New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Quote of the day

Posts

Quote of the day

#1

Quote of the day

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

"I have a still unused anvil (well, unused by me, used by someone else) and need to convince myself that I got it for a good reason."

David, you're not the only one who can make statements like that about tools.

Bill, more tools than reasons

Re: Quote of the day

#2

Moses Yoder

Re:Anvil use

Moses Yoder

I have a small anvil, I think 9 pounds, if I remember right cost me about $70 from Todd Hughes on the bay. I frame about 3 or 4 pictures every year and use a wire hanger with little aluminum tubes that are crimped on the ends of the wire to form an eye. So I use the anvil to hammer those tubes shut on the wire and it's always a pleasure to have just the right size anvil for the job.

Re: Quote of the day

#3

Re: Quote of the day

david weaver

Well, there are more dumb stories than that, involving the anvil, I guess, but I'll keep them to myself for now.

I had built three infills in a row using the anvil that is on the back of a large bench vise. This presents problems in accidentally marking up the plane you're building because the surface on the back of the vise is only like 3x4 inches (which leads to more lapping or leaving in stray marks).

I wanted an anvil that was flat and hard to pein planes, reason being that I use O1 for my planes in general, and it doesn't pein like butter as a brass and mild steel plane would.

I still don't have a stump for the anvil, so if I use it, I'll have to sit on the floor like i'm in japan or something (which is OK). I do have a plane that's about 3 hours of work away from being peined, so I may actually get to put it to use yet!

I paid full freight for it, it's a soderfors type (the seller told me it's soderfors, but I can't find a mark, i think it's an off brand of the same design) 125 pounder with a nice clean rust and wear free flat top of hardened steel. It did cost me $325, though, and being green, I didn't know to look for the maker's mark on it so I think I may have been swindled a little. I probably would've bought it anyway.

Using O1 to make planes, and O1 to make moulding plane irons and plane irons leaves me with a lot of flat stock that could be pounded into a fishtail chisel.

As far as excess tools, I do wish some days that I could undo some of my purchases without having to take pictures and deal with so many "would this be good for a beginner" or "is this ($10 item) going to be as good as a LN and will you take it back and pay shipping if I don't like it?".

I am tempted to just throw away any tool that is less than $15, becuase it just isn't worth the trouble.

Re: Quote of the day

#4

David Barnett

Sounds to me like you had a good reason... *LINK*

David Barnett

... although just wanting one would be good enough in my book.

Even if it isn't a genuine Soderfors, $325 is a really good price, I'd say, for any decent anvil with a "wear free flat top of hardened steel." 125 lbs is a very desirable size, too.

Apparently, you've already got some real use from it. Aside from hot work, I use my 200-pounder for all manner of cold work, as well. Forming, shaping, flattening nonferrous metals for hardware, even hammering out gold ingots for the rolling mill. Of course I have a bunch of small anvils, stakes and forming blocks for smaller work in gold and silver, but I wouldn't want to be without a 100+ lbs anvil for tool making and so on.

I covet a 120 lb Nimba Titan. There was a time when I might have actually needed one, too, but now I just want it -- I mean, look at it, just sittin' there cheesin' mad hard -- and as I said before, that'd usually be reason enough. Problem is, with an ounce of gold nosing back to double the price of the Titan, it makes the anvil seem even better priced at $900 than ever, but one can make things out of gold that would sell for way more than the material itself, and I have all the tools I really need several times over, and who knows how many years of even 2 lb hammer smite I have left in me (I used to be comfy with a 3 lb), so...

As for a stump, I kept looking for just the right one, never quite finding what I wanted so made my own out of walnut which looks nice in my home. It's an 'indoor' anvil, these days.


The 120-lb Titan is the little guy

Re: Quote of the day

#5

Re: Quote of the day

TomD

A friend left me a nice anvil on the back deck one day. A peter wright, around 120-140. I think it is a waste of time to worry about what it is good for when you have so much work to do making a forge, and buying stuff to move it with like an engine crane, lift truck etc...

Re: Quote of the day

#6

Re: the forge thing..

david weaver

.. is out of the question for me.

I never really intend to use it properly, but I will bang some small tool steel tools on it when I get the chance. I need it for the infills the most, because I have in mind another half dozen that I'd like to make and at this point, I'd rather them be mark free. It was OK while I was "learning", but they need to be better in the details from this point on.

I chose a 125 pound anvil because that size is easy to lift and move around, even for a guy like me who isn't necessarily a big guy.

The flat hard surface is essential for peining, though, to keep the plane being peined free of marks. Might be less of a deal if I had machinist tools, but I lap or drawfile every surface on a plane, and a deep mark on an 18 inch long plane presents a lot of lapping work.

Re: Quote of the day

#7

Re: You make a good point..

david weaver

... about the price, and being that it's used for infills, the flat hard top is the most important part. I would probably have bought it regardless because I didn't want to shop for an anvil for the rest of my life, and it has the specs I need.

That and being relatively heavy compared to the ASOs peddled everywhere, while still being a size that you can easily lift and walk around with without ending up hunched over the next day.

It's one of those things I don't really "need", just like I don't "need" to make tools, but it is nice to have after going absolutely minimalist for the first three planes.

Anvils are plentiful around here. The guy who sold it to me said that from time to time, he'll head home two hours away, pick up three, and bring them back and sell them on CL. He said he has 30, and his dad's got several times that, and he has no trouble picking up more of them to resell because of his and his dad's reputation.

Re: Quote of the day

#8

David Barnett

Why the marks?

David Barnett

"I'd rather them be mark free. It was OK while I was "learning", but they need to be better in the details from this point on."

Why are you getting these marks, David? Are there deep pits or tool marks in the face surface? I had a few on my Trenton 200-pounder when I first got it, all very minor, with a couple deeper chips in the edge, but after careful grinding work I was able to completely remove all face marks with plenty of hard steel plate left over. Took some work and time, but I actually ground my face by hand, ending up with a high rouge polish on the face, edges, table and horn. Metal spread like butter on it and without marks. Worth the effort in my case.

Re: Quote of the day

#9

Re: The marks

david weaver

The marks were actually from the anvil surface on the back of my bench vise. They're pretty much just from thinking I had the plane in question flat on the vise anvil section, when I instead had it drooping over the edge a little or from striking to pein an area that was closer to the edge than I thought.

The surface of the (imitation) soderfors anvil is wonderful and pock free. It should leave no marks at all, because the plane will have a nice wide surface.

To date, I haven't used it for a plane yet, but I did check it for flatness and it's just about right on with very little wear at the edges of the surface. I don't know who used it, a farrier (not sure who else would use an anvil of that shape)? Whoever it was, they were good to it. Most of the anvils I've seen have so much sway I wouldn't be able to use them, or the edges are smashed up. Either too much sway, or a top surface that's pocked or still covered with horrible rust. My anvil is brown with patina, but with no pitting on it.

One thing that I was looking for, for sure, was an anvil that I didn't have to surface or derust.

Re: Quote of the day

#10

David Barnett

For infills...

David Barnett

...I can see where a flat top would be key. When I first started using mine, flat seemed really important, but not so much now that nearly everything I do could be done on a smaller surface.

"That and being relatively heavy compared to the ASOs peddled everywhere, while still being a size that you can easily lift and walk around with without ending up hunched over the next day."

Some of those cast iron ASOs aren't even worth lifting, from what I've seen. I noticed my anvil has put on weight over the years. When I first got it, if it was up high enough I could lock my arms under it lift it with by straightening my back. Not a chance these days. Now it takes two people to move it, and that's getting much harder from whatever end I choose. I'm pretty sure I couldn't even lift the Titan, these days, another reason to not buy.

Sounds like you can be pretty choosy where you live. I got mine when I lived in MA but not a lot of old anvils here in FL. They're not getting any cheaper, that's for sure.

Re: Quote of the day

#11

David Barnett

Re: The marks

David Barnett

"The marks were actually from the anvil surface on the back of my bench vise."

Ah... I get it now. Yeah, I've done that on my 4"x4" bench block at the jeweler's bench when I was too lazy to go to the anvil, before I moved it within swiveling distance.

Pock-free is exceptionally fine condition, which tells me what you paid is amazing. While I never had anything so deep as pocks, I do have some sway, although it's minimal and never affected me adversely. I could've but decided not to bother flattening it any further. For infills, I would've completely flattened it.

One thing, because I'm more concerned with finish than coarse shaping, my forging hammers are all heavily radiused and crazy polished. They're buffed regularly and rest on chamois when set down while working and never touch one another. Of course, many of my silversmithing hammers and stakes have sharper edges and flat faces, but my forging hammers are highly unlikely to leave a mark even when I'm feathering edges on thin sheet.

"One thing that I was looking for, for sure, was an anvil that I didn't have to surface or derust."

That's a rare find, too. Lot's of stories about restoring anvil faces and edges with welding rod, and so on. Wouldn't be the kind of thing I'd want to do or buy. I was fortunate to find older anvils and stakes that had no more than a light fine coating of rust on any working surfaces, almost just a patina if I'd oiled and brushed it.

I have two small anvils that needed no real work, one 8 lbs, the other 18 1/2 lbs, and quite a few large and medium silversmith's stakes, some of them presumably made by their users. All were well cared for and cheap as dirt. I've seen little anvils that were so rusted that when the crust was removed you could even tell what it had been.


The larger of the two can be inverted and has several half-round and half-square (diagonal) swage channels for tube making, etc.

Re: Quote of the day

#12

Re: The marks

david weaver

It's definitely not in as good of condition as the two you showed!

While mine doesn't have large pocks on the surface, it does have enough that you couldn't do the fine work you can do on the anvils you showed.

I could probably surface it pretty easily, but I'll have to be presented with a reason to do that.

Before I went to look at anvils, who would've known there was so much different stuff out there? I would've thought I could just get one from a farm and that they'd all be flat on the top.

Re: Quote of the day

#13

Re: The marks

TomD

Mine has a lot of marks on it, but it really doesn't mater since anything I work on it is either going to look rough, or be ground. I wish it were a better surface, but it isn't. I do wonder what people did with these things. So many of them are thrashed so badly, which is about as sensible as a plane used to drive nails.

Of course most people don't want a forge, but for those who might, they are about as difficult to house as a hibachi sized BBQ or at the small end, a propane torch. I love mine, but I can only use it a few hours a day during the warm part of the year. I don't use it indoors.

Re: Quote of the day

#14

David Barnett

I like my wood matte and my metal tools polished

David Barnett

"It's definitely not in as good of condition as the two you showed!"

Well, they're small and that makes them easy to flatten and polish.

"While mine doesn't have large pocks on the surface, it does have enough that you couldn't do the fine work you can do on the anvils you showed."

My big anvil, the 200-lb Trenton, is like a mirror on all usable surfaces. the lower half of the horn (the shoulder), body, waist, base and feet are still has that beautiful dark brown wrought iron finish. It's impressive, but the important thing is the finish it leaves on my work.

Point is, I love polishing and I love anvils, so now that it's back in my thoughts, I might have to spring for that little Nimba Titan, just to polish it, and I will name him George, and I will hug him, and pet him.

Re: Quote of the day

#15

David Barnett

Mini-forges with torch burners

David Barnett

I'm casual with forging, too, Tom. I fuss over a lot of stuff but forges are so easy to throw together.

When I'm forging small tools, I just grab my oxy-propane jeweler's torch and use a largish tip, set it on its base and have at it. Occasionally, if I'm doing a bunch of repousse punches or something requiring several heats, I'll grab the little micro-forge, a single chambered-out firebrick with a hole for the torch, and it goes even easier.

A one or two firebrick forge costs next to nothing, can be made in less thirty minutes, mine have lasted years, and you can use just propane or propylene (replacement for MAPP) if you don't have oxy-propane or oxy-acetylene. I keep lots of drill rod, both round O1 and square W1 close by, some already cut to length, and when I need a new tool, voila!

Easy, fun, fast, cheap.

Re: Quote of the day

#16

Re: I like my wood matte and my metal tools polish

David Weaver

You never know when someone who is making an all hardened anvil in the US is going to stop.

If you'd rather have the anvil than the money it costs, by all means. You might not get the chance to make the same decision later.

Re: Quote of the day

#17

Re: I like my wood matte and my metal tools polish

TomD

I'd like to get or make one of these:

http://gulfcoastblacksmith.com/member-work-samples/chuck-robinsons-work/

Re: Quote of the day

#18

Re: Forges

david weaver

Well, I guess I don't know the terms well enough.

I have 8 firebricks that I set up to heat metal, and a 100,000 btu propane torch.

I guess when someone says a "forge", I think of a hood, coal and lots of black dust and heat.

I would like something smaller (like one of those little potbelly things with a firebrick internal structure) with less heat output to just heat metal that needs to be hardened. But that would cost money.

Re: Quote of the day

#19

David Barnett

Veering OT - playing with matches

David Barnett

That guy's a really innovative tool designer. I really like how compact his forge is. Took me a second to even see the top-mounted blower. Nice hammers, and the anvils are totally cool, too.

Right now, I'm approaching the final leg of a long-term project, building a small venturi burner crucible furnace for batching ancient-style glass from local sands, which run dark grey to black with fossil shark's teeth. In contrast, sixteen miles north, Siesta Key has the whitest 99% quartz crystal sand imaginable, but there's plenty of lime in our sand from the high fossil content, a pulverized Pleistocene boneyard.

I'm using 3100°F refractory although I hope to flux to under 2600°F melts with soda for the trials, but eventually fluxing with potash from burned seaweed for authenticity. This glass doesn't get blown, but instead is shocked into frit straight from a crucible pour, then ground and cast. Fun stuff, playing with gas burners.

Anyway, if I can rig a cheap heat exchanger to my swimming pool before the winter months, I'll have it made.

Re: Quote of the day

#20

Do you mean to tell me...

John in NM

That you actually need to heat a pool down there in Florida? :D :D :D

It is Florida, right?

Re: Quote of the day

#21

David Barnett

Your terminology's fine *LINK*

David Barnett

"I have 8 firebricks that I set up to heat metal, and a 100,000 btu propane torch. I guess when someone says a "forge", I think of a hood, coal and lots of black dust and heat."

Oh, both are totally forges. No black dust for me, though; no coal, no coke. I've always preferred gas for the kind of small stuff I do and the ability to turn it on and off with little preparation or bother. I use a small electric kiln for heat treating anything that requires a longer or more precise schedule, but for small tools and simple steels, I'll do that with gas, too.

For annealing larger sheets of copper, and so on, I use a turbo weed torch -- love those things.

"I would like something smaller (like one of those little potbelly things with a firebrick internal structure) with less heat output to just heat metal that needs to be hardened. But that would cost money."

You can use soft firebrick for that, which is lightweight and easy to work. You can even make a nice heat treating oven from a cheap trinket kiln replacement, a shaped firebrick and an inverted flower pot. Talk about cheap!. I have a handheld digital pyrometer that goes to 2000°F that let's me keep an eye on things. Also cheap.

If you prefer gas, you can make a beehive HT oven from refractory cement, Kaowool, or whatever's handy for a few bucks. If you already have a plumber's torch, you're in for ten to twenty bucks. Really, for quick and cheap muffle furnaces, flower pots are your friends.

For bigger metal, add more torches or a bigger torch (if you don't want to make a burner from plumbing parts and a fan) and bigger flower pots. Here's a site for a small venturi burner that will turn anything that traps heat into a nice oven or forge.


Easy, small, relatively cheap.

Re: Quote of the day

#22

David Barnett

Shrinkage

David Barnett

In the winter, on the colder days or at night when the solar panels go to sleep, you bet. The Keys or even South Beach, not so much.

Re: Quote of the day

#23

Funny thing....

John in NM

When I moved from Maine to Arizona, I expected not to be cold again.... but in the winter it was often almost as cold in my bedroom in AZ as it had been in ME, the house was just that much less insulated :D

Re: Quote of the day

#24

Re: Funny thing....

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I swear the coldest Christmas I ever experienced was in San Francisco. I am originally from ND, and even though the temps were 60F warmer in San Francisco, the buildings had no insulation, very little heat. I didn't warm up until I got back home in the frigid northern plains.

Re: Quote of the day

#25

As Mark Twain apparently did not say, *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

"The coldest winter I ever spent was a summer in San Francisco." (I've heard for years that it was one of his many zingers, but Snopes disputes it, see link).

Up here on the North Coast, an hour from San Francisco, we get lower winter temperatures - regularly below 30, in the low 20s now and again, every once in a while in the teens. And, as you point out, Bruce, the houses are often not well insulated or heated. The only insulation in our house* is the spiderwebs between the siding (no sheathing, even) and the lath and plaster; and since plaster is basically rock that you mix up, the walls get cold in the winter.

I can't speak for North Dakota, but our cold, ten miles from the ocean, is wetter than what I experienced in my brief time in Minnesota, and thus harder to take (the same was true in southeastern Michigan, where ten degrees above could cut through you more effectively than ten below in Minnesota).

Still, I've never had to worry about winter whiteouts, and we don't get the chewy humidity and equally chewy bugs in the summers; so I don't plan to move.

*except where we've remodeled and added insulation.


Snopes on Twain