david weaver

The bester 1200 is my favorite "summer" stone (I don't use soaked stones in the winter because my shop might get down to 40-45 degrees - no threat to the stone, but hard on hands). It's cheap, too (I think mine was $42 shipped, and takeshi kuroda still sells it for $47 shipped, maybe a couple of bucks more for stateside sellers and it's never really gotten its due over here except for from knife people). And it's hard.

Takeshi also sells the choseras pretty cheap (that's a relative term). When the discussion about the SPII 1200 came up, I looked it up vs. the chosera, my cheap rear end was expecting the SP1200 to be at or a slight notch above the 1000, but the price difference is signficant. I can still get the chosera 1000 a hair cheaper delivered (again from takeshi kuroda), but if I had a stroke of frivilousness, I would probably get the sp 1200 for a buck or two more because it can be left in water. That to me is by far the biggest problem with all of the choseras - the 10000 is like skiing on silk when soaked, but it is a job that has to be done consciously with it.

But discretion (and distaste for selling and shipping stuff, and dwindling curiosity) keeps me out of all of this until there is a huge quantum leap in stones - as in synthetic diamonds or CBN becoming inexpensive in quantities such that they can be put in a binder similar to what a shapton has or a little harder.

I am also glad to see that the shapton pro 1000 is at least getting a little of its due also (it has been out a long time), because there was a period there where it was almost described as being unable to cut metal and totally antiquated.