New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Having a hard time with my wood plane

Posts

Re: Having a hard time with my wood plane

#26

Re: What is a "double iron"?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

A double iron is a plane iron and a cap iron used to control tear out on woods with grain reversals. They can be screwed together as in a Bailey plane or just wedged together as in some Japanese planes. In experienced hands, the double iron eliminates the need for high angle planes.


Re: Having a hard time with my wood plane

#27

Thanks

Bill Tindall

that ties in with a Japanese publication on a planing study that Steve Elliot and I are working on translating to English. Stay tuned......

Re: Having a hard time with my wood plane

#28

Re: Side sharpening

eliot d

Have you seen the Harrelson DVD on Side sharpening? (If you have been doing it for years, you may be able to teach him a few things.) For me, a relative newbe, his method seems just about perfect-- and it really is easy. I suppose the most difficult aspect is what he calls getting the "sharpening swing" right when doing the bevel, in analogy to getting a golf swing down pat. But even I really don't find it difficult. The only, perhaps controversial, aspect is what he calls 'joining' the edge, where just about at the end of the process, when the blade is really extremely sharp but with a wire edge, he actually slides the edge with almost no pressure facing perpendicular INTO the stone to remove the wire. I posted a question here about this when I first heard about this joining but before I saw the video.

What stuck in my mind after watching that Swiss video was what looked like an extremely abbreviated sharpening procedure on ONE not very special looking stone -- and then planing beautifully with the result!

Re: Having a hard time with my wood plane

#29

Re: Side sharpening

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Some years ago now I wrote a review of the Sharp Skate and in this provided a pictorial of Side Sharpening.

http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ToolReviews/Side%20Sharpening%20and%20The%20Sharp%20Skate.html

I recall coming across research (in Japan) that demonstrated that the side sharpening method produced stronger edges than front-and-back. i assumed that this was due to the absence of micro serrations to the bevel edge.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Having a hard time with my wood plane

#30

Re: Side sharpening

Pam Niedermayer

Glad to hear all is well with your Krenov.

On the side sharpening, are you using a sharp skate?

Note, Tom and I attended at least one seminar at Harrelson's some years ago, probably Oct 2002, before he started selling the sharp skate; and Harrelson wasn't side sharpening at that time. I guess that started later. At any rate, I think Tom was asking what is the method you define as side sharpening, so many descriptions floating around and relatively few methods. :) I'm never sure what anyone means by side sharpening, but my interpretation is sharpening with the bevel parallel to the long sides of the stone, moving the blade up and down the stone, while keeping the bevel parallel.

Pam

Re: Having a hard time with my wood plane

#31

Re: What is a "double iron"?

david weaver

I am inclined to agree with warren, though my experience with which planes are actually capable of feeding with the iron tuned and set properly has been less than stellar (especially in regard to late 19th and early 20th century wooden planes, where the second iron is in horrible shape with its original milling marks, i.e., there was much work left for the craftsman in terms of bring the second iron in to shape).

Cheap metal bench planes with standard chipbreakers have been fine, though, at working anything I've worked in any direction without tearing out like they would if the iron wasn't properly set.

Convenience still has me leaning toward a single iron, steeper pitch and a tight mouth, though, but planes of that quality cost money or time (i've spent the time and money already though).

How does one set a japanese chipbreaker that tight? I can't see well enough down into the mouth of my japanese planes to actually set them as precisely as they need to be set to do that work.

Re: Having a hard time with my wood plane

#32

Positioning a chipbreaker in a Japanese plane

wilbur

There are two ways of setting a Japanese chipbreaker tight that I know of.

The first involves holding the plane over a light source so that the light comes up through the mouth. If you have good eyes and hold it at the right angle, you can see the change in the reflection of the light off the blade and the chipbreaker as you tap it closer to the edge. This takes some practice, and I can't do this with all of my planes because of how close the top part of the throat is to the chipbreaker. That's probably a technique issue on my part, because if a shaving can make it through, so should light.

The other method I've used is to take the plane blade and chipbreaker out, set the chipbreaker on the plane blade where you want it, and mark where the top of the chipbreaker sits on the plane blade. I've used a fine Sharpie to mark the top corner positions of the chipbreaker, and blue tape to mark the top edge. Then put the blade back in, and put the chipbreaker so that it lines up with your mark. There's probably some error involved in this, but it works pretty well.

Usually I just leave it out altogether. It's a lot less trouble that way.

Re: Having a hard time with my wood plane

#33

Re: Positioning a chipbreaker in a Japanese plane

david weaver

>>leave it out<<

That's basically what I do, because I haven't used my planes on anything other than curly maple, and when they're sharp, even that doesn't bother an 8/10 bu plane when smoothing.

I think a lot of my ledged dais are pretty tightly made around the mouth area, which makes seeing into the critical areas pretty difficult. It's pretty easy to set a chipbreaker on a western plane at 3 or 4 thousandths, but even with a sharpie, difficult to get that kind of accuracy (which is critical to function) deep in the dai on a nicely manufactured plane.

I almost always use a chipbreaker if the shavings are heavy, though, else they get hung up on the crosspin.

Every single "good" (japanese) plane I have gotten, perhaps that's 5, has ended up with a chipbreaker tight in the dai due to shrinkage, which I've always remedied with a belt grinder (on the side of the chipbreaker), which is yet more reason to leave them out.

Re: Having a hard time with my wood plane

#34

Re: Side sharpening

eliot d

Pam, I don't own a Sharp Skate; I just did my best to follow Harrelson's freehand side sharpening method. From a purely geometrical/ physics standpoint, the side method seems better for plane irons than the usual way because one has the entire width of the iron for leverage against rocking. I suspect that no matter how careful I would try to be in the usual way, there's bound to be some front-to-back rocking with only a narrow bevel for leverage; and it would seem this problem especially so for a thin blade. I know experienced workers manage in the usual way to get a feel for the bevel flat on the stone with practice, but it seems to me that the side method more or less guarantees some success right away. Thank you for your encouragement.

Re: Having a hard time with my wood plane

#35

Re: Side sharpening

Pam Niedermayer

I think it's great that you've found a method that works. That's a very good thing to do. Go forth and sharpen. :)

Pam

Re: Having a hard time with my wood plane

#36

Re: Positioning a chipbreaker in a Japanese plane

TomD

The way I do it is to just put the blade in to the level I want, then drop the sub-blade in. I keep setting the sub-blade in lower while trying a pass, when the shaving shoots straight up in the air, limp, I stop. I do think the Japanese system is superior in allowing the SB to be independently adjusted down, on the fly.

Re: Having a hard time with my wood plane

#37

Re: Result.  Well done!

eliot d

How nice of you to congratulate me on finally getting the plane to work right! I know you had no motive, but anyway, I just ordered your "collection". Not even sure what's in it: looked like some videos and some books. Possibly somewhat redundant because I have the Harrelson video on Side Sharpening, which I found extremely useful ( even if it is a shameless plug for Shaptons.) All this hand tool stuff is a bit new to me; I'm really a turner (something similar to David Ellsworth hollow vessels.) I find myself spending more and more time sharpening blades and tuning my two wood Krenov-style planes and enjoying it.