New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

William Marples and Sons woodworking tools

Posts

Re: William Marples and Sons woodworking tools

#2

Re: William Marples and Sons woodworking tools

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Thanks. It's good to have that as a reference. Nice job, btw!

Re: William Marples and Sons woodworking tools

#3

Re: William Marples and Sons woodworking tools

Charles

Anybody who doesn't adore the old Marples stuff doesn't have a pulse, or doesn't deserve to have a pulse.

Re: William Marples and Sons woodworking tools

#4

William Marples and Sons question

Larry Williams

When did Marples begin using chrome vanadium steel in their chisels and did it coincide with the drop forged round bolster? I've been avoiding old British chisels that lack the octagonal hand forged bolster because my earliest Marples with the round bolster seem to be the chrome vanadium steel that folds over so easily. I have a hard time understanding the frequent recommendations for Marples Blue Chip chisels because they're all made from chrome vanadium steel. Blue Chips simply don't have much going for them, IMO.

Re: William Marples and Sons woodworking tools

#5

I never understood why Blue Chips either

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I owned a set, purchased way back in the 1980s, that chipped if you touched them to a piece of wood.

I think it was their ubiquity. You could, at one time, find them in just about every woodworking store.

At the same time, people said nasty things about the equally ubiquitous Stanley No. 60 yaller-plastic-handled chisels, which I have adopted as my carpentry chisels, because they're tough, strong chisels that you can beat to death (and I'm not alone in this assessment); and Stanleys show up at garage sales, which Blue Chips don't. If I were starting out (and assuming the same state of poverty I had starting out), I think I'd watch for a few of the old No. 60s, and learn on those, while saving up the pennies for more expensive chisels.

But I digress from Mr. Pickering's original post.

Re: William Marples and Sons woodworking tools

#6

Re: I never understood why Blue Chips either

TomD

Blue Chips are good for opening paint cans. But they will do work. I converted a set into butt chisels, that my dad had. They were OK in the shorter form with a lot less vibe. They are dead soft, which is ok if they are not used on hard woods. The problem with chisels is that while there is an infinite gradation of chisel quality, it is hard to see how failure to own the best will actually make it impossible to do most stuff. The western saws I could lay my hands on in my first 20 years, really just didn't cut. But the chisels may have been bad but they did do the job.

Re: William Marples and Sons woodworking tools

#7

James Pickering

Re: William Marples and Sons question

James Pickering

Mr. Williams wrote:

"When did Marples begin using chrome vanadium steel in their chisels and did it coincide with the drop forged round bolster? .........."

I do not know the answer -- I have only researched tools made by William Marples and Sons up to their demise in 1972 (the subject of my web page) -- not those made by other succeeding manufacturers using the Marples name -- including the blue handled chisels marketed by Irwin.

JP

Re: William Marples and Sons woodworking tools

#8

James Pickering

Re: I never understood why Blue Chips either

James Pickering

Mr. Houghton wrote:

"......... At the same time, people said nasty things about the equally ubiquitous Stanley No. 60 yaller-plastic-handled chisels, which I have adopted as my carpentry chisels, because they're tough, strong chisels that you can beat to death (and I'm not alone in this assessment); and Stanleys show up at garage sales, which Blue Chips don't. If I were starting out (and assuming the same state of poverty I had starting out), I think I'd watch for a few of the old No. 60s, and learn on those, while saving up the pennies for more expensive chisels.

But I digress from Mr. Pickering's original post."

That's OK, Bill - I will also digress: I agree with your assessment of Stanley No. 60 chisels which have been around since the early 1930s (almost as long as me!) - as I discuss at http://jp29.org/wwstanplastichandles.htm

JP

Re: William Marples and Sons woodworking tools

#9

I have a couple of those yaller handle chisels...

John in NM

I use them for trimming the cow's hooves if she won't let me pick up her foot and rasp the bottom :D

I used to have a 1" Stanley that I knocked the handle off, re-hardened and was goint to re-handle before it disappeared in the move. I had doubts about the hardening/tempering, but I figured it couldn't get much worse :D

Re: William Marples and Sons woodworking tools

#10

Why they are so tough and the demise of Stanley

Bill Tindall

The plastic handles were made from cellulose acetate butyrate, one the toughest, and most expensive, plastics available at the time(and still is). It was a product of Kodak. It resulted from experimentation will cellulose materials for use as a film base, leading eventually to "safety film" which was cellulose acetate.

With the consolidation of retail stores came pressure on manufacturers to reduce costs. Eventually, most of Stanley's customers were represented by a handful of large chains, Walmart for example, where in the past Stanley's customers were thousands of local hardware stores. When Stanley sold mostly to hardware stores Stanley largely determined the quality of the product. In the end Walmart determined the quality of the product. Walmart would "suggest" a target price for a chisel and manufacturers were left to see who could meet it, usually by lowering quality. Needless to say expensive cellulose butyrate was an early casualty of the price wars between Walmart and hardware stores.

Maybe it is not all bad. Consumers that don't care or don't know can buy a cheap chisel at Walmart. and this junk has spawned a number of boutique companies making quality stuff for the discerning customer.

Re: William Marples and Sons woodworking tools

#11

Greenlee Hardwear Chisels

Patrick gibbons

My green plastic-handled Greenlees also have good steel. I did have a handle crack on me like it had brittled with age. While one may dislike their grinding, their steel can't be faulted. The patented handle was an innovation that benefitted carpenters more than cabinetmakers.

Re: William Marples and Sons woodworking tools

#12

Re: Why they are so tough and the demise of Stanle

TomD

Now that Kodak is gone, can we count on Apple to do as much to drive innovation in chisels? Interesting stuff Bill.

Chisels are a moving target. It isn't necessarily a lower quality product just because it doesn't meet the needs of cabinetmakers and tool snobs.

Re: William Marples and Sons woodworking tools

#13

James Pickering

Re: Why they are so tough and the demise of Stanle

James Pickering

Excellent information Mr. Tindall.

JP

Re: William Marples and Sons woodworking tools

#14

I had always assumed....

John in NM

That the softness of the chisels was due to the lawyerly fears of Stanley's counsel more than cost cutting, but it could be either really.

That yellow handle I took off was indeed some tough stuff :D

Re: William Marples and Sons woodworking tools

#15

no need for Apple.....

Bill Tindall

The chemicals part of Kodak, the part that invented chisel plastic as well as cyanoacrylate adhesive (crazy glue), was separated from Kodak in hte mid 1990's and it thrives today under the name of Eastman Chemical. The screw driver plastic is still made but its main market is an additive to automotive paint where it aligns the metallic flake thereby providing a more mirrored appearance. It is also the film former in "butyrate" lacquer.

Re: William Marples and Sons woodworking tools

#16

Re: no need for Apple.....

TomD

Bill, I think I need you on speed dial! :)

Re: William Marples and Sons woodworking tools

#17

Re: I had always assumed....

TomD

How would that help? You can cut yourself with very soft metal, in fact the broadheads in archery are about 52C.

I always assumed that they were soft so they would be easily sharpened, and possibly by a file. Such chisels work great for softwood. like doors etc...

Also, while any big maker probably is doing it differently from Joe Blacksmith, it is conventionally more expensive to make softer metals, since the tempering is done at higher heat, but presumably they have a single stage process.

Re: William Marples and Sons woodworking tools

#18

Not a question of cutting...

John in NM

Harder tools are more likely to fracture when mis-used, hence all the weird cautions about using eye protection when doing virtually anything any more (the back of my sheets of sandpaper suggest eye, ear, and face protection for heavens sake :D )

That the typical usage is unlikely to result in high speed shards is a subtlety seemingly beyond many product liability lawyers :D

Re: William Marples and Sons woodworking tools

#19

Re: I never understood why Blue Chips either

Charles

Maybe 'ole Ian Kirby can chime in - that's all he's pictured using in his dovetailing book and practically every article I've seen him do in multiple woodworking magazines in which a chisel is involved - it's always a Blue Chip.

I'm on my third set (for certain sizes). I don't wail on paring chisels though. Which is what they are. They respond much more kindly to a gentle persuasion with a mallet. Some guys hit chisels like they're driving grade stakes with a sledgehammer in July in Arizona. I've never understood it. I'd surmise that there is a hefty percentage of woodworkers who overpower bevel-edged chisels when using a mallet.

Re: William Marples and Sons woodworking tools

#20

Re: I never understood why Blue Chips either

Pam Niedermayer

I was building a chair at Homestead some years ago when I broke a brand new Funahiro mortising chisel (apparently a forging fault according to Hida) in some walnut. The school, run by Paul Sellers at the time, had Blue Chips, which worked fine for this job. So my guess is that some of them were very good.

Pam

Re: William Marples and Sons woodworking tools

#21

And why not....?

Bill Tindall

"overpower bevel-edged chisels when using a mallet." In the class I took with Will Neptune Will employed a yellow handled Stanley and smart whacks of the mallet to blast out the bulk of the waste and then pared to the base line with a finely honed chisel. The objective was to get the job done and the tool was selected for this objective. Others may prefer a different approach but it is a preference not a requirement limited by availability of a chisel to equal the task.

Re: William Marples and Sons woodworking tools

#22

Anyone considering Blue Chips ......

Bill Tindall

they are especially top heavy. They have "leaden" handles and long blades. I got such hand cramps from using them for chopping dovetails that it was a must that they be replaced.

I have noticed that all the professional woodworkers I have encountered in the past few years use short chisels for chopping dovetails so apparently I am not alone in gravitating to this feature.

Re: William Marples and Sons woodworking tools

#23

Re: I never understood why Blue Chips either

Charles

I've certainly been 'lucky' with the 3 sets I've owned - all pre-Irwin. Rather I should say that I guess it's luck based on the fisking these chisels usually get on all the woodworking forums.

I think that maybe the guys who are dissatisfied are grinding and honing them at a fairly low angle and then beating hell out of them. This is one of those circumstances in life, in other endeavors, and in woodworking, where you slow down in order to speed up. Putting a kill shot on a chisel is not the way to work rapidly and effectively.

Re: William Marples and Sons woodworking tools

#24

Re: Anyone considering Blue Chips ......

Pam Niedermayer

Yeah, they were way too long; but in an emergency the one mortiser did the job. I wasn't recommending them in general.

Pam

Re: William Marples and Sons woodworking tools

#25

Re: And why not....?

Charles

Well, the answer is obvious is it not? Some people may not choose to work in this manner by putting in an inventory of beater chisels.

One can certainly buy a steel-capped carpenter's butt chisel, grind and hone at 35*+ and wail away to their own delight.

I've used mortise chisels for bulk waste removal on many occasions. It makes sense if the going is tough. I still don't beat the mess out of them though - just a slightly harder tap than I'd give a Blue Chip.

All FWIW - I ain't no Will Neptune that's for sure.