New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

William Marples and Sons woodworking tools

Posts

Re: William Marples and Sons woodworking tools

#26

Re: I guess it depends on where you grab..

david weaver

I never had too much issue with long handled chisels, and on a lighter chisel, I usually grasp somewhere on the blade with my left hand to place in the cut.

But on something like blue chip sized chisels, I've not had an issue using them as long as I've gripped toward the handle to use them. It is definitely a bit less fatiguing on the fingers, though it takes a few more repetitions to get quick with it.

Re: William Marples and Sons woodworking tools

#27

Re: I never understood why Blue Chips either

David Weaver

I doubt they're as bad as they're made out to be. Chrome vanadium must be easier to get right than carbon steel, because even the chinese woodcraft chisels are pretty decent.

A day before this post started, I ordered a set of NOS chisels that aren't that old (marples blue chip), but they're pre-irwi (bag says "marples, record, bahco" on it).

I have better chisels, but I always admired the design of the blue chips and the boxwood handled marples chisels that came before them. And they were $39 for 5 chisels.

It's not that I've admired them because they have a classic design like an old english chisel with a hand forged bolster (they don't), but because they hung on to doing a reasonable grind long after every other chisel maker decided they'd have ugly inaccurate grinds with thick sides and they are a nice middle of the road side for hand and mallet work.

Re: William Marples and Sons woodworking tools

#28

I whack them all the time...

John in NM

As you say, it's about getting the job done, not preserving an overly delicate tool.

Now of course, I'm beating up some old plastic handled Sandviks, not a $40 fancy tool - but my dislike for blue chips has everything to do with there always having been better chisels in the same price range. I've used one blue chip in my life and it lived right up to it's bad reputation. If I had any expensive chisels, I might treat them with more caution, but then again I might not. They're still tools.

The chisels I've used the most are the Sandviks and some old Freud's the shop owned - they had octagon boxwood handles and were very nice chisels. Both stand up to the abuse Charles describes for about twice as long as that blue chip did, maybe longer.

Re: William Marples and Sons woodworking tools

#29

Re: I never understood why Blue Chips either

Charles

Well said.

Re: William Marples and Sons woodworking tools

#30

Re: I whack them all the time...

Charles

I've never understood the term 'abuse' when it comes to chisels. Why does a chisel need to stand up to 'abuse?' What other tools in your shop to you require stand up to 'abuse?' And what other tools to you regularly abuse? Why not just put a knife grind on and old, hard flathead screwdriver and whack away with it and be done with the exercise of finding abuse-worthy chisels?

Blue Chips take a nice edge and will tolerate light mallet work which I believe is the classic definition of what a bevel-edged bench chisel is supposed to be - one part paring chisel and one part firming chisel. Middle ground.

Bevel edged chisels, hit hard, twist in the cut. If you want to hit a chisel hard, geometry recommends a straight sided firmer.

Re: William Marples and Sons woodworking tools

#31

Perhaps abuse is the wrong word...

John in NM

However it gets used because it is the most expedient.

One does not use a sharpened screwdriver because the steel is not properly hardened to use as a cutting tool - if anything you would find worse results than with those blue chips :D For all I know, the steel may not even be for a cutting tool.

Personally, I do not seek out the "proper" chisel for heavy use because I do not wish to purchase ever more specialized chisels. Neither would I purchase Blue Spruce chisels and use them as I use the ones I own.

The point is that there is a demand for good all around chisels that can stand up to heavy use and yet take a fine edge for paring. Experience has shown me that there are several reasonably priced options that meet this demand, and that blue chips are not one of them.

Re: William Marples and Sons woodworking tools

#32

Re: Perhaps abuse is the wrong word...

Charles

When we're making furniture, and I assume that's what we're talking about here, we go to great lengths to inject deftness, accuracy, care, and precision into the woodworking. It's the nature of the beast - furniture making demands this. I'm not quite sure what comes over us when we have a chisel in our hands. I've certainly been guilty of it - I want to bash it through the work. I can say that nothing good has ever come out of it for me, or it rarely did. I don't really hit mortise chisels that hard either. I just let 'em cut their way through. Hit too hard in certain species and the chips are driven way too deeply and you have to end shoveling the joint out rather than cutting the joint with the chips coming loose on top of the chisel and easily flicked out of the joint.

As previously mentioned, a bevel edged chisel will twist anyway when used in this manner (at least they do in my hands). These simply are not designed to be driven deeply into the work, in "one swell foop." A straight firmer is better, a mortise chisel even better - the tolerance for bashing increases proportionally with the thickness of the chisel and straightness of the sides (the slight parallelogram shape of some mortise chisels nothwithstanding, which probably counteracts twisting in a deep joint.

Again, I think the old Blue Chips were/are classic bevel edged firmers - a decent side grind (as David Weaver mentioned) and equal parts firmer and paring chisel which will tolerate reasonable mallet use.

Folks who want to whack them hard for a solid hour would most certainly be disappointed, Unfairly so, though in my opinion. They were not made for that kind of work. Wrong tool for the job.

Re: William Marples and Sons woodworking tools

#33

While we are on this topic.......

Bill Tindall

The difference in manufacturing cost of a 1/2" chisel with the best steel and heat treatment can't be much different from what ever combination of steel and heat treatment that is used in the Blue handled and similar chisels. Could there be another reason for making chisels with what seems to many to be deficient properties? Could it be ease of sharpening, for example, or lack of propensity to break when used as a pry bar?

I am convinced that I can't find a kitchen knife that sharpens like my better plane irons because chefs don't sharpen knives the way I sharpen plane irons. They could not sharpen such a knife. Hence, what I perceive to be "crummy" steel in even my expensive knives is a result of sharpening technique not cost of production.....maybe.

Re: William Marples and Sons woodworking tools

#34

chef's knives..

david weaver

..at least western ones are usually desgined to be maintained on a steel. They also need to be chip resistant, thus the crummy steel on western knives.

If you get a blue steel japanese knife, it'll feel and sharpen just like a plane iron.

I don't know how the blue chips are hardened, but I have seen mass produced chisels going through impulse hardening and tempering. It happens as quickly as beer bottles go down a bottling line.

As far as cost, there's a huge difference between run of the mill chrome vanadium or regular carbon tool steel and more exotic steels. But the discussion doesn't matter as much now, because they're probably made of a chinese chrome vanadium steel, which makes the gap even wider than something like a swiss or austrian tool steel. The set of chisels that WC has that they used to put on sale for $40 from time to time has presumably chrome vanadium tool steel from china, and they were actually just fine for work, they just had a coarse grind.

Nobody would ever do anything woodworking that couldn't be done with those chisels.

When it comes down to what the retailers are paying for the tools themselves, I don't know if you could even get quality tool steel for the price the retailer likely pays for the entire chisel, without even having regard to tooling and the properties of the metal when it comes to stuff like work hardening and machinability.

Re: William Marples and Sons woodworking tools

#35

Wrong tool....

John in NM

Yes, a blue chip is the wrong tool for many jobs.

I will reiterate, one last time, that I have found other chisels, of the same style and size, that are the right tool for a larger array of jobs. I see no reason why I should have to buy two sets of chisels when one will do - I and many other users seem to feel that it is not outside of reasonable to expect a good all around chisel to be used for both paring and chopping and much in between.

I seem to notice that we are both making the same points over and over again. Isn't this getting a little tedious?

Re: William Marples and Sons woodworking tools

#36

Knives...

John in NM

I agree you won't find a new production knife that you can sharpen like a plane iron. What to look for is an old knife - when the bargain basement cheap stuff was carbon rather than stainless. The two or three of those that I've used took a fantastic edge. There is nothing mystical about it, just a change in materials used for mass production and a change in mass consumer expectations.

The closest I've found in new is an Opinel paring knife that is carbon steel. I gave one to my sister, since I like mine so much, and she complained that it rusted quickly and wasn't a good knife. The current consumer expectation has nothing to do with sharp and everything to do with looking "new" as long a possible.

The knife I have for the kitchen at work is one that was given to me for a camping knife years ago, because it was too old and ugly to suit whoever owned it before I did. That it looks old and ugly is a plus, it keeps the other guys from using it and dulling it up by cutting on a plate :D

Were I looking for such a kitchen knife, I'd try to find the kind of junk store (oh, excuse me, "antique" store) where the proprietor is so cheap that he'll never throw something out even if he's only going to get $2 for it. A place with lots of clutter and not a lot of valuable stuff, when I was a kid these were usually in someone's barn rather than a store front where one might have to pay rent :D

Re: William Marples and Sons woodworking tools

#37

Re: Knives...

Pam Niedermayer

Jane, Jack's mother, worked part time for a knife sharpener in Chicago. One Christmas about 20 or 30 years ago she gave me a set of used carbon knives which I immediately recognized as quality. I still have and use them, great tools and much easier to sharpen than my stainless steel knives that I've had forever.

Pam

Re: William Marples and Sons woodworking tools

#38

Old knives; a story

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

We inherited, from my grandmother, a long kitchen knife with an antler handle, that is my wife's absolute favorite knife. Carbon steel, ugly as day old sin*, never even sees a steel, maintains an edge that will cut those tomato slices you can read the NY Times through. We agreed, some years back, to be practice customers for the son of a friend, which son had allowed himself to get roped into one of those door-to-door knife sales jobs**. With the kindest of intentions, Arlene listened to his pitch and then brought out the ugly knife and just blew his best product away (they were actually pretty decent knives, considering; they were a step or two below the ugly knife, rather than five to six steps below, as common department/hardware store knives would be). I hope he was better prepared for surprises as he went out into the world to sell those knives.

*The handle, which is rotting away, increases the ugly factor on the knife. This is one of many, many projects for which I need a larger round tuit inventory; I have three antlers, found at yard sales, I just need the time to cut, shape, and mount one.

**I am convinced that having a really bad job can be an important growth opportunity for the young; I trust he learned from it.

Re: William Marples and Sons woodworking tools

#39

Veering towards OT...

John in NM

I know a guy on another forum who regularly makes antler handle knives and just posted some step by steps if you're interested.

Pretty easy of course, cut section of antler, drill hole, epoxy in (he said he's using a concrete epoxy product from Sherwin Williams). If you want to get fancy, you can burn the antler surface a little with a propane torch and then sand the ridges down a little.

I had been going to buy some unhandled blades from Traditional Woodworker and do some similar stuff, but they stopped carrying them. Annoying when that happens before one gets around to it, but then on the plus side it saved me from spending time and money on yet another CBU project (Cool But Useless - I have a bit of a problem in that department :D )

Re: William Marples and Sons woodworking tools

#40

Well, mine arrived yesterday..

david weaver

... they are from the 1980s bahco-record era (just a white circle on the handle that says marples and nothing printed on top of the blade like the newer ones), totally unused still with their prophylactics on the ends.

I kind of like them. They are not ugly like the new irwin chisels and whoever ground them understood what they'd be used for - they're really quite nicely ground, all are a bit hollow (and easy to prepare) and what I've played with them so far, they (these particular ones) are not as soft as their reputation. Maybe that varies.

I'm not aware of any low-priced chisels available with grinds as good as this and the new ones made by irwin certainly don't have a grind nearly as nice - those have a side like a firmer.

Re: William Marples and Sons woodworking tools

#41

Re: Well, mine arrived yesterday..

Charles

One thing's for sure - there has been a lot of woodworking done with Blue Chips from that era and earlier. No doubt about it.

Re: William Marples and Sons woodworking tools

#42

I've always recommended blue chips for beginners

James Watriss

Why? They're soft, and beginners need more practice sharpening than anything else. Yes, they're soft. But reground to 28-30, they hold up better. They will still work just fine. Eventually you'll get tired of resharpening, and then it's time for an upgrade.

I compare this to a guy I knew who insisted on 'nothing but the best.' He had a chest full of L-N, but it took him longer to get a handle on sharpening, because A2 is harder to sharpen, and he wasn't doing it often enough to really let it sink in.

Long-term, everyone wants to work more and sharpen less. I still believe that good steel won't really help much if it's badly sharpened.

Blue chips aren't the bees' knees, but they work well enough. And they're cheap, which is another virtue for a beginner. Up front costs to get your feet wet are high enough without paying for fancy stuff.

Re: William Marples and Sons woodworking tools

#43

Re: Wrong tool....

Charles

John - I kept and used my first set of Blue Chips simply because I knew good woodworkers I respected were getting the job done with them. I had neither the money, time, nor navel gazing skills with which to question the purchase and get stuck in an endless loop analyzing steels, Rc numbers, etc. I bought them and lived with the decision and I'm not unhappy to have done so.

I happen to have an old FW article (black and white) comparing and contrasting chisels and the Blue Chip was solidly middle of the road. Worked then and still works for me now.

They do indeed have a pretty fine bevel grind that tapers to a thin edge and are therefore not meant to be struck with a lot of force, not necessarily because the lack of quality of steel but simply because geometry makes driving a thin-edged beveled chisel deeply, with hard mallet strikes, incongruent with the shape.