New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Having a hard time with my wood plane

Posts

Having a hard time with my wood plane

#1

Having a hard time with my wood plane

eliot d

I've made two wood Krenov a-style planes, one, years ago with David Fink, and another one just recently. They're both pretty much the same, but the new one just doesn't work well. Shavings ALWAYS jam. I posted here about it a while back, and someone suggested that I widen the mouth. I did it, but that didn't help at all; and I notice that the old, better one, has a much narrower mouth anyway -- just a hair, actually. And that one doesn't jam. I have sharpened both irons exactly the same way, and the geometry of the planes is the same -- EXCEPT for one aspect; and I am asking here if this is the problem: when I widened the mouth on the new plane, that process created a small vertical "wall" on the angled slope opposite the blade edge (the 62 degree angle.) This "wall" is about 1/4 in. high. That's the only real difference I can see. If this is the problem, then it would appear that widening the mouth can always cause trouble( which I've not heard.) And if this is the problem, then I can't see an easy way to fix it -- short of cutting it all apart and getting rid of the "wall". Has anyone experienced something like this?

Re: Having a hard time with my wood plane

#2

Re: Having a hard time with my wood plane

wilbur

I'm having a hard time picturing what you mean by a vertical wall. But in general, when I've ran into wooden planes that jam, the most common reason is that the throat of the plane isn't opening in a smooth fashion, or worse, is actually closing in spots.

Re: Having a hard time with my wood plane

#3

Re: Having a hard time with my wood plane

Jim Crammond

In my experience, when shavings jam and and there is an open mouth, the shaving is hitting an obstruction such as the cap iron or the wedge. It doesn't take much and the shaving crumples, causing the subsequent shavings to jam behind it.

Jim in Monroe, MI

Re: Having a hard time with my wood plane

#4

Re: Having a hard time with my wood plane

eliot d

Picture the plane when it's first glued up with the iron in it , but the mouth is so narrow that the cutting edge of the iron hits the 62 degree face of the large triangular section in the middle of the plane body; so there is no room at all. So you take the iron out and file or cut to open the mouth, and you file in a direction perpendicular to the sole. Now there is a little ledge, what I called a "wall" along the mouth opening going straight "up" that face of the triangular opening. (I'm not referring to the wedge that holds in the iron; I mean the large triangular wedge that you cut at first to make the plane body.)

Re: Having a hard time with my wood plane

#5

Re: Having a hard time with my wood plane

John Pappas

I'll take a stab at this. Move the chip breaker back some. If that solves the problem, then I would think your 'wall' needs to be angled some....making some clearance for the chip breaker, without opening the mouth more.

Re: Having a hard time with my wood plane

#6

Re: Having a hard time with my wood plane

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Eliot

It sounds to me that this "ledge" or "wall" at the mouth is encouraging shavings to move straight up, and then they curl back towards the wedge. It may just be too high to prevent them moving onto the escapement. What you can do is add a small bevel to the top of the "wall", thereby lowering it.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Having a hard time with my wood plane

#7

craigd

Re: Having a hard time with my wood plane

craigd

If I understand "wall" correctly (the front of the mouth is perpendicular to the sole), that is fine (all my planes are like that, on some the wall is ¼"). You can even have the mouth parallel to the blade (some Japanese planes).

I don't have any suggestions other than check for chatter - if the blade isn't bedded solidly, it can dig in and create a huge chip that will jam.

Re: Having a hard time with my wood plane

#8

Re: Having a hard time with my wood plane

Pam Niedermayer

Only time I've had jams in a wooden plane I was advised to sharpen the blade. It worked.

Pam

Re: Having a hard time with my wood plane

#9

Re: Having a hard time with my wood plane

TomD

+1 with Craig on that. I always put a little wall there, or a return. The reason is that if the plane actually sees some serious wear, then the mouth will not open if the sole is reduced in thickness. So as said it should not cause any difficulty. I don't doubt one could evolve a geometry where this was a problem, some combination, but it would not be typical. Also, even with a "wall" you can polish if up smooth, wax, it, round over any sharp corners (othert than the mouth/sole itself)

The most common Krenov fault is the position of the crosspin, or it's dimensions. One really has to standardize these details from the book, or a successful model. I have two gauges, a taper that represents the wedge, and a parallel piece that represents the gape between the pin and the ramp. The pin needs to be correctly dimensions, located the correct height above the sole, the correct space for the ramp/blade combo. I realize you mentioned everything was identical, but I have seen this get away from people. I have been making these and teaching them since the late 70s.

Can you watch the plane from the top and see where the shavings are holding up?

The way Krenov actually showed making planes in his book was that when establishing the position of the parts prior to glue-up, he would hold the blade about 1/8 above the sole while lying on the ramp. Then he would close the angled mouth block till it touched the blade. The result is that the mouth actually starts under the point of the blade. So by the time the mouth is filed open enough to take a shaving, the angle above the mouth will be quite a bit steeper than the primary angle. Not a "wall", but getting closer to one than the primary angle would suggest.

I hate to mark a book, but the mouth angle was not given in my Krenov book, so I gently drew in some lines and measured it. The mouth was 72 degrees, so with the opening he did the "wall" of the mouth would be steeper still. Pretty close to where you are.

Over the years, I have come to prefer a plane with a vertical mouth, and much lower angled primary angle, but the original format does work. I did notice, though, in the Krenov plane making video, that the operators at the school, filmed in the video, have to use their fingers to clear the plane cavity with virtually every pass, which suggests a bad design.

Re: Having a hard time with my wood plane

#10

Re: Having a hard time with my wood plane

wilbur

Got it. I also found David Finck's article on making a Krenov plane, which helped me figure out your situation.

How close is the wall to your chipbreaker or your wedge? If it's too close, or if the passage between the wall and your chipbreaker/wedge doesn't continuously open, shavings will jam. I had a plane that did this, and figured out that the issue was that the throat area just above the mouth was not quite parallel with the plane blade (this was a single iron plane, with no chipbreaker), and in fact narrowed a little as the shaving tried to pass through the throat of the plane. Plus, there was a rough area as well. Both of these things caused shavings to jam. When I filed the throat area back just a little, not to open the mouth, but to smooth out the passageway and to get it to continuously widen, it was unbelievable how the shaving started shooting out of that plane. It was not a subtle change.

Re: Having a hard time with my wood plane

#11

Re: Having a hard time with my wood plane

david charlesworth

No one has mentioned the front edge of the chipbreaker, (if there is one).

These are always sold unfinished. We need;

Perfect fit to blade back.

Top surface polished and creating a sharp edge where it meets underside.

The angle of this top surface must not exceed 45 degrees at front.

Any hint of a square edge at the front is liable to cause choking.

Best wishes,

David

Re: Having a hard time with my wood plane

#12

Ditto

Bill Tindall

same experience. I have a high angle LN 5 1/2 and if I don't get the chip breaker just right it jams. In a wooden plane the problem could be chipbreaker or wedge. The higher bed angle planes I have seem more prone to jamming.

Re: Having a hard time with my wood plane

#13

Had the same experience

Bill Tindall

I was bedeviled by jamming and stubbornly refused to believe such a simple thing would be the source of the problem. Finally shaped and polished the chip breaker and become a believer.

Re: Having a hard time with my wood plane

#14

Re: Had the same experience

david charlesworth

Bill,

referring to your earlier post, there is a potential issue with high angle frogs.

With a standard frog, and a square front edge to the throat, a 45 degree front edge chipbreaker works well and can be set as close as one wants. (for fine finishing)

Now with a 55 degree frog, either the front edge of throat can be filed 10 degrees forwards, or the front edge of the chipbreaker can be prepared at no more than 35 degrees. This will be easy with the L-N new improved chipbreaker.

(If this is not clear a crossection drawing helps).

Best wishes,

David

Re: Having a hard time with my wood plane

#15

Re: Had the same experience

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi David

With a woodie - since we the thread involves a problem with a woodie - especially one with a high angle frog (say around the half-pitch range), I think that a cap iron is just asking for trouble. This is a time for a single, thick iron. This is a rule followed by all of the planemakers I can think of: HNT Gordon, Holtey in the 11SA, Brese in his version of this plane, and Old Street.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Having a hard time with my wood plane

#16

Indeed

Bill Tindall

One might guess that the "New improved chip breaker" resulted from the fact that the old style didn't with the high angle frog. The new chip breaker was shipped on planes shortly after I bought mine with its old chip breaker. When I discovered this flaw I tried taking advantage of LN legendary customer service and offered to exchange mine for the new style, but my generous offer was refused. And I haven't bought anything from them since.

Re: Having a hard time with my wood plane

#17

Re: Indeed

TomD

Blades can create a lot of trouble. He mentioned his planes are similar, if they share the same blade just switch them. Or run the plane without the chip breaker, or pull it way up. With a wedged plane you can do all that stuff pretty easily.

You can also get material wedged under the front of the wedge. Most of these issues are pretty obvious. The plane feels dull, it has shaving bits jammed under various parts, and so forth. How tall is the jam. If it is jamming at the mouth, or the chip breaker, it probably isn't going to be jammed full of material up to the crosspin.

Blade projection makes a difference in some planes, they work well with some cuts and not others. I think he mentioned trying to make a fine cut plane, different problems than a rough plane.

What kind of chip breaker does it have. I prefer the sub-blade style. Don't mind the Hock ones, but some of the ones for metal planes turn the shaving too hard for some wooden planes.

It would help to have some pics of the plane jammed, and of the plane parts, but I guess we would have those if they are easily available.

Re: Having a hard time with my wood plane

#18

double irons

Larry Williams

There's more than one reason traditional steeper pitches vanished when the double iron was introduced.

Re: Having a hard time with my wood plane

#19

Re: Having a hard time with my wood plane

eliot d

Thanks all! Would you believe that I did most of what was recommended, and the plane works fine now! Here's my attempt to "give back" what information I can. (I have to assume that not EVERYONE is more experienced than I am so that they can benefit.) First off, I don't think that "wall" was a big deal after all. Still, I smoothed it up and angled it back a bit. I began to see that the pin was too big, so I chiseled and rasped it to a smaller shape. I also was having trouble getting the wedge out; so I sanded it and reshaped it a bit until it went in and out more smoothly, while still holding the iron well. I tried moving the cap back just to see what would happen, and sure enough there was a slight improvement. So I smoothed the rounded forward part with a high speed wire wheel, followed up with honing on a hard felt wheel with stainless steel powder( the grey stuff) and made sure that the down side of the cap was smooth and in perfect contact with the iron all along the front edge. I polished that , too. It's about 1/16 in back from the edge. I then took Pam's advice and resharpened the iron. Believe it or not, the plane works beautifully now.

Incidentally, I got Harrelson's DVD on Side Sharpening and followed his directions almost to the letter to sharpen the iron. I say.'almost' because I don't have Shapton stones; mine are Norton. I use 1000, 4000, and 8000 and the Norton flattening stone to lap the stones with lots of water, just the way he does. I even built a glass-bottomed sharpening station that looks like the one in the video. After sharpening for a bit, I find that I just need the 1000 and 8000. I think this may be useful information to someone contemplating purchasing the Shaptons, and the diamond glass flatting plate, which are really expensive. The Norton system seems to work beautifully at less expense. Harrelson uses 1000, 8000. 16000 and even 30,000 grit Shapton stones. But my plane works great now with my more modest sharpening equipment. ( I did finish off by honing with the green compound on some leather;that was my way to try go a step beyond the 8000.

Anyway, thanks again!

Re: Having a hard time with my wood plane

#20

Result.  Well done!


Re: Having a hard time with my wood plane

#21

Re: Having a hard time with my wood plane

Bruce, a MN Galoot

David,

you said "The angle of this top surface [chipbreaker] must not exceed 45 degrees at front."

Does this only apply to high angle planes, or is it generally true about regular bedded planes as well. The reason I'm asking is that I have a type 11 #4 Stanley that I can't seem to keep from clogging when I try to move the frog forward and I'm wondering if the chipbreaker angle might be a factor.

Thanks.

Re: Having a hard time with my wood plane

#22

Re: Having a hard time with my wood plane

david charlesworth

Bruce,

That was for regular metal bench planes.

If you visualise a chipbreaker with front edge top surface at 45 degrees to the blade, the surface will be parallel to the vertical front edge of throat. Therefore no shaving trap.

I have come across many old Stanley and Record chipbreakers where the surface is too steep.

Best wishes,

David

Re: Having a hard time with my wood plane

#24

Re: What is a "double iron"?

Larry Williams

In a double iron plane the iron is an assembly of a plane iron and cap iron, some call this a chip breaker but it doesn't really "break chips." A single iron plane has no cap iron. Beginning in the last quarter of the 18th Century single iron bench planes with traditional pitches; 45º, 50º, 55º and 60º; began being replaced by common pitch double iron bench planes. Molding planes pretty much continued to be made single iron and at different pitches.

Here's a photo of an early shear steel single plane iron:


Re: Having a hard time with my wood plane

#25

Re: Side sharpening

TomD

First off great to hear that plane is cured.

Always interested in "new" techniques like side sharpening. Is there anything more to it? I was interested to see the dude in the Swiss plane making video from 83 was side sharpening. I have been doing it for ever, but in earnest when I was pressed into the use of paper by the conditions of mys shop. I normally let the bevel tell me what method will give me the most stable results.